Afghanistan After 2014 Essay

1263 words - 6 pages

Afghanistan after 2014

Munir Akram

VIEWED through today’s political telescope, Afghanistan’s future appears as turbulent as it’s past, and ominous for Pakistan.

Hope for peace in Afghanistan was aroused when President Barack Obama declared that US (and Nato) troops would be fully withdrawn from Afghanistan by 2014 and responsibility for security and governance transferred to the Afghan National Army and the Kabul government. Apart from being responsive to domestic American sentiment, withdrawal is sensible, since the principal US aim of destroying Al Qaeda ‘Central’ in Afghanistan has been largely achieved and the Taliban-Pakhtun insurgency is unlikely to be suppressed militarily.
...view middle of the document...

Nor is the US Congress likely to continue allocating over $20bn annually to subsidise the Afghan government and army. Without money, and without a political solution, it is likely that the Afghan army will splinter into rival ethnic militias and the Kabul government may simply disintegrate.

It seems that the US has doubts about its own publicly propagated plans. It is pressing Karzai to accept a ‘strategic partnership’ which — contrary to the Obama pledge — would allow the US to station an unidentified number of its troops for an undetermined period of time in Afghanistan after 2014 for ‘training’ and support to the Afghans. A permanent US military presence in Afghanistan will almost certainly mean there will be no real negotiations with the Taliban or other Afghan insurgents.

Since the US is unlikely to be able to suppress the insurgency with a smaller force than it has at present in Afghanistan, it will need to rely on continued support from the Northern Alliance to sustain its presence. The Afghan civil war would thus continue and even intensify. The rump American force would probably be stationed in protected bases, capable of punitive forays against the insurgents but unable to ‘hold’, much less ‘build’ in most of south and east Afghanistan. As in the past, most of the blame for failure would be transferred to Pakistan. Acrimony could escalate to actual conflict, as witnessed last week.

For this reason, and because of the threat of possible US military intervention from Afghanistan against its nuclear and strategic capabilities, Pakistan is likely to oppose the permanent American military presence in Afghanistan. Iran too must be concerned about possible US or Israeli strikes against its nuclear and military facilities and thus likely to be strongly opposed to an indefinite US presence. The opposition of Afghanistan’s two most important neighbours will render the continued US military presence in Afghanistan extremely difficult to sustain.

Given its proclivity to use force, it is entirely unclear if the US genuinely desires a dialogue with the Taliban. More likely, it wants, in Gen Petraeus’ words, to “whack” them to the negotiating table. This is unlikely to happen. And, so long as the Northern Alliance leaders and other warlords are confident of continued American dependence on them, they are unlikely to be amenable to any plan Pakistan or others propose for a political settlement with the Taliban. It is only if and when they see the imminence of total American withdrawal from Afghanistan that the hard-liners in the Northern Alliance will become open to an accommodation with their Pakhtun opponents.

Thus, it is not surprising that the Kayani peace plan — to start with a mutual halt in hostilities followed by dialogue and political accommodation — has not evoked active support from Washington or Kabul. Awaiting resolution of the policy contradictions in Washington, Pakistan has temporised so...

Other Essays Like Afghanistan After 2014

Launching Military Coup Is Justified Essay

1680 words - 7 pages against such an autocratic government actually speeds the process of democratization as the incoming government needs legitimacy; something a democratic election can provide.3 This debate is written shortly after the 2014 coup in Thailand but it is not specifically about that coup this because it has not fully played out at the time of writing so it is difficult to know precisely what the intentions of the coup leaders are. Secondly it is quite a

Change Management Essay

3235 words - 13 pages Essay Questions for Cirric Development Q#1 Lord George Robertson was known as an independent-minded leader who takes personal decisions seriously. For instance, he opposed the decision to unilaterally disarm nuclear weapons.[1] However, it is pertinent to mention that some of the decisions made by Robertson have been quite illogical. He was expected to support the disarmament proposal after joining NATO even though he never showed any

Research Paper

1682 words - 7 pages Persist. Harvard University, n.d. Web. 06 Feb. 2015. "PTSD: National Center for PTSD." Mental Health Effects of Serving in Afghanistan and Iraq -. U.S. Department of Veteran's Affairs, 3 Jan. 2014. Web. 06 Feb. 2015. "US Veterans and Military Families | Costs of War." US Veterans and Military Families | Costs of War. N.p., n.d. Web. 06 Feb. 2015.

Unmanned Technologies: Drawbacks of This Policy

3426 words - 14 pages Joel Perez Professor Stoil Organizing War December 12, 2014 What have been the chief motivations behind the development and deployment of unmanned technologies and what are the chief drawbacks in this policy? With the advancements in robotics, unmanned battlefield technology seems to be the military’s newest obsession. This policy of unmanned vehicles came to the attention of the American public with heavy drone use under President

Dr. Watson–– the Time Epitome

1937 words - 8 pages alterations of Dr. Watson within current Holmesian adaptations provide an insight into how modern-texts continue to use Watson to represent and cater to its twenty-one-century audiences. In BBC’s TV series Sherlock, directed by Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss, John Watson is portrayed as a former military doctor back from Afghanistan. Throughout Sherlock, John Watson is still characterized as a loyal, professional, moral and ordinary partner of

Promote the Best Qualified, or Consider Diversity?

