Big Time Toymaker Essay

1436 words - 6 pages

Case Scenario: Big Time Toymaker
Jordan Czarapata
December 10, 2012
LAW/421

Abstract
This intent of this paper is to go over the scenario between Big Time Toymaker and Chou over an agreement to distribute a new strategy game. Some of the areas covered are whether or not a contract existed between the two parties, objective intent, and how e-mail comes in to play with enforceability. Also we see if the statute of frauds applies to this scenario and the defenses that either party has in the case. Lastly, we look at the different remedies that can be sought out to reimburse the party harmed by the breaching of the contract

Case Scenario: Big Time Toymaker
In the Theory to ...view middle of the document...


Objective Intent
In terms of the parties’ objective intent, Chou would be in favor with the oral agreement and also the email that he immediately sent to BTT after their request for a distribution agreement contract. BTT had paid Chou $25,000 for exclusive negotiation rights so obviously BTT was serious about making an agreement on a distribution contract. According to Melvin (2011), “the law requires only that the parties’ acts or words lead the other party to reasonable believe (objective standard) that an agreement has been reached (Melvin, 2011. p.130). The fact that would weigh against Chou is that there is no technical written agreement that was signed by either party. There was only an oral agreement but it was not drafted before the 90-day period that was given in the original agreement. For this reason, the new manager of BTT was not obligated to distribute since there was no valid contract.
Communication through Email
The fact that the two parties were communicating by e-mail does have an impact on my analysis. In today’s world communications and business transactions are done in large part with e-mail. According to section 7 of the Uniform Electronic Transaction Act (UETA), "any law that requires a writing will be satisfied by an electronic record. A contract may not be denied legal effect or enforceability solely because an electronic record was used in its formation,” ("Uniform law commission:," 2011, para. 6). Both BTT and Chou communicated their intent and also they both agreed through e-mail.
Statute of Frauds
The statute of fraud applies to this scenario because of the agreement that BTT paid Chou $25,000 in exchange for exclusive negotiation rights for a 90-day period. Not only did the agreement between the two parties state that no distribution contracted existed unless it was in writing but also as stated by Melvin (2011) under the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC), “the the statute of frauds applies to any contract for the sale of goods for $500 or more, and any lease transaction for goods amounting to $1,000 or more,” (Melvin, 2011). Even though the e-mail from BTT stating the terms and specifics of the agreement could be considered an enforceable contract under the stipulations in the above paragraphs, it is missing one important element required by the statute of frauds, which is a signature (Melvin, 2011). However, in Case 6.3 of the text (Stevens v. Publicis), the court focused on the name at the end of the e-mail messages. The exact words of the court being, “the e-mails constitute ‘signed writings’ within the meaning of the statute of frauds, since the name at the end of the e-mail signified the intent to authenticate the contents,” (Stevens v. Publicis, Melvin, 2011, p. 152). It is uncertain in this scenario if there were any names at the ends of the e-mails because the text doesn’t mention anything pertaining to this.
Doctrine of Mistake and other Defenses
A mistake according to Melvin (2011)...

Other Essays Like Big Time Toymaker

Law 421 Final Exam Essay

661 words - 3 pages LAW 421 - Week 1 Assignment. The author is working in the field of education from last 5 years. This article covers the basic of LAW 421 class from UOP. Other topics in the class are as follows: LAW 421 - Week 1 - Role and Functions of Law Paper LAW 421 - Week 2 - Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues Simulation Summary LAW 421 - Week 3 - Case Scenarios: BUGusa, Inc. LAW 421 - Week 4 - Case Scenario: Big Time Toymaker LAW 421 - Week 5 - Case Scenarios: Grocery, Inc., Presentation For further information on the above topics you can always visit the website www.StudentWhiz.com

Book Review - Brick by Brick the Lego Story

4748 words - 19 pages buildingblock materials continued to appeal to those groups for years, as the company turned out more and more themed building sets and expanded its markets. Submitted  by  Mazin  Meaboob  C  [roll  no.102]   Chapter Three: Losing Control. The Scattered remains of runaway innovation On the surface, the Lego Group didn’t look as if it was in trouble. The fourth-largest toymaker in the world at the time (today it is fifth-largest

The Separation Of Capital Ownership And Control

1577 words - 7 pages to monitor management deviation has been proposed. Supporters of this view believe that no matter how alienate is controllers form owners, fixed claimants from banks like loans and interests have to be paid. International big banks are suggested to take the role of supervising manager behavior. However, the obvious withdraw of this suggestion is that banks plays significantly different role from investors in an economy, and therefore they have

The Versatility And Flexibility Of OLED's

1014 words - 5 pages periods of time, or over a lifetime. Curative action could be taken immediately instead of waiting for an analysis. This sensing chemistry can be selected to detect pathogens or other analytes a person might be exposed to, and with the small OLED size, multiple hazards can be measured at once on a small chip. (Aylott). The versatility and flexibility of OLEDs as sensors is their biggest prospect. Some proposed systems could contain up to 16x16 = 256

