Analysis Of Critical Essays On Benito Cereno

1349 words - 6 pages

Analysis of Critical Essays on Benito Cereno


It is possible to divide the critics into two camps regarding Herman Melville's purpose in writing "Benito Cereno." Joseph Schiffman, Joyce Adler, and Sidney Kaplan all argue that Melville wrote the story to make a comment on slavery. On the other hand, Sandra Zagarell and Allan Emery contend that Melville goes beyond slavery and is pointing out other flaws in mid Nineteenth century American notion.


"Benito Cereno" tells the story of a slave revolt on a ship at sea. Schiffman, Adler, and Kaplan argue that Melville wrote the story as a comment on slavery. Schiffman and Adler contend that Melville's novella is a ...view middle of the document...

At the end of the essay, Schiffman contradicts himself by proclaiming that Babo's head being "unabashed" as Benito Cereno, the slave trader, "follow[s] his leader" is an indictment of slavery.



"'Benito Cereno': Slavery and Violence in the Americas" is Joyce Adler's analysis of

Melville's story. While agreeing with Schiffman that Melville wrote an anti-slavery book, she

goes beyond her predecessor by claiming that Melville intended to show intricacies of the

master/slave relationship and the violence that slavery breeds. Adler argues that the master

and slave are "inseparable, irreconcilable, and interchangeable" (82). She points out that Babo

frees himself and subsequently enslaves his former master, Don Benito. She says that

Delano's statement, "Ah, this slavery breeds ugly passions in man," is Melville's indictment

of the practice (86). Adler does not accept Schiffman's color analysis. She contends that black

and white are merely opposites and have no significance other than their relative positions in

the master/slave relationship. She also places the story in a much broader historical context.

She concludes that "Benito Cereno" is Melville's attempt to warn the United States of its

critical flaw: slavery. To this end, Adler includes exhaustive evidence that Melville linked

Spain and the United States in the characters of Benito Cereno and Amasa Delano,




Sidney Kaplan argues in "Herman Melville and the American National Sin: The

Meaning of 'Benito Cereno'" that Melville wrote a book in favor of slavery. He contends that

Babo, and therefore symbolically black, is inherently evil and that Melville intended to show

the innate depravity in blacks. He says that blacks are slaves because they are evil. Kaplan

states that the reverse color imagery of "Moby-Dick" that Schiffman relies on is not present in

"Benito Cereno" (44). He believes the pro-slavery ideas of the story come from Melville's

change in "notions about the innately jolly, minstrel, religious nature of Negroes" (46).

According to Kaplan, Melville's past assumptions are those of Delano at the beginning of the

novella. Kaplan stands in direct contrast to Schiffman: "... nor is Schiffman to the point when

he contends that the anti-slavery intention of 'Benito Cereno' is shown by Melville's mere

choice of the subject of slave revolt" (37). Kaplan argues that the animal imagery that is

present in "Benito Cereno" is not Delano's but Melville's.


To assume that Melville wrote "Benito Cereno" as a far-reaching political statement,

Allan Emery and Sandra Zagarell must make many assumptions. Emery, for instance, focuses

on the implications that "Benito Cereno" makes in regard to Manifest Destiny in his article,

"'Benito Cereno' and Manifest Destiny." He assumes that Melville subscribed to Putnam's

Monthly Magazine, and that he read specific...

Other Essays Like Analysis Of Critical Essays On Benito Cereno

Critical Analysis of the Arab Spring

2598 words - 11 pages Critical Analysis of the Arab Spring A Tunisian male named Bouazizi set himself on fire during late 2010 in protest against the poor economic situation in which he was living (CNN, 2011). Shortly, after other Tunisians took the opportunity to resist their government and possible overthrow the leadership of Ben Ali. Citizens felt as if it was their responsibility to fight for the common good. Simple demonstration against the Tunisian government

Critical Analysis of Raja Ram Pal Case

1027 words - 5 pages Constitution can be a ground to challenge the validity of an Act of Parliament just as it can be a ground to challenge the constitutional validity of a constitutional amendment. It has been submitted on behalf of Union of India that basic structure doctrine is inapplicable to Statutes. Mr. Sachar was, however, at pains to submit arguments in support of affirmative plea in this regard. He referred to Dr. D.C. Wadhwa & Ors. v. State of Bihar &amp

Critical Evaluation of Banking on Ebusiness

2964 words - 12 pages Write critical evaluation of the following article. Submissions will be evaluated based on the thoroughness with which the topic is addressed. Paper should be three to four pages in length. Citigroup is dramatically expanding its Internet presence in an effort to approach its target of 1 billion customers By Bob Violino | | | | itigroup, the financial-services giant formed by the merger last fall of Citicorp and Travelers

Critical Analysis of "The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock"

3555 words - 15 pages     Critical  Analysis  of  “The  Love  Song  of  J.  Alfred  Prufrock”     The  title  of  the  poem  is  Eliot's  first  hint  that  this  is  not  a  traditional  love   poem  at  all.  "J.  Alfred  Prufrock"  is  a  farcical  name,  and  Eliot  wanted  the  subliminal

