Case Study Of “Rigorous Or Not?: A Case Of Auditor Judgment For Deferred Tax Issues”

2168 words - 9 pages

Case study of “Rigorous or Not?: A Case of Auditor Judgment for Deferred Tax Issues”

Judgment Framework and Professional Judgment

Discuss the importance of “judgment framing.”

“Judgment framing” occurs early in the judgment process. The definition of framing follows: Frames are mental structures that we use, usually subconsciously, to simplify, organize, and guide our understanding of a situation. They shape our perspectives and determine the information that we will see as relevant or irrelevant, important or unimportant. Frames are a necessary aspect of judgment, but it is important to realize that our judgment frames provide only one particular perspective.

The importance is ...view middle of the document...

A common mistake in evaluating the quality of a judgment is to focus only on the outcome and ignore the quality of the process that led up to the outcome. Because uncertainty is involved in making choices, it is often best to evaluate judgment performance by considering the quality of the judgment process employed rather than focusing solely on the outcome that resulted from the judgment.

d. Reach a Conclusion: It is important to consider whether the conclusion reached makes sense when taking into account the bigger picture. At this stage, it is appropriate to consider the strength of evidence and whether the alternatives considered and evidence gathered have been considered in a way that is objective and unhindered by judgment traps.

e. Articulate and Document Rationale: This step is included as a separate step in the KPMG Professional Judgment Framework because it is extremely important to properly document the work performed in an accounting or auditing setting. In this final step, we need to be prepared to articulate our rationale to those who may not agree with the conclusions reached. It is also appropriate to document positive/supportive evidence as well as evidence that went contrary to the ultimate conclusion. Documenting the rationale also helps to make sure that all of the other steps of the judgment process were completed in an appropriate fashion and that the logic holds together when documenting the process and conclusion.

Describe the availability tendency in your own words, and give an example of how the tendency could result in auditor bias.

The tendency for decision makers to consider information that is easily retrievable from memory as being more likely, more relevant, or more important for a judgment. Example: An auditor who identified a significant amount of unrecorded liabilities on a prior audit is likely to overestimate the likelihood of the presence of unrecorded liabilities on a subsequent audit.

Describe the confirmation tendency in your own words, and give an example of how the tendency could result in auditor bias.

The tendency for people making judgments to seek and to put more weight on information that is consistent with their initial beliefs or preferences. Example: If management has taken a particular stance in accounting for a complex transaction and the authoritative standards are not clear on the subject, the auditor may be likely to seek and to place inordinate weight on evidence that supports or “confirms” management’s treatment of the transaction.

What are some common judgment traps that prevent exercising good professional judgment?

• Shortcuts: May lead to systematically biased judgments.
• The “Rush to Solve”: The tendency to want to immediately solve a problem by making a quick judgment.
• “Judgment trigger”: Can lead the decision make to skip the crucial early steps in the judgment process.

What is the most important factor in avoiding traps or reducing bias?


Other Essays Like Case Study of “Rigorous or Not?: a Case of Auditor Judgment for Deferred Tax Issues”

Case Study of Tweeter

654 words - 3 pages Case Study of Tweeter Decision: APP would not continue to be an effective policy in the future. Instead, Tweeter may think about abandon the APP strategy and focus on high-end market, emphasizing ‘high quality and high service’. Several considerations about the decision: 1. Customer Based on the dimension of ‘price’ and ‘quality/service’, there will be 4 segments, which are ‘entry-level customer’, ‘the price bitter’, ‘the convenience

Case Study: to Market or Not to Market

1453 words - 6 pages IHP-504: Healthcare Policy and Financing Case study: To market or not to market Southern New Hampshire University The evaluated case study depicts a scenario wherein a recently established local nonprofit healthcare organization has been in operations for a little over a year. It was founded by a number of healthcare professionals (volunteers) including nurses and administrators who share a common mission, vision and goals. Their mission

Analysis of Case Study

1255 words - 6 pages nutritional value. This can be serve as viand or snack. The proponents decided to use direct channel of distribution. Veggielicious Siomai is offered at a competitive price of Php5.00 each weighing 25grams. Its color is off-white when it is not yet cooked and light brown when it is already cooked. Its smell gives you allusion that the product tastes good. Project Summary The objective of the study is to identify the feasibility and success of

Legal and Ethical Issues of a Medical Error Case

1063 words - 5 pages later charged with negligent homicide. Legal Aspects of this Case Four elements must be present for negligence; duty to care, breach of duty, injury, and causation. Negligence is a civil personal wrong of unintentional commission or omission of an act a reasonable prudent person would or would not do under similar circumstances (Pozgar, 2013). According to the National Coordinating Council for Medication Error Reporting and Prevention, a

