Compare Vygotsky's And Piaget's Approaches To Cognitive Development

1104 words - 5 pages

Vygotsky suggests that cognitive development occurs as a result of social influence due to the inheritance of cultural tools and learning from others through scaffolding. An opposing view is that of Piaget who proposed learning is construed through adapting schemas and a stage theory in which a child has to be biologically ready in order to develop cognitive abilities.

Vygotsky proposed a zone of proximal development which refers to the area between what a child is able to accomplish by them self and what they can do with the aid of another, such as a parent. For example, a child can play with Lego just joining the pieces together, but with the aid of an adult they would be able to ...view middle of the document...

A similarity between both theories is that both can be applied to educational contexts and have had contributions to improving the quality of learning. Piaget can be applied through discovery learning, the idea that a child learns better as a result of independent exploration of their environment whereas Vygotsky can be applied through guided participation and having another person aid a child when learning, for example a teacher. Although Piaget had an impact on the approach to education in schools, a limitation is that if a child has no input from another individual, they may be unable to understand more complex ideas therefore their development could be compromised, this gives Vygotsky’s’ theory an advantage as it outlines how important aid from another is when learning and has been shown by Hedegaard (1996) who investigated working within the zone of proximal development with Danish primary school children. The children were presented three interrelated topics and were presented through various interactional methods such as group discussions. The findings were that the children were successful when answering questions, which provides strong support for applying Vygotsky’s theories to education. However, as the sample only consisted of Danish primary children and therefore lacks external validity and cannot be effectively generalised to other populations.

Another advantage that the theories of Vygotsky have over Piaget is that they aren’t culturally specific, whereas Piaget’s theories are westernised and cannot account for other cultures. This was demonstrated by Gladwin who conducted a study on Polynesian children and found they could display complex cognitive processes such as navigating from the stars yet failed to understand conservation etc, whereas according to Piaget they should have had an understanding. Vygotsky’s theories can account for this as the children may have learned such difficult tasks through social interaction and the inheritance of cultural tools, therefore showing a particular strength of the theory as it can be applied to cultures outside of westernised society.

Another weakness is Piaget’s theory is reductionist and only explains development in terms of innate and maturation factors. He ignored the importance of the social and cultural contexts which a child is exposed to during development. This gives Vygotsky an advantage as he does...

Other Essays Like Compare Vygotsky's and Piaget's Approaches to Cognitive Development

Compare and Contrast the Approaches of Buchanan and Monderman to Ordering Public Spaces That Include Pedestrian and Motor Vehicles

1482 words - 6 pages , produced in 1963 and a thesis by Hans Monderman, both of these look at the connection between social ordering in public spaces between pedestrians and motor vehicles. The essay will compare the studies and show the similarities and differences between them, and how they both solve the problem to traffic management. It will also discuss the models in which both Monderman and Buchanan use in their thesis. The Buchanan report was published in 1963

Compare and Contrast the Approaches of Buchanan and Monderman

1539 words - 7 pages 'Compare and contrast the approaches of Buchanan and Monderman to ordering public spaces that include pedestrians and motor vehicles.' Social order is embedded into peoples' daily actions although it generally goes unnoticed by many. It exists to eliminate the disturbances of public order and many people devise different strategies in an attempt to make things run more smoothly. It demands peoples' cooperation to interact with each other in

Compare and Contrast Person Centered and Cognitive Behavioural Therapy

1304 words - 6 pages Compare and contrast person centered and cognitive behavioural approaches understanding and making use of the counseling relationship Introduction This assignment is an attempt to discuss two different types of therapy, cognitive behavioural therapy and person centered therapy and highlight some important similarities and differences between them. Cognitive behavioural therapy John Watson (1957) believed psychology should be

Biological and Humanistic Approaches to Personlity

1427 words - 6 pages Biological and Humanistic Approaches to Personality PSY/250 February 23, 2014 Biological and Humanistic Approaches to Personality Within an individual’s family an individual can have his or her Fathers individual body features or Mother’s features, additional one behaves like his or her Father or Mother. These aspects evolve from an individual’s genes; however, others believe the way an individual behaves is because of human nature

Integrating Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches to Research

1415 words - 6 pages Integrating Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches to Research Independientemente del paradigma de investigación, la calidad de las preguntas manejan los métodos de investigación. Como supuestos iniciales se plantea que las aproximaciones cualitativa y cuantitativa no están separadas y discretas, sino más bien son una aproximación conjunta continua. Se debe diferenciar metodología mixta de métodos mixtos, donde la integración de las

