Atheism Euthyphro And Socrates Essay

611 words - 3 pages

For those who haven't shared a class with me, one of my major concerns in conversations of a certain higher degree is the validity of claims presented as well as logical reasoning. The mind is a smart 'machine', so smart that it can trick itself into believing something that is not true. David Patrick Moynihan, four-term U.S. Senator from New York is quoted in saying that: "Everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not his own facts."

A logical fallacy is a flaw in the structure of a deductive argument, which leaves the argument invalid. There are several of these, yet two of the most popular are circular reasoning and false premises. Reading through the text beginning on page 20 and ending on page 23, we see Socrates toying with his mental adversary, Euthyphro. 

One of my primary concerns with this conversation is that by the ...view middle of the document...

Euthyphro’s false premise comes when he instantly asserts his tract of god’s existences, and that holy is synonymous with good. Socrates twice brings up morally questionable acts that some of the gods in Euthyphro’s pantheon would have appreciated individuals committing, yet Euthyphro would be wrong to do so which at the very least weakens the appeal of holiness.

In addition to Socrates questions, which were good within the confines of his line of reasoning, I'd like to add the additional questions to begin my own line of reasoning. My internal goal that I would only externalize post hoc (after the fact) would be to increase the circle and add more to things we could both (hopefully) later count as fallacious. Socrates did “good” in the time he had, but If the following questions were asked, even more of a 'victory' may have been won that day in my opinion.
1. Assuming the existence of your gods, how do you support a claim that you could know what they think is 'good' and 'loved' by them?
2. You state that some things are holy and others unholy. So what? Why is what is holy necessarily good? 
3. You have stated the difference between doing holy acts and just, human acts. What good has come of doing what is holy? (This last one is in close correlation with the stated question on page 23 where he asks how the gods benefit from our offerings)

Two more of my most disliked logical fallacies are the Texas Sharpshooter, which deals with selection biases in causal and correlative relationships:
https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/the-texas-sharpshooter

…and the Strawman, which builds a phony argument where you should be discounting your opponent’s argument and then easily dismantles it:
https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/strawman

What other questions would you have asked if you were there?
Reference:

Velasquez, M. G. (2014). Philosophy, a text with readings (12th ed., pg 20-23). Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Pub. Co..

Other Essays Like Atheism - Euthyphro and Socrates

The Unexamined Life Is Not Worth Living

1240 words - 5 pages the Apology and Euthyphro. The words, ‘the unexamined life is not worth living’ by Socrates comes from Plato’s Apology when Socrates is sentenced to death after being accused of corrupting the youth and impiety (Ahbel-Rappe & Rachana, 229). Patterson posits that apology is one historical account of Socrates’ defense during his trial (Patterson, 16), and these words appear at the end of the Apology when Socrates is going through possible

Philosophy 100 Exam 1 Essay

1107 words - 5 pages with the Socratic form of questioning. In easier terms, Socrates would begin a discussion with someone who asserts a thesis and secure their thesis. Then he would provide examples contradicting one another in which the questioned would both agree with. Thereby rendering their thesis false and naming the contrary to be true. A strength is that this method helps to find deeper meaning through simple questioning and makes the questioned think. 2

Righ and Wrong

661 words - 3 pages ourselves, while Socrates means to argue that obeying the state is a requirement right up until we die. Here it might be useful to apply the same healthy disrespect for moral authority that Socrates himself expressed in the Euthyphro. The second argument is that it is always wrong to break an agreement, and since continuing to live voluntarily in a state constitutes an agreement to obey it, it is wrong to disobey that state. (Crito 52e) This may be a

I Donthave Anything to Upload

922 words - 4 pages self-seeking, and it is not easily angered. Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth.  It always protects, always trusts, always hopes, and always perseveres. - Corinthians 1:13 The Euthyphro dilemma is found in Plato's dialogue Euthyphro; and asks the question ‘is something good because God commands it, or does God command something because it is good?’ The dilemma is that if the acts being performed are morally good because

Metaphysics Testing

2098 words - 9 pages and manipulate. | What is a dialectic? | Dialectic is the process of using counterpoint to evaluate in order to come to the truth. | What is Socratic ignorance? | A self-description by Socrates that he didn't know anything. | What is Socratic irony? | In the writings of Plato, in the beginning, Socrates claims to not know something and his opponent claims to know. By the end, the opposite is true. | What is the Socratic method? | A

