America Beyond Nation State Essay

1428 words - 6 pages

   In his book: “Who Are We? The Challenges to America’s National Identity”, Samuel P. Huntington showed his strong worries with the American identity.
   According to this book, Huntington thought because of lack of common enemies and opposites, the cohesion power and common identity of American people diminished in the past twenty years. He also blamed the Latino immigrants, especially the Mexican immigrants for threatening the American political foundation with the impact on American culture and language they brought. Under this circumstance, he called on a more concrete American identity, which not only includes the “American creed”, but also embodies a core culture. Different with ...view middle of the document...

As follows, I have six arguments to support this conclusion.
   First, American peoples are ones of the most patriotic peoples in the world, while United States is never a real nation-state no matter ethnically or culturally. Huntington’s statement that America has a historical mainstream of Anglo-Protestantism is untenable. There is never one ethnic group or culture dominating America since independence. Even in the colonial period there were American Indians and African Americans living on this land. American people do not have a common blood, a common art system, or even a common history. Without shared cultural symbol and common memory, the “American” ethnicity cannot be established. In this case, why are American people still so patriotic? Different from most of the other countries, most American people are not “born” American, instead, they, or their parents and grandparents, “choose” to be American. In present world, with people generally awakened and personal choice outweighing inborn attribute, this way of becoming citizens with American characteristics actually create firmer nationality.
   Second, what makes American people superior from the initial Mayflower is mainly not their British ethnicity or their Protestant religion belief, but their “settler” identity. It is this identity that distinguishes colonial people from their suzerain in personality and class. Most of the great characteristics of American people, such as courage, ambition, independence, openness, and justice, are inherited from this settler tradition. And these virtues, not some inflexible bloodlines, are what American people should get from their ancestry.
   Third, even if America is not an absolute “immigration” country, America is not an absolute “settler” country either. It is deeply shaped by immigration throughout all its history. The settlers might dominate the American culture at the beginning, but for centuries there are always new immigrants becoming American. Although it is immigrants inspired by the existing American people and culture at the beginning, existing American people also learn from these “new” American people as well. Continuous immigrants continuously inject fresh blood into and offer new options and contrast to America. In this way, American culture and identity keep developing and progressing, in accord with contemporary American people, and in pace with the world.
   Fourth, the most important good of nation-state is to achieve common recognition towards state and its regime through equating nation to state and a natural national identity, but this function is useless to United States. United States derives its political legitimacy from the active participation of its citizenry. All the American people have had a social contract with the state since they choose to be American. And the fundament of the regime also lies in the “American creed”. Since this mechanism is more direct and stable, why should they shift to nation-state?

Other Essays Like America Beyond Nation-State

Homelessness in America Essay

1027 words - 5 pages interventions need to continue. Efforts include developing consistent and better methodologies for conducting the annual point-in-time counts of homeless persons. In addition, the HUD requirement that youth be included in the point-in-time counts will provide much needed information on an overlooked homeless subpopulation and provide a more comprehensive view of homelessness in the United States.” (The State of Homelessness in America, Internet

Citing Specific Evidence from Chaucer's Canterbury Tales (Not from the Textbook), How "Religious" Was Medieval Society (or Was It Not Religious

2721 words - 11 pages What We Owe Iraq: War and the Ethics of Nation Building, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2004. · Francis Fukuyama (ed.) Nation-Building: Beyond Afghanistan and Iraq, Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2006. · Williams H. Garland Engineering Peace: The Military Role in Postconflict Reconstruction, Washington, DC: United States Institute of Peace Press, 2005. · Raymond A. Hinnebusch The International Politics of the Middle East

Lexus and the Olive Tree

990 words - 4 pages (almost ten years after 9/11). Could the two be related? All in all, the idea of globalization is still a work in progress and not terribly out of reach for America. The events on and following 9/11 definitely changed history and international relations, but not beyond repair. Friedman’s advice still holds true. “we can do this by supporting our public schools, paying our taxes, understanding that the government is not the enemy and always making sure we’re still getting to know our neighbors over the fence and not over the Web” (p. 174).

