This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Anthropology Essay

1305 words - 6 pages

Jared Diamond: Convincing Argument, Faulty Conclusion

In his book The Third Chimpanzee, Jared Diamond lays forth a compelling argument explaining why humans “smoke, drink, and use dangerous drugs” (192). Diamond claims that the primary reason people consume alcohol and drugs is because of an old animal instinct in which we display dangerous traits or weaknesses, paradoxically, as a means of strutting genetic superiority. While his argument is mostly sound, I have discovered flaws in its assumptions and conclusions. As I map out Diamond’s argument, I will explain as best as I can its flaws (as I see them), ultimately leading to my own conclusion: that people use drugs and alcohol not ...view middle of the document...

Upon his return from the inspirational plane flight, Diamond recalls a theory described in a paper published in 1975 by the Israeli biologist Amotz Zahavi, and relates it to his own experience with the incongruence of human alcohol and drug consumption. As Diamond describes, Zahavi’s theory can be explained as follows: a bird with a really long tail (three feet, for example) seems to be at a major disadvantage in terms of survival because of its slow speed and large, hard-to-miss-if-you’re-a-lion size. However, because the bird is alive, it shows other animals that, in order to overcome its seeming “disadvantage,” it must be superior in many other aspects. For example, the bird must be well adapted to fending off disease, escaping predators, or finding food. The same can be said of a peacock, whose large feathery display makes it quite noticeable (and slow), but the fact that it is alive speaks volumes towards its now certain assets. In essence, as Diamond notes, “the bigger the handicap, the more rigorous the test has passed” and the greater likelihood he or she will attract a mate (198).
Diamond believes this interesting paradox can be applied to human behavior as well. Indeed, human behaviors that are known to be dangerous, such as driving fast, consuming alcohol, doing drugs, and skydiving, are engaged upon on a regular basis. Why do we behave like this? Diamond believes we do so to display our ability to overcome obstacles and still survive. We show off our ability to take on risks without dying, hoping to attract mates. As with a long-tailed bird, potentially detrimental attributes and behaviors in humans may actually be used to display superiority and lead to greater odds of reproductive success.
Later on, Diamond again references his own experience to illustrate how Zahavi’s theory is alive in humankind today. Diamond mentions a young friend and biologist named Ardy Irwanto, whom he met during time spent in Indonesia. Ardy, Diamond describes, is a “kung-fu grade eight” (200). Diamond explains that kung-fu grade eights drink kerosene once a month to test their strength. Obviously, this behavior catches Diamond off guard when he first sees it, as he fears for the young man’s health. But Ardy assures him that because he is kung-fu grade eight, everything will be fine, as in fact it turns out to be.
The point is that humans, even non-Western ones who have had no exposure to things like advertisements, still participate in dangerous chemical consumption despite the obvious risks. Diamond finds this helps his theory, that human consumption of dangerous chemicals is largely due to an animal instinct we have in which we take on risks and survive, hoping to display our ability to overcome obstacles to potential mates.
While Diamond’s argument thus far is valid and makes good sense, I do not...

Other Essays Like Anthropology

Anthropology Essay

809 words - 4 pages Quiz number two covered chapter 4, “Becoming Human: The Origin and Diversity of Our Species” and a reading titled “Body Ritual among the Nacirema.” Chapter 4 discussed evolution through adaptation. It reviewed evolution, which refers to change over time, and natural selection. Charles Darwin stated that individuals who have biological characteristics that are best suited for certain environments are more likely to survive and reproduce than those

Anthropology Essay

1225 words - 5 pages The Chains of Race It can be argued that since the Europeans sailed the ocean and landed in America, the notions of inferiority and race have been prevalent. The Europeans had “discovered” America and in the same way “discovered” the Native Americans. The question became, how do the natives fit into the Europeans’ belief-system. The Natives were ultimately seen as inferior due to their beliefs which differed from the European’s belief patterns


1948 words - 8 pages Name Professor Title Date The Masai People of Kenya and Tanzania The Masai people commonly written Maasai make up one of the numerous varied African tribes inhabiting most of northern Tanzania and southern Kenya. In Kenya, they are located in three counties, specifically Samburu, Kajiado, and Narok. Smaller groups like the Njemps (Ilchamus) reside around Laikipia District and Lake Baringo. In Tanzania, the huge population inhabits Kiteto

Anthropology in Action

2283 words - 10 pages Anthropology in Action As we learned in our very first lecture video by Dr. Stacey Camp, anthropology is considered a holistic field- meaning anthropology encompasses almost every aspect of human life, whether it is in the past, present, or future. Anthropologists Study everything that was involved in a certain time period or in a certain place, or even with a certain group of people. There are four fields of anthropology; physical

