A Comparison Of Freud And Fromm

1853 words - 8 pages

Sigmund Freud was born in Monrovia on May 6,1856. He entered the University of Vienna in 1873 at the age of 17. He finished his degree in 1881. Freud died in England in 1939. He was an active therapist, theorist and writer to the very end. ( Ewen 19-20) Erich Fromm was born four years after Freud in 1900 in Frankfurt, Germany. Unlike Freud, Fromm had no medical training in his background. He received his PHD from the University of Heidelberg and later studied at Berlin Psychoanalytic Institute. Erich Fromm died March 16, 1980 in Switzerland. (Ewen 187)
While Freud and Fromm were contemporaries and shared some basic beliefs, their approach to most issues varied greatly. Freud’s attitude was ...view middle of the document...

( Ewen 195-196) These characteristics compromise the productive frame of orientation. The nonproductive frames include narcissism, necrophilia, dependence, compulsive strivings for power or wealth and the mechanisms of escape. Fromm had four other nonproductive orientations that he devoted a great deal of attention to. These were receptive, exploitative, hoarding and marketing. Three of these orientations can be loosely compared to Freud’s oral-dependent, oral-sadistic and anal character without the sexual implications.
Freud and Fromm both believed that dreams are the “royal road” to the unconscious. ( Ewen 198) Fromm agreed with Freud that dreams could serve the purpose of wish fulfillment, that the day’s events set them off, and that a person may conceal truths in different ways. While both men believed in dream symbols, Freud believed most dreams involved childhood sexual impulses and Fromm regarded many symbols as asexual. Fromm believed that dreams could have obvious and undisguised meanings that did not have to involve childhood conflicts. To understand Fromm’s approach to clinical diagnosis, his theory of character must first be understood. His theory of character development was that humans are distinguished from other animals by a larger neocortex with fewer instincts. Character shapes human instinct. Human survival is not merely a matter of physical survival, humans are social animals who must relate to others, and they are spiritual animals who must infuse their lives with meaning in order to function. Humans require a sense of hope to keep from turning off. They also require caring adults in the early years to be teachers that teach them to control their fears and passions and live in harmony with others.
Religion both sacred and secular can give meaning to life and give a sense of identity and rootness. Fromm accepted Freud’s definition of mental health saying that it is the capacity for love and productive work. Fromm also agreed with Freud in saying that psychopathology represents a difference in degree, rather than in kind. Fromm states that besides pathogenic behaviors that neurosis is often caused by the culture in which one lives. He says that neurosis consists of a conflict between two opposing forces. Which is when our healthy innate drives toward self-realization and independence are blocked by parental or societal influences. Freud states that neurosis invariably begins in infancy and childhood, however it may not become evident until much later in life. Some cause’s of neurosis is a lack of physical affection, overindulgence or too much frustration during a psychosexual stage will result in harmful fixations, or a child may suffer from traumatic events. Freud and Fromm both shared the conviction that “the truth will set man free”, (www.maccoby.com) but Fromm moves in a different direction from Freud’s emphasis on psychoanalysis as a process that patiently uncovers and interrupts resistance in order to regain lost...

Other Essays Like A Comparison of Freud and Fromm

Comparison of Head of Alexander and Head of a Bodhisattva

1031 words - 5 pages The Kushans of the first to third century CE embraced artistic, religious, and cultural practices of others graciously. They connected cultures together and were considered one of the most accepting cultures and honored diversity. From their coinage, to the early rise of Gandharan art with Hellenisitic traces, it was rarely truly developed from that area specifically. When is art or culture developed through a vacuum with no outside influences

A Comparison Of The Australian And North Korean Economies

1834 words - 8 pages as South Korea and America. North Koreas communist regime and economy have possibly had an effect on the way of life which is reflected, in comparison to nations such as Australia. The Quality of life in Australia reflects one of the highest in the world. From indicators such as the HDI (Human Development Index) we are ranked in third place behind the countries of Norway and Sweden. The cost of living in Australia is relatively expensive on a

Comparison Of The Great Gatsby And A Streetcar Named Desire

1493 words - 6 pages Gatsby and Blanche devote a lot of their lives to finding true love, their searching leaves them unsuccessful. Gatsby and Blanche are blinded by their own pasts. Gatsby decides to live in a constant fantasy that he will get Daisy back. He is not willing to accept that she is married and loves another man. This is shown through this quote "he stretched out his arms toward the dark water in a curious way, and, far as I was from him, I could have sworn

A Comparison Of Karl Marx And Max Weber

581 words - 3 pages         During the nineteenth century, Karl Marx and Max Weber were two of the most influential sociologists. Both of them tried to explain social change taking place in a society at that time. On the one hand, their views are very different, but on the other hand, they had many similarities. Weber had argued that Marx was too narrow in his views. He felt that Marx was only concerned with the economic issues and believed that that issue is

