This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

An Evaluation Of Singer Essay

1352 words - 6 pages

Logic: Peter Singer
An Evaluation of Singer
Peter Singer questions our conception of equality as it relates to the human species and other animal species. He fundamentally argues that, “The principle of the equality of human beings is not a description of an alleged actual equality among humans: it is a prescription of how we should treat humans.” The statement, revealing Singer’s essential argument, also comprises two approaches we might take towards establishing equality among living things. Let’s trace Singer’s claims surrounding these two approaches and finally consider his fundamental, philosophical assumption.
One approach to equality stems from philosophers, who determine a ...view middle of the document...

Furthermore, evidence suggest that abilities may associate with certain races and sexes more than others; that is, abilities may derive from genes rather than the environment, but studies are still inconclusive.
The case of Singer against the argument from“factual equality” is largely inductive, tracing the reasoning of the argument to its logical conclusion. While it rests on deductive principles of logic, Singer gathers evidence to construe his argument inductively. He begins with the assertions of his opponents, presents examples of low-functioning humans and high-functioning non-humans, and concludes that his opponent’s reasoning is difficult to maintain. As long as Singer is presenting his opponents fairly, which I have reason to believe he does, his argument is strong. Based upon attributes and capacities, such as IQ, exceptional cases of human disability to call attribute-determined equality into question.
The other approach to equality is from presumption. Singer claims that if we begin with the prescription, “all humans are equal” without a basis of ability, it is quite difficult to exclude animal species from the lot. Singer disfavors one version of the presumption argument. He traces “distinctive human dignity” back to Renaissance humanists and asserts the following:
Once we ask why it should be that all humans—including infants, mental defectives, psychopaths, Hitler, Stalin, and the rest—have some kind of dignity or worth that no elephant, pig, or chimpanzee can ever achieve, we see that this question is as difficult to answer as our original request for some relevant fact that justifies the inequality of humans and other animals.
In other words, the humanists cannot have their cake and eat it too. They cannot justify the claim that inherent dignity lies only in humans rather than also in non-humans.
From here, Singer forwards a more positive argument. Having demonstrated that we should not logically exclude non-humans from our claims of equality and dignity, he advances that animals deserve our consideration because they are “interested” species, that is, they have the capacity to suffer and to enjoy. He remarks, “If a being is not capable of suffering, or of experiencing enjoyment or happiness, there is nothing to be taken into account.”
Again, Singer reveals the logical conclusions of his opponents, and does so with validity, however, as we shall see in the next section, he overlooks the basis for certain claims to human “dignity.” At this point, we should note that Singer takes up his own version of “factual equality.” He states that the possibilities of suffering and enjoyment constitute the fundamental traits of “interested” species, and therefore, species that deserve consideration within our purview of equality. This claims depends upon Singer’s underlying utilitarian philosophy, which champions the effects of actions and holds these as primary when determining moral decisions.
Counterargument
While Singer...

Other Essays Like An Evaluation of Singer

An Evaluation On The Socio Economic Characteristics Of Solar Lighting Users To Determine The Market Segment For Solar Products As A Basis For Expansion: The Case Of Card Bdsfi Experience, Philippines

1897 words - 8 pages AN EVALUATION ON THE SOCIO ECONOMIC CHARACTERISTICS OF SOLAR LIGHTING USERS TO DETERMINE THE MARKET SEGMENT FOR SOLAR PRODUCTS AS A BASIS FOR EXPANSION A PAPER ON DESCRIPTIVE STATISTICS Submitted to; Dean Agnes Rola In fulfillment of the requirements for PAF 203 2nd sem 2011-2012 University of the Philippines College of Public Affairs CLARISSA M. DIMACULANGAN March, 2012 I. Introduction In the Philippines, until today, some remote

An Evaluation Of Porters Diamond As A Means Of Explaining Why Some Countries And Industries Have Competitive Advantage Over Others

1618 words - 7 pages As internationalisation of the world economy continues to gather pace all aspects of management have to be seen in a global context. This is especially true for corporate strategy. Even if an organization does not plan to import or to export directly, management has to look at the international business environment, as it will inevitably have an affect on their business activities. They have to consider how the actions of competitors, buyers

The Rise of Sound Film

1823 words - 8 pages value of a film, some people do not. Jonathan D. Tankel noted that “The Jazz Singer can be viewed as an important influence on the conversion to sound…The Jazz Singer was dependent as much on its aesthetic qualities and values as its position as the first major film with dialogue. In this sense, The Jazz Singer was the final proof of the success of sound, not the first”. Additionally, it is first really sound film. But also, the producer made

thoreau

436 words - 2 pages Walker KeenanPhilosophic History of American EnvironmentalismProf. Mark Fowler302-11Although Singer is an advocate for humane utilitarianism and Leopold is an advocate for the environmental ethic, they both believe decisions should be guided more by ethics than by economics. However, Leopold expands the definition of what a moral patient is to beyond just animals, while Singer restricts the definition of moral patient to individual animals