Comparing The Moral Virtues Of Antony And Julian The Apostate

1103 words - 5 pages , consequently he did. Every time he would be asked to do something by God, he would never hesitate. Antony was an extremely devoted man. For numerous years, he was alone in the deserts of Egypt, spending his days praying. Frequently, the devil endeavored to tempt him with many methods although Antony would resist his attacks by constantly praying and fasting. With time the attacks became more severe and after resisting one of the attacks, Antony

Living In A Cashless Society

1637 words - 7 pages government will have to be the central part of the system. That means that the government will be in control. One other reason why cashless society would be the best option is time convenience and place preference. Client can make transaction at anytime and when convenience. Users can log on to their account any time of the day but would have to have a computer with a steady internet connection which does not matter whether the bank is still open

The French And Indian War: The "Real" First World War

1955 words - 8 pages generation after it” (Acknowledgments). The author fully embraces his desire not only in the amount of research that he did but also in the time spent analyzing and interpreting the information into written and yet living history. Borneman seems to have truly grasped the scale of the war, acknowledging that there was no real way to ever understand every aspect of neither the period nor the events that would transpire. In trying to explain the overall

Is The Use Of Animals In Medical Research A Necessary Measure?

1513 words - 7 pages research (Thomassen 2). During his time, religion played a main role in society, making people believe they were supreme rulers over all other living beings on the earth as stated in the bible. Because of this fact, humans and animals were not linked and research was conducted only to learn more about non-human species. It was not until 1859 when Charles Darwin came up with his theory of evolution that human and animal body systems were connected

Education And The Evolving Job Market

2363 words - 10 pages activities which are effective in quickly grabbing student’s attention, eliminating distractions, and piquing interest. Sponge activities can be used to “soak up” extra time without loosing an educational opportunity. Other strategies include graphic organizers, metaphorical and analogous thinking, cooperative group learning, independent work assignments, and role-playing (Gregory, et. al., 2007). The more a teacher can provide variety in the

Young And Relentless

1737 words - 7 pages , they will soon rebel against their parents and start using drugs such as alcohol. Subsequently alcohol advertisements are all around us which draws teens to picture what a “fun time” it is. Countless advertisements include urging strategies and tempting traps that aim for people of all ages. Alcohol is one of the most popular forms of substance use displayed throughout the world and it growing more and more every year. There are many

The Natural Law Theory

1231 words - 5 pages Obeying by the natural law theory is the only true and moral way to live life; especially a life lived in God’s image. God’s presence is a guiding factor to obtaining a moral and virtuous life, which can only be obtained by following the natural law theory. God created a set of laws as a supreme guide for humans to live life, like any law these laws were created to ensure wellbeing for everyone. The laws he created are the civil law, the natural

Related Papers

Case Scenario: Big Time Toymaker Essay

746 words - 3 pages Case Scenario: Big Time Toymaker In a business environment contracts are used on a day to day basis and they are an important area of focus for owners and managers. According to (Melvin, 2011)”A contract is formed when two or more parties agree to a particular set of terms.” Contracts are essential to businesses because it helps companies to do business with other companies without posing too much of a risk on their end, as long as the contract

Theory To Practice "Big Time Toymaker"

918 words - 4 pages Theory to Practice "Big Time Toymaker"Georga A. SmithLAW/421August 5, 2014Eric Nord Running head: THEORY TO PRACTICE "BIG TIME TOYMAKER" 1 THEORY TO PRACTICE "BIG TIME TOYMAKER" 5 Theory to Practice "Big Time Toymaker"In this report, it will answer several questions base on the case scenario of "Big Time Toymaker". The report will discuss at what point, if ever, did the parties have a contract? What facts may weigh in favor of or against

Big Time Toy Maker Essay

748 words - 3 pages Big Time Toymaker Ronda Bonny LAW/421 AUGUST 13, 2012 JAMES ZACCARIA Big Time Toymaker 1. At what point, if ever, did the parties have a contract? After reading the case scenario, I do not believe either of the two parties involved ever established a binding distribution contract. It is true an oral distribution agreement was achieved just three days prior to the 90-day deadline, which was a condition established in the original

Bussiness Law Essay

1330 words - 6 pages BIG TIME TOY MAKER Larry E. Linton Law/421 October 27, 2014 Professor Rachel Lyne BIG TIME TOY MAKER 1.) The parties have a contract the moment that Chou and Big Time Toymaker (BTT) entered the exclusive negotiation agreement. A contract is considered perfected the moment the parties reached an agreement which signifies their consent, the object of the contract and the consideration or price. It bears to stress that the first element to test