This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Capital Punishment Essay

1212 words - 5 pages

Three of Rajiv Gandhi’s assassins have been scheduled to hanged to death on Sept 9.
Last execution in India was in 2004: Dhananjoy Chatterjee
96 countries have already abolished CP.
34 are observing official or non-official moratorium on CP.
CP is a throwback to a medievalist bloodlust that has no place in the modern criminal justice system.

Some issues
* Long pendency of clemency petitions

NHRC Chairperson K G Balakrishnan has favoured capital punishment arguing that it is awarded in the rarest of rare cases and has a deterrent effect.

Gabriel Garcia Marquez's classic, One Hundred Years of Solitude, begins with a line that could be read as a powerful argument against capital ...view middle of the document...

The ‘Model Prison Manual for the Superintendence & Management of Prisons In India' (2003) recommends that all prisoners going to meet their fate at the gallows be made to wear “a cotton cap with flap” so that he/she will not be able to see the gallows — an highly ineffectual aid, surely, under such circumstances.
Internationally, India continues to remain in an ambiguous position. It is party to the International Convention on Civil and Political Rights that requires countries to move towards the abolition of capital punishment, but has desisted from ratifying the Second Optional Protocol to the Convention and last November it voted along with China and Saudi Arabia to oppose a UN resolution for a moratorium on the death penalty.
So while there may be some curling of toes over the prospect of denying criminals on death row their right to life, the Indian State has consistently balked at doing away with the hanging option. By and large, the argument put forward by the Law Commission of India in 1967 continues to hold sway. In its 35th Report, the Law Commission pronounced that “Having regard… to the conditions in India, to the variety of the social upbringing of its inhabitants, to the disparity in the level of morality and education in the country, to the vastness of its area, to the diversity of its population and to the paramount need for maintaining law and order in the country at the present juncture, India cannot risk the experiment of abolition of capital punishment.”
Necessary risk
The fact is that 139 countries in the world — and their number is rising not declining — despite serious security challenges have taken this “risk”, precisely because it is a risk that modern and modernising states should take, given that not doing so would compromise the very notion of an enlightened state. Remember that many of these countries have had long and grisly trysts with capital punishment. Pre-19th century England, for instance, had over 200 “crimes” that could invite a hanging sentence. The list included thievery (goods valued at five shillings and more), maiming horses, impersonation and ‘sodomy'.
One of the justifications for persisting with the death penalty is, of course, that inchoate, arbitrary, unquantifiable and often irrational concept known as “public opinion”. Indian courts, incidentally, have been sensitive to “public opinion”. In a judgment, Dhananjoy Chatterjee v State of West Bengal, that had led in 2004 to the last public hanging India has witnessed so far, the Supreme Court stated: “Imposition of appropriate punishment is the manner in...

Other Essays Like Capital Punishment

Capital Punishment Essay

997 words - 4 pages are too lax and criminals of today take advantage of them, ie. organized crime, knowing very well that the punishments for their crime, whether it be murder, theft, or any other number of criminal activities, will be so negligible that it may be well worth their risk. Although in the past, the number of crimes that were subjected to capital punishment, defined simply as the death penalty for a crime, were

Capital Punishment Essay

607 words - 3 pages Capital Punishment is the lawful infliction of the death penalty. The three most common death penalties are the gas chamber, lethal injection, and the electric chair. These methods are used to be a deterrent against crimes such as murder. The point given to these people is that they are less likely to commit a crime knowing they’ll receive the ultimate punishment to kill. "No other punishment is to deter man so effectively from committing a

Capital Punishment

1532 words - 7 pages Capital Punishment Capital Punishment is the most effective deterrent to anyone thinking of committing a serious crime such as premeditated first degree murder. Capital punishment may seem harsh, but a comprehensive study in the United States indicates that it makes a person think twice before committing such a serious crime, and therefore actually saves lives. Here is a brief history of the death penalty and it's application. The

Capital Punishment

1272 words - 6 pages Human Rights - Capital Punishment The Humans Rights Issue I have chosen to discuss today is Capital Punishment. Quite simply, capital punishment is the death penalty given by the government of a country, via their legal system, to people who have committed the most evil of crimes. Many countries have abolished the death penalty from their laws, but there are many that remain which still practice the act of killing a person

