Are People Obedient Essay

679 words - 3 pages


Does everyone in society go against what they believe in merely to satisfy an authority figure? Stanley Milgram’s “Perils Of Obedience” expresses that most of society supports the authority figure regardless of their own personal ideals. Milgram says to the reader, “For many people, obedience is a deeply ingrained behavioral tendency, indeed a potent impulse overriding training in ethics, sympathy, and moral conduct” (Milgram 606). Is Milgram’s statement telling us obedience is an unparalleled force in today’s society? Two authors, George Orwell and Langston Hughes, provide us with incidents that support Milgrams findings.

George Orwell’s work, “Shooting an Elephant,” can be used as an example of Milgram’s discoveries. He recalls an account of himself as a British policeman called upon to take action against a belligerent elephant rampaging through a small Burmese Village. Orwell makes it a point to show that the natives of the village, ...view middle of the document...

Suddenly, they have taken on the role of the authority figure and Orwell the conforming citizen. In Milgram’s “Perils Of Obedience”, the test subjects or “teachers” follow the experimenter’s authority and inflict punishment upon the actors or “learners” without any regard to their own feelings. In Orwell’s writings, he has also put the natives or “authority” ahead of his own personal convictions and has proven Milgram an astute judge of human character.

Langston Hughes, author of “Salvation” offers us a different perspective on Milgram’s findings, “obedience before morality.” Mr. Hughes paints a picture of himself as a little boy, whose decisions at a church revival, directly reflect mans own instinctive behavioral tendencies for obedience. A young Langston, “who’s congregation wants him to go up and get saved,” gives into obedience and ventures to the altar as if he has seen the light of the Holy Spirit. Can he really see it or is this just a decision to give into the congregation, or what we consider “the authority?” Milgram’s “deeply ingrained human impulses” are evident at this point. Hughes goes on to say, “So I decided that maybe to save further trouble, I’d better lie, too, and say that Jesus had come, and get up and be saved; So I did” (Hughes 32). In saying this, Young Langston has obviously overlooked his personal belief of a “visual” Holy Spirit to meet the level of obedience laid out by the congregation. Once again, Stanley Milgram’s theories are correct. His discoveries bind us to the fact that people may believe strongly in an idea or thought but, will overlook that belief to be obedient.

In conclusion, what does this leave the reader to think? Do people conform to authority? Is society holding back its views inorder to meet a level of obedience? Stanley Milgram has pointed out a human characteristic that may very well be in each and every one of us. George Orwell and Langston Hughes have both given us two examples that support and defend this theory. With all this evidence compounded, we “the reader” can make a justified assumption that everyone in society has, at one time or another, overlooked his or her personal feelings to conform. This occurrence, whether it is instinctive or judgmental is one that each individual deals with a personal level.

Other Essays Like Are People Obedient

The Presentation Of The Characters Beatrice And Hero In Much Ado About Nothing

547 words - 3 pages people at Leonato’s (governor of Messina and Hero’s father) home. My ideas about the two women are that Beatrice is a feisty one with a great wit that everyone admires and Hero is almost the complete opposite being obedient and demure. I also believe they lead completely different relationships with men, I reckon Hero’s relationship with Claudio is romantic and well placed in society for the age and that Beatrice’s

Shakespeare's Three Comedies Essay

1770 words - 8 pages everything will end up all messed up in the most comical way. He is the cause of all the confusion in the play. He anoints the wrong people with the magical ointment, creating the most disastrous, yet funny results. The king and queen of the fairies are fighting over a boy that they both want. To steal this boy away from Titania, the queen of the fairies, Oberon, the king, makes her fall in love with a weaver who has grown

The Need for a Multicultural View on History

1096 words - 5 pages hard work keeps them in a state where they simply have to work hard. Another reason is that they are obedient, but obedient to whom? Obviously obedient to white people. The third reason was that they are self reliant, to show that although these people work hard, they do not ask much in return. So that means that the majority wants all minorities to work hard for a society, which does not even consider them to be a part of it, without asking

understanding behaviour of soldiers during war

905 words - 4 pages far people would go in to obey orders that could potentially harm another person. His work is known as one of the most famous studies of obedience in Psychology looking at the conflict between obedience to authority and a person’s own conscience. Were people just obeying orders even though commands were morally wrong, is obeying an order a reasonable defence. Milgram devised an experiment to see how far people are willing to go to follow