The Jazz Singer

854 words - 4 pages Company, and the first one built in Hollywood was founded by filmmaker David Horsley's general manager Al Christie in 1911, in an old building on the southeast corner of Sunset Boulevard and Gower Street. The Jazz Singer was the first feature length movie containing songs and dialogue. The movie was silent for much of its length, the popular American entertainer Al Jolson sang and spoke in only 4 scenes. The film used a vitaphone which is

Acupuncture

800 words - 4 pages Acupuncture is considered to be a new alternative medicine in western society, and has recently become very popular in the United States (“All About Acupuncture”). Acupuncture is the insertion of hair-fine needles into the body’s surface, which is supposed to cause psychological effects on the body to cure the patient of an illness. These illnesses may be emotional mental or physical (Singer). But some doctors question the validity of this

Overview of Famine, Affluence

612 words - 3 pages utilitarianism. A utilitarian would work hard to produce the greatest amount of happiness over any pain. Singer maintains that this is the real world and that theory simply does not apply. I think we all would agree than an idealistic world would be void of pain, suffering, and evils like poverty. The existence of a moral imperative to help those in need was evident in the recent presidential election. If enough people give, small donations can be a powerful social force that can make difference.

Term Paper

1617 words - 7 pages In Peter Singer’s paper on “The Singer Solution to World Poverty,” he explores the possibilities of each and every American giving up about 2/3 of their income. However, rather than simply talking about his own solution as another theory, he tells the reader in so many words that they are wrong. In this paper, I will argue that Singer fails to establish that we are morally required to give to charity. In Peter Singer’s paper he makes the claim

Music Comparison

755 words - 4 pages 1.) Aretha Franklin-Mary J. Blige Modern day Mary J. Blige can be much compared to “The Queen of Soul,” Aretha Franklin. Aretha Franklin is known for one of the best voices in musical history. She is one of the most famous singer, songwriter and pianist, born March 25, 1942. Mary J. Blige is an American recording artist, songwriter, singer, and actress born on January 11, 1971. Blige has received the World Music Legends Award for combining hip

The Power Of DNA In The Courtroom

1142 words - 5 pages geneticists have determined that the chances of somebody having these matching bands is one in 57 billion (Singer pg 1 par 1). Still, the jury acquitted Simpson of the charges. Evidently, the jury needed something more than a DNA test to condemn a man to life in  prison. Even though the DNA was an exact match, because much of the other evidence presented in the case was questionable, the jury opted for reasonable doubt. This is only one

Peter Albert Singer Area 51 Argumentative Essay

946 words - 4 pages be an opportunity for scientists to use alien survivors in experimental studies. Peter Singer in his book ‘animal liberation’ believes in utilitarian idealism as a measure of good ethical behaviors and treatment of animals. He believes that this concept should be applied to animals and that the relationship between animals and humans is only arbitrary (Singer, 1979). He states that there is a big difference only between a great ape and an

Related Papers

An Evaluation Of An Alternative Approach To Quality Control And The Effects

1947 words - 8 pages An evaluation of an alternative approach to quality control and the effects Alternative method for Quality Control that FPS can use Quality control is a system for ensuring the maintenance of proper standards in manufactured goods, especially by periodic random inspections of the product. A strategy that can be used to ensure this and to suit FPS is to test each individual compartment separately this also add value because your in the

Evidence Informed Practice: An Evaluation Of The David Bennett Inquiry Report

3558 words - 15 pages Evidence-Informed Practice: An Evaluation of the David Bennett Inquiry Report In this essay I will evaluate the David Bennett Inquiry Report, which was set up by the North, Suffolk and Cambridgeshire Strategic Health Authority (NSCSHA) to investigate the death of Mr David Bennett. I will define evidence-informed practice (EIP) and summarise the inquiry report. I shall highlight and critically analyse some of the key issues raised in the

An Evaluation Of The Legacy Left By Che In The Radical Ideas And Political Behaviour Of Latin America

1754 words - 8 pages Ernesto ”Che” Guevara “An apostle of the Immaculate Revolution" ------------------------------------------------- A judicious evaluation of the legacy left by Che in the radical ideas and political behaviour of Latin America. "Podran cortar las flores, pero no detendran la primavera." "You may cut the flowers, but it will not stop the spring." (Popular Latin American proverb) The very intention of mine is to provide the reader

Evaluation Of An Existing Health Essay

1164 words - 5 pages which include: Oldorando, Matrassyl and Sunkist. The southern part consists of Ottasol and other neighboring farms that extend to the mountainous regions. This region is purely an agricultural area with almost a third of the land being under rural and commercial forms of farming. Agricultural activities include livestock farming of beef and dairy cattle, pigs and poultry. The residents are also involved in vegetable and fruit farming. Another