This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparative Essay Murmuring Judges (David Hare) And Measure For Measure (Shakespeare) Good For A Level Eng Lit+Lang (Theme Of Power)

2370 words - 10 pages

"My opinion is, that power should always be distrusted, in whatever hands it is placed. (Sir William Jones, 1835)

The theme of power is addressed in different ways in each of the two plays. The title of Shakespeare's play, 'Measure for measure' is an indication for the audience of the possible themes and makes an allusion to the old testament teaching 'an eye for an eye' (Leviticus, 24:20) and also conjures the mental image of a pair of scales, with each 'measure' or action done weighed up and then punished or given mercy.
Hare's play, 'Murmuring Judges' gets its name from the law that condemns the condemnation of the judiciary, an offence punishable in law in Scotland today. It is obvious ...view middle of the document...

Isabella is especially deferential to the Friar as she is 'in probation of a sisterhood'. In Act 4.1 the Duke visits the 'brawling' Mariana to try to comfort her. She is truly in awe of his religious persona and this is shown by her deferential speech in line 22. She tells him 'I am always bound to you' which shows that she is his subject. The adjective 'bound' means that she is obliged to do as he wishes and also compelled to do so. She uses the adverb 'always' to him which shows that she will always follow his example and will do his will in any situation. Her absolute trust is manifested when she agrees to entrust her chastity as the Friar asks. In the Jacobean society Shakespeare lived in women would have always done as they were bid by order of men, but especially if the order was given by a man of religion. These words show the absolute compliance that the Duke is able to gain through becoming a pseudo-friar. The Duke abuses this religious power to gain insight into people's souls for his own ends. He knows that Angelo wishes Isabella to 'give up the treasures' of her body and uses the two women to gain more power over Angelo.

The power over the mind in Hare's play, 'Murmuring Judges' is addressed in a different way. In 1980's Britain people weren't as religious as they were in Jacobean Society. The new 'religion' in Thatcher's Britain was the obsession with political correctness, equal opportunities and public relations. Bureaucracy and political correctness bind the police force in the time of Hare's play. According to the 'Sapir-Whorf hypothesis', people are bound in thought by their language and this is shown clearly through the police men and women through scenes where they interact. The police force is bored by the fact that they have to fill in to many forms, and that they have little time to do the actual practice of catching criminals. Short phrases such as 'Crimes of opportunity. Not being able to resist it…Possession.' convey Sandra's annoyance, in Act 1.5, at the routine of arresting people for petty crime. These truncated lines show the audience Hare's message that the police should be less interested in the paperwork of the police and more in the actual act of crime fighting. Sandra exaggerates the amount of bureaucracy in the line 'Each officer carries thirty-six bits of paper about their person at any one time' and this hyperbole displays clearly to the audience the disillusion of the police force. Sandra shows that she views the paperwork as unimportant and frustrating when she refers to it as 'bits of paper'. She uses this phrase instead of the actual names of the forms to illustrate her point. Sandra feels powerless to stop crime when she spends most of her time 'getting through biros'. Sandra is imprisoned by the bureaucracy of the police force.
Sandra is not the only officer that feels this frustration- Lester also seems bored by the endless paperwork and displays his disinterest in the monotony of everyday police...

Other Essays Like Comparative Essay- Murmuring Judges (David Hare) And Measure For Measure (Shakespeare) Good For A-Level Eng Lit+Lang (Theme Of Power)

Is The Use Of Animals In Medical Research A Necessary Measure?

1513 words - 7 pages enacted the Animal Welfare Act (AWA), a law regulating animal research. Unfortunately, the use of rodents is excessive because they are not one of the warm blooded animals protected under the AWA. The sole purpose of the Animal Welfare Act is “to regulate transportation, sale, and handling of dogs, cats, nonhuman primates, guinea pigs, hamsters, and rabbits intended to be used in research or "for other purposes””, and to some extent this purpose

Eng Worksheet for Juniors Grammer Essay

600 words - 3 pages crush, and make the water slimy, and poison valuable fish in the nets, such as the tuna and salmon that the fishermen rely on to make a living. No one knows for sure what's causing this jellyfish traffic jam. It's possible that oceans heated by global warming are creating the perfect jellyfish breeding ground. Another theory is that over fishing has decreased the numbers of some fish, which may allow the jelly fishes to chow down without

'Theme Parks - Value For Money?' Discursive Essay

824 words - 4 pages I don't agree with this statement because the entry fees are way too much to get into the big theme parks such as Disney and Universal and there are extra things to pay for on top of the entrance price. The entry prices are way too high and they usually have an adult price and a child's price and quite often the upper age limit for child tickets is only 9 or 10 and at this age, they are not tall enough to get on many of the rides so it is a

Gdp vs. Hdi- the Adequate Measure of Societal Well - Being

1804 words - 8 pages single measure of economic well-being in a society. It speaks to us how the economy in each country is working, and from there the government can bring out the right policies to adjust the economy. Issues with GDP being a measure for societal well-being. Opinionstage.com – a website which oftens seeks for viewers’s opinion once did a small survey with the question: is GDP growth a good measure for living standards? For the results, the answer

