This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Are Uniforms A Good Way To Improve Student Discipline And Motivation?

2115 words - 9 pages

The school uniform has a fairly short and somewhat chequered history. For all practical purposes, school uniforms as we know them today have their roots in the British public school system. For the sake of clarity, a British public school is equivalent to an American private school, and an American public school is equivalent to a British State school.

Up until the middle part of the 19th century, British public schools were the preserve of a wealthy elite, the later mandarins of the British Empire. Nevertheless, they were quite disorderly, with students behaving much as they wished. Uniform began to be introduced as a means of instilling a greater degree of discipline and team spirit, ...view middle of the document...

In 1996, President Clinton instructed the then Secretary for Education Richard W Riley to send a Manual on School Uniforms to every School District in the country. The manual set out the Government's position, creating guidelines for all schools on which they could model their uniform requirements. The Government view was that the adoption of school uniform would reduce violence and indiscipline in schools, but did not go as far as making uniform mandatory, the decision being left to individual school districts.

The view of the Government was clearly not shared by parents, pupils or the school districts' administrators. By 1998, only 11% of Public Elementary Schools had adopted a uniform policy, and by 2000, that figure had only increased to 15.5%.

The decisions to adopt uniform were not consistent across the country.
Suburban schools had a relatively lower rate of uptake, perhaps reflecting the efforts of a more highly politicised group of parents.

The proponents on either side of the debate about school appear to have entrenched and almost polar opposite opinions, and there is a fog of statistics and counter-statistics available to support either proposition.

Are they in fact beneficial in improving discipline and motivation_ I believe so, and the experience at South Houston suggests that I am right!

The staff reported a considerable decrease in violence and indiscipline, and an average across the board increase of two grades in academic performance by the end of the year within which a uniform policy was introduced. Could it just be co-incidence? It seems hardly likely.

There is no doubt that when a school adopts a uniform policy, it is sending a clear and unequivocal message to parents and students alike. It is saying that this is an inclusive organisation where everyone is seen to be equal, and will be treated as such. School is about learning, not about showing off or scoring fashion points.

Some people would have us believe that children hate uniforms -indeed, many children will say so themselves, but the facts belie this opinion. Children, when they join an organisation with a uniform, just can't wait to get into it.

Most of us have an innate need to belong, to feel part of a group, to feel accepted and understood by our peers, and if possible to have their admiration and respect. This does not just apply to children; it applies to the members of your local chapter of Hell's Angels aware.

Of course, one of the obvious marks of a discrete group is its uniform.

When you provide a child with a uniform, you are giving him an instant key to acceptance within a group, the chance to belong to it and feel part of it.

Those who oppose uniform will say that by putting a child into uniform, you are taking away his constitutional right to freedom of expression. Nevertheless, isn't it interesting to note that left to themselves, children will to a greater or lesser degree choose a uniform of their own. These may...

Other Essays Like Are Uniforms a Good Way to Improve Student Discipline and Motivation?

good way to customer complaint Essay

760 words - 4 pages know what was going on and also she had no clue of what products you guys had on offer. It took her about 10 minutes and another man to finally realize that Mcdonald’s had launched new blueberry products. Our order was quite simple a blueberry milkshake and a blueberry mcflurry but the lady repeatedly kept saying that they are no such products on offer. Then finally after about waiting for 10 minutes she finally got the order right. Then to

Explain the Relationship Between Discipline and Obedience from the Montessori Perspective. Explain How Discipline and Obedience Are Linked to the Development of the Will

1927 words - 8 pages . Usually discipline is achieved through among others threats, bribes, coercion and fear. In the perspective of Montessori however disciple is described to be active and comes from within the child as a result of his own internal motivation. A child’s discipline emerges as he works in a purposeful manner in a prepared environment (Montessori 2007a). According to Montessori (2007b, p51) ‘ the discipline we are looking for is active. We do not believe

Dress Codes and Uniforms are not needed in the Schools

949 words - 4 pages Are dress codes and uniforms needed or not? Some parents, teachers, and school boards think that by telling kids what to wear will improve behavior, safety, and will make them into better adults ready for the work life. Some even say it makes bullying less of a problem. What makes people think by telling kids what to wear will make any type of improvement? Dress codes and uniforms are not needed in the school systems because it is against the

Good and Evil : to Kill a Mockingbird

1241 words - 5 pages In addition to bearing the title of the novel, Harper Lee uses “To Kill a Mockingbird” as an opportunity to convey the significance of moral veracity to depict the alleged Mockingbirds of May comb county. She uses the innocence of children such as Jem and Scout to experience the underlying reality of good and evil in society, as their father, Atticus Finch attempts to teach them the morals of killing shadowed innocent beings who are helpless to