A Comparison Of Love In Othello And King Lear

1512 words - 7 pages What is love? Love is the pinnacle of all emotions, it is the epicenter for life, what is the point of living if there is no love, ironically love is the cause of many a down fall. William Shakespeare has single handedly captured and embraced this necessary feeling and has allowed us to view in on it through the characters in his two masterpieces, Othello and King Lear. Three different kinds of loves explored in both Othello and King Lear

A Comparison of Ethical Theories

681 words - 3 pages A Comparison of Ethical Theories Ethics are codes of behavior, adopted by a group; a family, community or nations, setting the boarders for behavior. Some examples of ethics theories include: virtue ethics, utilitarianism, and deontology.  The virtue theory of ethics can be summed up with the statement, that if a person’s character is good, they will make good choices. The choices they make are strictly based on their internal thoughts and

A Comparison Of Love Poems

2691 words - 11 pages sonnet. This is made obvious due to the single verse consisting of 14 lines. It is also again a love poem expressing a particular idea, which in this case is mutability. It tackles the deep concept of beauty changing and decaying.The first line opens the poem with a rhetorical question making a comparison to a summer 's day. It is then answered in the second line stating that this beautiful woman whom the speaker is addressing is indeed far 'more

Literary Comparison Of A Clock

1841 words - 8 pages A Literary Comparison Of A Clockwork Orange and The Crucible      The existence of evil in the world is a universal question that is often contemplated. Anthony Burgess and Arthur Miller in their novels A Clockwork Orange and The Crucible address this question of evil. One of these stories is set in the future, and the other in the past confirming the belief that the human struggle between good and evil is timeless

A Comparison Of The Declaration Of Independence And King's I Have A Dream

1285 words - 6 pages       Every individual has their own definition of freedom.  Depending on time, place, religion, or race, this definition varies, but essentially comes back to one point: all men, regardless of anything, are created equally, and therefore have a right to be free.  "The Declaration of Independence," by Thomas Jefferson, and Martin Luther King, Jr.'s "I Have A Dream" are two works addressing this concern.  Although Jefferson and King led

A Comparison Of A Streetcar Named Desire And The Master Builder

769 words - 4 pages The Comedy and Tragedy of A Streetcar Named Desire and The Master Builder It has been said that the world is a comedy to those that think, and a tragedy to those who feel.  This philosophy is supported by two important literary works, A Streetcar Named Desire by Tennessee Williams and The Master Builder by Henrik Ibsen. In each piece, the sensitive and emotional characters experience tremendous pain, while the cold and unfeeling

Catholicism And Comparison Of Beli

2052 words - 9 pages Catholicism and Comparison of Beliefs The Catholic Church is the world’s largest single religious body, and comprises 23 "particular churches," or Rites, all of which acknowledge a primacy of jurisdiction of the Bishop of Rome and are in full communion with the Holy See and each other. As the oldest continuously operating organization, the Catholic Church has a distinguished history. The Church has also been involved in many of the

Related Papers

Freud, Neo Freudians, And Post Freudians: A Comparison

1039 words - 5 pages Freud, Neo-Freudians, and Post Freudians: A Comparison PSY5102- History & Systems of Psychology Sigmund Freud Free Association | When a patient is prompted to say whatever comes to mind | Sex determined neurosis | Freud reported that most of his female patients reported sexual abuse in their past. He also believed neurotic people did not have a normal sex life; therefore they went hand in hand. | Dream analysis | Dreams

The History Of Freud And Psychoanalysis

2988 words - 12 pages "Psychoanalysis is (a) the method developed by Sigmund Freud and extended by his followers for treating mental disorders. (b) The theory of personality, which grew out of experiences with the psychoanalytic method of treatment. The theory emphasizes the role of unconscious processes in personality development and in motivation." (Atkinson, 1953). Sigmund Freud, Carl Jung and Alfred Adler all influenced the school of psychoanalysis; however

Life And Studies Of Sigmund Freud

1267 words - 6 pages thought or feeling in the unconscious mind. Besides Freud’s theory on the conscious and unconscious mind, Freud has also done great research on how a person’s instincts work. (Wagner) Freud’s theory on instinct was that a person has not only one instinct, but rather two, which consist of the life instinct and the death instinct. The life instinct is basically a person’s everyday needs, such as needing food and water. The life instinct is also

A Comparison Of Christianity And Taoism

2803 words - 12 pages A comparison of Christianity and Taoism It is not precisely known when the concept of religion was first introduced to mankind but, it is thought to be pre-existed when the very first form of human civilization emerged. Thus, the religion always occupied the greatest part of human civilizations. As the civilization advanced, the religion also advanced. About two thousand years ago, there were few powerful countries which could exert both