"Breaker Morant Builds A Convincing Argument That It Is Those At The Top Of The War Hierarchy That Are Truly Guilty, And Not The Lowly Soldiers Who Carry Out Orders." Discuss

574 words - 3 pages

Throughout the course of the film of Breaker Morant, a convincing argument builds that those who are at the top of the war hierarchy are the truly guilty ones as opposed to the common soldiers who simply follow orders. The film shows this through the court trials, as J.F. Thomas repeatedly stresses that Harry Morant, along with Hancock and Witton, were simply following orders from Lord Kitchener. We has also shown the conditions that the Bushvelt carabineer's were in juxtaposed by the situation of the British high class officers, and the guilt that they truly posses. War has been familiarized by people all around the world, and it is well known that soldiers follow orders from higher class officers. It is military ...view middle of the document...

He consults with his colleagues about sacrificing the three Australian soldiers for shooting the prisoners, as they had neither the facilities nor the supplies to keep prisoners. Lord Kitchener thus gave the order to Captain Hunt not to keep prisoners, but to shoot them, Lord Kitchener was aware of this, and thus it is he himself who gave out the orders to shoot prisoners, Breaker Morant was merely following these same orders, shooting the Boer wearing British Khaki, and yet he was placed on trial along with Witton and Hancock. We see Thomas repeatedly stress this point through the course of the court trial, that the orders were given down from higher class officers, and that the three Australians were obeying these orders. Each time we see Lord Kitchener we are shown a glorious white mansion, and within, high class furniture, as well as the people acting sophisticated and elegant. We see these men in their comfortable environment tossing away orders, looking as if they had never tasted the bitterness of war. As Col. Ian Hamilton and Lord Kitchener have their talk, we are revealed to their true guilt. We see that orders were given down by Kitchener, and that he is the one truly guilty for these crimes. He adopts the Utilitarian point of view as he states that he is willing to sacrifice the tree BushVelt Carabineer's, Harry Morant, George Witton and Peter Hancock for the greater good of the British Empire. In conclusion, through the scenes of Lord Kitchener and the compassionate spirit through the course of the trial, it is evident that higher class military officers are the ones truly responsible for the military crime, and they are the ones who are truly guilty, as opposed to the lowly soldiers who simply follow orders.

Other Essays Like "Breaker Morant builds a convincing argument that it is those at the top of the war hierarchy that are truly guilty, and not the lowly soldiers who carry out orders." Discuss

Assets That Are Not Included in the Balance Sheet

1042 words - 5 pages to be an assets e.g. providing future economic benefit, can be controlled. A loyal and creative workforce eventually enables business to earn extra revenue and make it easier to have loyal customers as they might be satisfied with the service given. The reason why this asset is not included in the balance sheet is their values are not measureable in term of money. This convention also states that assets should be valued at “cost less their

Examine The Argument That Poverty Is Best Explained In Terms Of Personal Moral Failings

1547 words - 7 pages a child, they would then become a single income family even if for only a short time, and this would mean a fall in income. When the children are older they may leave home meaning that the parents would again have a higher income, only for it to fall again at retirement. As statistic show 21 per cent of those living on a low income are over 60 years of age.The World Development Report is the World Banks contribution to an ongoing dialogue on

What Is the Best Step for Troika Towards Those Countries That Need Financial Support?

3207 words - 13 pages to cut the pay of 10%, the demand curves shift to the left and the supply will decrease at the same time. In this case, the Spanish government is trying to use pay cut to reduce their debt, it could work for that purpose only in the short run. In order to recover from recession, building up a healthy economic environment would be essential, which is not simply done by cutting pay cut may causes (Parkin)   pay

Look at the Way a Theme or Character Is Presented in Your Chosen Text. Include in Your Response Any Social, Cultural and Historical Contexts That Are Important to Your Understanding of the Theme or...

887 words - 4 pages is not likely to be kept on at the ranch much longer and has no one who will help him. This is his best chance to survive and his last chance to feel useful or have a little dream of his own. Candy owns a small and very old dog that he has grown very attached to, later in the book his dog is shot after the rest of the ranch all agree it isn’t any good and it is just cruel to keep it alive in the sorry state it is in (going blind and limping

To What Extent Do You Agree That a Revolution Happened in Germany at the End of World War I

671 words - 3 pages To what extent do you agree that a revolution happened in Germany at the end of World War I In Germany between 1918 and 1919 there were major political changes. They went from being an autocracy to a democracy. A revolution is defined as a forcible overthrow of a government or social order for a new system. It was called a revolution for numerous reasons. On October 29th 1919, a mutiny started to spread near Kiel because sailors refused

There Are Two Types of Observation, Covert and Overt. the Difference Between Them Is That Covert Observation Is When the People Being Observed Do Not Know They’re Being Watched or Studied, and Overt...

