Boys Will Be Men Essay

1410 words - 6 pages

Roger Logan
Professor Garvin
English 1010
Paper #3
Comic Book Boys
Peter Middleton’s essay “Boys Will Be Men” begins with simple anecdotes about the relationships between boys and men of different ages. Middleton then changes his focus towards comic books, where his focus remains all the way through the rest of the paper. Circling back to his original thoughts, the focus on comic books leads to an analysis of comic books in regards to children and their development into men. In his conclusion to the essay, Middleton states, “Nevertheless, action comics for boys are certainly damaging because they offer false solutions to the difficulties of growing up which both sexes face” (Middleton ...view middle of the document...

In other words, along with the costume’s portrayal of masculinity with its tight fit over chiseled muscles, Batman shows a complete disregard for the law that seems to go hand in hand. Middleton touches upon this in his essay, “Not that [Batman] is a criminal but he is not simply an agent of city hall. In many of the stories he is at odds with the official handling of an investigation, and in the way” (Middleton 127). This is the exact type of situation that unfolds in the movies, more specifically in The Dark Knight, where city hall actually calls for the arrest of Batman and issues the warrant to make it official. Batman’s infamy is what makes him popular. His ability to walk a path in which he fights for justice but not in the way that justice wants him to sets Batman up as a figure of supreme masculinity. This is possible because of the history of courageous and testosterone driven men acting outside the law.
The latest Batman movie was titled The Dark Knight not because it was something cool, but because it cleverly held the meaning of Batman. The knight of medieval times is seen as a representative of the code chivalry. Chivalry in turn gave birth to the first heroes, in that they were destined to battle heroically, always for sake of justice no matter what the means, and often for the sake of a woman. All of these traits point to the modern Batman because in actuality he is a Knight, but a Dark Knight because he fights for justice but by his own means. In “Boys Will Be Men,” Middleton comments upon justice, “These superheroes can be said to gain their power from the law… In the superhero comics justice exists independently of the hero, although he draws the power of his manhood from it” (Middleton 127). Middleton argues that it is both the connection to the law and the disconnection to the law that is seen as manly to the readers of the comic books. As such, Batman becomes more like a cowboy than a Knight, while a Knight answers often to a King, a cowboy answers to himself and justice alone. Furthermore, the fact that cowboys were always seen as the real men throughout popular lore, Batman’s masculinity is increased by his role within justice.
While it would seem accurate to say that Batman is the definitive leader among the DC Comics world in popularity, Spiderman is Marvel Comics’ equivalent lead man. Although not shrouded in notoriety as is the Batman throughout the Marvel series’ history, Spiderman goes through phases due to the same reasoning. Spiderman often goes from being immensely popular and loved by the general population to periods in which he has operated under the radar as is customary of Batman. Within the Spiderman movies of late, audiences witness both periods in Spiderman’s life, from hated to loved with little change in his behavior. And it is Spiderman’s costumed behavior that must be looked at to see the presence of masculinity. As Middleton states,
“The stories are about being, not becoming, a man. Superheroes...

Other Essays Like Boys Will Be Men

Various Factors Explaining Why Boys are Boys and Men are Men

1630 words - 7 pages Various Factors Explaining Why Boys are Boys and Men are Men This paper is going to describe various key factors explaining why boys are boys, men are men, and how boys adapt in this male dominant society to become men. Growing up in Pensacola Florida in a single parent home wasn’t something I wished are hoped for, but something I had to adapt to. My mother, even though she couldn’t be the male role model I needed, help me understand

The Lords Of Discipline Essay

468 words - 2 pages The Lords of Discipline Not many of the boys who enter the Carolina Military Institute as freshmen leave the school as graduates. Set in South Carolina, this is a story seen through the eyes of Will McLean, a sensitive, yet rebellious young boy, who aspires to be an "institiute man". He is an intelligent, honest, sarcastic and incredibly funny Irish, working class youth who doesn't hide from the truth or his fears. Secondary characters Dante

Hear What I Am Really Trying to Say,

1852 words - 8 pages conflicts is really the result of the opposite natures of male and female. It is the nature of men to be dominant, and it is the nature of women to be submissive; any revolt against these natures, will cause conflict amongst men and women. Tannen says, “If a man experiences life as a fight for freedom, he is naturally inclined to resist attempts to control him and determine his behavior”(p.152). Since male and female “natures