Case Study Paper For Borderline Personality Disoder. Shows An Actually Sitiution Of A Person With BPD

1176 words - 5 pages relationship, first initiating them, and then ending them, not long after they begin. She loves, and gets some sort of a high, when her partners seemed puzzled, or even extremely upset, when she ends the relationships that she so willingly started. She enjoys being close to someone physically. She needs this. But she dreads being too emotionally involved. She immediately ends a relationship, once she begins to feel anything for the person. Elizabeth

Case Study: Bank of America

1111 words - 5 pages  Case Study Bank of America: Mobile Banking April 29, 2014 AMBA 650 section 9040 Professor Boyle TABLE OF CONTENTS I. CASE SUMMARY 3 II. KEY ISSUES 4 III. ANALYSIS AND EVALUATION 4 IV. RECOMMENDATIONS 7 Appendix A: REFERENCES 13 I. CASE SUMMARY Bank of America (BoA), established their online presence in the early 1990s. The goal was to provide their customers

Applications of Epidemiology-Case Study

1807 words - 8 pages Applications of Epidemiology-A case study Analyze Good Health Hospital’s records and itemize recent nosocomial infections that occurred within the past year. In your report, categorize the different parameters (i.e. person, time, place and ethnicity and gender) used in the compilation of data into the information summative. Hypothetically, Good Health Hospital is assumed to have possessed nosocomial infections as in any real hospitals where

Case Study of Helen Leonard

1597 words - 7 pages delusional) nearly every day (not merely self-reproach or guilt about being sick). 8. Diminished ability to think or concentrate, or indecisiveness, nearly every day (either by subjective account or as observed by others). 9. Recurrent thoughts of death (not just fear of dying), recurrent suicidal ideation without a specific plan, or a suicide attempt or a specific plan for committing suicide. B. The symptoms cause clinically significant

Case Study of Anz Offshore

622 words - 3 pages , unprincipled and corrupt" media empire in history. People process management of News Limited should not be influenced by Murdoch culture when making decision. Talk about something how it should hire people. CR: more interesting news yields more profit. Rebuttal: Like News of the world stewed in its own juice, ultimately unethical employee behavior will lead to a failure of the business. Plus, due to deontological theory that the rightness or wrongness depends on the inherent intention rather than the consequences, although there might be a chance to generate higher profit, it is not ethical to recruit immoral employees who get their jobs done by unethical way.

The Case Study of Lv

892 words - 4 pages company should make an explanation to tell the consumer does not have the situation because there is no evidence. This can regain the trust of customers and not damage the credibility of the brand. The other way is to apologize to the public. A part of consumers question from the quality of the product. At the same time make a reasonable explanation. Provides explain of Louis Vuitton made in China with no quality issues. The production of LV in China

Bank of America Case Study

808 words - 4 pages relationships. We are concerned about getting banking business instead of just generating brand awareness and brand association, or generating more retail traffic. Sponsorships for Bank of America is ultimately a banking business decision- a decision to help our line of business. NASCAR With a broad reach as 1800 racing events and more than 110 tracks in 36 states it is ranked number one corporate involvement and per-event attendance, and number

Related Papers

Case Study Ethical Issues

617 words - 3 pages 1. What are the ethical issues in this case? Ethical issues for this company relate to how much of an impact they have to the environment in regards to waste. An ethic problem NBB is having is to whether or not to put their product into cans. They will be reducing the amount of co2 by 30% since cans are lighter to transport. Another problem would be the amount of water wasted. NBB is a company that relies heavily on water to brew their beer

A Case Study Of Wal Mart

1432 words - 6 pages display it, which contributes to responding to customer needs. However, the primary source of differentiation in terms of HR management is that the company places tremendous emphasis on reducing shrinkage (which is a euphemism for pilferage or shoplifting). This reduction can be attributed to the program established that passes on half of any reductions in shrinkage in a particular store to the employees. As a result, there is great incentive to

A Case Study Of Green Mountain Inc

775 words - 4 pages . Although sales were flat, retail locations can be used as a vehicle for customers to sample Green Mountain coffee. If customers are unfamiliar with the taste of Green Mountain coffee, they will not purchase Green Mountain coffee at supermarkets or other sale locations. Starbucks' success is due to its retail locations. Customers understand the reputation of Starbucks and are familiar to the expensive, social, great tasting coffee. Opening retail

Case Study Of Pji

1165 words - 5 pages responsibility for carrying out the debt-equity conversation scheme to make the PJI operation feasible and viable. Case Analysis The privatization of PJI is one of the highest priorities or it will mean a substantial addition to the government and a further boost to the economic recovery program of the country. Indeed, it is more urgent and deserves greater priority and attention than the recovery of the alleged ill-gotten wealth of Benjamin Romualdez