Capital Punishment - 1652 words

1652 words - 7 pages liberally, as did the Church of the Middle Ages. As history tells us, capital punishment, whose definition is "the use of death as a legally sanctioned punishment," is an acceptable and efficient means of deterring crime. Today, the death penalty remains an effective method of punishment for murder and other heinous crimes. There is debate over the morals and effectiveness of such a harsh sentence. Most commonly, the death penalty is

Capital Punishment - 2201 words

2201 words - 9 pages Capital punishment From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia (Redirected from Capital Punishment) Jump to: navigation, search "Death penalty" and "Death sentence" redirect here. For other uses, see Death penalty (disambiguation) and Death sentence (disambiguation). "Execution" and "Execute" redirect here. For other uses, see Execution (disambiguation) and Execute (disambiguation). For other uses, see Capital punishment (disambiguation

Capital Punishment

1314 words - 6 pages punishable by death. In Massachusetts there were only thirteen crimes punishable by death which include; cursing, adultery, lying under oath, praying to idols, etc. Throughout the colonies Ohio, New Jersey, Massachusetts, and New York kept the death penalty while in others they opposed and abolished the law. Michigan was the first state to do away with capital punishment. After that the states followed although Maine teeter tottered until 1887

Capital Punishment - 1691 words

1691 words - 7 pages "Capital Punishment" Throughout the United States of America the death penalty, or execution, is a means of punishment used to put an individual to death from a crime or crimes that they have committed. The crimes resulting in the death sentence are capital offenses or capital crimes including aggravated murder, drug trafficking and crimes related to homicide (Moore 17). Most societies have practiced the death penalty in the past, but have

Capital Punishment - 1762 words

1762 words - 8 pages Justice can not be served until the debate on capital punishment is resolved and all states have come to agree that the death penalty is the best way to stop crime completely. "The bottom line is, one method of execution is just as brutal and as barbaric as the next," says Mr. Breedlove of the National Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty. This comes straight from the mouth of a member of a national organization against capital

Capital Punishment - 1586 words

1586 words - 7 pages VICTIM IMPACT STATEMENT, AND CAPITAL PUNISHMENT ALTERNATIVE TO SEMINAR SESSION By GINGER SMITH KEN METCLIFF INTRODUCTION TO CRIMINAL JUSTICE 09/14/2014 The victim impact statement can be a written or oral statement to the courts at pretrial, sentencing or parole board a statement of the crime committed on or towards the victim or the family left behind. The victim impact statement is allowed in the fifty states the attorney or victim

Capital Punishment

786 words - 4 pages argument to support a controversial act is not only unacceptable, but it is irresponsible. If there is any validity to this argument, it is negated by the actual amount of time an offender spends on death row. Endless appeals, delays, technicalities, and retrials keep those condemned to death waiting for execution for years on end. If the majority of death row residents live to an old age anyway, why would anyone be afraid of capital punishment

Related Papers

Capital Punishment Essay 566 Words

566 words - 3 pages Is the state justified in executing people convicted of crimes? The state should not have the right to execute people convicted of crimes. I see capital punishment as an immoral practice because capital punishment has failed to prove any benefits. Capital punishment is not cost effective and does not have a deterrence effect. I believe that the influence of media has caused the widespread support for the capital punishment. The public needs

Capital Punishment Essay 630 Words

630 words - 3 pages Should the U.S. continue to use capital punishment? CRT/225 CLARENCE MITCHELL April 5, 2009 Should the U.S. continue to use capital punishment? Should the U.S. continue to use capital punishment? I say absolutely! I believe that fear of sever punishment is a deterrent for many people that may cross the line of decency and commit heinous crimes. We really need to look at examples of other countries that have gone away from

Capital Punishment Essay 1606 Words

1606 words - 7 pages Outline and examine the religious and moral arguments used in the case for and against capital punishment. In order to ensure justice prevails in society, rules or laws are created by the governing authorities so that individual members of society are aware of what is considered to be acceptable and unacceptable behaviour. To vindicate these rules, punishments are given. One of these types of punishment is retribution, i.e, capital punishment

Capital Punishment Essay 930 Words

930 words - 4 pages Capital Punishment Introduction: Think for a moment about the fall into sin. Think about the people in Noah’s day. Sodom and Gomorrah. What is the punishment inflicted upon all of them by God? Death. The death penalty, or capital punishment, is the first and harshest penalty for sin. Although it has evolved and changed form over the years, and is now decided upon by men playing God, it is still an acceptable, God pleasing form of