Clash Of Arguments On Slavery Essay

2861 words - 12 pages

There are hundreds of different views about ‘slavery’. As Paul Finkelman says; few subjects in American history have been as compelling as slavery. Actually the reason, of why this is one of the most compelled and debated issue, is “slavery is not only one of the most ancient but also one of the most long-lived forms of economic and social organizations” . All antebellum Americans, in north and south, were affected directly or indirectly by slavery. When we look at the economic aspect of slavery, I can say that slavery helped the economic growth and development of the United States. It was a harsh but profitable system. Contrary to the arguments that see slavery as inefficient and detriment ...view middle of the document...

Of course, there are not only black and white (against and favor of slavery) opinions in the debate; some historians represent the “gray” color of opinion like Eugene Genovese and Kenneth Stampp. I am going to discuss different interpretation of slavery from the words of Phillips who was against slavery, Fogel and Engerman who were favor of slavery and besides these clear-cut opposers and defenders of slavery, as the mild facets of the debate, I am going to touch upon the Genovese and Stampp’s arguments on slavery.
Ulrich Bonnet Phillips was a Southerner by birth, and a professor of history at the Universities of Wisconsin, Michigan and Yale. In his book “American Negro Slavery”, Phillips wrote about the old South and black people’s inferiority. He thought that slavery was an unprofitable institution. He believed in white supremacy. In his other book “The Slave Economy of the Old South”, he focuses on slave economy and the inefficiency of slave labor. Phillips thought; “slavery became an economic burden in America, and that the purchase of the un-free laborers made a great drain upon the earnings of the community that imported them. American slaveholding was essentially industrial in character; and industry under the slave-using system was essentially capitalistic. For the sake of controlling the labor, a very large portion of the capital was invested in the legal ownership of the labor itself. This system was expensive not only to the individual planter, but also to the whole community. The burdensomeness of the slaveholding and slave trade in the South was a very general phenomenon”. Also he added that planters shouldered the burden of slavery because they supported and maintained the institution for other reasons. In his both books, Phillips provided numerous examples intended to demonstrate the inefficiency of slavery and the inherent laziness, docility, and incompetence of blacks, whether enslaved or free.
Slavery had hurt rather than profited the economy of the South. It had hurt not just the blacks but also whites, not just the nonslaveholders but also the slaveholders. Phillips argues that slavery was not only “immoral” but also it was an inefficient and wasteful economic system. Phillips drew up the all the economic detriments of slavery. He says; “it was an inefficient and unprofitable economic system which degraded labor, led to misallocations of investment, stifled technological prgress, inhibited industrializaton, and thwarted urbanization”.
Phillips made an argument on data that he collected with respect to the prices of slaves and prices of cotton. In his article ‘The Economic Cost of Slaveholding in the Cotton Belt’, he made an argument that; “ the inefficiency of slave labor made it a profitable investment only when there was a conjunction of three conditions. These conditions were; an extreme scarcity of, and a high price, for free labor; a system of agricultural organization and a set of crops that permitted the...

Other Essays Like Clash of Arguments on Slavery

Slavery Issue Essay

467 words - 2 pages The article discusses the different opinions of historians on how slavery began in the New World. The major two points are: some prescribe that racism caused it, others subscribe to being economic factors. Both views have valid facts that support their arguments. At its pinnacle, blacks were seen as inferior to Europeans; in addition, they were the backbone of the flourishing plantations.The question, then is which if either was the cause of

Civil War Essay

1121 words - 5 pages violation of their constitutional rights and as being part of a plan to eventually abolish slavery. The Republican Party, dominant in the North, secured a majority of the electoral votes, and Lincoln was elected the first Republican president, but before his inauguration on March 4, 1861, seven slave states with cotton-based economies formed the Confederacy. On March 4, 1861, Lincoln delivered his inaugural address to a fractured union. Speaking

Give me liberty

1244 words - 5 pages the contest. There is no retreat but in submission and slavery! Our chains are forged! Their clanking may be heard on the plains of Boston! The war is inevitable--and let it come! I repeat it, sir, let it come. It is in vain, sir, to extentuate the matter. Gentlemen may cry, Peace, Peace--but there is no peace. The war is actually begun! The next gale that sweeps from the north will bring to our ears the clash of resounding arms! Our brethren are

Sectional Compromises In The 19th Century

1303 words - 6 pages 19th century, the North and South constantly fought over the question of slavery- where it should be allowed, who should be allowed to harbor it, and what should be done about the rights of those enslaved. As a solution to these recurrent arguments, several compromises were made. However, the statement, "The sectional compromises of the first half of the 19th century were not in fact compromises but rather a ‘sectional sellout' in which the

