A Critique On Bertrand Russel's 'why I'm Not A Christian'

2162 words - 9 pages

a. Background information to introduce the issue
Bertrand Russell was a revolutionary in the field of humanitarian ideals and freedom of thought. Aside from that he was probably one of the most profound and sophisticated spokesman for atheism from the last century, His literary and communication skills are definitely almost unprecedented winning a nobel prize for Literature. His influence and iconicness that stood the test of time and his literary works that are still being talked about years after his death is a proof of his undying influence.
Despite the fact that he was agnostic and an atheist, he felt that he was not up to the pedestal of being a Christian because he ...view middle of the document...

Thesis Statements:
Bertrand Russel’s Essay about why he’s not a Christian is both unpersuasive and shallow due to the fact that the criterion he used for grilling Christ’s character was very arbitrary and that his attempts at finding holes in the argument for design were not only futile but shallow at best.

A.)Main Argument 1:
Russell tries (and fails) to debunk Christ’s character and divinity by the type of arguments he used
In this argument, Russell tries to throw out the Character of Christ by using an unethical way of arguing by having no respect to the context of the verses and using selective and arbitrary criterions of explaining these verses which just made him unprofessional and shallow. For example, Russell picks out a verse from the bible like this:“But I tell you, Do not resist an evil person. If someone strikes you on the right cheek, turn to him the other also.” (Matthew 5:39; Luke 6:29). Russell asserts that not many Christians turn their other cheek when someone does them wrong, and since Christians font follow this rule, there’s something wrong with the Christians and by extension, Jesus Christ himself. But what Russell forgets is that this verse is taken out of context and has no respect to the entire text which offers a better explanation! And according to D.A Carson,
“...we must agree that absolutizing any text, without due respect for the context and flow of the argument, as well as for other things Jesus says elsewhere, is bound to lead to distortion and misrepresentation of what Jesus means.‛ ( Jesus’ Sermon on the Mount, pg 54)

What the verse really meant In the larger passage of Matthew 5:38-42, Jesus Christ was referring to the act of personal self-sacrifice; and a smite on the cheek was typically referred to as an insult as opposed to an act of bodily harm, which was translated from the Greek text, something not present on the english translation. Jesus was saying that to be Christian, you shouldn’t stoop down to insults, he wasn’t referring to ignore your sense of self-preservation. To conclude otherwise would be a misrepresentation of Christ’s words.

Jesus believes in hell because a just God would never let a grave mistake to go unpunished, not doing so would just steam more criticisms from Russell. In this argument, we are criticizing Russell for criticizing Christ’s concept of hell. He then makes this statement: “I do not myself feel that any person who is really profoundly humane can believe in everlasting punishment” and also this: “vindictive fury against these people who would not listen to his preaching”, he combines these verses to once again question Christ’s morality into the table
And as evidence of his contentions, Russell, again selectively picks out a random verse from the bible: “you snakes! You brood of vipers! How will you escape being condemned to hell? ‛”(Matthew 23:33). And just like his previous argument, he arbitrarily takes out a verse out of it’s context...

Other Essays Like A Critique on Bertrand Russel's 'Why I'M Not a Christian'

A Short Christian Theology Essay

960 words - 4 pages , His perfect holiness, and so on. The point to be made is this – God is absolute, and as an absolute being is above, and indeed completely unsusceptible to any change or imperfection. God exists eternally as a spirit. However, about 2015 years ago, God the Son came to earth to offer a way for us to have the hope of living forever with Him in Heaven after we die. This was necessary because we, as sinful and depraved humans, have broken the

A Critique of Articles Essay

519 words - 3 pages thumbs down on Brown and it would have been the same if Brown had been a gladiator and I would have been a roman centurion. On the other hand, Mitchell Farnum gets a smile out of me although he does mention and hints at controversial matters like Nazi, abortion, racism etc. He says that he is against Orientals joining his club, because it is his club. He makes the rules here .Although he does not say it, I get the message that maybe if

Cell Phones in Schools: a Necessary Convenience, or Irritating Intrusion? This is a persuasive essay on why cell phones should not be allowed in schools

324 words - 2 pages Who can work while listening to the incessant ringing of a cell phone? This does not creat an inviting classroom environment for students. Although cell phones would be useful in the event of an emergency, they should not be allowed in schools because of the increased amount of disruptive and social problems.Despite the interruptions, cell phones do provide on advantage. They allow quick communications during times of an emergency; they also

What Is a Christian Worldview

901 words - 4 pages I. What is a worldview? Whether conscious of it or not, every person has a their own set of unique perceptions and beliefs of the world which constitutes their reality. It serves as a basis for all areas of their life which they use to govern their judgments and interpret the world around them. II. The Christian Worldview Origin - The Christian worldview is entirely rooted in God. Christianity affirms that God is infinite

Technology Is Revolutionizing the Way Students Learn. but Not Everyone Believes These Changes Are Positive. Do You Believe Technology Is Having a Beneficial Effect on Education? Why/Why Not?

