This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Comparing Yeat's "The Lake Isle Of Innisfree" To "Heaven" By Cathy Song

1000 words - 4 pages

The Desirability of Desire:
comparing and contrasting the use of longing in
“The Lake Isle of Innisfree” by W. B. Yeats and “Heaven” by Cathy Song

Cathy Song and W. B. Yeats are poets from completely different eras and cultural backgrounds. In spite of these initial differences their works are connected by a similar theme. Although the poems “The Lake Isle of Innisfree” and “Heaven” by Yeats and Song respectively are bound by the common theme of longing, their use of poetic expression, most importantly of diction, style and meter, leads the poems to be completely different from each other in tone.
The sense of longing that is prominently present in both poems is explained through ...view middle of the document...

The speaker in “The Lake Isle of Innisfree”, while bringing across a feeling of ardent longing, still seems to speak in a rather detached and observing manner. This, combined with the rather simple and straightforward metaphors used within the poem, makes for a figurative style that on the whole is not very complicated. The words are pretty, illustrative and never feel insufficient, but they nonetheless lack a certain urgency, lending the poem an air of faraway fantasy, a dream if you will. It is as if this longing for Innisfree holds no real life value for the poem’s speaker, but instead functions as reassuring mental image of what life could be, an imagining of better times in better places. Something quite different can be observed in “Heaven”, where the imagery is far less idealistic, making for a style that can be described as being more realistic. The comparisons that Song draws between her two different places (“Did a boy in Guangzhou dream of this / as his last stop?”, lines 24-25) and her view of the longed for China are more profound and complex than the ideas presented in “The Lake Isle of Innisfree”. This is to be expected in a poem that is as close to real life as “Heaven” is.
Analyzing the poems’ meter and rhythm leads to a similar observation as the one made above. Song chose to completely omit any kind of recognizable meter, which leads to the poem sounding like a genuine depiction of an actual person’s train of thought, not constructed but merely recounted, with the occasional addition of an afterthought. Yeats, on the other hand, chose the iambic meter as the most prominent sound effect, with various occurrences of phyrric feet throughout. This, again, steals away from the worldly relevance of the poem, because it doesn’t directly address the reader, seeming more like a private musing of the speaker’s.
The aforementioned...

Other Essays Like Comparing Yeat's "The Lake Isle of Innisfree" to "Heaven" by Cathy Song

Jesus And The Kingdom Of Heaven

919 words - 4 pages Jesus and the Kingdom of Heaven The Gospel of Thomas is unlike any other scripture written about Jesus. It is a collection of Jesus' secret sayings that only someone who actually knew him, like his "twin", would be able to recount. Jesus, in the Gospel of Thomas, is a teacher that points his followers in the direction of the Kingdom of Heaven. He explains that the kingdom is a place with no poverty, where all is revealed and that it

The Song of the Songs Essay

721 words - 3 pages ‘The Song’ of Vision The Song of Songs written by Ellen Gilchrist explores the theme of love. Characters in this story are Barret Clare, Charlie, Charles, Amanda McCamey (Barret’s mother), Katie, and Gustave. Barret Clare is a woman who has never felt the touch of her birth mother, who left her for adoption shortly after her birth. The older she gets the more she craves to meet her mother. The story began in a Christmast day. Clare had a

Poem Analysis Of 'A Song Of The Republic' By Henry Lawson And 'If You Forget Me' By Pablo Neruda

982 words - 4 pages I have chosen two poems, A Song of The Republic, by Henry Lawson (1867-1922), and 'If You Forget Me' by Pablo Neruda (1904-1973). Both of these poems use many different techniques to reflect the context of their time and their values and beliefs.Pablo Neruda was a Nobel prize winning Chilean poet who lived during the times of World War 1 and 2 as well as the Spanish civil war. Due to his first hand experiences, his poems changed overtime from