3943 words - 16 pages election. However, for most Fulham voters it was almost certainly housing, food prices and employment that influenced their vote. 1933 Oxford Union resolved by 257 to 153 votes that ‘this house will not fight for King and Country’ Oct/Nov 1933 Hitler held a confirmatory plebiscite to approve his pulling out of the Disarmament Conference and the League of Nations – gained 95% approval. 1933 Britain proposed (to get Germany back in the conference

Discuss the philosophy of materialism. Explain its basic claims. Give the names of some who hold this position and point out some of the problems with materialism

377 words - 2 pages Materialism is space and what takes up within it. The belief that which can be explained and perceived consists of a foundation relating only to the physical world. Matter reduced to the sole medium of the known reality. Thought, feelings, and will being derivations of configured elements. Considered terse by idealists; found lacking in the explanation of reality. Today, various schools are popular amongst materialists: extreme and

The Greatness of Individuals Can Be Decided Only by Those Who Live After Them, Not by Their Contemporaries

954 words - 4 pages effectiveness and practicality of their great deeds. However, in other fields as science and arts, people's greatness would not be easily acknowledged and appreciated because the value of not only science but also arts is not only face value---whether they are truly of great value needs to stand the test of time. One example in the scientific world that at once pops up into mind is Albert Einstein, the greatest theoretical physicist in America in

Asses the View That Gender Difference in Achievement Are a Result of Outside the Educational System

1652 words - 7 pages . Nonetheless the question is why boys are underachieving in the current education system. One external factor in which boys are underachieving is due to their literacy skills. It is argued that parents spend less time reading to their sons. Also, it is the mother who does most of reading to young children, who came to see it as a feminine activity. Boys’ leisure pursuits such as football does not require them to communicate as a result they are not

What Are the Effective Study Skills That Provide a Sole Foundation of a Sound Rducation

845 words - 4 pages birth to two years. At birth a child uses their natural instincts of sucking, grasping, seeing and hearing. As they develop through this stage the main thing they will overcome is the difficulty to understand that even though something cannot be seem it still exists, realising this will move them onto the second stage of preoperational lasting until they are about seven. In this stage they start using their imagination more including pretent

"Just Marvelous, Lewis. Everyone Thoroughly Enjoyed It, Didn't Think It Was Possible, Came Right Out of Their Shells. They Blossomed, Blossomed!" 'It Is Lewis Who Truly Blossoms in Cosi.' Do You...

713 words - 3 pages , hence confirming that Julie also truly blossoming ‘Cosi’. Overall, it is observant (Evident) that Lewis has blossomed throughout the production of the opera, through his perseverance of the directing of the production, even with his stereotypical views on the mental patients at first, also his development and appreciation of true values like Love and fidelity gaining a view on commitment about its importance, On the other hand it is witnessed that not only Lewis has blossomed but also Julie with her illustrating loyalty and the means of commitment, but even with this said it is truly Lewis who outshined and blossomed in ‘Cosi’.

Related Papers

Information Security And The Areas That Truly Affect It

1623 words - 7 pages urgency to the problem but not overdo it. I was an auditor for an IBM mainframe when the first rounds of SOX audits were being done. At this point, I’m a techie working for the CFO and remember that the CFO and CEO are personally liable for financial misstatements. Since the IT department didn’t like want I was doing, they turned to attack me. The CFO is the threatened one here and he negotiated the permissions for me to demonstrate

Who Should Have Won The French And Indian War? An Essay That Describes Important Events In The French And Indian War In A Way That The Reader Can Decide For Himself Who Should Have Won It

732 words - 3 pages Who really should have won the French and Indian war? France and Britain engaged in a succession of wars in Europe and the Caribbean at several intervals in the 18th century. Though Britain secured certain advantages from them -- primarily in the sugar-rich islands of the Caribbean -- the struggles were generally indecisive, and France remained in a powerful position in North America at the beginning of the Seven Years War in 1754.By that time

Evaluate The Claim That Miracles In The Bible Are Not A Reliable Form Of Experience

854 words - 4 pages Evaluate the claim that miracles in the Bible are not a reliable form of experience. Prior to discussing this, it’s important to understand what it means to read the Bible. There are two common interpretations of the Bible, a literal reading and a non-literal reading. Having said this, I will argue that miracles in the bible, on balance are not a reliable form of religious experience and will consider the case studies of Jesus’ resurrection

Arguments In Support Of The Claim That It Is Not Wrong To Eat Animals

1837 words - 8 pages because of the overconfidence on the future growth in prices for home in the U.S. . Banks also used those credits to generate money by leveraging in the financial sector that triggered off a series of action in the financial market. They bought mortgages and transformed them to funds and sold it to the investors who want to invest in the US to earn money. It helped increase the hosing price. While some