This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Assess The Short Term Significance Of The Russo Japanese War For Russian Government And Politics

2260 words - 10 pages

The Russo-Japanese war undoubtedly had a large significance and effect on Russian government and politics in the early 20th century. A report by Stalin on the war in 1905 states that the “Unbearable conditions” of the war are causing “unrest and discontent among the troops” - further suggesting that the soldiers blamed their superiors, and therefore the government for their treatment during the war through the soldiers “no longer blindly obeying the orders of their superiors”. Through this, it could be suggested that the soldiers were becoming dissatisfied with a regime that they saw did not help them at all (as shown through the poor organization of the war effort - lack of food, proper ...view middle of the document...

However, this judgement is also based on Stalin's account of the situation - which could be interpreted as heavily biased. Stalin was, quite noticeably, a bolshevik supporter - he had eagerly joined them when they were formed by Lenin, and was active in creating and distributing propaganda, organizing strikes and raising funds. Through this, it can be suggested that his account of the situations within the camps was heavily exaggerated, as he would have wanted to make it appear as though all Russians shared the same views as him, perhaps in order to bolster support for the Bolsheviks. However, each of the sources corroborate on the view that war angered the Russian people - soldiers and commoners alike, and therefore I believe it is very likely that war had some of the most short-term significance within Russian government and politics, primarily influencing the outbreak of Revolution in 1905.

Economic factors had a large short term significance in causing the 1905 Revolution. Tsar Nicholas writes about “The troubles that have broken out” in the villages, showing that there was discontent, and continues to write about the “violence and crime” among the peasant population - suggesting that the Tsar agreed to change the economic policy because of how unhappy the peasantry were with the large amounts of money they were paying to the crown in taxation.This change (reducing the peasants land tax and offering better terms for peasant loans) shows how unpopular the previous policies were and how they may have caused the revolution, as this source was written in November - months after the revolution started, suggesting that upon seeing the severity of the revolution the Tsar gave into demands for change in a hope to quell it. As this was written by the Tsar after the start of the revolution, it may be biased - calling an uprising or revolution a “trouble” could be an attempt to downplay its severity and confirm his absolute power over Russia. It does, however, still admit there were troubles and suggests that they were caused by the Russian people being unhappy with the unfair and heavy taxation, causing them to turn to demand reforms. The discontent with tax and, subsequently pay, can be supported through the petition set up by Father Gapon, that outlined the people's want of “a normal working wage” and a “eight hour work day and limit of overtime”, further suggesting that the revolution was influenced heavily by economic factors - as Bloody Sunday was the prelude to Revolution, and the workers petition heavily referenced their economic grievances. This source is further supported by Yaizhul’s account of the situation of factory workers, in that it’s stated that many factories “still regard workers as serfs” in terms of how they are paid, further suggesting that the Russian were treated poorly, supporting the tone of discontent in Father Gapons petition. However, Yaizhul was an advocate for fair working conditions - having set up the Russian state...

Other Essays Like Assess the Short Term Significance of the Russo-Japanese War for Russian Government and Politics

Outline and Evaluate Research Into the Duration, Capacity, and Encoding of Information in Short-Term Memory

641 words - 3 pages “Outline and evaluate research into the duration, capacity, and encoding of information in short-term memory.” Peterson and Peterson conducted a study of the duration of short-term memory. The experimenter said a consonant syllable to the participant, followed by a three-digit number, for example: IDM 302. The consonant syllable had to not have a meaning, for example: not BBC. Immediately after hearing this, the participant had to count

Assess the significance of the role of individuals in reducing racial discrimination in the USA throughout the period 1877-1981

649 words - 3 pages would have had little effect. The likes of Booker T Washington and Du Bois set the foundation for civil rights along with the Second World War; however other individuals such as Martin Luther King help to actively progress the movement. Along with this the government and various presidents more so in the latter of the period of 1877-1981 helped to change attitudes and enforce legislation which was vital in reducing racial discrimination in the

Significance of the Brain and Conscious Experience

1824 words - 8 pages Page 1 The Significance of the Brain and Conscious Experience in Human Life I have chosen to write on this topic of chapter one because it discusses the study of all of the physiological, evolutionary, and developmental mechanisms of behavior and experience. Much of biological psychology is concentrated and focused on studying the brain functions that a person will have to encounter when having to deal with the “machinery of the bodyâ

Brazilian Government and Politics

605 words - 3 pages and agencies affiliated to the Executive. The form of government is that of a democratic republic, with a presidential system.[13] The president is both head of state and head of government of the Union and is elected for a four-year term,[13] with the possibility of re-election for a second successive term. The current president is Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva. He was elected on October 27, 2002,[44] and re-elected on October 29, 2006.[45] The

Causes of the Russian Revolution

665 words - 3 pages point. After this event, the Russian citizens believed that they had to do something about developing Russia so that it would become powerful again. The Russian Revolution was caused from numerous causes, but the most significant of them all were World War One, poverty, and the defeat of the Russo-Japanese War. That time was a very dark time for the Russians. They lived terrible lives, and there were many wars going on at the time. Finally, they all decided to revolt against the king, and improve their lives. These causes were important because they were all significant causes that had great impacts on the Revolution in Russia.

