Article Rebuttal Essay

654 words - 3 pages

University of Phoenix |
Article Rebuttal |
Hector WesterbandBCOM/275Prof. Thelma Gonzalez-Arvelo |
October 18,2011 |

The article, “Life-at-fertilization initiative has hope in Miss.”Published by Emily Wagster Pettusand and printed by the Associated Press, talks about voters of the state of Mississippi trying to approve an amendment declaring that life begins when a human egg is fertilized. The state of Mississippi is the only state that has such an amendment on its ballot but efforts are being made to put this question for voters in at least 4 other states. The amendment at the state level would have a conflict with the US Constitution. The article also states that this amendment is trying to overturn the Supreme Court case Roe vs Wade, the 1973 U.S. Supreme Court decision that established a legal right to abortion. The article touches on the subject of malpractice to physicians who perform birth control procedures like ...view middle of the document...

According to Barbara Collura, executive director of RESOLVE, "Many procedures that are part of in vitro fertilization (IVF), such as embryo cryopreservation and PGD, will be very difficult to continue to do, if not illegal, if Initiative 26 passes." (The Chilling Effect Of Mississippi'S 'Personhood Amendment', 2011). This does not seem like an amendment that is pro life to me when you think about all the parties that can be affected.

There is already legal action against this amendment. One of the plaintiffs Cristen Hemmins was raped and brings to the table a very valid point that women should not have to be forced by the state to carry an unwanted baby. If the amendment passes, it will outlaw abortion in the state entirely, even in cases of rape or incest. It might even leave some forms of contraception, and procedures such as in vitro fertilization, on life support. According to Guy N. Texas, “Note that this is “fertilization” — union of egg and sperm — not implantation in the uterine wall. The latter is, as I understand it, the line the medical profession uses to mark the beginning of a pregnancy. So if this passes, it would appear that a woman could be subject to murder charges for using an IUD or taking a “Plan B” (morning after) contraceptive.” (Texas, 2011). This amendment does not seem pro life to me. It takes away the human right of a female to be able to decide what she can do with her own body. I don’t think the state has the right to interfere with the rights of women when it comes to her body. This amendment can also incriminate physicians who are trying to help young women with contraceptives so that they don’t become pregnant and in turn have to have an abortion. In my opinion this is just another case of religion interfering with the state. The only thing that I can say about this is that I’m glad I don’t live in Mississippi but in Puerto Rico.

References
The Chilling Effect of Mississippi's 'Personhood Amendment'. (2011). Retrieved from http://www.fertilityauthority.com
Texas, G.N. (2011). Mississippi may ban abortion in cases of rape or incest ‘Personhood Amendment'. Retrieved from https://notesandrestsmakemusic.wordpress.com

Other Essays Like Article Rebuttal

A Moral Arguement on Abortion Rebuttal

596 words - 3 pages A Moral Argument for Abortion Rebuttal Casey Garza December 6, 2012 A Moral Argument for Abortion Rebuttal Casey Garza December 6, 2012 Davidson Loehr’s article “ A Moral Argument for Abortion” is based on a wide range of arguments based on bates over abortion. One of the arguments I found that I

Obama Rebutal Essay

618 words - 3 pages Obama Care Rebuttal BCOM/275 I chose to rebuttal a article I read titled Obama Care. In this rebuttal I will discuss how Obama care hurts hard working Americans, how Obama care rewards the lower class by destroying the middle class and how Obama care will fall into pieces. Obama Care is hurting all classes of Americans. I am going to use my wife and I as an example. My wife’s company offered health care for the both of us for $300 a

Bcom 275 Uop Complete Class Homework Aid Entire Class Individual and Team Assignments and Dqs Bcom 275 (Business Communications & Critical Thinking)

1230 words - 5 pages . Format your paper consistent with APA guidelines. BCOM 275 week 3 Individual Assignment Article Rebuttal Locate an article on a controversial subject where the author makes an argument you do not agree with. Write a 350- to 700-word rebuttal to the article using valid arguments and supporting data. In the rebuttal, offer an analysis in which you do the following: • Analyze the reliability, credibility, and validity of the data used by the

Bcom 275 Entire Class Individual and Team Assignments and Dqs Bcom 275 (Business Communications & Critical Thinking)

1225 words - 5 pages guidelines. BCOM 275 week 3 Individual Assignment Article Rebuttal Locate an article on a controversial subject where the author makes an argument you do not agree with. Write a 350- to 700-word rebuttal to the article using valid arguments and supporting data. In the rebuttal, offer an analysis in which you do the following: • Analyze the reliability, credibility, and validity of the data used by the author. • Identify any logical