Eng 221 Week 3 Request for Proposal

566 words - 3 pages [Type the company name] | Request for Proposal Microsoft Office Training | | | | [Pick the date] | | Company Description and Goals | Company Description [Company Name] is a small design company started in January of 2010. We design marketing materials and websites for businesses and information products sold online and in print. Company Goals [Company Name] goal is to continue to expand our customer base by

2 Poems From "Death Of A Naturalist" And Heaney's Techniques For Exploring The Theme Of Nature In His Poetry

1115 words - 5 pages change from good to bad very quickly. Heaney sometimes uses the theme of nature as an analogy for other arguments. For example, in the first poem, he suggests that what is true for blackberries may be true of good things generally: how these never last. Nowadays however we can preserve our fruit by freezing it - so does this mean that hopes are not disappointed after all? This is also done in "Death of a Naturalist" where in the heart of civilisation there is this wild element, Heaney seems to suggest that it is also in the very heart of man; that every man has an untamed and wild streak buried in the very deepest parts of himself.

Brave New World Short Essays for Lit

1580 words - 7 pages feel and why they feel a certain way. Their actions, which speak as loud as their internal thoughts, shows us what kind of people they are, for example: what hypnotic phrases they repeat most, how their body language expresses their words, what will and will not do, what they wear, etc. 4. Themes: * Technological Control – A strong and stressed theme in BNW is the progression of technology and how it controls the denizens of the New

Corruption-Good for a Country's Economy

3394 words - 14 pages CORRUPTION IS MORALLY BAD, BUT ECONOMICALLY BENEFICIAL FOR A NATION’S PROSPERITY. CORRUPTION AND INDIA: According to Transparency International (TI), ‘Corruption’ is operationally defined as the abuse of entrusted power for private gain. TI further differentiates between "according to rule" corruption and "against the rule" corruption. Facilitation payments, where a bribe is paid to receive preferential treatment for something that the bribe

Theme for English B

639 words - 3 pages that having a paper come out of you and coming true isn’t always true. Maybe it can be true for all of the white people, but not for him because he is black. Realistically in this time period, if he wrote about blacks having the same rights as whites, then that would not come true in that era. When he mentions that he is the only colored student in his class, it seems as if he is stating that not every black person has the privilege to attend

Theme Of "Dr. Jekyll And Mr. Hyde" Good Vs. Evil

520 words - 3 pages The book Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde made the biggest impact on me. This book was written in the late 1800's and the theme still has deep meaning today. In my opinion, the theme of the story is based on the idea that we all have a good side and an evil side. I believe that there are life lessons to this idea. I also enjoyed the theme because I could relate to it in some ways.Dr. Jekyll was a very kind and friendly man, unsuspected to be the cause of

Diploma Level 3 for Children and Young People

1191 words - 5 pages from shops. Communication can be used to negotiate things, for example, children and staff can negotiate incentives for doing certain jobs around the house, eg, In my work place we communicate with the boys to choose a weekly jobs like taking recycling out, gardening, washing cars and at the end of the week they get a weekly incentive of £4.00 this are done by organising community meeting in the house and the young persons get an option to choose

Related Papers

Shakespeare's Measure For Measure Essay

4243 words - 17 pages seek refuge in the imagination was undertaken because the prevalent state of civil society placed human integrity and virtue in grave jeopardy. Appropriate political measures are necessary to ensure that the human renewals and fresh beginnings celebrated in the comedies can be preserved and fostered when we leave Arden to resume our places in the workaday world. This reading will suggest that Measure for Measure is not a celebration of family

How To Measure The Effectiveness Of A Business

2583 words - 11 pages completely different skill set from what the Reagan ambassadors possessed. The CEO, being in crisis management mode as a result of the IG report, was operating from a political frame, where there was a great deal of conflict and various constituencies were competing for power and resources. He did not take the opportunity to view, first hand, the contributions Dulles ambassadors were making to their customers. He just equated the “kids dressed

Measure Of Economic Welfare (Mew): Essay

836 words - 4 pages MEASURE OF ECONOMIC WELFARE (MEW): HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF MEW: In 1960’s, there started a widespread interrogation on the standard of living, traditional ethics and customs, and the ‘consumption oriented society’ in particular. In this general phase of rebellion allied with ancient and eroded institutions, morals and customs, and economic growth as evaluated by GDP became the center of objection and denial. Some critics claimed that

Jerome Groopman's The Measure Of Our Days

1065 words - 5 pages . Groopman takes his title from a Psalm of David, Psalm 39, "Lord, make me to know mine end, and the measure of my days, what it is; that I may know how frail I am. Dr. Groopman, as well as being a prolific writer, has an exceptional insight of the importance of confronting one's death, both for the patient and for their family and friends. The eight patients he synopsis’s vary extensively in their personalities and in their ailments, yet each