Comparing Equality In Henry James' The Turn Of The Screw And Edith Wharton's The Lady's Maid's Bell

1831 words - 8 pages

The Theme of Equality in Henry James' The Turn of the Screw and Edith Wharton's The Lady's Maid's Bell

Henry James' The Turn of the Screw and Edith Wharton's "The Lady's Maid's Bell" share a common theme: all people are equal. Both authors generate this theme by bridging class barriers with a generous master and mistress who have revolutionary ideas. Although circumstances differ in both stories, the common theme remains easily discernable with the words and actions of both Mrs. Brympton in "The Lady's Maid's Bell" and the young master, Miles in The Turn of the Screw. Through their friendship, trust, and eventual love for their servants, both the master and mistress prove their modern ...view middle of the document...

Besides a friendship, the mistress and new maid develop a relationship of nurturing, love, and loyal devotion. Although Miss Hartley obviously cares for for her mistress, Mrs. Brympton unexpectedly begins to take care of Hartley. Concerned with Hartley's health and knowing about her illness, Mrs. Brympton insists "that [Hartley] should take [her] walk regularly, and often invent[s] errands for [her]: a yard of ribbon to be fetched from the village, a letter posted, or a book returned to Mr. Ranford" (Wharton 20). Further illustrating Mrs. Brympton's caring nature, Hartley once discovers her "mistress lying very weak and still, but she forced a smile when she saw [her]" (Wharton 25). Additionally, Mrs. Brympton also notices that Hartley looks "pale," and Hartley when says she "[has] a headache," the mistress thoughtfully says "she would not require [her] again that evening, and advise[s] [her] to go to bed" (Wharton 32). As a result of the care she receives from her mistress, Hartley begins to fill the loyal position of Emma, the former maid, to Mrs. Brympton, and a bond of love grows between them exemplifying the equality of Mrs. Brympton's servants. Their loyalty and devotion toward one another increase with Hartley's loss of subservience and lower-class status in the eyes of Mrs. Brympton.

As a result of Mrs. Brympton's compassionate nurturing, her handmaid becomes a loyal servant and friend, and Mrs. Brympton grows "more and more dependent on [Hartley]" (Wharton 29). She clearly needs her handmaid despite the occasional presence of her husband and her lover, Mr. Ranford, in her husband's absence. Mrs. Brympton has "grown attached to [Hartley], and seem[s] to like to have [her] about" (Wharton 29). No longer does Mrs. Brympton simply like her, or take care of her, but she truly needs and loves her servant. Hartley has become a sort of confidante for her mistress- a loyal servant outside of Mrs. Brympton's personal conflicts and struggles (including her mismatched husband and secret lover) in whom she can depend and confide. For example, Mrs. Brympton wordlessly admits her extramarital affair with Mr. Ranford by giving Hartley the task of going to the druggist and taking a note to Mr. Ranford specifically "before Mr. Brympton is up" (25). Faithfully upholding Mrs. Brympton's trust, Hartley completely denies Mr. Brympton's accusations that he saw her come home "through the shrubbery"; she responds, "No, sir, you didn't" (26). Mrs. Brympton's past and present relationships with her servants provide evidence that she sees more than a servant in her handmaid; she regards them with equality and love, and she treats them likewise. Not only this, but Hartley becomes a confidante, an outside loyalty, necessary, even irreplaceable, to Mrs. Brympton in the complicated and multifaceted life she leads.

Similar to Mrs. Brympton, the young master Miles, in The Turn of the Screw, demonstrates equivalent feelings of the equality between higher social...

Other Essays Like Comparing Equality In Henry James' The Turn Of The Screw And Edith Wharton's The Lady's Maid's Bell

The Rise and Fall of Equality

1038 words - 5 pages THE RISE AND FALL OF EQUALITY December 9th, 1989 10:45 pm was a definitive moment in the course of modern politics, not just because it marks the dissolution of some wall, but because it marks the collapse of a political system which had dominated the better part of the 20th century. It marks the collapse of a philosophy which promised universal liberation, but soon turned into a doctrine of oppression. It marks the collapse of communism

The Narrator of the Bell Jar

737 words - 3 pages , model, or pattern. Unfortunately that standard is determined by a close-minded, unyielding force called society. "Society is one vast conspiracy for carving one into the kind of statue it likes and then placing one in the most convenient niche it has." Society tells us what to do and who to be. Esther, the narrator of The Bell Jar, was considered a menace to society because she had difficulty conforming to the image that had been designed for her

"The Bell Jar" And Esther's Depression

676 words - 3 pages In "The Bell Jar" by Sylvia Plath the main character, Esther Greenwood, sinks into depression during the summer after her third year of college. There are many factors and components that cause this to happen to Esther. The social restrictions placed upon women of her time, her own insecurities over her identity, and the pressure she receives from all of her close ones. She felt like her mind and soul should be with her body so she decided to