Secular and Biblical Approaches to Depressive and Anxious Problems

2843 words - 12 pages stated in the Course Study Guide. --------------------------------------------------------------- SECULAR AND BIBLICAL APPROACHES TO DEPRESSIVE AND ANXIOUS PROBLEMS Table of Contents: * Introduction * Dysthymia * Diagnosis * Combined efficiency * Different Views * Sufficient and insufficient of medicine * Conclusion * Bibliography A comparison of the effectiveness of medical vs.non-medical treatments for any

Integrative Approaches to Psychology and Christianity: an Introduction

1637 words - 7 pages Abstract Integrative Approaches to Psychology and Christianity allowed me to comprehend fully the past occurrences of psychology and theology. The book displayed the faith and confidence that both psychology and Christianity must be combined in order for it to have a better understanding and allowing the client a better chance of healing. In order to do this there must be a complete understanding of each component in and of itself

The Four Contemporary Approaches to Management and Their Relations to the Environments

701 words - 3 pages The four contemporary approaches to management and their relations to the environments Before going through the four contemporary approaches to management, there is a need to understand what a management process is and how it works. Management is the process of reaching organizational goals by working with people and other organizational resources. It involves and concentrates on organizational goals, and is the series of continuing and

Outline and Critically Assess the Key Assumptions Underpinning Approaches to Crime Prevention

3181 words - 13 pages Outline and critically assess the key assumptions underpinning approaches to crime prevention.Outline and critically assess the key assumptions underpinning approaches to crime prevention. If we look at the definition of crime, we can learn that crime is “an action or omission which constitutes an offence and is punishable by law”.Crime could be labelled as one of the most disturbing facts in human`s life. Even if we can see the decrease in

Descibe and Evaluate Two Approaches to the Treatment of Self Defeating Behaviours

2848 words - 12 pages Writtle College: CHELMA 2A 13 Tutor: Kay Milton Title: “Describe and evaluate two approaches to the treatment of self- defeating behaviour” Word Count: 2774 In this essay I will describe what self defeating behaviours are and where they originate from, their causes and maintenance of the behaviour. As an example I will show two treatments that might be offered to help the presenting condition of depression in a person who

How to Contrast and Compare in an Essay

1856 words - 8 pages How to compare and contrast essay As you generate points of comparison, consider the purpose and content of the assignment and the focus of the class. What do you think the professor wants you to learn by doing this comparison/contrast? How does it fit with what you have been studying so far and with the other assignments in the course? Are there any clues about what to focus on in the assignment itself? Here are some general questions about

Related Papers

Piaget's Stages Of Cognitive Development Essay

2062 words - 9 pages (ICELS). Thus this staged is marked by the child’s ability to harmoniously reason abstractly and logically as well as not be limited to concrete thinking. The influence of Piaget’s ideas in developmental psychology has been enormous. He changed how people viewed the child’s world and their methods of studying children. Piaget's ideas have generated a huge amount of research which has increased our understanding of cognitive development. His

Behavioral And Social/Cognitive Approaches To Forming Habits

1343 words - 6 pages Behavioral and Social/Cognitive Approaches to Forming Habits John Smith Jr. PSY/250 June 16, 2011 Brian Garavaglia Behavioral and Social/Cognitive Approaches to Forming Habits This paper will be analyzing the formation of habits using the behavioral and social/cognitive approaches. In This paper the subject to analyze is one of my habits. It will state how that habit started and what role models if any I had for this habit. It also

Physical And Cognitive Development Essay

996 words - 4 pages child’s teachers and parents. A child develops how to interact and understand other people during the childhood years and how to interact with one’s external environment (Sternberg & Grigorenko, 2001). Factors like intelligence, language learning approach, information processing, reasoning, memory, and idea learning and understanding affect cognitive development during childhood years (Blumberg, 2004). Cognitive development has been studied

3m And General Physics Make Leadership Count Innovative Approaches To Leadership Development

1812 words - 8 pages 3M and General Physics make leadership count Innovative approaches to leadership development A ccording to a survey carried out on a total of 756 CEOs in 2002 by The Center for Creative Leadership and Chief Executive Magazine, leadership development has been hailed as a critical component of competitive advantage. While this may not come as much of a shock to some organizations, the surprising fact is that despite widespread acceptance