A Perfect Society Essay

1734 words - 7 pages

A Perfect Society
Through his profound scrutiny about human nature, Machiavelli shows us some essential
qualities that a prince or ruler must have in order to maintain his state. On the other hand,
Thomas More’s Utopia clearly illustrate how to maintain a “perfect” society by abandoning
private property and money. Although both Thomas More and Machiavelli write about the basic
issues about how society work and what should be our position in the society, they have quite
different view about power management, governmental system and overall human nature.
Machiavelli represents power is one of the most important things that a prince should
possess in order ...view middle of the document...

Machiavelli would argue that this type of government will eventually
be more vulnerable to foreign enemies. Because, distribution of power among common people
would diminish ruler’s ultimate power and eventually make himself nothing but a common
people. Therefore, these type of society would be more vulnerable to foreign enemies and
eventually will collapse.
Machiavelli represent human as evil and self-seeking creature. As he says “One can make
this generalization about men: they are ungrateful, fickle, liars and deceivers, they shun danger
and are greedy for profit” (The Prince, 54). Therefore, according to Machiavelli, deserving
something good from human is not only realistic but also harmful as well. He would argue that,
set up an idealistic human society with the basis of justice and truth is quite impossible. Because,
for his inherent nature man will betray eventually and therefore, ruler has to use his cruelty in
order maintain his state. On the other hand, Rafael would argue that in Utopian society, there is
no way that human can be selfish, because, men will grow up in a society where everything is
perfect. And a person will be good or evil completely depends on the society where he raises in.
Therefore, in this perspective, Rafael would say that his Utopian would be better than
Machiavellian society.
According to Rafael, money is the root for all problems. As he says, “The rich will be
greedy, unscrupulous, and totally useless characters, while the poor will be simple, unassuming
people whose daily work is far more profitable to the community than it is to them” (Utopia, 45).
Therefore, he strongly supports abolishing private property in order to create a balanced and just
society. But Machiavelli would argue that taking private property from all the citizens regardless
of their social or cultural status is not reasonable at all. Because when people will realize that he
will get everything what he wants, he will become lazy and will not feel any initiative to think
about his future at all. Eventually, the whole nation will be less intellectual. Therefore, a nation
cannot be sustain very long with all sorts of dull and lazy people.

Furthermore one cannot simply break a capitalist society by taking all the wealth from
rich people in order to establish a Utopian society. According to Machiavelli, a prince cannot
simply accept new principalities without destroying everything in that society. Therefore,
abandoning capitalism for the sake of moneyless communism is not only logical but also harmful
for hard working people who want to work hard in order to improve their condition. Therefore,
according to Machiavelli, this type of Utopian society will collapse either from internal rebellion
or external enemies.

Social Habits or Customs
Our way of life,...

Other Essays Like A Perfect Society

There Are Many Points Of Matter Expressed In The Book Frankenstein. One Of The Points Of Matter, Which Still Plagues Our Society, Is The Notion Of Playing God

656 words - 3 pages There are many points of matter expressed in the book Frankenstein. One of the points of matter, which still plagues our society, is the notion of playing god. Another of the stories numerous points of matter are no one will ever be or be able to create a perfect man. Also, every person, no matter if they aren't attractive, wants and needs to be loved.When Victor was creating this monster in his laboratory he was concentrated on his one goal

Family Roles And Perceptions In Canada

761 words - 4 pages they were raised. They are so consumed with how the perfect lives should be lived and could suffer from self-esteem, conformity issues and that acceptance feeling you get with children who do live in that nuclear family situation. With these varying domestic arrangements of children living in an extended family in today's society, the thought of one aspiring idea of a nuclear family almost seem ridiculous. Instead of aspiring to the nuclear

Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis Is Unethical And Immoral

929 words - 4 pages choosing the gender of their child. Dr. Steinberg has expanded the options of the PGD cycle to include eye, hair and skin color when making a perfect baby. "I can't say with 100 percent certainty that parents will be able to choose something like eye color -- more like 80 percent certainty," Steinberg said. Allowing parents to choose the genes of their child may eventually cause society to shun those who cannot afford the PGD cycle, cause long-term