The Bell Jar

897 words - 4 pages Herman Grewal May 18th, 2011 The Bell Jar Research Paper Mr. Kindle 10:00 class The Bell Jar Research Paper Edward James Hughes, more famously known as Ted Hughes, was married to Sylvia Plath prior to her suicide and has been thought to be the reason for her suicide. Hughes was an English poet and children’s writer. He is considered to be one of the best poets of his time and was given the title of British Poet Laureate, which is

The Bell Jar Story

1067 words - 5 pages In most coming of age stories, the main character is faced with a problem. After solving the problem (and finding fairy tale type love along the way) Esther finds herself a changed person, and is ready to take on life. However, the Bell Jar is unlike this. In The Bell Jar by Sylvia Plath, Esther Greenwood has problem after problem and things seem to get worse and worse. Instead of feeling like a part of society, she feels alone, or as she puts

Comparing the Use of Qualitative and Quantitative Research in Marketing

1318 words - 6 pages Running Head: IMC 612 Qualitative vs. Quantitative Research 1 Comparing the Use of Qualitative and Quantitative Research in Marketing IMC 612 Qualitative vs. Quantitative Research 2 Qualitative vs. Quantitative Though qualitative and quantitative researches differ in their

How Is Battle Represented in the Charge of the Light Brigade and Henry V?

979 words - 4 pages How is battle represented in the Charge Of The Light Brigade and Henry V? The poem Charge of the Light Brigade, written by Alfred Lord Tennyson, is based on the battle of Balaclava which took place on the 25th October 1854 in the Crimean war. Act 4 Scene 3 of the Shakespearean play, “Henry V”, contains a speech which King Henry V gave to inspire and motivate his soldiers before they go to fight in the battle of Agincourt which took

Comparing the Theories of Durkheim and Marx

1672 words - 7 pages Comparing the Theories of Durkheim and Marx Emile Durkheim and Karl Marx were two of history’s most influential theorists. While both of these classical theorists played a significant role in the development of social science, their views on social issues differed greatly. Emile Durkheim was the first sociologist in France to hold an academic post. Much of his career was focused on promoting sociology as a “legitimate and significant

Comparing The Religions Of Christianity And Hinduism

2568 words - 11 pages “If I were asked to define the Hindu creed, I should simply say: Search after truth through non-violent means. A man may not believe in God and still call himself a Hindu. Hinduism is a relentless pursuit after truth... Hinduism is the religion of truth. Truth is God.” -- Mahatma Gandhi "I believe in Christianity as I believe that the sun has risen: not only because I see it, but because by it I see everything else." -- C. S. Lewis

The Biography Of James Madison

1053 words - 5 pages James Madison's second inaugural speech was on March 4, 1813. Madison was a member of the Democratic-Republicans, but still held some views of the Federalist Party. The War of 1812, also known as Madison's War, with Britain began in Madison's first term and continued throughout his second. He had to deal with countless trading problems with France and Britain, the large split between Republicans and Federalists, and conflicts with

Gender Equality in the Aztec Civilization

699 words - 3 pages An all too commonly trend shared with various nations and civilizations around the world is the mistreatment of women. With very few exceptions, the belittling of women seems almost ubiquitous throughout history. Was this trend practiced in the aztec civilation? Or did the Aztecs understand and appreciate the importance of women's role in their society? Overall, women were unappreciated and were not considered equal to men. To begin with, the

Related Papers

Turn In The Road Essay

1093 words - 5 pages disconnects the engine from turning the wheels and the car will slow down. If we should slow down too much or come to a stop gently ease up the clutch up again to just above the biting point to get the car moving again. Whilst doing this briskly turn the steering wheel to the right until you can’t turn it anymore (to full lock). Try and do this in the first two or three feet (the first metre) of the move – the quicker you steer the quicker you get the

Labour Day: Dreaded Bell In The Schoolyard Of The Mind

672 words - 3 pages Labour day brings and the complete disappearance of it once school starts. He enforces these thoughts through similes and metaphors by developing them into reasons as to why Labour day is a unique statutory holiday. All other statutory holidays are a getaway from school where as Labour day is its entrance. The fear of going back to school becomes stronger as Labour day approaches. Amazingly, one holiday can mean the end of two months worth of sheer freedom. Bruce, Henry. “Labour Day is a Dreaded Bell in the Schoolyard of the Mind” Essays: Thoughts and Style. Ed. Brian Kellow and John Krisak. Prentice Hall Ginn Canada. Scarborough: 1996. Pg. 3-4

The Life Of Equality Essay

606 words - 3 pages The Life of Equality ​What if you lived in a society with no freedom? How would you feel, how would you survive, would you want to live? Well that’s exactly what Equality7-2521 has been going through since he was born.”There was no pain in their eyes and no knowledge of the agony of their body. There was only joy in them, and pride, a pride holier than it is fit for human pride to be’’. This quote was chosen because it depicts the experiences

Equality Of Sexes In The Labor Market

524 words - 3 pages Equality of sexes in the labor market There was a time when it was the woman’s place to stay at home and tend to the needs of the family, while the man went into the work force to earn a living to sustain the family. However, as the demands of everyday life have changed, so too has the role of women. As a result, an ever increasing number of women have joined the work force, shedding themselves of their traditional role, that of the