Philosophy Review

2522 words - 11 pages systems of the period before the Socratic period. Any philosopher of this period Classical – Socrates, Plato, Artist, & Post-artist Neo-Platonic - A philosophical system developed at Alexandria in the third century A.D. by Plotinus and his successors. It is based on Platonism with elements of mysticism and some Judaic and Christian concepts and posits a single source from which all existence emanates and with which an individual soul can be

Postmodernism

2067 words - 9 pages concept of existentialism and injected a new nihilism and atheism that influenced culture. The early 20th century saw aspects of postmodernism arise with the emergence of the Dada movement, which focused on the framing of objects and discourse as being as important as, or more important than, the work itself.Many philosophers during the mass postcolonialism period after World War II speculated that one could not have an objectively superior

Self Deification

3450 words - 14 pages , or Socrates, or your Freud and Jung for that matter. How do we know unless we explore. . . .Most of our great thinkers have professed to have had an intuition or guidance that they couldn't describe, something they ultimately called a force or God or a higher recognition of truth that required a quantum leap of inspired faith. As Carlyle put it, "The unfathomable SOMEWHAT which is not WE." Or as Matthew Arnold said, "the 'not ourselves' which

Shakespeare's Measure for Measure

4243 words - 17 pages (special grace) which miraculously salvages and sustains our intrinsically worthless natures. Shakespeare reiterates the point made by Socrates in the Euthyphro, that human virtue is for our own good and for this reason pleasing to God in that it glorifies the goodness of his creation. We should not emulate the third servant in the parable who buried his talent in the ground for fear of losing it. Like Angelo, this servant believes in an unjust

The Separation Of Capital Ownership And Control

1577 words - 7 pages The argument of whether the separation of capital ownership and control is an efficient form of organization has constantly been a controversial issue. The criticism whether the controllers’ act is in the best interest of the owners’ wills never end as long as hired managers operate management. As the number of public companies has been increasing over the course of this century, meanwhile the American style of contact based corporation has

The Versatility And Flexibility Of OLED's

1014 words - 5 pages In April 1, 2002, organic light emitting diodes gain rise in the scientific community with their published, more practical form at Ames Laboratory. “Scientists at the U.S. Department of Energy's Ames Laboratory, in collaboration with scientists at the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, have developed and demonstrated a novel, fluorescence-based chemical sensor that is more compact, versatile and less expensive than existing technology of its

Related Papers

The Analyzing Of Euthyphro Essay

626 words - 3 pages a murderous hired hand. Socrates flatters Euthyphro, suggesting that Euthyphro must be a great expert in religious matters if he is willing to prosecute his own father on so questionable a charge. Euthyphro concurs that he does indeed know all there is to be known about what is holy. Socrates urges Euthyphro to instruct him and to teach him what holiness is, since Euthyphro's teaching might help Socrates in his trial against Meletus. First

Philosophical Contribution From Socrates And Euthyphro's Dialogue

390 words - 2 pages The dialogue between Socrates and Euthyphro shows Socrates wanting to learn the definition of piety from Euthyphro, who claims to know what piety is-that which is loved by the gods. Ironically, Socrates plays the student, and Euthyphro the teacher, while Socrates is really trying to teach Euthyphro that his definition of piety is not justified. Eventually, we learn that what is pious may be loved by the gods, but being pious and god-beloved

Socrates And Piety Essay

1364 words - 6 pages Socrates Search for the Meaning of Piety Despite that there are a significant amount of atheists, religions and cultures throughout the world, piety is still relevant to today’s society. But what does it really mean? Euthyphro is a strong believer that he contains the divine knowledge of what the God’s deliberate to be pious. Euthyphro provided numerous definitions to Socrates throughout the dialogue, none of which seemed to satisfy Socrates

Plato’s Portrayal Of Socrates Essay

2450 words - 10 pages from is meletē. In fact, “Socrates puns on Meletus’ name by arguing that ‘Mr. Care doesn’t really care.’”5 In Plato’s Euthyphro, however, Socrates’ humor changes slightly. Still intellectual, it changes only in that he uses it for very personal enjoyment rather than something as public as the stage of the Athenian court. Euthyphro is the story of a meeting on the street between Socrates and his friend Euthyphro. Their exchange