Causes of Revolution

3194 words - 13 pages ? | | | | | | | | | |What were some of the arguments centered on slavery and territorial expansion? How did the | | | | |Compromise of 1850 fail to solve them

Human Resource Management

591 words - 3 pages 1. Personalities and emotions can play a large role in labor- management negotiations. If the personalities are similar it can cause the negotiations to go quicker and smoother. On the other hand, if personalities clash, then it can cause the negotiations to be long and drawn out. When the personalities clash there can be a lot of arguments and quarrels that are a result in the two sides not agreeing. But when the two sides have similar

Causes of Civil War

944 words - 4 pages on wage manual worker, not slaves. At the same time, the Southern states continuously to depend on slaves for their agricultural economy and cotton manufacture. South made enormous revenues from cotton, slaves and struggled to sustain them. Northside did not require slaves to maintain their economy so they fought to free abolish slavery as whole from United States. History shows us the agricultural economy was indeed one cause of civil war, but it

Bleeding Kansas

480 words - 2 pages . Pro-slavery forces said every settler had the right to bring his own property, including slaves, into the territory. Anti-slavery "free soil" forces said the rich slaveholders would buy up all the good farmland and work them with black slaves, leaving little or no opportunity for non-slaveholders. Violent clashes soon occurred as a result of the conflict, one of the most publicized events that occurred in Bleeding Kansas was when on May 21, 1856


893 words - 4 pages €™ benefit, etc. The rationalizations and defenses given for slavery and the slave trade were absurd and self-serving. Slavery was a truly barbaric, and those who think that they can control what another group of people eat, where they sleep, whether they are to live or die, or even whether they are to be bought or sold, are acting on a totally inhumane level. But just as important as the critique of the slave trade is that need to discover how the

Outline of Syllabus for Unit 1 History

1100 words - 5 pages . |Identifying learning styles of students. |syllabus for the course. |policy, expectations, etc. |Computer Lab. & Multiple | | | |Introduction to the historiography on |2. Students should appreciate the rationale|Class discussion. |Intelligencies exercise

The World’s Anti- Slavery Convention of 1840 While reading this

398 words - 2 pages it also had many other effects on the world back then.The author's thesis clearly states this convention helped things out extremely, and was also a good push in the right direction for the woman's suffrage movement. He thinks this because in his opinion, the convention is best known for its disputes over the rights and admission of the women delegates. The author's final statement re-states the point that the second anti- slavery convention was

Related Papers

Assess The Moral Arguments And Political Actions Of Those Opposed To The Spread Of Slavery In The Context Of Two Of The Following

473 words - 2 pages Assess the moral arguments and political actions of those opposed to the spread of slavery in the context of two of the following:The Missouri CompromiseThe Mexican WarCompromise Of 1850Kansas-Nebraska Act The moral and political actions of those opposed to the spread of slavery in the context of The Mexican War and The Kansas-Nebraska Act are very conflicting. With the upset in balance of the Mexican War, antislavery activists

America The Decisive Years A Discussion On Slavery; Britain's Treatment Of The Colonies And Weaknesses Of The Articles Of Confederation

1390 words - 6 pages them (Olaudah Equiano, 1789).Once the slaves reached America, conditions were not much better. Slaves were considered chattel and treated no better than animals (Diethorn, 1986). Slaves rarely escaped or purchased their freedom. One of the lucky ones was Josiah Henson. Josiah Henson spent thirty years on a plantation in Montgomery County, Maryland before he escaped slavery and became a Methodist preacher, abolitionist, lecturer, and founder of a

Detecting Media Bias Essay

967 words - 4 pages underage youth. As Mr. Clash announced his resigning, another lawsuit was being filed in federal court charging Mr. Clash with sexual abuse of another youth. Sesame Street went on the record to say that the controversy surrounding Mr. Clash’s personal life has become a distraction and that he can no longer be effective in his job. The following day, Mr. Clash’s first accuser recanted his charge and said that his encounter with Mr. Clash was as

Expansion Of Cotton Production Essay

926 words - 4 pages grown. This group also believed that it was their right to continue to use slaves to grow cotton in the new western territory. The start of the proslavery arguments happened because of the growth of abolitionism and they wanted to justify the institution of slavery. Much of their mindset was based on the ideas of white superiority as well as religious justifications. These advocates wanted to convince both Southerners and Northerners that