The Statesmen, the Writer, and the Military Man

1712 words - 7 pages The Statesman, The Writer, and the Military Man: How George Washington, Thomas Paine, and Andrew Jackson Helped Construct America’s Identity All of America’s founding fathers contributed greatly to the formation of the United States and helped build this nation through their accomplishments and dedication to making their home a better place for all Americans. But of the 55-plus men whom history has given the name of “founding father,” the

Post Colonial Thoughts of Iqbal, Jinnah, Nehru and Gandhi

4707 words - 19 pages , looked for Muslim to be aware of each other and possess unity not only based on a vague geographical concept of nation but rather on religious grounds adhering to a higher Power. In light of such view, we can say that Iqbal was promoting religious unity and hence not an ‘imagined’ community. Iqbal primarily looked at Muslim’s to return to the state of how a Muslim society should have been in the times of the advent of Islam (Naim, 1984; Vahid

International Business

1438 words - 6 pages Islamic) Keniichi ohmae s pharase ‘ the boardless world ‘ , captures the sense of radical progress and modernity , and of life beyond of the constrain of the traditional nation state. Which infuses much of the popular writing about globalization (ohmae 1990 ).certainly the concept has meaning for those in senior management position . in growing innovative companies ,internet user communication spesialis., frequent business , shop around and

Is the United States Following in the Footsteps of Ancient Rome’s Decline?

1325 words - 6 pages America has not come yet. America, according to the effect of history, will not reign forever. It logical in the motion of history to understand that U.S. reign is only another period in history waiting to be recorded. The Roman Empire and the U.S. has similarities and differences in their functioning of the state. The U.S. has found the connection of the three ingredients to a successful nation-state. It is only logical to understand the

Rsst1 Nation, State, and Nation-State

2519 words - 11 pages , they are also citizens and residents of Kurdistan and share a national identity and culture which specifically corresponds to the geopolitical boundaries of Kurdistan. This shared identity is unique to the people of Kurdistan and is not shared amongst Kurds in general. It is this overlap of national identity and state sovereignty which defines a nation-state. The United States of America is an example of a nation-state and one that we will explore

Where Would the World Be Without Mlk Jr

1190 words - 5 pages of the movement, it was about more than getting a seat in a restaurant or on a bus; it was about making America truer to its best self. Martin Luther King Jr., who has come to symbolize the movement, recognized that and saw beyond the battles of the moment. He looked toward universal human rights and toward brotherhood that transcended color and nationhood. He didn't lose sight of immediate struggles, but his philosophy, his motivations and his

Views of Jonathan Bayard Smith for a Debate

550 words - 3 pages firmly disagree that we must ratify an entirely new constitution to achieve this goal. The Establishment of a more significant and thus powerful central government is consequential for the prosperity of our young nation. The reasons behind this statement are that in order for America to maintain international credit it must appear fully united in the eyes of European Nations therefore allowing America to borrow both domestically and abroad which is

American History Examination Essay

2049 words - 9 pages to be the best, to be superior, which the U.S has clearly shown in the Middle East. From the birth of America, to America today, the driving force and the heart of America has always been the "American Dream." By looking at America today, the most powerful nation in the world, the dream has literally become a reality. The United States has always strived to be superior and it is today the most powerful nation in the world. The United States right now can not go much farther than it has already reached. If it tries to go beyond the dream, it could become a nightmare.

Related Papers

Captains Of Industry Essay

594 words - 3 pages 1890s when the United States' decided to expained their controls beyond the North American Continent. Since then, it has changed changed significantly because the world has changed. We have become a much larger, industrialized, socially, economically, as well as politically stable county. The department of State sends ambassadors to one hundren and eight nations. Throught negotiations, America works to maintain peaceful allies and to support a

The Us: Communist Or Capitalist? Essay

555 words - 3 pages state, control a country's trade and industry for profit. The United States of America is not communist but capitalist because America does not share land between citizens, does not force the disabled to work, and Americans can communicate how they please and ship their goods wherever. The United States of America allows citizens to own private property, unlike communist nations that Marx describes in his essay. In a communist nation, the

Think Piece: Beyond The Euphoria Essay

1260 words - 6 pages This editorial article taken from the Jamaican Gleaner Newspaper entitled "Beyond the Euphoria" contains valid and prudent commentary. It is based on the myopic view of the fifty years independence and Olympic success celebrations which outcast real issues faced by the nation. The writer gives his opinion that although they have reasons to engage in merriment there are problems facing their nation which they should direct their attention to

The Colonies Essay

826 words - 4 pages many more issues beyond simply cutting the ties with Great Britain; they also had to create and maintain a working system of rules which could guide them into becoming the United States of America. Once Independence was gained in 1783, the Articles of Confederation were created, but with many deep flaws in the system. The Federal government had no power, and the states were loosely held together and hardly acted as if they were a single united