2626 words - 11 pages , Native-Americans, Pacific Islanders, and more that help balance out its demographic profile. Soldiers who are Caucasian make up the majority of the Army demographic (Army G1, 2014). What is most impressive is the ability for everyone to work together to accomplish the Army’s mission with so few cases of equal opportunity violations per capita. While the Army celebrates diversity by recognizing different women and minorities during certain

Effects of Deployment on Military Families: a Literature Review

2493 words - 10 pages ; Lester & Flake, 2013; Lowe, Adams, Browne, & Hinkle, 2012; Paley, Lester, & Mogil, 2013). The effects of deployment can occur before, during, and after the deployent itself. Link and Palinkas (2013) states, “For over a decade, the deployment of US military personnel to the conflicts in Iraq (OIF/OND: Operations Iraqi Freedom and New Dawn) and Afghanistan (OEF: Operation Enduring Freedom) has been a significant stressor for military

Habeas Corpus and the Rights

2094 words - 9 pages The Right of Habeas Corpus Lavina Kindlon POL 201 Professor Chancey June 27, 2014 The Right of Habeas Corpus Introduction Throughout antiquity, the inspiration of man’s personal significance has been fulfilled in the dominance of those with insignificance or no authority in the nonexistence of the reign of the law. The war on terror has bestowed the United States with an arbitrary confrontation while terrorists are dispossessed of

Turkemistant Swot Analysis

1685 words - 7 pages Turkmenistan is one of the Turkic states in Central Asia bordered by Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Afghanistan, Iran, and the Caspian Sea. It gained its independence upon the dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991. Upon researching the country and reading different articles, I will be conducting a SWOT analysis to evaluate the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats involved with the country. Strengths being characteristics of the

Video Game Influence

3267 words - 14 pages causing the pain tolerance, it is still a sure way that is used as treatment. Another study was done involving children in the matter. It seemed that virtual reality distraction worked in kids, but only for a small amount of time. Those over ten years of age, however, could tolerate pain for much longer periods of time. Sam Brown was a lieutenant in the U.S. Army. He was deployed to Kandahar, Afghanistan in 2008. On the last day of his mission, he

Habeus Corpus

3250 words - 13 pages Article 1, Section 9 of the Constitution it states that “The Privilege of the Writ of Habeas Corpus shall not be suspended, unless when in Cases of Rebellion or Invasion the public Safety may require it” (Longley 2006). This means that detainees and people imprisoned have the right to know why they are being detained, the right not to be imprisoned or detained without a trial and the right to this amendment regardless of what is written after

Related Papers

Recent Upsurge In Foreign Military Intervention In Africa, A Case Study Mali

1025 words - 5 pages crime and potential intensification of separatism and sectarian discord among Iraq’s neighbours. The spillovers identified hold true for Afghanistan as well. The United Nations High Commission for Refugees (UNHCR), estimates there are roughly 600,000 internal displaced people (IDPs) in Afghanistan, with a refugee population of 1.6 million living across the border in Pakistan. The UNHCR expects this numbers to increase by end of year 2014

Assignment 6.3

654 words - 3 pages Jones International University Case Study — Groupon vs. LivingSocial: Coupon Wars Assignment 6.3 Instructor Terry Miller BBA304 Marketing Management By Daniel Rhodes Kabul, Afghanistan July 12, 2014 Groupon vs. LivingSocial: Coupon Wars After reviewing our course material this week and reviewing the case study, I believe LivingSocial is using the Sales-Oriented Pricing Objectives approach. With this approach

How Is Building A Brand In A B2 B Context Different From Doing So In The Consumer Market

626 words - 3 pages CASE STUDY VIII Employment Law For Human Resource Practice ALTHEA E. McFADDEN Professor: 2 October 2014 TO: Pepsi Cola Distribution Company – Mr. Joseph Snuffy CEO FROM: Mrs. Althea E. McFadden – Human Resource Manager Date: August 26, 2014 Re: Mr. David Doe – Discrimination Due to Military Obligation A four tour veteran of Afghanistan and Iraq Mr. Snuffy is

The Army Profession And The American Culture

1301 words - 6 pages gets life without parole. Retrieved January 20, 2014, from http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/08/23/us-usa-afghanistan-trial-idUSBRE97L0YV20130823. ----------------------- Tables and Figures are placed after the Reference Page. See Table and Figure documents posted in Doc Sharing that show correct formatting. . Remove this text box prior to typing in this page