Assessment Of The Usefulness Of Individualistic Theories Of The Causes Of Poverty

1037 words - 5 pages

Assessment of the Usefulness of Individualistic Theories of the Causes of Poverty

An individualistic (cultural) perspective suggests that poverty comes
as a result of behaviour and lifestyle more likely to result in
poverty. This perspective is often referred to as ‘victim-blaming’.
They are said to be ‘work shy’, preferring instead to live on state
welfare benefits. This explanation of poverty argues that the poor'
subculture may be so pervasive that these deviant attitudes are
reproduced from one generation to another by parents who act as
‘deviant role-models’ to their children. In this way the poor are said
to be a part of a subculture, which is ...view middle of the document...

-Patterns of consumption reflect immediate gratification values,
rather than planning for future prosperity.

Life-course decisions, reflected in high incidence of single parent
families, dilute family resources.

North Regions: -

-Unwillingness to move to jobs in south.

-Attachment to particular style of life.

-Regional pride.

Oscar Lewis (1961) carried out a study in which he observed peasant
culture poor communities of Mexico and Puerto Rico. He found attitudes
of fatalism, apathy, immediate gratification and failure to
participate in institutional life. His theory also shows that this
attitude is passed on through generations. The theory shows that
poverty has a structure and a rationale, so that policy to alleviate
poverty requires a systematic and integrated approach. Theory led to
direct intervention strategies to improve the situation of those in
poverty by altering their way of life.

Arguments directly against Lewis’s study come from the anthropologist,
Mangrins (1968), who researched slums in Peru and found the poor were
far from apathetic or resigned and also had remarkable organising

Coates and Silburn (1970) studied a slum in Nottingham called St
Annes. They did find helpless poor but they argued this was a
consequence (see later explanations) and not a cause.

Rutter and Madge (1977) suggested there was “little documentation of
my communities in this country which might correspond with the
descriptions of a culture of poverty given by Lewis. Interestingly,
Rutter and Madge did a separate study arguing there is a ‘Cycle of

A Situational perspective argues directly against this suggesting that
poverty is due to a through no fault of their own but argue there are
many social, economic and environmental factors which prevent poor
from improving their position. It argues that behaviour is a reaction
to this social situation but not a cause. This difference in situation
means different norms and values from the rest of society. For
example the elderly have insufficient resources during working life to
make provision for retirement. Hannerz (from Haralambos), a Swedish
anthropologist studied a black low-income area of Washington DC. He,
(like Coates and Silburn in their study of Nottingham) found
fatalistic behaviour but believed this was due to the way these
constraints have moulded them.

Social democratic structural explanations argue poverty...

Other Essays Like Assessment Of The Usefulness Of Individualistic Theories Of The Causes Of Poverty

Usefulness of Mobile Phones Essay

1350 words - 6 pages Comp I September 28, 2015 Essay I Final Draft The Usefulness of Mobile phones Most people believe that Mobile phones have taken over people’s lives. Some even say that they are ruining social skills and relationships. None of that is true as long as people can be responsible with their Mobile phone and their time. Phones do not ruin social lives, if anything; they actually enhance our relationships with our peers. Mobile phones are used

Theories of Poverty and Community Development

3503 words - 15 pages aimed to address the causes of poverty. Building a full understanding of each of these competing theories of poverty shows how they shape different community development approaches. While no one theory explains all instances of poverty, this paper aims to show how community development practices that address the complex and issues of poverty more effectively by reducing poverty compared to programs that address a single theory. Theories of

The Causes Of Crime

1558 words - 7 pages Missing Works Cited The Causes of Crime The causes of crime seem to be indefinite and ever changing. In the 19th century, slum poverty was blamed; in the 20th century, a childhood without love was blamed (Adams 152). In the era going into the new millennium, most experts and theorists have given up all hope in trying to pinpoint one single aspect that causes crime. Many experts believe some people are natural born criminals who are born

The Causes of Unemployment

2779 words - 12 pages attention to employment issues, especially in terms of the quantity of jobs created and their quality. It is the second generation strategies, more geared towards accelerated development, that have begun to consider employment creation as one of the objectives to target in the context of poverty reduction. 3.3.5 Main cyclical causes of unemployment, underemployment, vulnerability 45. The cyclical causes of unemployment, underemployment and

The Causes of Divorce

733 words - 3 pages eroding. So around the world, divorce is becoming more acceptable. In the following paragraphs we will examine some of the causes that can lead to divorce. A lack of communication, infidelity, premature marriage and incompatibility or personality conflicts are factors which are usually at the heart of marital conflict all over the world. Firstly, and most likely the most common cause of divorce in today’s society is a lack of openness and

At the Edge of Poverty

1542 words - 7 pages David Shipler’s essay “At the Edge of Poverty” describes the poverty in America and that’s what caught my attention. It is explaining the nightmare happening right now. Nightmares like getting low-pay and getting dead-end jobs. There are so many similarities between his essay and present reality of the issues with health care and education. Through a combination of hard facts and moving accounts of hardships last by individuals it fills in the

To What Extent Were Poverty And Prosperity Causes Of The 1789 French Revolution?