Critical Analysis Of Problems And Issues In Education

1694 words - 7 pages Analysis & CEO America. (1998). The voucher wars (No. 264). Nelson, J., Palonsky, S., & McCarthy, M. (2010). Critical issues in education. New York: McGraw Hill. No Child Left Behind (2011). Retrived June 2, 2011 from Peterson, P. (2003). A choice between public and private schools: what next for school vouchers. Spectrum: The Journal of State Government. Reed, J. (2011, March 28). School

Pierre Bourdieu's Critical View On The Field Of Te

2250 words - 9 pages "On television" Pierre Bourdieu's critical view on the field of television © Nicolas Germon, february 2001 Contents 1. Introduction 2. On bourdieu's sociology : society as a social space 3. the social re-construction of reality through television 4. "Invisible censorship" and "fast thinkers" 5. The news as a show 6. The influence of television on all fields of cultural production 7. Conclusion 8. Bibliography 1. Introduction The publication

A Critical Analysis of Evolution of Cooperative Federalism and Obstacles Ahead for Its Development

2760 words - 12 pages V SEMESTER B.A.LL.B.(HONS.) COURSE  ARTICLE SUBMISSION A Critical Analysis of Evolution of Cooperative Federalism and Obstacles Ahead for Its Development For the academic year 2014-15  Prepared & Submitted by: Submitted To : Bharat Singh (12BAL112) Ms. Alinkrita Tripathi Acknowledgment This study is the culmination of the efforts of a number of individuals and organizations. I gratefully acknowledge the support and

A critical Marxist analysis of figurational theories justification of pain and injury within boxing

2740 words - 11 pages A critical Marxist analysis of figurational theories justification of pain and injury within boxing. Pain and injury has existed as a part of sports for thousands of years. However it is only recently that sociologist have begun to explore pain and injury from a sociological perspective. Most of the research that has been conducted in the field of pain and injury was primarily concerned with the bio-medical model and viewed pain and

Critical Thinking Application Paper on Child Illness of Acute Lymphoblastic Leukemia (All)

719 words - 3 pages 29th day of his treatment a minimal residual disease (MRD) test by biopsying Anthony’s bone marrow. It was a test that was looked under a microscope and evaluated how many leukemia cells are in every thousand cells. The gathering of the minimal residual disease (MRD) data was being gathered as a predictor of outcomes. Our decision to enroll Anthony on a critical trial did not come without seriously taken everything into consideration

Effectiveness Analysis of an Imc Plan – Analysis on Djuice

3863 words - 16 pages |Effectiveness analysis of an IMC plan – analysis on Djuice. | |Research Report | | | | | Table of Contents Contents Executive Summary 3 Background 4 Statement of the Problem 11 Approach to the Problem 12 Research Design 14

Analysis Of The Impact Of Fta On Singapore

4456 words - 18 pages ------------------------------------------------- ANALYSIS OF THE IMPACT OF FTA ON SINGAPORE’S TRADE AND RELATIONSHIP WITH ITS ASIAN NEIGHBOURS MIB39 GROUP A INSTRUCTOR: Phil EYRE GROUP MEMBERS: Janani GANESAN Rohan GULAGI Elea GINO Matilde GOMEZ GUZMAN TABLE OF CONTENTS Sr No | Title | Page Number | 1 | Introduction | 3 | 2 | Summary and Scope | 3 | 2.1 | Tariff Reduction | 3 | 2.2 | Outward Sourcing | 4

Related Papers

Analysis Of A Critical Situation

967 words - 4 pages Analysis of a Critical Regulatory Issue in Health Care Alfreda Bostick HCS/430 December 5, 2011 Lori Lewellen Analysis of a Critical Regulatory Issue in Health Care There are many types of critical regulatory issues that trouble the medical field. Never has anything been more important that the critical regulatory issue been more important than dealing with life or death. When a situation of this nature arises, a person must follow his

Critical Analysis Of Joyce's Araby

1046 words - 5 pages Analysis of “Araby” In many cultures, childhood is considered a carefree time, with none of the worries and constraints of the “real world.” In “Araby,” Joyce presents a story in which the central themes are frustration, the longing for adventure and escape, and the awakening and confusing passion experienced by a boy on the brink of adulthood. The author uses a single narrator, a somber setting, and symbolism, in a minimalist

Free Essays Psychological Analysis Of Hawthorne's Young Goodman Brown

906 words - 4 pages Psychological Analysis of Young Goodman Brown                Most of the works can be analyzed by one of the three critical approaches: traditional, formalistic or psychological approach.  When it comes to Young Goodman Brown (by Nathaniel Hawthorne), I think that psychological approach is the best one to use.  The story is all about the three components of our

Critical Analysis Of "To Kill A Mockingbird"

1752 words - 8 pages Task 2: Critical Analysis Ngien Sing Jier For this semester, we are analysing a novel entitled ‘To Kill a Mockingbird’ written by Harper Lee. I find this novel very meaningful and interesting to read as well. After reading and analysing the novel a few times along with the teachings of my lecturer, I can differentiate the story told from different perspectives, parts when Scout was young and parts when she was an adult. It is about the life