This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Comparison Between Halfway House And A Doll's House

2698 words - 11 pages

Throughout the play Ibsen takes pains to enforce and reinforce Nora’s identity. Right at the beginning of the play we witness the following exchange between Helmer, Nora’s husband and Nora herself

Helmer. Is it my little squirrel bustling about?

Nora. Yes!

Helmer. When did my squirrel come home?

Nora. Just now. (Puts the bag of macaroons into her pocket
and wipes her mouth.) Come in here, Torvald, and see what I
have bought.

Helmer. Don’t disturb me. (A little later, he opens the door
and looks into the room, pen in hand.) Bought, did you say?
All these things? Has my little spendthrift been wasting money
again?

Immediately even with this brief introduction several ...view middle of the document...

They try to leave the house (Mahendranath, Binni and Savitri all try) but return eventually. In the words of critic N.S. Dharan:

“Each individual in the family feels lonely but none dares to leave the coop. And if at all anyone leaves, it is only to come back. The play, in effect, portrays loneliness in the midst of relationships, and also the impossibility of escaping into the world outside. One goes out only to come back and live as one used to in the past. The wheel goes round and round, but the spokes are precariously hinged, likely to fall off any moment. But nothing happens, the stasis is frightening.”

In fact the depiction of the trapped and isolated individual was one of Mohan Rakesh’s foremost concerns while writing this play. He says

“Most of my stories are about people living through the torture of relationships and loneliness, where I have tried to depict through the individual his environment. The loneliness is not the loneliness of the socially isolated individual but the loneliness that comes from living within society and it leads not to any kind of cynicism but the need to live through it.”

Thus living such a life of isolation only frays and weakens bonds. It is the spring of disharmony and dissatisfaction in A Doll’s House and the spring of uneasy incompleteness in Halfway House.
For any marriage to be successful, it is a given that both the husband and the wife must know and understand each other – feelings, motives, ideas and emotions thoroughly. It also goes without saying that a stable marriage is the foundation stone of a happy family.

But neither Nora and Helmer nor Mahendranath and Savitri understand each other and hence do not empathise with each other. They are unable to take that next crucial step to cement their marriage: reconciling their differences so that love can grow between them.

Nora. We have been married now eight years. Does it not
occur to you that this is the first time we two, you and I,
husband and wife, have had a serious conversation?

Helmer. What do you mean by serious?

Nora. In all these eight years—longer than that—from the
very beginning of our acquaintance, we have never exchanged
a word on any serious subject.

Helmer. Was it likely that I would be continually and forever
telling you about worries that you could not help me to bear?

Nora. I am not speaking about business matters. I say that
we have never sat down in earnest together to try and get at
the bottom of anything.

Helmer. But, dearest Nora, would it have been any good to
you?

Nora. That is just it; you have never understood me.

Similarly Savitri has never understood Mahendranath. Again I would like to quote critic N.S. Dharan :

“ Mohan Rakesh’s insistence that the same actor should play all the five roles, namely the Man in the Black Suit, Mahendranath, Singhania , Jagmohan and Juneja shows his meticulous care for dramatic techniques. The same man playing five roles is a unique dramatic...

Other Essays Like A Comparison Between Halfway House and a Doll's House

Living in a Doll's House Essay

580 words - 3 pages Kareem Abdul Jabar Mr. Gene Simmons Communications Two, A Doll House analysis 9 November 1975 The Ragdoll That Once Was Nora Helmer Henrik Ibsen’s play, “A Doll House,” was written in 1879, which was during a time when women and men’s roles in society were looked at as being two completely separate entities, and equality between the sexes was nowhere near in sight. While men were meant to go out and provide financial support for the

A Doll's House-Opinion Paper

994 words - 4 pages “You and I both would have to transform ourselves to the point that- Oh Torvald, I’ve stopped believing in miracles…that our living together could be a true marriage.” A very dramatic ending to the play, “A Doll’s House” written by Henrik Ibsen in 1879. This play is based on Ibsen’s opinion toward the roles of society in those times and how the female gender was treated. In the play, you are able to apprehend Ibsen’s belief about the roles of

Anna Karenina and A Doll's House: Feminist and Marxist Critisism

874 words - 4 pages Introduction At the time Anna Karenina and A Doll’s House were written, both published around the 1870s, Russian women were primarily under the control of their fathers and husbands. For this very reason, marriage was, in a way, a career goal for Russian women at that time. This feeds into the marxist theme because every character in each novel is In both Anna Karenina and A Doll’s House, the problems Anna and Nora face from the marxist

Dialogue and Monologue in Antigone and a Doll's House

1679 words - 7 pages enhances the major theme of individual vs. state. Furthermore, in Ibsen’s play, A Doll’s House, one of the important themes is deception. Ibsen uses dialogue between several characters of a play to inform the readers and audience of events, and therefore, develop this theme. For example, Dr. Rank speaks with Nora, and explains how his disease will soon cause his death. He makes sure that Nora does not tell Helmer of this, as Dr. Rank does not

Determinism and Free Will in a Doll's House

835 words - 4 pages . A Doll's House is really about the conflict between society and human nature, Ibsen uses the character of Nora to represent free will, by making her a woman he was able to make a stronger point, as women were the most restricted group in society at the time. Torvalds character represents some of the wrongs in society, but the humanization of these wrongs makes the play more powerful, as it disguising the constraints of 19th century European society as his free will. It is only when Nora sees through this disguise that she is able to be free.

