Analytical Critique Essay

1579 words - 7 pages

Quality Research Article Critique Factors Influencing Emergency Use of Nurse Practitioners: A Critique
Problem and Purpose
This is critique of a Qualitative Nursing article, the article is: Factors Influencing the Decision to Use Nurse Practitioners in the Emergency Department by Laurie A. McGee, MN, ARNP and Louise Kaplan, PhD, ARNP, published in Journal of Emergency Nursing, Volume 33, Number 5, October 2007. The problem that is stated in the article is there is a growing and serious problem facing the overcrowding of emergency rooms within the United States. There is a current epidemic of the population that relies on emergency room care as primary care. “The 2004 National Hospital ...view middle of the document...

The purpose of the study is clearly stated and is to “determine factors that influence the decision to use nurse practitioners in the emergency department.”
Emergency rooms cannot turn away non-emergent patients. Facilities that only use physicians will need to evaluate all emergent and non-emergent patients. The non-emergent patients can be seen by nurse practitioners. The research question is broad enough for a qualitative approach of the reasons and factors regarding hospital view of hiring nurse practitioners. “One national survey of hospitals, however, found that only 17% of respondents employed nurse practitioners in the emergency department and only an additional 9% were planning to hire new nurse practitioners. This low level of employment of nurse practitioners in emergency departments occurs despite nurse practitioners having a proven record of professional performance and effectiveness in their ED roles.”
Methods, Design and Approach
Qualitative studies facilitate exploration to a research approach that allows for an issue or phenomenon that is no readily understood, to be explored through a holistic or multi-faceted view. Using the design study a qualitative exploratory study, this investigated factors influencing the decision to use nurse practitioners in the emergency department. Exploratory studies are describes as descriptive studies even if they describe relationships and associations Survey and mixed methods are most commonly used in qualitative studies as well as an initial study into a issue and this was a pilot study. The setting of emergency departments is appropriate to the study. The study used a convenience study of five emergency department managers, four of which participated. The study was approved by the internal review board and all the rights of the participants were protected, even the right to not participate which one of the five requested to participate had the right to not participate. The study was conducted using an interview process which is appropriate for qualitative exploratory studies. The four emergency room participants were scheduled for interviews, at their convenience, and informed consents were obtained before interview to protect the rights of the participants. The research team used audio tapes and conducted semi-structured interviews. The audio tapes were then copied verbatim into transcripts then the transcripts were analyzed using content analysis. Qualitative studies do not typically use a detailed procedure upfront, so the researchers allowed for all for participants to share other data such as the number of emergency department visits per year and how many were for primary care problems or non-emergent problems, all four shared information.
This was a pilot study conducted in one state, so the sample was small and may not reflect all hospitals. Because all four of the participants were managers of emergency rooms, are nurses and all had similar points to add to the...

Other Essays Like Analytical Critique

Intelligence Testing Article Analysis

1071 words - 5 pages suggesting that flourishing intelligence is composed of three major aspects: analytical intelligence, creative intelligence, and practical intelligence (Sternberg, 1985). From this perspective, intelligence can be defined as “purposive adaptation to, shaping of, and selection of real-world environments relevant to one's life" (Sternberg, 1985, p. 271). Sternberg’s theory is unique in that it suggests methods of intelligence in contrast to

Critical Thinking Essay

870 words - 4 pages our feelings and emotions to evaluate and identify those most appropriate for a given situation. Thus, critical thinking is not a cold and unfeeling analytical process, but involves emotions and passions, in a positive way (Richard 1990). References Epstein, R. (2006). Critical thinking, 3rd ed. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth. Paul, Richard (1990). Critical Thinking. Center for Critical Thinking and Moral Critique.

Employee Training and Career Development Paper

1308 words - 6 pages destined to examine and solve organizational issues, where the employee can voice recommendations, while being scrutinized by the rest of the committee members (DeCenzo & Robbins, 2007). Lectures and seminars, offered both in-house or through outside vendors are the traditional forms of instruction and training for knowledge and development of conceptual and analytical abilities. Simulations provide the employee the opportunity to develop by

Case Study 1 And The Fraud Continues

1153 words - 5 pages would take if you suspected fraudulent activity within an organization where you work, 3) Critique the ethical nature of Pavlo’s actions in the case and 4) Apply one (1) theory related to crime causation to this case. The internal control weakness that exists at MCI was Pavlo; he was able to manipulate the AR (Accounts Receivable) system because he was the creator and developer. The lack of segregation of duties takes please here because the same

