This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparing Plato's Allegory Of The Cave And Maimonides' Limits Of Man's Intellect

540 words - 3 pages

Plato's Allegory of the Cave and Maimonides' Limits of Man's Intellect

 
   Enlightenment is the key subject of both Plato's "Allegory" and Moses Maimonides' "Limits of Man's Intellect." To them, obtaining knowledge is life's most significant objective. Plato stresses "the Good" while Maimonides encourages "Perfection" as the aim of this objective. While both authors share compatible thoughts toward the subject of enlightenment, there are key differences between "the Good" and "Perfection" that should be duly noted.

 

In Plato's "Allegory" we see mankind in a state of imprisonment. What they consider reality is merely shadows that are cast on a cavern wall. This can be linked to Maimonide's essay in that he views man's youth as a kind of imprisonment when ...view middle of the document...

Maimonides equals this emphasis by acknowledging that man must earnestly seek knowledge and strive toward "Perfection" where he may find peace in the study of theological problems (295).

 

Although both authors speak of similar goals, Plato's "Good" and Maimonides "Perfection" suggest different entities. When Plato refers to the "Good," he is talking about an ultimate state of perfection that is beyond man, and though he may approach it and learn from it, while on earth, man can never possess or obtain it. I see Plato's "the Good" as a sort of deity which is not something man can strive to become or even fully understand. On the other hand Maimonides' "Perfection" is a mortal possibility that man should strive for. It is a process that can be followed if he paces himself and acknowledge his limits. While Maimonides speaks of "Perfection" as a process of learning through time, Plato tells of a "truth" that man already possesses and through "the Good" can remember what he had once known.

 

Of the two views presented by Plato and Maimonides, I feel that the process of learning by pacing oneself is definitely more applicable to a college student such as myself. I agree with Maimonides when he speaks of "man being born a wild ass" (298). When I graduated high school, I attempted college, but because I was still "wild," I did not perform as well as my abilities should have merited. However, now that I am older and wiser, I have the patience and desire to obtain knowledge and take the time necessary to succeed in higher education.

 

Works Cited

 

Jacobus, Lee A. A World of Ideas: Essential Readings for College Writers, 5th ed. Boston: Bedford Books, 1999.

Maimonides, Moses.  "On the Limits of Man's Intellect." Jacobus, 289-303.

Plato.  "The Allegory of the Cave."  Jacobus, 275-85.

 

Other Essays Like Comparing Plato's Allegory Of The Cave And Maimonides' Limits Of Man's Intellect

Allegory of the Cave Essay

517 words - 3 pages The Allegory of the Cave is an imaginary, fictitious scenario, described by Plato, in the form of an intellectual dialogue between Socrates and Glaucon. Contemplate an underground cave inhabited by prisoners since childhood; their necks and legs restrained by chains which prevent any movement other than glaring at a wall ahead. Socrates goes on to say, the prisoners can observe shadows, projected on the wall carrying various items and if

Plato’s Allegory of the Cave Essay

728 words - 3 pages ------------------------------------------------- PLATO’S ALLEGORY OF THE CAVE ------------------------------------------------- (flow of events) Plato's allegory of the cave describes a group of prisoners living in a dark cave. They are bound in chains preventing them from moving easily. Being stuck in the same place and position all the time, they have nothing to do but stare at the wall in front of them. A fire casts a light against that

Plato - Allegory of the Cave

663 words - 3 pages Plato - Allegory of the cave In Plato’s “Allegory of the Cave”, prisoners have been chained up in a dark cave for most of their lives and can only look at a wall without any access to the outside world. Behind them is a roadway used by travelers and behind that is a fire that casts shadows on the wall the prisoners look at. They know nothing else in life except these shadows. In the allegory, one of the prisoners is released and he is blinded

On the subject of education, how are Plato’s “The Allegory of the Cave” and Malcolm X’s “Learning to Read” simil

816 words - 4 pages “If we are thinking about effect of education – or the lack of it – on our nature, there is another comparison we can make.”(The Allegory of the Cave by Plato p.1) Plato was a philosopher in Classical Greece; he was fighting for freedom and education. Malcolm X was an African-American Muslim who was fighting for human rights. We have two stories one is “The Allegory of the Cave” and “Learning to read”, why do we have

The Limits of Dream

982 words - 4 pages Since the time of Freud, the body has been ascendant in cognitive science, the mind hidden and apparently described by neuron-to-neuron chemical connections in the central nervous system. The last half of the 20th century presented challenges to scientific understanding and logic that would force a profound change in the older sciences. Mathematics, astronomy, physics, chemistry, genetics, and cellular biology, scientific fields once