Legalizing Marijuana

1552 words - 7 pages Legalizing Marijuana Article Rebuttal Bruce Wayne BCOM/275 October 24, 2011 Dr. Phil Jackson Legalizing Marijuana Article Rebuttal A persuasive article on legalizing marijuana was published by TIME magazine. The reasoning for legalizing marijuana was that it would generate the government an estimated 1.4 million dollars in tax money. This figure does not include additional taxation which could be applied to activities or jobs within

A Rebuttal of "Disarming Law-Abiding Citizens Doesn't Make Them Any Safer"

757 words - 4 pages A Rebuttal of “Disarming Law-abiding Citizens Doesn't Make Them Any Safer" Larry N. Farmer BCOM 275 August 5, 2013 Steve Boylan Abstract A Rebuttal of “Disarming Law-abiding Citizens Doesn't Make Them Any Safer" In the article, “Disarming law-abiding citizens doesn’t make them any safer”, (Spartanburg Harold-Journal, 2012) the Spartanburg Harold talks about the ban on guns will leave law-abiding citizens vulnerable to criminals

Essay on ”Race, Class, Violence and Denial: Mass Murder and the Pathologies of Privilege” by Tim Wise

1022 words - 5 pages is something almost everyone more or less agree on, since it is something everyone wants to end. He claims that the only way to ever set a stop to this madness is for the communities to take responsibility. All these arguments connect in a fine way, but his use of rebuttal does almost not exist. If the article had been for at newspaper or anything else with more critical readers of more dissimilar opinions, he would need that to seem less

The Pros And Cons Of Nuclear Power

1163 words - 5 pages UCS both describe their points clearly but Swartz and Reise also incorporated the well being of the public, almost in a rebuttal of what the UCS has to say. The UCS poses three questions right from the beginning of their article, 1. In the opinion of the UCS, why has the Nuclear power industry been unable to attract investors? 2. According to the UCS, How should spent nuclear fuel be disposed of? 3.In the author’s view, why has Global Nuclear

Is Pop Culture Actually Good for You?

1516 words - 7 pages rarely the case anymore. Now [his] concentration often starts to drift after two or three pages...” (Carr) So it can be concluded that pop culture has a way of affecting not just the young and innocent, but also mature adults. In “Watching TV Makes You Smarter,” Johnson proposes that, “...it [TV] is largely a force for good: enhancing our cognitive faculties, not dumbing them down.” (Johnson 279) In a direct response to this article, Stevens

Shouls Abortions Be Legal or Illegal

1890 words - 8 pages child and the public opinion on legalized abortions would change. Dudley does not provide the statistical data to support the argument that legal abortion is safer than illegal abortions. Dudley explains the many risks which can occur with illegal abortions but also provides all the risk and complications that could potentially occur during a legal abortion so the facts are just not in the article. In the article Dudley provides percentages

Criticisms for Nicholas Carr's Article

1753 words - 8 pages already have. I would contradict this by saying that it doesn’t matter what is bought, but what can done with it is the real dilemma. Paul Strassmann, professor at George Mason University says, “Carr most likely used the same Microsoft Word program to write his article as I used in my rebuttal [letter to Harvard Business Review], yet we got different results.” [4]. He also said that Carr’s statements have to be challenged [5], but this was

Related Papers

Article Rebuttal Essay

530 words - 3 pages Knowing your Audience Paper and Communication Release Kevin Danielson BCOMB/275 October 15, 2012 Steve Boylan Article Rebuttle The Article is “Really? Don’t limit freedom to marry?” This was in the Minneapolis Star Tribune on September 23, 2012. In the article On November 6, Minnesota voters will decide whether marriage should be protected in the state Constitution. “The human race's two sexes -- male and female

Bcom 275 Article Rebuttal Essay

546 words - 3 pages Article Rebuttal BCOM 275 Article Rebuttal An article located on a controversial subject is discussed. The article is titled “A Very Controversial Article” written by Athena Louise. The

Article Rebuttal Essay

516 words - 3 pages College Athletes The article is about should College Athletes be paid this is written by Steve Wulf. He will be sharing with his readers about college athletes, and how their place of being athletes in the schools are unfair, and attend where athletes ' talents are in the school's interest , because of the college athletes , and their popularity, and their appeal to

Bcom275 Article Rebuttal Essay

750 words - 3 pages Illegal Immigrant Rights BCOM/275 02/24/2015 University of Phoenix ILLEGAL IMMIGRANT RIGHTS Immigrants or people that come to this country by a means of crossing borders without checking in with the proper authorities is crossing illegally. Why are these people not checking in with the authorities? Is there something they are hiding? What are the motives that people are coming over the borders illegally? The definition of