Critique of Anthropology

655 words - 3 pages Article Critique: “The Scope of Anthropological Contributions to Human Rights Investigations” In the 2005 article The Scope of Anthropological Contributions to Human Rights Investigations, by Steadman and Haglund examines the participation of anthropologists in international human rights investigations between 1990 and 1999 by surveying four of the most active organizations, including the Argentine Forensic Anthropology Team (EAAF

The Importance of Anthropology to Law Enforcement

528 words - 3 pages Forensic Anthropology is an example of applied anthropology where anthropological methods and theories are utilized to solve contemporary human problems. The forensic anthropologist, a highly specialized physical anthropologist, is an expert in the analysis and identification of human remains. He or she very often also has training in crime scene investigation, toxicology and human anatomy Using anthropological techniques, these professionals

Sexual Anthropology: Nnlt vs. Feminist Revisionists

825 words - 4 pages interpretation behind the moral laws. Compare and contrasting the Natural Law Theorists and Feminist Revisionists, I will explore their perspectives on sexual anthropology and conclude with my own interpretation of the sexual human. Beginning with the New Natural Law Theorists (NNLT), their main perspective behind the sexual person is mostly thread within the principles of the physical being while almost completely disregarding the “emotional” or personal

Anthropology Final

2009 words - 9 pages Jordan Edwards ANTH 332 Professor Trencher Final Assignment In considering the possible essay prompts mentioned last week, this essay will focus on the second and third choices; being written from my standpoint as a hypothetical incoming Director of Global Business of a restaurant, that is launching a new service and product from American to China and Japan. This piece is seeking to explain to the board and potential investors of the

Social Anthropology

933 words - 4 pages As I observe him, I imagine that this is typical of him and his friends. The lights are dim, and he sits in front of a computer screen. “Come here, let me show you this video card, it makes the graphics run so smoothly!” Excitement, it’s clear to me that he’s grown tired of showing this to his girlfriend, she stands in the kitchen ignoring our exchange. “Oh my god!! Look at the graphics on this video! The creators of this game are amazing

Anthropology - Annotated Bib

587 words - 3 pages I. Cheney, D.L., and Seyfarth, R.M. Social and Non-Social Knowledge in Vervet Monkeys. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences. Vol. 306. London: The Royal Society, 1985. 187-201. II. Summary: The authors of the chapter in Philosophical Transaction of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Science called “Social and Non-Social Knowledge in Vervet Monkeys” describe how vervet

Decribing Forensic Anthropology In The Book "Dead Men Do Tell Tales" By William Maples. Forensic Anthropology Is The Examination Of Skeletal Remains

940 words - 4 pages Forensic Anthropology"They are speaking secrets to me and to my students, yielding up hidden information, furnishing ideas and evidence to the world of the living" (Maples 33). This is a quote from the book Dead Men Do Tell Tales, written by Williams R. Maples, Ph.D. He is referring to bones and how many stories they can tell to Forensic Anthropologists. Forensic anthropology is the examination of skeletal remains. This examination can be used

Related Papers

Anthropology Essay 4771 Words

4771 words - 20 pages What is Anthropology??? • • • 20:41 Anthropology • Scientific Approach, OBJECTIVE • Study of Humankind- human groups • Seeks to produce useful GENERALIZATIONS about people and their BEHAVIORS • To arrive at an UNBIASED UNDERSTANDING OF HUMAN DIVERSITY • Only scientific discipline that attempts to embrace an understanding of all of humanity • Helps us understand ourselves an others Anthropology Perspectives • Holistic Approach

Anthropology Essay 1751 Words

1751 words - 8 pages choice. The alleged bride later clarified that she was only present to hand over cattle and gifts to Mr Motsoaneng and was not gift herself. The girl explained later that she was just practicing her culture and tradition, She clarifies that she was just an usher nothing more. In generally, to some other people these allegations could be true, depending on the average of the understanding of the Venda culture. According to anthropology as the study

Anthropology Essay 1903 Words

1903 words - 8 pages Kinship: How important is kinship in any society? Tita A Atah ANT 101: Cultural Anthropology Lecia Sims 04/26/2013 In this paper the objective is to understand why in some societies like the Batek, the tribes, and clan food is considered an indispensable commodity. Understanding the importance and the role it play in any society and its culture will provide a basic understanding in how to manage food through which societies and

Cultural Anthropology Essay

1426 words - 6 pages applying their knowledge and skills to the goals of international development. Provide (2) two examples for each- (2) two in support and (2) two against. Anthropology involves the study of human cultures in the past as well as present; it also includes application of knowledge to the solution of human problems. On the other hand, the goals of international development can be analyzed as an aspect of human condition, with that, anthropology could