Women's Issues In And Concerning A Doll's House

1513 words - 7 pages Women’s Issues In and Concerning A Doll’s House A Doll’s House was a groundbreaking play upon its original theatrical release. Critics were extremely negative at first, as demonstrated by Rosefeldt’s opinion, “In Henrik Ibsens A Dolls House, Nora abandons her children. This offense against motherhood shocked the plays original audience just as it shocks some students of literature today. Certainly the play questions the real definition of

The Theme In Ibsen's A Doll's House

958 words - 4 pages The Theme in Ibsen's A Doll's HouseThe Doll's house is one of the strongest plays that Ibsen has produced in the way of character painting and artistic handling of situations. There has always been a very big and noticeable gap in the roles that both women and men play in the everyday societal developments. During the late nineteenth century women were enslaved in their gender roles while the roles assigned to men were also explored. The

Criticle Analysis of a Doll's House

2586 words - 11 pages Critical Analysis of "A Doll's House" by Henrik Ibsen Henrik Ibsen’s A Doll’s House was a controversial play for its time because it questioned society's basic rules and norms. Multiple interpretations can be applied to the drama, which allows the reader to appreciate many different aspects of the play. This paper examines how both Feminist and Marxist analyses can be applied as literary theories in discussing Ibsen's play because both center

A Push to Freedom in Henrik Ibsen's A Doll's House

1436 words - 6 pages Rights. He explained to the group, "I must decline the honor of being said to have worked for the Women's Rights movement. I am not even very sure what Women's Rights are. To me it has been a question of human rights" ( ). "A Doll's House" is often interpreted by readers, teachers, and critics alike as an attack on chauvinistic behavior and a cry for the recognition of women's rights ( ). Instead its theme is identical to several of

A Feminist Reading of Henrik Ibsen's a Doll's House

829 words - 4 pages A Feminist Reading of Henrik Ibsen's A Doll's House Chronicling women's struggles for acceptance and equal status in society as depicted in modern literature: Ibsen's views on feminism in A Doll's House History bears testimony to the struggles women have had to undergo in trying to realize their rights to freedom and equality of status in society. In all ancient societies girls and women were kept under male subjugation. Unfortunately

A Doll's House - Portrayal of What Constitutes a Healthy Marriage

1511 words - 7 pages Daniel Mariano A Doll’s House Henrik Ibsen’s play, A Doll’s House, was a “challenging” play as it evoked marriage and what was acceptable within it given the time period it was written. In the modern day, the play serves as sort of a guide of what not to do in a relationship. This is because it dances with what love is, what marriage is, and what comprises a healthy marriage. In the play, the two female protagonists, Nora and Mrs. Linde

Related Papers

A Doll's House 3 Essay

4183 words - 17 pages be intuitive and deficient. In 1879, Ibsen sent Nora Helmer out into the world with a demand that a woman too must have the freedom to develop as an adult, independent, and responsible person.3 The playwright was now over 50, and had finally been recognized outside of the Nordic countries. "Pillars of Society" had admittedly opened the German borders for him, but it was "A Doll's House" and "Ghosts" (1881) which in the 1880s led him into the

A Doll's House 5 Essay

727 words - 3 pages A housewife’s dream: the perfect house, beautiful children, a delightful husband, and “piles and piles of money”. All these things and more fill Nora’s head at the start of Henrik Ibsen’s _A Doll’s House_. Nora’s husband Torvald Helmer has just become the manger at the bank he works at and will receive a significant raise. Nora acts as a child flitting around the house and telling anyone and everyone about her good fortunes while Torvald

A Doll's House Essay

2357 words - 10 pages Often in literature characters are presented as victims of society. There are many examples of this in Henrik Ibsen’s controversial play, “A Doll’s House”. Written during the Victorian era, Ibsen’s play would have raised a lot controversy on the roles of males and females in society. The audience would have noticed the constant similarities between themselves and the characters that are presented as victims of

"Henrik Ibsen's" A Doll's House Essay

715 words - 3 pages Henrik Ibsen's A Doll's HouseIn Henrik Ibsen's A Doll's House, the main male character, Torvald Helmer, speaks very condescendingly to his wife, Nora throughout the first act of the play. He has a definite and narrow definition of a woman's role, which is clearly exemplified in his dialect towards his wife as well as in reference to her. In his opinion, it is the divine duty of a woman to be a good wife to her husband and a good mother to her