Human Cloning

855 words - 4 pages Science fiction authors have for many years instilled in us the fantastic idea of great armies of cloned men and women, fighting mindless battles for the betterment of human kind. Perfect beings created under the microscope of fantasy to accelerate the evolutionary process, a brave new world, of disease free and identical people. But is there truly an application for human cloning in our 21st century society? Some scientists argue that one

The Picture of Dorian Gray: Research and Analysis Paper

1028 words - 5 pages the end of chapter five Dorian finds out the truth about Vane and breaks up with her. Dorian only likes Vane because he thinks she is perfect. Wilde uses this to make a statement that society will destroy something the moment it realizes that it is not perfect. The Victorian era is considered a time of progress and improvement. Dorian does not want to be associated with something imperfect so he says, “You have killed my love. You used


347 words - 2 pages Jonas lives in the best society in the world. Think about it, there is no crime, no diseases, or anything bad!. What a perfect place to live. It would be paradise living there, and that's why I am going to tell you how I think this place is a Utopia. In this following essay you will read why this is a Utopia society.To start things off lets talk about how there is no crime. There is no crime because Jonas's society have removed it from were they

Fahrenheit 451 Essay on Family and Society

549 words - 3 pages and don't value relationships. In part two of the novel their concept of family is truly revealed. Their society does not have relationships, they do not love their family members or friends. Mrs. Phelps states that if her husband were to die in war she would not cry and just get married again, she also says she is independent and this is her and her husband's both third marriage. That shows a lot about their society's concept for love, marriage

The Reputation of Anyone Who Is Subjected to Media Scrutiny Will Eventually Be Diminished

566 words - 3 pages well as his undisciplined behavior. However, he is still the model of presidents in American history who play an important role in drawing American economy to the right track and tackling many problems rooted in the American society. Thus, since a hero is common person in his daily life, we can not set a perfect moral image for them. Ultimately, I maintain that media should serve as the beat means for propaganda the positive influence of

Capitalism vs. Communism

771 words - 4 pages years the capitalistic economy system has been the most influential economical as well as political system. Like capitalism communism also has many benefits for its people. First everyone has a job and is treated the same. Communism can be defined as an economic and political system in which facts of production are collectively owned and directed by the state (essay.com 1). In a perfect society, communism would be desired to

Devience Is Socially Defined

1789 words - 8 pages society” (Merton, 2002) The American society is the perfect example of a society that exerts unreasonable pressures, and therefore leads some of its members to deviant behavior (Merton, 2002) New Social Theory The new social theory suggests that deviancy is people simply responding normally to the social situation in which they are. Merton states that some social structures exert definite pressures upon certain persons in the society to engage in

Brave new world - Embrace misfits?

1446 words - 6 pages already perfect world. The following paragraphs will discuss that by abolishing feelings, individuality and intellect to perfect a community, faults and outcasts are emphasised. In the world today, people are encouraged to value the family. Incorporated with a family is sex. A portion of females in our society today, are brought up to cherish their virtue and taught that sex is a very sacred and special thing that should be only shared with the one

Related Papers

The Republic, By Plato Essay

1030 words - 5 pages Plato’s ideal society is one that depends on the just actions of its people. In his utopia, all men and women are able to maximize their potential and in turn utilize their talents and skills for the good of all. Happy citizens form a happy society. This perfect society has been both praised and criticized on the basis of some radical elements it possesses: The citizens of Plato’s ideal society are able to curb their self-interest, and because

Hero Quest Essay

662 words - 3 pages relatable and able to fit into society. These modern heroes are expected to uphold a strong moral code and under every circumstance at least make an attempt to save the endangered. While we always want them to win battles, society also accepts that heroes may make mistakes, become injured and even die while fighting for the cause they are defending. Still being seemingly perfect with their good looks, intelligence and power, these new heroes have

War Against Terrorism In Pakistan Essay

809 words - 4 pages Class 9th English Guess Paper | | |Important Questions from Prose Section: | |Why did Alamo Equal want a separate state for the Muslims of India? | |Define Nursing? Who was Florence Nightingale? | |How do we get

Fat Essay

709 words - 3 pages bellies hanging out. The men in this picture were smiling, laughing and obviously having a good time. In another picture, I see two models with perfect, curvy, slim stomach, long legs, beautiful face and great bodies. I also noticed that in this picture the women are laughing and having a good time. In both pictures the men ad women seem to be happy and satisfied with their images. In the society that we live in today, the human body is the center of