All My Sons Essay

1701 words - 7 pages

All My Sons In the play All My Sons, as in Death of a Salesman, love is the basis of all the evil and tragic events that happen in the play. The play involves the Keller family, of which the two boys are grown men. One of the sons, Larry, went to war and was reported missing. The family never knew what happened to him. While the father, Joe, and other son, Chris, have come to realize that after three years he must be dead, the mother, Kate, refuses to believe it. Joe worked for a factory that made parts for the fighter pilots in the war. He was accused of murder when twenty one planes crashed because the part that Keller had made had a crack in them. He was sent to jail, but later released ...view middle of the document...

From all this it's plain to see that even though the circumstances are depressing, the action inside the family is very positive and sanguine.At the end of the play, when Joe is trying to defend himself against his son, trying to explain to him why he allowed the defective parts to be used, he uses the excuse that he did it for him. "Joe: "¦Chris"¦Chris, I did it for you, it was a chance and I took it for you. I'm sixty-one years old, when would I have another chance to make something for you? Sixty-one years old you don't get another chance, do ya?"12 Not only does this show that Joe loved his son, but it shows how love was the reason for the calamity. Joe believed that he hadn't done anything wrong, that he had had a good reason for what he did; this reason was his love for his son. He had lost sight of reality when he excused himself for what he had done, but he had persevered to overcome this incident, but despite his persistence it had caught up with him and engulfed him in his guilt. As a result of his son's rejection, and the realization that his other son had killed himself because of what he had done, Joe Keller kills himself. Joe had tried to do what he thought was best for his family, out of his love for them, but it backfired on him and he couldn't live with himself knowing that his sons despised him. The literary critic, Barry Gross, addresses this topic in one of his criticisms of this play, and more specifically of Joe Keller. "Joe's suicide is less a moral judgment than an act of love"¦ Joe commits his second anti-social crime in the name of the same love that motivated the first."13 From this passage Gross shows that Keller committed suicide for what he believed to be the right reason. In Joe Keller's mind, he was doing it for the greater good of his family. Although this may seem sick and twisted to many people, it proves that the tragedy was for a meaningful purpose, and was a positive thing. This is from the view of the main character, and most likely doesn't coincide with the opinion of other people.Although All My Sons is a tragedy and something terrible happens at the end, the overall view is a positive one. It shows the strength of love, and the extent that people will go to for it. More specifically it shows a man's devotion to his family, what he would do, and not do to keep his family together. In spite of the fact that what he did was wrong, the reason he did it was for the greater good of the ones he loved.What Defines a Tragedy The definition of tragedy has been argued for thousands of years. Literary scholars have different ideas, none of them wrong, but distinct in their own ways. Some have loose definitions, with very flexible standards. There are others that believe quite the opposite, having very strict definitions with no room for variations. Aristotle was one of these latter scholars. His definition was very exact, with no room for flexibility. He believed that, "A tragedy is the...

Other Essays Like All My Sons

All My Sons by Arthur Miller

789 words - 4 pages The play takes place in the confines of the Keller backyard. This location is simple and deceptively mundane. Miller describes the setting of All My Sons in the stage directions as the “back yard of the Keller home in the outskirts of an American town” (5). While Miller left out the town’s name in the script, the location is thematically significant for him, and therefore it can also be significant to us. Although he describes the house itself

Death Of A Salesman And All My Sons As Optimistic Tragedies

4243 words - 17 pages Death of a Salesman and All My Sons as Optimistic Tragedies     This essay deals with Arthur Miller, and his uniqueness as a tragic playwright. The research question that this paper attempted to answer was, why were Miller's plays different from many other tragedies. Two of Arthur Miller's tragedies were used in this essay, Death of a Salesman and All My Sons. The thesis of this essay is, Arthur Miller deviates from the standard

A Father/Son Relationship

827 words - 4 pages A Father and Son Relationship Life in the 1940s was a very male-dominant time. The father was the head of the house and his work was passed on to his sons. A solid relationship between a father and his sons was essential to sustaining a strong household. If the relationship began to decline, the whole family collapsed. Death of a Salesman is a play by Arthur Miller in 1949. It tells a story of how the relationship between Willy, the

Grief of a Child

566 words - 3 pages FAR EASTERN UNIVERSITY January 22, 2011 GRIEF OF A CHILD These two photos were taken when I was only 9 or 10 months. I was with Lolo Peping, my grandfather, in the first picture. My parents were never married. My mother had her first husband and two sons before my father came into her life. Like any other couples, by doing the deed, I was the result of the love of my parents… And so, on the 7th day of November 1993, a beautiful


