Benchmarking Human Resource Systems Are We Ready For It?

5062 words - 21 pages


The 1996 Directors' Workshop at Jodhpur ushered into SAIL, the hottest new buzzword in management, BENCHMARKING. An adequate working definition of this term has been provided in the documented outcomes of the conclave.

"Simply put, benchmarking is the search for the industries best practices that guide and lead to superior performance level".

Best practices are generally understood to be the methods used in work processes that produce outputs which best meet customer requirements in a particular 'marketplace'. The conversion of best practices into measurements of best performance result in benchmarks i.e. ...view middle of the document...

A schematic of the key benchmarking process steps as per this framework is placed at Annex-I. Any other approach to benchmarking will necessarily adopt similar steps, the only variation likely being the degree of detail in which these steps may be broken down to as guidelines for action.

To meet the objective of this paper, i.e. gauging our preparedness and readiness to utilize benchmarking as a performance improvement tool, it would be sufficient to work through the first three key process steps i.e. the Planning Phase, of this particular framework of implementing a benchmarking exercise. After all, actually implementing benchmarking in our context would only be feasible if we are able to cope with the planning requirements.


In determining the subject to be benchmarked the focus will necessarily be on performance improvement in areas related to:
- products or Services we produce
- work processes or business practices we use
- factors which are critical to the success of our operations.

After arriving at a listing of possible subjects, the choice would generally be determined by how critical the particular subject is to achieving customer satisfaction or how significant is the problem to be solved. Another key aspect of choosing a subject for benchmarking is also the determination of the measurements that should be used. It is important to select measurements that are true indicators of performance in the subject area chosen.

In the Human Resources realm, our 'marketplace' comprises primarily of internal customers. We have very few tangible products in the conventional sense of the term. Our products are largely the outputs of systems and work processes we adopt and employ to discharge the requirements of a clearly spelt out HR policy framework. Hence, our targets for performance improvement would have to be these systems and work processes with the objective of continuously tailoring their outputs to meet the expectations of our customers.

Given that the focus is ultimately on customer satisfaction, an appropriate start point in listing of the possible subjects to be benchmarked would be to examine the deliverables expected by our customers.

Some of the more critical areas of customer expectations and the deliverables expected by them as enumerated in the ICS interactions are listed below. Alongside these expectations, the boundaries within which the function is currently expected to operate in these areas are also listed.

Manpower "Putting the right man, with the right skill and attitude, on the right job, at the right place at the right time". The expectations on manpower have to be achieved within the overall Corporate HR budget guidelines of manpower rationalization as also conformance to a rigid legislative framework that gives precedence to protecting workers' interest even at the cost of overall business or industry interests.

Growth ...

Other Essays Like Benchmarking Human Resource Systems-Are We Ready for It?

Graduation Speech: We Are Prepared For The Challenges That Await Us

635 words - 3 pages to make it on time to first period. Along with our cars came part-time jobs that sometimes seemed like full-time when we added them to our busy school schedules. Many of us have become adults and are now able to vote. With growing up, came maturity and we began taking an active role in the community by volunteering. This year we collected 10,000 cans of food and beat Terrace during PPP. Tonight we are at the start of the most crucial time of our lives. We all are ready to move on with our lives and continue to build our future. By making the choice to finish high school and graduate, we have already shown that we are prepared for the challenges that await us.

Human Resource Management Is All About People. If You Like To Talk To People Then A Job In Human Resources Is For You

1858 words - 8 pages Human Resource Management is all about people, and deals with issues related to people such as compensation, hiring, performance management, safety, wellness, benefits, employee motivation, communication, and training. A career in HRM isn't just for those who enjoy talking to people, it is also for those who like systems, analytics and processes as HRM professionals are typically given ownership over a process, specialty area or task with a

In What Way Has the Computer Been a Useful Tool for How We Think About Minds? What Are Its Limitations?

3967 words - 16 pages . So we can apply the same way of thinking to the mind: minds are devices running on complex chunks of software – in our case, the human brain. The distinction between role and occupant is like the distinction between software and hardware: the software is the programme, or set of instructions for converting inputs into outputs, and it can be run on different kinds of machine or hardware. Philosophers felt encouraged to compare the mind to a

This Essay Critiques The Use Of Force In "When We Are Kings", "Bowling For Columbine", And "Do The Right Thing"

1055 words - 5 pages Force is something that we have all experienced. Force can be positive or negative. Violence and persuasion are two types of force that are present in the three movies. The three movies we watched in class all use force to get their message across. In Bowling for Columbine Michael Moore uses persuasion as a type of force; while Do the Right Thing and When we were Kings use violence as a force. Force can have a great impact on a person's

