A Not Quite Happy Ending: Hazard And Love In Shakespeare's Merchant Of Venice

2148 words - 9 pages

A Not-Quite Happy Ending: Hazard and Love in Shakespeare’s Merchant of Venice
By Hubert Ahn

William Shakespeare’s Merchant of Venice begins on a note of melancholy. Antonio, the eponymous merchant, pronounces “In sooth, I know not why I am so sad” (1.1.1). His friends offer possible reasons, all of which are rejected by Antonio. The issue is quickly superseded by a more immediate one. Antonio’s beloved friend Bassanio arrives with a proposed suit to win the lady Portia’s hand in marriage, Antonio immediately grants it, and nothing more is heard of Antonio’s sadness. Portia herself is introduced by way of her own particular sadness--“By my troth, Nerissa (her ...view middle of the document...

.while I live I’ll fear no other thing, So sore as keeping safe Nerissa’s ring” (5.1.306-7). Venice is widely considered a comedy with dramatic elements. Shylock provides the drama; the intertwining love stories the comedy. But even omitting the Shylock storyline, there is a very deep level of pathetic drama at work. This essay will argue that the undertone of melancholy is generated by the lovers’ failure to realize an ideal of love, and that this failure is gender-based.
What is the ideal of love, then, in Venice? Renaissance Neoplatonism depicted love as a “chain or ladder from the basest carnality to the supreme love of God for humanity” (Bevington 75). This supreme love is almost senseless in its generosity—nothing within humanity is worthy of it. Anything which hinted at baseness, anything lower than the absolutely spiritual, is considered a lower form of love. Bassanio correctly dismisses all base desire and artificial beauty when he chooses the lead casket, but the only positive motivation he has for choosing correctly sounds almost capricious: “thou meager lead, which rather threaten’st than dost promise aught, Thy paleness moves me more than eloquence” (3.2.106-7). Bassanio’s choice is quite lucky. Technically, if we are to believe these lines sincere, Bassanio chooses the casket simply because it is plain. But the choice is correct because of the casket’s promise, which is borne out in the plot: to win true love one must “give and hazard all he hath” (2.7.9). Bassanio is leery of this message, but he is in fact already a practitioner: his speech about shooting a second arrow to reclaim the first (1.1.140-45) demonstrates his awareness of the principle. If we are to take the concept of “give and hazard” as the purest form of love that the world of this play has to offer (and if we believe Shakespeare was being sincere with the casket plot-line, as we must if we are to consider it anything but a mean joke), we may take it as the base-line from which to measure the relationships in the play.
It is inarguable that the relationship between Antonio and Bassanio comes closest to the mark, and it doesn’t make a whit of difference whether you consider them friends, lovers, or closet homosexuals. Antonio must, indeed, hazard everything--first, everything he owns, then his own life. Bassanio ends up giving away Portia’s ring, an act which she has made it known would “presage the ruin of your (Bassanio’s) love” (3.2.173), to a near-stranger, simply to redeem the honor of his friend. Such reckless hazarding is rewarded—nowhere in the play is trust betrayed between these two, nor even a sharp word spoken between them.
Hijinks abound amongst the play’s male-female romances, some of them of a quite generous and daring variety. But they all fall short of the bench mark set by its two central men, often for reasons quite deliberate and unavoidable. Jessica and Lorenzo engage in a love affair which...

Other Essays Like A Not-Quite Happy Ending: Hazard and Love in Shakespeare's Merchant of Venice

The Comedy of the Merchant of Venice an in-Depth Analysis on Shakespeare's Shylock

2906 words - 12 pages crucial to its development as a comedy. These parallels can be drawn to The Merchant of Venice. In the trial of Antonio, Shylock is awarded power through the law. However, this is rapidly taken away when the letter of the law is used against Shylock (Merchant, 4.1. 304-5). Not only is Shylock unable to take one pound of flesh from Antonio, he is cited as breaking the law and sentenced to give up his entire fortune (Merchant, 4.1). Portia prevents

Stereotype in Merchant of Venice Essay

624 words - 3 pages Shakespeare play The Merchant Of Venice, as most of the main characters are looked upon with a stereotypical point of view. However Not all of the main characters are, some take a different perspective and are a completely different breed of character compared to the others. A good example of a stereotypical character in The Merchant of Venice would be Shylock. the villainous Jew. He is a man who is sought after only for a loan, as it was only Jews who

Younger Generation in Merchant of Venice

723 words - 3 pages Portia’s fathers, Launcelot’s father is also quite protective and offers Bassanio ‘a dish of doves’ to thank him for accepting his son to be his servant. In a way, Bassanio is also protected by a father figure, Antonio. They have a strong relationship and he is sad when Bassanio falls for Portia. But still, like a parent, Antonio gives him money, letting him do what he wants: ‘Try what my credit can in Venice do to furnish you to Belmont, and fair Portia’.