The Essence of Literature is in the Tension Between Emotion and Intellect

1553 words - 7 pages THE ESSENCE OF LITERATURE IS IN THE TENSION BETWEEN EMOTION AND INTELLECT We often blame our mistakes on irrational decisions – things done in the heat of the moment. We say that ‘our emotion got the better of us’. But realistically we would be nothing without our emotion. Without emotion, life becomes sterile, silly, and actually without substance. It is in the finite balance of emotion and reasoning that true life exists. The

Metaphors in Plato's the Republic: the Sun, the Line and the Cave

2495 words - 10 pages . With the cave segment of the story, there are metaphors for ignorance, enlightenment by philosophy, the immorality of the world without philosophy and the natural progression of the human race from the creation of mankind onward. The divided line, as the second allegory introduced to Glaucon, can be taken as a metaphor for the natural progression of some people based on their individual level of intelligence, and the difference between the levels

The limits of heart of darkness

1765 words - 8 pages examples of this. He constantly refers to the "stillness" and "darkness," never finding better terms. He defines a man's "inborn strength" at first as "his own true stuff" (32). The list goes on. At one point, Marlow breaks from the narrative to examine his limits. When trying to evoke the effect Kurtz's name had upon him, he says to his listeners, "He was just a word for me. I did not see the man in the name any more than you

The President of No Man's Land

1081 words - 5 pages , almost like a story being told from one friend to another. Smith manages to keep the atmosphere light and semi casual although the themes touched upon are sometimes dark and grave. In prolongation to this, the first person narrator, which is also the main character, becomes alive and reveals his qualities of self-sarcasm and irony, alongside a bright intellect, having a microbiology degree and the ability to speak several languages. (p. 3, ll

Essay of the White Man's Burden

995 words - 4 pages Essay of “The White Man’s Burden” (1980), Jan Needle. This is a short story by Jan Needle. We follow the teenager Tony Robertson, who really wants to be friends with immigrants and thinks very positive of the multi-cultural society. It is pretty ironic that although his amiable behavior, two Paki-stanis eventually end up beating him up. Tony is liberal, he thinks that everyone should have the same chances, and he doesn’t prejudice anyone

Comparing the Theories of Durkheim and Marx

1672 words - 7 pages Comparing the Theories of Durkheim and Marx Emile Durkheim and Karl Marx were two of history’s most influential theorists. While both of these classical theorists played a significant role in the development of social science, their views on social issues differed greatly. Emile Durkheim was the first sociologist in France to hold an academic post. Much of his career was focused on promoting sociology as a “legitimate and significant

Related Papers

Plato's Allegory Of The Cave Essay

315 words - 2 pages This allegory was written to show a number of things. The main point in the piece is that humankind can function without any knowledge of what is going on around them. This allegory has a number of "prisoners" trapped in a cave, without the ability to turn their heads around. All the prisoners only can see the wall in front of the cave the way which they are facing. There is a fire behind the prisoners with objects in between them and the fire

Plato's Cave Allegory And Metaphysics Philosophy

1222 words - 5 pages Plato’s Cave Allegory and Metaphysics Plato’s allegory is a good example that shows how different views of the world can create different perceptions of reality. What is real to me might not necessarily be something that you believe in. It is a concept that tells you that what we experience in lives is what drives our beliefs in reality. If an individual has not seen something, it does not make any sense to explain its existence. To better

Interpreting The First 5 Lines In Plato's Allegory Of The Cave

464 words - 2 pages Interpreting Plato's Allegory of the CaveLines one through five of the essay "Allegory of the Cave" focus on the shadows on the cave wall. This passage is important in setting the scene for the essay. Plato tries to explain "how far our nature is enlightened or unenlightened." He employs figurative language and strong imagery to convey a sense brutality towards the prisoners of the cave.Plato's use of language creates a vivid picture of the

Allegory Of The Cave Essay

1141 words - 5 pages Professor Nina Askary Langaroudy English GLL 121 CA 20 July 2010 ‘The Allegory Of The Cave’ is a story that demonstrates how humans are afraid of change and what they do not know. In this work, Plato suggests a situation in which men are living in an underground cave.  The one entrance is located near the top, a burning fire casts shadow.  The men of the cave are chained so that they can only see the wall and cannot turn around.  When