3. Immanuel Kant: Human Beings Are the Only Animals with an Existential Need for Work (Cited in Svendsen 2008, P.30)

812 words - 4 pages Immanuel Kant claimed that human are the only animals with an existential need for work. Without work, we would simply be bored to death because work provides our lives with content (Kant [1803] 1902- :471). One thing we can’t deny, work is a fundamental part in a human life. Everybody needs to work, and surely there’ll be a certain amount of people who enjoy and find passion in theirs. But in contrast, there’ll be people who endure boredom, or

In Order to Write a Persuasive Essay, You Need to Come Up with a Few Arguments in Favor of Your Point. Here Are Some Potential Arguments for This Idea: It Makes the Children Feel Equally Loved by Both...

1252 words - 6 pages Assume Equal Responsibility In Raising Children Children And Young People Essay Naturally, family is made up of mother, father, and children. Children are supposed to be raised by both parents, and we all accept that father and mother have vital roles in upbringing their children into potential and useful people to contribute to social development. However, it is quite challenging if we want to compare whether mother or father is more


2722 words - 11 pages market level (Keegan, 1998)… thirdly, the particular processes or strategies in the firm (Bogan and English, 1994). For example, at the company level, Microsoft Corporate launched Windows XP, by benchmarking it with their NT series. Or direct benchmarking with competitor, like Microsoft Corporation, benchmarked the Apple Macintosh and, then, launched Windows operating systems. Kumar and Chandra (2001) suggested that when choosing the


1512 words - 7 pages decisions the organization can make for improvement for the company overall. There are five other limitations for benchmarking: if there are uncooperative sources in an organization, meaning that if there are people who have the best practices but they do not want to help out by sharing their efforts with others, if there are managers who want to learn and achieve the best practice but are not capable of it because they do not have a good and


4692 words - 19 pages or processes) with others; identifying gaps in performance; developing performance improvements to close the gaps thus identified; implementing the improvements; monitoring progress and; reviewing the benefits The key questions on which successful benchmarking turns are: • How do we do it? and • How do they do it? – in other words a comparison of your processes with (a) more successful organisation(s) to establish exactly where the differences

Project in Total Quality Management

3635 words - 15 pages what you know into what you do. The executor dimension of the leader focuses on the question, “How will we make sure we get to where we are going?” Executors translate strategy into action and put the systems in place for others to do the same. Executors understand how to make change happy, assign accountability, and know which key decisions to take and which to delegate, and make sure that teams work well together. They keep promises to multiple

Riordan Gap Analysis: Organization Human Resource Practices

1800 words - 8 pages Identification Issue Opportunity Reference to Specific Course Concept (Include citation) Concept Designing human resource systems for specific business situations Riordan’s sales force can become top producers and provide sustained profits and growth. In addition to product knowledge and sales skills, key behaviors which the HR system would need to support include motivation to receive training to develop one’s knowledge, skills, and

Related Papers

Equity Policies Are Important For Human Resource Management Because They Affect The Whole Range Of Employment Practices And Policies In An Organization. Why Is This So? Explain Your Answer

254 words - 2 pages Equity policies influence many areas of employment practices in an organization. This is because equity issues affect the bottom line of an organization. Areas such asEquitable treatment in all matters related to employment. It is important that the HR department ensures that every employee is given fair and equitable treatment in all maters related to employment. HR has a responsibility to make sure that the 'best' person is hired for the job

Implications For Human Resource Development Paper

1089 words - 5 pages very important role. They are responsible for several different components within the workplace and discrimination is one of those things. They are not allowed to discriminate against anyone when it comes to hiring them and if they are any reports of discrimination within the workplace it is up to Human Resources to do any necessary investigations on the matter and to handle things accordingly. Human Resources needs to uphold all of the laws

Agression Are We Born Agressive Or Is It Learned

1743 words - 7 pages , it would seem that an environmental stimulus/cue is needed for this behaviour to be shown.It would therefore be sensible to suggest that a persons genetic makeup provides the potentialities for aggression, but the environment to which we are exposed and the experiences we have throughout our lives, determine to what extent and to what degree they will develop.BIBLIOGRAPHY Atkinson,Smith,Benn,Nolen-Hoeksema - Introduction to Psychology 13th

Climate Change Are You For Or Against It

613 words - 3 pages the advanced onset of climate change. “ Human activity is causing the Earth to get hotter primarily by two actions: Burning fossil fuels, with a smaller contribution from clear cutting forests, known as deforestation. Natural amounts of carbon dioxide have varied from 180 to 300 parts per million (ppm). Levels today are around 400 ppm. That’s 40% more than the highest natural levels over the past 800,000 years. We also can tell that the