921 words - 4 pages causes was the French social structure, the Ancient Regime. The division into three estates with different rights and duties, produced a clear situation of injustice with poverty for the greater part of the people and the extreme wealth for just a few. 1 To what extent were poverty and prosperity causes of the 1789 French Revolution? To a great extent because the prosperity of the bourgeois encouraged the poverty, peasants, to make justice for

Assess the Usefulness of the Functionalist View of the Family (24 Marks)

670 words - 3 pages Assess the usefulness of the functionalist view of the family. (24 marks) Functionalists believe that society is based on a value consensus – a set of shared norms and values – into which society socialises its members. This enables them to cooperate harmoniously to meet society’s needs and achieve shared goals. They view the family unit as a construct that fulfils important functions and keeps society running smoothly. Functionalists

Assess the Usefulness of Interactionist Approach to the Study of Society

928 words - 4 pages Assess the usefulness of interactionist approach to the study of society Unlike action theory, structural theory is the opposite and primarily focuses on small scale interactions between smaller groups. This includes gangs or cults. Sociologists who support action theory believe that we as humans are actively thinking and are unpredictable; therefore we cannot generalize human social behavior. There are many examples of humans defying the

The Fourth Kind: a Movie Portrayal of the Usefulness of Hypnosis

1270 words - 6 pages The Fourth Kind: A movie portrayal of the usefulness of hypnosis Consciousness has always captivated my attention and has been the subject of my interest. I have decided to pursue an issue that the media never seems to depict properly. Hypnosis is best defined as the connection between two or more people, “In this interaction the hypnotist attempts to influence the subject's perceptions, feelings, thinking and behaviours by asking them to

The Developmment of Comm Theories

2642 words - 11 pages THE DEVELOPMENT OF COMMUNICATION THEORIES: A Critique Paper Since the inception of communication as a discipline of knowledge, scholars have come up with many theories related to its components. In fact, the encyclopaedia of communication theories (Littlejohn, 2009) has identified more than 300 relevant theories, a testament that the field is already making a big wave in the academic arena. It has been a product of many minds converging

Related Papers

Assess The Usefulness Of Feminist Theories Of Religion. (33 Marks)

1512 words - 7 pages Assess the usefulness of feminist theories of religion. (33 marks) Like Marxist’s, feminists believe that religion can be an instrument of alienation and oppression , the key difference between Marxist theories of religion and feminism is that feminist’s believe religion exists to serve patriarchy as opposed to capitalism. The key feminist thinkers of religion are, Mary Daly, Simone de Beauvoir, Karen Armstrong, Jean Holme and Nawal El Sadawi

Assess The Usefulness Of Functionalist Theories In Understanding Religion Today

657 words - 3 pages explain religion to teach us how to conform by teaching us morals and norms; doing this we learn social control and order. This theory and way of looking at religion gives us a good understanding of religion, therefore when looking at Durkheim’s theories of religion they are reasonably useful. A second theorist is Parsons; Parsons emphasised the role of religion in providing the core values of any culture, along with the social norms which

Summarise Two Theories Of Identity And Compare Their Usefulness For Explaining The Real World Issues Discussed In Chapter 1

665 words - 3 pages Summarise two theories of identity and compare their usefulness for explaining the real world issues discussed in Chapter 1. Social identity theory (SIT) is a theory designed to explain how a persons sense of who they are relates directly to the groups that they belong to. Henri Tajfel was a Holocaust survivor that wanted to understand relationships between groups and the processes that led to prejudice.This theory also identified that

Usefulness Of Standardized Testing Essay

900 words - 4 pages Usefulness of Standardized Testing In the United States, standardized testing is used to measure how knowledgeable or unknowledgeable a person is in a particular subject. Standardized tests are exams designed to measure a student’s scholastic performance. These tests are a controversial issue, because some people feel the test do not show the students’ intelligence. I am one of these people. What the test may cover may not be what the