Merchant Of Venice

1423 words - 6 pages The Merchant of Venice The play, ¡°The Merchant of Venice¡± by William Shakespeare has two main settings. One setting is Venice, a city where many businessmen live, a place, full of unhappy and unkind people. It a world of commercial and law. Shakespeare has portrayed Venice as the ¡°real¡± world. The other setting is Belmont, a city which houses a rich, happy society of beautiful people. Belmont is a fairy-tale world of music and love. In this

The Merchant of Venice

547 words - 3 pages Book Review Title: The Merchant of Venice Author of the Book: William Shakespeare First published in year: 1597 Genre of the Book: Play One of Shakespeare “short” and “easier to understand” plays. The language is comparatively easy than most of his plays. The play is basically put under the category of comedy, but with the passage of time, modern readers take it more as a tragedy than comedy, because it actually depicts Christian

Merchant of Venice

2381 words - 10 pages 1. MERCHANT OF VENICE a) Bassanio, Antonio’s dearest friend, confesses that he is madly in love with a girl of exceptional beauty and of rich inheritance at Belmont and her name is Portia. He also tells Antonio that he wishes to pay a visit to that place in order to win her as his wife. Already in debt to Antonio, Bassanio asks for more money to finance his suit to Portia

Merchant of Venice Antonio

887 words - 4 pages “Bigoted and spiteful”and “well-intentioned and loyal”, which of these views best describes the character of Antonio in your question. In “Merchant of Venice”, Antonio is the main character as he is the “merchant” in the story in Venice. As Antonio is a Christian, he is quite anti-Semitic and rude to Shylock, making some people believe that he is spiteful and bigoted. However, most of the play centers on him being the victim of the “villain

Discuss the Moral Issues Raised in ‘the Merchant of Venice’

659 words - 3 pages court to be reasonable and to not let Shylock go through with his bond however the law cannot be broken and the rules of Venice must stand. Prejudice is another moral issue developed in this passage. Bassanio speaks of “curbing this cruel devil of his will” however is Shylocks will so wrong after years of mistreatment for the lone factor that he is a Jew? Although Shylock is in the right the duke still does all he can to lawfully stop him

Merchant of Venice - Dramatic Effects

1079 words - 5 pages As you read the play, it is important to imagine yourself watching and listening to the action. It is a drama, not a novel! Shakespeare provides us with very few stage directions, so to help us imagine exactly what is going on, we need to picture each character's actions and reactions clearly. During the course of The Merchant of Venice we see comedy and near-tragedy. We see three sets of lovers get together and almost see a man murdered on

Merchant of Venice Main Theme

929 words - 4 pages Shakespeare’s The Merchant Of Venice was intended to be a comedic play but it revolves around racism and discrimination. In this play, the main theme is racism and discrimination. First, Racism is shown towards the Prince Of Morocco because of his skin color. Next, Portia is shown discrimination from her father by limiting her own choices on who to marry. Lastly, Religions such as Catholic and Jews who is Antonio and Shylock goes against each

The Merchant Of Venice By WIlliam Shakespeare

868 words - 4 pages decision solely based on those arguments. In the play, however, this was simply not the case. The Duke tried to reason with Shylock, he begged Shylock to show mercy towards Antonio and abandon the bond. He said “And where thou now exacts the penalty, which is a pound of this poor merchant’s flesh, thou wilt not only loose the forfeiture but, touched with human gentleness and love, forgive a moiety of the principal, glancing an eye of pity

Related Papers

Shakespeare's Presentation Of Shylock In The Merchant Of Venice

662 words - 3 pages Shakespeare's Presentation of Shylock in The Merchant of Venice In every play or story, you need a villain, someone you can hate - in Cinderella you have the evil stepmother, in Harry Potter you have Lord Voldermort, and in the Merchant of Venice you have Shylock. In this scene, I see Shylock not as the comical buffoon or villain but as the outsider. The scene opens with a conversation between Basanio and Shylock

Shylock In William Shakespeare's The Merchant Of Venice

1587 words - 7 pages Shylock in William Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice There are many reasons how this scene is more effective than all the others in the play for range of reasons. In this one scene it goes through nearly every other thing that has been mentioned earlier in the play. Also why most scenes have mainly one big point to them, this one has five, and some more sub - plots. Before it starts there is the aspect of Christian

William Shakespeare's The Merchant Of Venice

1609 words - 7 pages William Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice "The Merchant of Venice" by William Shakespeare features, Shylock a very controversial character due to his religion, profession and personal traits. Professionally Shylock lends money to people in debt, in order to gain interest and profit. Although, this is very much central to our modern way of life, in the Elizabethan period, money lending was not accepted as an

Comparing The Different Ways That Love Is Used As A Theme In The Merchant Of Venice And A Thousand Splendid Suns

1112 words - 5 pages compasses sexual desire and domestic comfort in a way that Antonio’s act of kindness could not quite effect” so it is clear that Bassanio’s sexual needs cannot be satisfied by Antonio, removing the idea of homosexuality in The Merchant of Venice. In lineage to the love Mariam has for her few material and intangible possessions in part one of A Thousand Splendid Suns the end of The Merchant Of Venice shows the resolution of Antonio's