Compare And Contrast The Approach To Studying Children’s Friendships Taken In The Bigelow And La Gaipa (1974) Study With That Taken By William Corsaro

1581 words - 7 pages

Compare and contrast the approach to studying children’s friendships taken in the Bigelow and La Gaipa (1974) study with that taken by William Corsaro
Children’s friendships have been studied by a number of researchers and psychologists. The two studies that will be looked at will be those conducted by Bigelow and La Gaipa (1974) and by William Corsaro. Each study will be looked at in depth; this will include what was researched and also the methods that were used during the study. With this information, similarities and differences will naturally arise and give grounds for comparing and contrasting the two.
When looking at the content of both studies there is a clear similarity and this ...view middle of the document...

This is also true when in correlation with the research methods that were used. Bigelow and La Gaipa’s approach was to ask children to think about a best friend of the same sex and with this the children were then asked to produce an essay consisting of what they sought after and expected from a best friend. They were also asked to include within the essay, how they might differ their expectations of less closer friends (Brownlow, 2010 p. 242). This approach could produce more varied answers and results from that of observations and experiments. On the other hand, Corsaro took the approach of taking detailed notes and video recordings of children’s interactions in their own environment (Brownlow, 2010 p. 250). With this Corsaro encountered results on a more personal level.
Bigelow and La Gaipa collected information consisting of 480 individually written essays. A compiled list of twenty-one preselected characteristics was used against these essays in order to analyse what had been written by the children (Brownlow, 2010 p. 242-245). This content analysis approach enabled researchers to look for patterns in the data and create comparisons between the ages and gender of the children used. William Corsaro used a very different method. He used an Ethnographic approach which included watching and observing the children from a distance. He did not interact with the children until they approached him and invited him to be a part of their social circle (Brownlow, 2010 p. 251). This gave insight as to how children go about dealing with friendship and how they may or may not act as a friend towards another. Corsaro mentioned, “I think a key here is, to be seen not as a typical adult, is to let children bring you in” (Interview with William Corsaro (2010). Through this method being used, Corsaro was able to produce rich and complex data as he was interacting with the children on their level so that they would feel relaxed and hopefully reduce the chance of the children not acting as they normally would around each other.
The type of research method used determines what sort of evidence is collected. Looking back at Bigelow and La Gaipa’s method, where written evidence was collected and then analysed, it would be said that the data collected was qualitative as it contained very detailed an personal thoughts on the research matter however the data then changed into quantitative as all the personal information wasn’t used by the researchers only the words that had been pre-selected were counted (Brownlow, 2010 p. 242). This is different from the data that Corsaro collected. He used the information and evidence that he gained from talking as one of the children. With this in mind the evidence collected was of quantitative nature; he analysed each individual perspective that the data preserved.
With both studies focusing on different methods, each study found different things from their research. Bigelow and La Gaipa (1974) discovered from the data that was...

Other Essays Like Compare and Contrast the Approach to Studying Children’S Friendships Taken in the Bigelow and La Gaipa (1974) Study with That Taken by William Corsaro

Paul Reveres Ride Write a brief essay in which you compare and contrast Longfellow's poem with a historical account of the event. Explain why you think Longfellow presented details in a way that is...

506 words - 3 pages , Paul Revere's Ride, told the story of the ride with some accuracy. In order to warn the people of Lexington of the route the British was going to take; lanterns were used to alert the colonists. If there was one lantern, the British took the land route and two if the British took the sea route. This was similar to what Longfellow's poem stated. One other similarity between the poem and the historical event was that Revere did

Compare and Contrast ‘Porphyria's Lover’ and ‘La Belle Dame Sans Merci’, Commenting on Their Content, Style and Form. How Successful Are the Poets in Revealing Their Characters Through Their Chosen...

1960 words - 8 pages Compare and contrast ‘Porphyria’s Lover’ and ‘La Belle Dame Sans Merci’, commenting on their content, style and form. How successful are the poets in revealing their characters through their chosen poetic style? There are many contrasts between ‘Porphyria’s Lover’ and ‘La Belle Dame Sans Merci’, although they both deal with love, but different types of love. ‘La Belle Dame Sans Merci’ is about a love sicken knight. Who meets an

Focusing on Just Two External Environmental Areas from the Economic, Social, Political and Legal Environments, Analyse the Key Forces and Trends That Have Taken Place Within These Two Environmental...

781 words - 4 pages Focusing on just two external environmental areas from the economic, social, political and legal environments, analyse the key forces and trends that have taken place within these two environmental areas over the past decade. Introduction Marketing concept as outlined by Kotler and Levy (1969), is perceived by most as an undertaking to find and stimulate buyers to achieve a firm’s goals. The process entails product development, pricing

Compare and Contrast the Ways in Which the Plutarc Attempts to Discredit Antony with the Ways This Is Done in the Speech Attributed to Octavian by Cassius Dio

785 words - 4 pages other (Dio) is personating Octavian, as is written as if to be perceived as directly from history and therefore the style of the writings are both very different. The passage by Plutarch attempts to discredit Antony in a way which at face value is completely different to Dio, appearing at first glance a much softer attack on his character, for example mentioning that Octavian had marked the passages of Antony’s will that served to best discredit