Researching a Strategy Paper - Motivation to Exercise

1157 words - 5 pages are from reputable sources. I will be more apt to exercise regularly if I know what dangers can come from not staying active and what good comes from working out. Time Saving Workouts My evaluation process of the time saving exercises will consist of me checking my information for its validity and for a comparison on the time each source is giving me to complete a workout regiment. I want to ensure the information regarding the quick

To Kill a Mockingbird: Coexistence of Good and Evil

543 words - 3 pages To Kill a Mockingbird: Coexistence of Good and Evil Evil men are always interfering with a good man’s dream. In “To Kill a Mockingbird”, there were many different signs of good and evil. However, the meanest of them all was Bob Ewell and his daughter, Mayella Ewell: I got somethin’ to say an’ then I ain’t gonna say no more. That nigger yonder took advantage of me an’ if you fine fancy gentlemen don’t wanta do nothin

“Revelation” And “A Good Man Is Hard To Find

281 words - 2 pages In two of Flannery O?Connor?s short stories, ?Revelation? and ?A Good Man is Hard to find? we find a lot of similarities in the author?s portrayal of the characters as well as themes. ?O?Connor?s stories are challenging because her characters, who initially seem radically different from people we know, turn out to be, by the end of each story, somehow familiar- somehow connected to us.? (424) However, each story also depicts it?s own unique tell

Look at the Way a Theme or Character Is Presented in Your Chosen Text. Include in Your Response Any Social, Cultural and Historical Contexts That Are Important to Your Understanding of the Theme or...

887 words - 4 pages Look at the way a theme or character is presented in your chosen text. Include in your response any social, cultural and historical contexts that are important to your understanding of the theme or character. The character I have chosen to write about is Candy in the novel ‘Of Mice and Men’ by John Steinbeck. Candy is sort of like a narrator in the beginning of the story. He is the oldest ranch hand in the novel, who knows just about

A Leader Must Improve the Idea to Commercialization Process

539 words - 3 pages A Leader must improve the Idea to Commercialization Process: Apple Inc. As a Leader in either big or small company, one thing that must always be put on concern is to keep the products stay at the top competing with others. One thing that certain is that if a company stops making any improvements towards its product means that the company is going to meet a dead-end to its development. But a good leader won’t let that happen, he/she will

Nursing Student Perceptions and Incidence of Performing Breast Self-Examinations Related to Educational Level in a Baccalaureate Nursing Program

2536 words - 11 pages menstruating, because breasts are non-tender and not swollen, or on the same day each month if a regular period is not applicable (Lowdermilk, 2007, p. 94.) Early detection can improve the likelihood of the diagnosis of breast cancer, as the frequency of breast exams will allow for a woman to detect a tumor in an early stage which is directly associated with a lower stage of cancer and a better outcome(American Cancer Society [ACS], 2008.) Although

A Good Man Is Hard to Find

751 words - 4 pages is waiting for her. O’Connor is truly a writer in the southern “Gothic Tradition” because she bases her writing on the decaying south and its people. She writes without any thought about kindness or evil. The way she wrote in the grandmothers issues, shows her underlying distaste of gracefulness. The other characters in “A Good Man Is Hard to Find” are ignorant and self-satisfying people, who see the worst and are shocked into self-realization.

Related Papers

Do Uniforms Really Help With Discipline And Motivation

1993 words - 8 pages ). Pros and cons of school uniforms [Uniforms]. Message posted to uniforms-182.html Morse-McNeely, Pat &, Oland, D. (2002, April). Are uniforms a good way to improve student discipline and motivation?. NEA Today. Retrieved from Munro, N. (2009, September 3). Are uniforms a good way to improve student

Are School Uniforms A Good Idea?

945 words - 4 pages Are School Uniforms a good idea? Many public schools in America are making students wear school uniforms. Uniforms were first instituted in 16th century England at the charity schools for the poor children. It was not until the 19th century that the great English public schools began instituting uniforms and even later for them to be widely accepted at state schools, especially elementary schools. In the 20th century, schools all over the

School Uniforms: For The Good Of The Student Body?

1178 words - 5 pages personality. The original question was whether school uniforms help the student body or not. The arguments for the issue state that the uniforms do help the student body by decreasing the violence, and increasing the performance in the schools. The arguments against the issue state that the uniforms are not for the good of the student body, that they suppress the individuality and diversity of the students. Either way the issue of school uniforms is

Is Corporal Punishment A Good Way To Punish Children?

526 words - 3 pages physically. As a matter of fact, we have to regard our children as individuals like us. Even though they are in need of care and education, they are solely human beings to be protected from any kind of abuse.To conclude, the question whether corporal punishment is a good way to punish children should be answered not to be used. Corporal punishment itself is not effective in terms of discipline of children. Besides, the abusive corporal punishment can influence to create violent characteristics of children. Mostly importantly, we have to loot at our children as individuals with human rights.