" Sex, Lies and Conversation" by Deborah Tannen

459 words - 2 pages is the cornerstone of friendship. By sharing secrets, thoughtsm feelings, and impressions, girls and women build intimacy in their relationships. Where as young boys build relationsips by doing things together. Young boys are more inclusive with each other, creating larger groups of friends. Within these large groups, boys compete with each other to avoid the subordinate position. Intimate conversation is a form of weakness for boys and men

Co Education

525 words - 3 pages Research, show that single-sex schools that have been found successful could be because of smaller class sizes, stricter admission policy and more of an emphasis in education and not because of the distraction the opposite sex seems to cause. Life is simply co-ed. So I believe if boys and girls in the same institution, they will prepare the students for the real world. They’ll learn how to act with one as well as influence each other. They can learn to adjust to the opposite sex in able to work together and establish some form of relationship. Which is the in the nature of the human race.

Asses the View That Gender Difference in Achievement Are a Result of Outside the Educational System

1652 words - 7 pages Asses the view that gender difference in achievement are a result of outside the educational system. The gender difference in achievement in the past and the present portray two different perspectives. In the past boys did better than girls’ bout as times go on due to internal and external factors this has changed as girls are doing better than boys in the current education system. In this essay it will explore how the perception of girls in

The Feminine Mystique And The Organization Man

1129 words - 5 pages looked at more closely; are they fair on both sides, or do they in fact discriminate against he two sexes. Men are taught to be emotionless in times of stress and women are taught to be helpless and needy. This is how our society expects men and women to behave. Maybe in the near future as a culture we will use gender transcendence, in which as a people we will abandon our assigned gender ideas, so that other aspects of life become separated and gender free.

The Power of Talk

841 words - 4 pages expected to give orders and push the stats boys around. While girls who are “bossy” or as the leader are viewed negatively. Also in situations where the women is the one-up position and the man is the one-down position based on the rank, men will tend to view the women as a “bully” or other less kindly words. Whereas if the man was in the top position, his requests and demands would be respected.

Transforming Gender Relations in Ghana

2366 words - 10 pages focused on separate targeted activities for women. Gender mainstreaming is also about examining how gender dynamics affect decision-making within the families and communities including whether girls or boys will be sent to school and whether women or men have influence over how family resources are spent. These discussions on the various terms and strategies have helped conceptualize the scope of gender. In order to push the agenda forward and

He Is and Always Will Be

905 words - 4 pages Saray Rivera L. Riddell English 50 26 September 2012 I.E.: He is and Always will be A woman can go on a date with a man and she might not know if he is a bad boy or a stage five clinger. Usually men try to give women a great impression; therefore, it is quite simple to stereotype them most of the time. All men have different personalities, but it can be easy to categorize them by their actions. Women encounter different types of men every

Toy Store Practicum

1015 words - 5 pages before... Walk into any toy store and you will see, recapitulated in the store's aisle arrangement, the strict distinction and separation of the sexes along specific gender lines: Barbies, My Little Ponies, and She-Ras in one aisle; He-Man, the Transformers, and Thundercats in another"The toy department in Target unmistakably displays the differences in the roles of little girls and little boys. The simple fact that a person knows what toy is meant

Related Papers

Boys Will Be Boys Essay

544 words - 3 pages kids I had my good times and my bad times. My first few years were pretty much up to par with the status quo of behavioral and educational standards. I would do all my homework and be a good little boy in class. It wasn’t till I reached junior high that I started rebelling a little. In my seventh grade class I felt as if I were ready to be treated as an equal adult. What I mean by this is, I didn’t want to be told what to do

Co Education In Schools Essay

763 words - 4 pages create a feeling of comradeship between boys and girls. Plato was a great supporter of the education of women. Therefore, he wanted them to be educated with men in the same institutions. He felt that if men and women are taught together, it will develop their personality to the maximum. They will not feel any shyness from each other. He advocated that it was the only method in which both could become useful members of the society. Plato in reality

Boys' Antisocial Behavior Essay

1823 words - 8 pages that at that time men were the ones who were working and running the show, while the womans' job was to stay home and tend to the children. At that time boys were treated fairly in the school system. The boys' behaved rowdy and aggressive as boys do, but the teachers accepted it, to an extent, because they understood that boys will be boys and that this was their natural behavior. The boys would outgrow their anti-social behavior in due time

A Case Study For Same Sex Schools And Classrooms

948 words - 4 pages results. There is a debate as to whether boys and girls should attend separate schools or not. Some people think they should be integrated and others believe that they should attend separate schools. While there are advantages and disadvantages to both arguments, I agree that boys and girls should attend separate schools because they can concentrate better on their studies and will have respect for the opposite gender. A single-sex