The Road Not Taken" and "Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening”

654 words - 3 pages where he needs to make a decision between two courses in life. In “The Road Not taken” the speaker decides the irregular approach in making a logical choice, as a result showing his individually and trying mentality however in “Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening” the speaker tries to live life without any grieve and exertion but at the conclusion, he has to abide by social obligation, this reflects his duty to society. In “Stopping by Woods

"The Road Not Taken" By Robert Frost. The Teacher Asked Us To Read This Short Story And Them Write A Summery Of It And Relate To The World Or Our Lives In Some Way

580 words - 3 pages "The Road Not Taken" by Robert Frost is a short poem about a person's last quest. This is a poem that everyone in an English speaking country has readapt least 10 times.It starts off with the journeyer at a fork in the road in the middle of the woods in winter. He would like to travel both but he is just one person. He stands there at the fork in the road for a long time staring at each road and where it goes. Wondering which one to take. After

The Road Not Taken by Robert Frost

691 words - 3 pages The Road not taken By Robert Frost The Road not taken By Robert Frost is about a man who had to choose between two roads which diverged (Split) in a yellow wood. The road becomes an extended metaphor for the choices that we have to make in life. The representation and symbolism of the road is every person’s journey through life .The split in the road is the difficult or easy decisions we have to make. The tone of the poem makes us feel related

Essay to Compare and Contrast "God's Gradeur" with "The World Is Too Much Without Us."

1195 words - 5 pages Essay of Poetry “GOD’S GRANDEUR” & “THE WORLD IS TOO MUCH WITH US” FOR A CONTRAST AND COMPARISON Each poem written in Petrarchan sonnet form begins with “The world.” Each poem is an expression of their concern related to the impact of the industrial revolution on the natural landscape. Equally, they express that it is polluted and abused for economic gain. The difference by which they address their concern is that one man

Symbols, Symbolism, Imagery, And Theme In Robert Frost's The Road Not Taken

734 words - 3 pages Symbolism, Imagery, and Theme in The Road Not Taken   The Road Not Taken is told by one person - there is no designation as to sex, station in life or age.  This person has come to a crossroads in their life and has two options to choose from.  The place in this poem is a fork in a path in a forest, and time is not specified though it could happen today, so it would be considered a contemporary piece.  The premise of the

The Road Not Taken

578 words - 3 pages the choice of two different paths in life? The road most taken and the road least travelled, two different life choices. “Two roads diverged in a yellow wood” (Clugston, 2010, section. 2.2, para. 5). The fact that he took the road less travelled on caught my imagination and made me think about my recent choices. The choice to stay in my current position with a lot of stress that is stable or move to less stressful position where my job could

The Road Not Taken

772 words - 4 pages A traveller is faced with an unbearable decision; The road less travelled or the road taken more. He chooses the road less travelled but really what is the author trying to tell you? This poem would be quite meaningless if it didn’t have a hidden metaphor. The literal meaning is the by far the easiest to explain, and probably the easiest to understand. The literal meaning of this poem is about a traveller hiking in the woods. He has to make a

Related Papers

Compare And Contrast The Approach Taken By Researchers In Two Of The Papers You Have Read In Units 1 4

1703 words - 7 pages OPTION 1 – COMPARE AND CONTRAST THE APPROACH TAKEN BY RESEARCHERS IN TWO OF THE PAPERS YOU HAVE READ IN UNITS 1- 4. The two papers that I have chosen to compare for this assignment are the research paper by Elizabeth Coates and the paper by Aldgate and Bradley in The Reality of Research with Children and Young People Edited by Lewis et al . The paper by Coates involves the observation of children in nursery and

Compare And Contrast A Toxin That Affects The Nervous System

669 words - 3 pages exposure to mercury by frequent consumption of fish has a strong positive connection with increased arterial blood pressure. In contrast, other studies show that mercury exposure could increase risk of hypertension, myocardial infarction, coronary dysfunction, and atherosclerosis. Data showed that mercury exposure was associated with the progression of atherosclerosis and an increased risk of developing cardiovascular disease (Azevedo, et al

Compare And Contrast The Attitudes To Travelling To Paris In Text 1 And Text 2 And Explain The Expectations Of Paris That Are Conveyed In The Texts

695 words - 3 pages Compare and Contrast the Attitudes to Travelling to Paris in Text 1 and Text 2 and Explain the Expectations of Paris that are Conveyed in the Texts. Text 1, 'Stories are Waiting in Paris' is multimodal text of a transcript for a Eurostar advert. A multimodal text relies on more than one medium, meaning that you not only have to read but listen and watch. This makes it more powerful as it appeals to your different senses, for example the sound

Compare And Contrast The Approaches Of Buchanan And Monderman To Ordering Public Spaces That Include Pedestrian And Motor Vehicles

1482 words - 6 pages Social Order is how people ‘fit’ together with each other and the world around them ( Silva, 2009. pg 311), it is how people know how to behave and what they expect from others in social situations. Social Scientists understand there are many factors to consider when studying order; it is a combination of imagination, practices and the ideas of past and the future (Silva, 2009. Pg 311). This essay will look at an influential report by Buchanan