Share Jesus Without Fear Book Critique

1850 words - 8 pages moment. Fay says that the responsibility of the believer is not to cause the conversion, but to be obedient to the high calling of the Great Commission (Fay, 143). He makes the point of saying that there are only two kinds of people in the world, “those who talk about the lost and those who talk to the lost” (Fay, 144). Implementing these principles and points from the book is a great strategy for those who have committed their hearts to

Sold by Patricia Mccormick Essay

898 words - 4 pages words and gentle touch. She doesn’t believe in happiness anymore, since her childhood and her innocence was taken at such a young age. She has been betrayed and lied to and the american, talking about a clean place and a happy vibe, was the only person she could trust in her time of need. However, Lakshmi changes by giving into the americans wise words and trusting the people who are not suppose to be trusted, also known as betrayal. A

The Christian Life

3869 words - 16 pages lives, a life where they are obedient to God and stand in faith on His promises. Reliance on the Holy Spirit Paul teaches that the mind is the key to obedience, but that the mind is helpless to the desires of the flesh unless the person has the Spirit active within him or her. Without the indwelling Spirit, a person simply cannot be obedient to God. Paul explains why in Romans 8:5, indicating that the fundamental reason for people’s inability

Understanding the Ten Commandments

617 words - 3 pages a pact between Jehovah and his people. Using Moses as a mediator between them, he provided these laws that would guide them and protect them in every field of their lives. While they would maintain loyal and obedient to him, he would be by their side and use them to bless other nations to come. Sadly enough, as we continue to read in the bible, while Moses long forty day stay on the mountain, the people of Israel grew impatient and made a

Stereotype in Merchant of Venice

624 words - 3 pages . Jewish stereotypes:Jewish people have been stereotyped throughout the centuries and made scapegoats for a multitude of societal problems. Jews are still stereotyped as greedy, nit-picky, misers. They have often been shown counting money or collecting diamonds. Antisemitism prevailed for centuries and reached a climax in Nazi Germany during World War II. Stereotypes in The Merchant of Venice: Stereotypes are explored greatly in the

The Evil of the Rockefellers

558 words - 3 pages the General Education Board, which provided major funding for schools across the country and was especially active in promoting the State-controlled public school movement. The General Education Board was not interested in encouraging critical thinking. Rather, its focus was on organizing children and creating reliable, predictable, obedient citizens. These people saw schooling as a branch of industry and a tool of governance. The


1604 words - 7 pages . Traditional education focuses on the principle of children being unquestioningly obedient to a teacher with punishments employed to persuade children away from ‘doing things their own way.’ Instead, Montessori children are encouraged to be obedient to the internal voice that indicates to them what they need to learn next, and when they need to learn it. Additionally, Montessori children come to respect their fellow students, their teacher and

Related Papers

Obedience And Conformity Essay

636 words - 3 pages ) suggested that we live in a socially obedient environment. Our experience has taught us that authorities are generally trustworthy and legitimate. This creates a socially obedient environment. Adorno et al. (1950) felt that personality was a better explanation of obedience. They proposed that some people had an authoritarian personality. Such people are most likely to be obedient (and most likely also to be prejudiced

Women In Othello: Gender Roles In Elizabethan England

1469 words - 6 pages In modern society women have equal respect from men. Women do not need to be compliant to men and are free to express themselves. Although some pockets of discrimination exist in present-day society, it was not the same in Elizabethan England The disrespect that women received was unparalleled. Different levels of society bolstered this dramatic inequality of people, especially women to new heights. William Shakespeare writes influential books

Bible Essay

1130 words - 5 pages every tongue confess that Jesus Christ is lord , to the glory of god the father. Philippians 2:5-11 What these passages are telling us or in my opinion what these passages are telling us is that Jesus had the best attitude towards everything good or bad that happened to him, and that God wants us to have the same good attitude that Jesus did. God knew that most people could not grasp the meaning of equality that’s probably one of the

Comparative Analysis

1520 words - 7 pages them to handle. Lastly, its likely that they both felt pressured by the other to say yes, because they did not want to swim against the stream; so instead they merely went along. In terms of society, currently, there are plenty of instances in which people are put in situations each and every day where they are forced to chose whether to obey or not. The moral values held by each individual are often questioned when being obedient threatens to go