510 words - 3 pages am, and what I have done.Now I wish that I could change the rainy days, and long dark nights that I spent away from home, and that my ex-wife would take me back.I want to be with my sons, and I want to teach them not to be like me, but to be strong, and to be not a womanizer, such as all the older men in their lives.I......................... (to be continued)

The Realism Of Authur Miller

326 words - 2 pages Author Millers dramatic plays inflect a social realism as the personal or general character of an individual relates to society, a social consciousness.Author Millers plays reflect a social realism in the way the individual relates to society. The methods he uses in experimentation result it a social consciousness and social responsibility. The social reality of the individual consciousness and the consequences as in "All my Sons" and the effect

Grade 10 History Editorial

557 words - 3 pages and sons are in Europe risking their lives every day for the greater good of Britain? But now the cowards can be forced to go to war to help our brothers, fathers and sons because of conscription! I hear you asking “What is conscription?”, “Who will it affect the most?” and “Why should I vote for conscription?” All good questions which I am going to answer. Conscription is forcing men over the age of 18 to enlist in the Canadian armed forces

How to Be a Good Son or Daughter

619 words - 3 pages important qualities of a good son or daughter. First of all, a good son or daughter should be a hard working person. A good child usually makes parents happy, and parents are happy when their children do what they are supposed to do. For example, if a child is a student, she is supposed to study hard. If she studies hard, whether she gets good grade or not, her parents are pleased with her. In addition, in Vietnam we value children as good sons

Term Paper

1502 words - 7 pages THE FROG PRINCESS Long ago, in ancient times, there was a king who had three sons, all of them grown. The king said: “My children, let each of you make a bow for himself and shoot an arrow. She who brings back you arrow will be your bride; he whose arrow is not brought back will not marry.” The eldest son shot his arrow, and a general’s daughter brought it back to him. The second shot his arrow and landowners haughtier brought it back to him

The Virus of Evil in Shakespeare's Macbeth

953 words - 4 pages , it continues to steer him on the path of evil. For example Macbeth states, "Put rancors in the vessel of my peace Only for them, and mine eternal jewel Given to the common enemy of man To make them kings, the seeds of Banquo kings. Rather than so, come fate into the list, And champion me to th' utterance." After the death of Duncan, Banquo and his sons are in succession to be king, which causes problems for Macbeth

Love In The Odyssey

1254 words - 6 pages either the husband or the wife. Even the gods do this act. “Come, my beloved, let us to the couch, Vulcan is here no longer; he is gone.” Thus, Cytherea and Ares committed adultery and violated the marriage covenant. Most importantly they disarrayed their family. Despite all of Odysseus’s faults, his marriage bed has remained sacred; no one has defiled it from the twenty years he has been away. His wife has been loyal to him even when sorely tried

Related Papers

All My Sons Essay

855 words - 4 pages ‘All my Sons’ By Arthur Miller ‘All my sons’ by Arthur Miller is a play that is about an average American family who has made a lot of money from a business that made parts for plane engines during the war. The play is set in the back garden of the family home, the father Joe Keller has a guilty secret which only his wife Kate knows. Joe has 2 sons, Chris has fought in the war and his personality has changed from a greedy and self-centred

All My Sons Essay

581 words - 3 pages Chris in the play All My Sons. After George’s visit, Chris begins to distrust his father after finding out that he was the person to be blamed for the death of those 21 pilots. Chris is amazed that his father was able to kill those 21 pilots for the good of the business. Chris thinks that what his father did was wrong and he should pay for what he did. Chris is right and Keller is completely wrong. Chris stated that he looked up to Keller as his

All My Sons Essay 3

1151 words - 5 pages Courtney Krus 4th hour AP Lit Throughout the play All My Sons by Arthur Miller, Kate Keller hopes that time will stand still for everyone so that her family’s past won’t become publicized, and realizes that while she may be stuck in time everyone else is moving on. She also denies the fact that her son, Larry, has died and that her husband is responsible for the death of 21 solders so that her family will survive. Kate does those

View Of War In All My Sons

833 words - 4 pages All My Sons, a play by Arthur Miller, tells predominantly the story of the Kellers. This play takes place after World War II, in the year 1947. It is a criticism of the “American Dream,” which can be defined as a life of personal happiness and material comfort as traditionally sought by those in the U.S. The pursuit of the American Dream consisted of anything tangible, such as things, numbers and people. There is no mention of anything