Government and Politics

1640 words - 7 pages What are the main purposes of elections? * We are electing Members of Parliament to represent the constituency as a whole and us as individuals if we feel we have a grievance against the state. * We are delivering a verdict on the performance of the government in power. If we are satisfied, we will vote for it party’s candidate, or we may not vote for them at all. This occurred in 1997, when the electorate decided it wished to express

Ap Government and Politics

1394 words - 6 pages federalism) – Views the Constitution as giving a limited list of powers—primarily foreign policy and national defense—to the national government, leaving the rest to the sovereign states. Each level of government is dominant within its own sphere. The Supreme Court serves as the umpire between the national government and the states in disputes over which level of government has responsibility for a particular activity. Cooperative federalism

Assess the View That Cults and Sects Are Fringe Organisations That Are Inevitably Short Lived and of Little Influence on Contemporary Society. (33 Marks)

1119 words - 5 pages Yana Garcia Mander 13.0 hw. Assess the view that cults and sects are fringe organisations that are inevitably short lived and of little influence on contemporary society. Cults and sects are often hard to differentiate from one another, as a lot of them have very similar features such as a world-rejecting values and the offer of alternative explanations to traditional beliefs. According to Troeitsch, sects tend to be small, tight

The Start of “Sick Man of Asia”: the 1895 Sino-Japanese War

2945 words - 12 pages modernize. Following the assassination of a pro-Japanese reformist in 1894, a Korean religious sect, the Tonghak , began the Tonghak Peasant Revolution. The Korean government requested help from China in suppressing it. When China contributed assistance, the Japanese government sent an expedition in support of the reformists, and had seized the royal palace in Seoul by June 8, 1894. War between Japan and China was officially declared on August

Strategic, Long-Term and Short-Term Objectives

1037 words - 5 pages //Here, we discuss about the differences among strategic, long-term and short-term objectives of an Organization as the objectives of a firm are very much critical for its success. //  Strategic Objectives: Strategic objectives refer to the purposes that an organization strives for. Strategic objectives relate with an organization’s vision and mission. Strategic objectives of an organization have multi-year timeframes for the achievement of

The Significance Of The Title

1222 words - 5 pages innocents, it did show how Holden obtained relief from depression and melancholy as soon as he encountered what he held to be innocence. In other words, when he met children.An additional example of when Holden demonstrated his role as the 'catcher in the rye', was when he learned that Stradlater, his roommate, was going on a date with Jane Gallagher, a friend of his. Holden was a sensitive, caring individual who showed concern for the well being

Related Papers

How Far Was The Russo Japanese War Responsible For The Outbreak Of The 1905 Revolution?

1794 words - 8 pages and ashamed to be Russian. They were losing to a nation very few had heard of and it was humiliating. However, many of the defeats to the Russian military occurred after the Revolution had started, not causing its outbreak, but merely adding to the opposition to autocratic rule by the Tsar and prolonging the Revolution. The Russo-Japanese War also brought about economic problems for Russia, and this therefore meant there was a significant lack of

How Did Two Major Conflicts, The Sino Japanese War (1894 1895) And The Russo Japanese War A Decade Later, Influence Western Perceptions Of Japan And Asia?

2288 words - 10 pages 6) How did two major conflicts, the Sino-Japanese War (1894-1895) and the Russo-Japanese War a decade later, influence Western perceptions of Japan and Asia? The Sino-Japanese War from 1894-1895 and the Russo-Japanese War a decade later were monumental events in the history of Asia and its ripples were felt in the Western world. In the Sino-Japanese War, the Western world witnessed the fruits of Meiji Japan’s modernization program, its modern

Causes For The Russian Civil War

659 words - 3 pages power the Czechs defeated the Reds in most of Siberia and gave help to their white opponents. The second reason for which the Czech legion was important for the Russian civil war was that they gave leeway for other foreign armies to join the fight against the reds. The third cause of the Russian civil war was the foreign opposition to the Bolshevik government. This opposition was due to two interconnected factors. The first being that the

The Russian Civil War Essay

1323 words - 6 pages worked together as a unit because it is a big task to take individuals and make them a team. The white commanders were unsuccessful and therefore were ineffective as a fighting force. A final reason why the communists won the war was the introduction of War Communism. War communism was a system that Lenin introduced in Russia. The government took control of the economy. This is because it was vital for the reds that their