576 words - 3 pages easily access at home. If you don’t know what grade you got for your schoolwork, you could just access at home by going into school site. In my school, the technology system has developed a lot, so parents and I would go into the school website and check my grades. In conclusion, using technologies in class will give positive impact on students learning. They would not need to think about bringing pencil cases to school, they just need to bring computers to school.

Critique of a Writer's Exchange

560 words - 3 pages book is something everyone should have on his or her bookshelf. It provided me with the details, which wasn't covered in the textbook. Now, I would like to bring to your attention one thing I noticed about the grading system. The reader/grader provides some great details about the essays I wrote. It is my suggestion that the reader/grader provide a critique of the students writing ability. After the reader/grader has graded three or four

Thelma & Louise; A Humanist Critique

650 words - 3 pages feel to Geena Davis's character, Thelma Louise Dickinson.The three aspects of the film that will be discussed and analyzed will be:1. Why is this perceived as a "male bashing" movie when it really is a story of friendship?2. The metamorphosis of the two lead characters.3. The Southern country-like settingExplanation of how the film aesthetics create meaning - use of specific examples from the film (15)mountainous scenes and barren

What It Means to Be a Christian

1303 words - 6 pages life has been strengthened by these ideas, and that is why I believe they are all essential to the growth and maturity of every Christian’s spiritual walk. They assist in defining what it means to be a true Christian. II. Section One: The Life of a Christian The first of these important concepts deals with the lifestyle of a Christian. Every aspect of a person’s physical life is directly involved with their spiritual health whether they

Creative Writing About A Boy Called Christian

1865 words - 8 pages you think you’re going?”He turned to see his mother stood in the corridor with her arms crossed and Frank almost cowering behind her.“Out,” Christian sharply replied, “is that a problem?”“Yes, as a matter of fact, it is.”“Why? I’m sure you don’t want me in your way while you pack your stuff and, to be honest, I’m fed up of looking at you.”He’d felt this coming on while he had

A Reaction Paper on Education Is Not the Hope

541 words - 3 pages ANN MARLITA MONTEJO-AREVALO DR. RENATO F. DE LEMON MAED Educational Management Professorial Lecturer September 4, 2010 EM 201 A REACTION PAPER on “Education Is Not The Hope” The essay, “Education Is Not The Hope,” by Jose Ma. Montelibano is a paradoxical elucidation of

"So What If I'm Not 21?" Opinions On The Legal Drinking Age- We Should Lower It To 18

1039 words - 5 pages to draw the line between right and wrong when consuming alcoholic beverages.I definitely have to side with the opponents on this issue, not because I want to go out and drink, but because I want those that do to be able to do it safely. I believe that the parents should be ultimately responsible for educating their children to drink wisely, and for setting a good example for their children to follow. Taking these steps would greatly reduce the

Related Papers

Why I Became A Christian Essay

1894 words - 8 pages , instead of selfish things. It makes NO difference whether youre a Catholic, Protestant or belong to ANY OTHER denomination. YOU MUST BE BORN AGAIN INTO A PERSONAL RELATIONSHIP WITH JESUS CHRIST TO SPEND ETERNITY IN HEAVEN WITH GOD!!! What about the Jehovahs Witnesses and The Mormons/ Church of Latter Day Saints? At first, groups like these APPEAR to be just another Christian denomination, but Ive learned that this is NOT true. BOTH of these

Why Not Cheat On A Test

1123 words - 5 pages my life. I was always a working student and a great mother to my child, but to me that wasn’t enough. I needed a bigger change for my family and I so that’s why I chose Wilson College. Other students may not think the Honor Principle is that big of a deal, but if u really was dedicated to the school, you would make it a big deal. Students may walk around campus with a smile on their face because they know that they probably cheated their whole

A Christian Perspectavie On Cloning In A Short Essay Format

486 words - 2 pages The facts surrounding how the earth came into existence have been in question for a very long time. Atheistic scientists believe that our universe simply "popped" into being, while Christians and other religions believe that it was created. Some scientists do not put the same value on life as Christians, because of differing opinions of the soul of these people. Also brought into question is when a person is a person, and if a person is created

Why I Am Not A Criminal

1498 words - 6 pages activities, and hold on to the belief that their values will take them far in life. (Akers, R. L. & Sellers, 2012) Social control theory helps explain why I am not a criminal because I have successfully met the conditions that the theory poses to be the factors of avoiding crime. As I stated above, informal social control is the most important kind of social control because as humans we possess a need to be wanted and try to avoid