Research Terms

1238 words - 5 pages * Mere authority „world renowned author X said it so it must be true“ * Imperfect analogy * Failing to distinguish factual statements from opinion Forensic criterion 1. Identify key arguments in a piece of work and evaluate the soundness of the logic 2. Scour the piece for examples of weak arguments Soundness of arguments * Premises * Inference words * Conclusion Radical critique * Challenges assumptions * Identify a

Term Paper

1314 words - 6 pages participate in committees destined to examine and solve organizational issues, where the employee can voice recommendations, while being scrutinized by the rest of the committee members (DeCenzo & Robbins, 2007). Lectures and seminars, offered both in-house or through outside vendors are the traditional forms of instruction and training for knowledge and development of conceptual and analytical abilities. Simulations provide the employee the

Research in Sids Ursing

4667 words - 19 pages essential to critiquing the research as it is vital for the reader to understand the aims and questions of the research in order to answer sections of the framework. Critiquing frameworks enable the reader to make a judgement regarding the soundness of the research. While it is possible to critique a piece of research without them, frameworks serve as useful aides-memoires for those who are not used to critiquing research (Nursing Times,2006

N.S.A. Spying

3689 words - 15 pages City, but London has 500,000. So this is one perspective a person could reason with about more surveillance. "These cameras reveal very private information, where you go, who you go there with,"etc. "They can record you going into the sex therapist's office, the gay bar, the abortion clinic, any number of places that you would probably not want other people to know that you're going .” An analytical perspective on NSA illegal spying can be

The Nation-State, Core and Periphery: a Brief Sketch of Imperialism

2354 words - 10 pages balance of power between the dominate nation-states of the North American, European and East Asian triad. Therefore, at the close of the 20th century the cores domination of the periphery persisted and global capitalism had not rendered the nation-state irrelevant. Imperialism as an analytical category remained pertinent. Bibliography Arrighi, G. (2002), Global Capitalism and the Persistence of the North-South Divide, Science & Society


2415 words - 10 pages discussed to provide a thorough critique of whether or not traditional budgeting tools should be disregarded by organizations. Time Wastage Libby and Lindsay (2007) argue that preparing a budget is time consuming. Their research presents evidence of a survey in which they analyze the average time that is spent by managers when preparing a budget. In this study, various tactics were used to specify the average time a manager spends on

Management Accounting Developments

3336 words - 14 pages Mariusz Zaborowski Norwich 12/30/2009 CHOICE OF SUPERTRAIN DEPENDS ON CIRCUMSTANCES MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING DEVELOPMENTS ARE NO EXCEPTION NBS-3f1Y ADVANCED management ACCOUNTING Coursework assignment (10%) Submission date: by 3.00 pm Wednesday 14 January 2010 (Week 2) In this assignment, you are asked to discuss: ‘The critique drawing on the developments and theoretical explanations for the

Related Papers

Critique Of Research Report

1202 words - 5 pages current and primary sources? * Is the literature review well organised under subheadings in a chronological order according to the year of the study? * Is the literature review presented in an analytical wayto draw the mmeaningful inferences? CRITIQUE OF THE METHODOLOGICAL ASPECTS RESEARCH DESIGN * Is the design specified correctly? What was the design used? * Is the desiign appropriate to answer the research question

What Is Women's Studies? Essay

867 words - 4 pages to seek the truth through a variety of perspectives. Further, the role of women’s studies is not to simply point out the hindrances of society but rather to encourage critique and merge knowledge, education, and feminist activism. “Women’s studies involves questioning how systems of power based upon race, class, sexuality and ability interact with gender” (Gotell and Crow, 1). Such questioning resulted in open discussion among individuals and

Intelligence Critique Essay

818 words - 4 pages Intelligence Critique Intelligence Critique The two types of theories that will be critique in this paper will be Sternberg’s triarchic of intelligence, and Gardner’s eight frames of e mind. Intelligence is the ability to acquire and apply knowledge and skills. Sternberg’s triarchic of intelligence states that intelligence comes in three forms analytical intelligence, creative intelligences, and practical intelligence. Analytical

Strategic Analysis Of Koh Brothers

595 words - 3 pages the firm based on your SWOT analysis? Part 2 – Company Strategy Analysis The purpose of this analysis is to recommend a strategic course of action for the company you selected. You should use analytical techniques and frameworks covered in class to examine the firm's strategic intent, its strategic position, and viable alternatives/strategic options. Suggested outline A. Mission Statement/Strategic intent/Vision. * Why is this