The Writing of the Long Song

985 words - 4 pages The writing of the long song “How can I be proud of my Jamaican roots, when my ancestors had been slaves”? This question asked by a woman with Jamaican roots followed British novelist Andrea Levy for a long time. She wondered how anyone could be ashamed of his or her legacy and thus the foundation of her book, The Long Song, was laid. However, writing the book was a more difficult task than presumed. Levy considered many things at the

Comparing and contrasting "Macbeth" by Willian Shakespeare to "Lx" by Pablo Neruda. In this essay many examples of death are used to explain the emotions of the main characters

446 words - 2 pages In Macbeth by William Shakespeare and the LX by Pablo Neruda, imagery is the main thing used to describe how both Macbeth and LX are alike. In both pieces, many examples of hatred, darkness, and death are used to give the readers an idea of how the characters are alike in the way they feel.In Macbeth, readers were given clear images of how he was feeling throughout the play. After the murder of Duncan, Macbeth was plagued with many different

Comparing And Contrasting Two Poems On The Theme Of Childhood By

1245 words - 5 pages Comparing and contrasting two Poems on the theme of childhood By Seamus Heaney. Comparing and contrasting two Poems on the theme of childhood Having read the four poems from Seamus Heaney's collection "Death of a Naturalist", I have decided to Compare and contrast the two poems that I like best, which are "Death of a naturalist" and "Follower". Both of these are childhood stories set in the countryside. These reflect how Heaney

Comparing Piece Of Art To America

406 words - 2 pages Art is a very relative creation. Our society applies their own experiences and sentiments to understand a work of art. The Waterlilies by Claude Monet needs no detailed description as to what it is portraying. However, I have an original outlook on this famous piece as it describes my outlook on life in the United States.I was born here and know nothing else of living by other countrys' standards, however all of my relatives in Iran would sever

Critical Analysis of "The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock"

3555 words - 15 pages  personality."  He   crystallized  his  ideas  about  how  to  achieve  this  extinction  of  personality  in  another   Regan    2   essay,  "Hamlet  and  His  Problems":  "The  only  way  of  expressing  emotion  in  the  form   of  art  is  by  finding  an  'objective  correlative

Comparing the Written Report of Derek Bentleys Execution to the Film

743 words - 3 pages Comparing the Written Report of Derek Bentleys Execution to the Film The film was made in 1999 ,40 years after the murder trail of Derek Bentley. The movie is not a documentary its a writers and directors view of what happened in side the prison. The film is an interpretation of the true story. This movie very sympathetic towards Derek an his family. The written report is from a Book published in 1954 by Montgomery Hyde

Song of a Battery Hen” by Edwan Brock War Without End” by Brue Dawe

753 words - 4 pages I agree that poetry can illuminate important issues in our society. This is obvious in “War Without End” by Brue Dawe, which explores the issue of deaths in road accidents, “Song Of A Battery Hen” by Edwan Brock, which explores the issue of cruel treatment that battery hen have to endure an “Bran Nue Day” by Jimmy Chi and Mick Manolis which explores the issue of injustice and discrimination towards Australian Aborigines. “War Without End” uses

Movie Analysis: "Kingdom Of Heaven", Part A) Answers To General Questions About Movie Part B) Movie Response Essay

2528 words - 11 pages Part A) "Kingdom of Heaven"-Movie Questions-1. Why were people fleeing Europe to join the Crusades?People were fleeing Europe to join the Crusades in search of fortune or salvation. Europe was in a state of disease, poverty and famine; the people suffered greatly. During the Middle Ages, illness and misfortune was considered punishment from God for sins committed. It was thought that in order for people to be free of their despairs they had to

Related Papers

The Insurance Industry In The Isle Of Man, Key Trends And Opportunities To 2017

638 words - 3 pages The Insurance Industry in the Isle of Man, Key Trends and Opportunities to 2017 Aarkstore Enterprise (India), April 3rd , 2013: The report provides in depth market analysis, information and insights into the insurance industry in the Isle of Man, including: • The Manx insurance industry’s growth prospects by insurance segments and categories • The competitive landscape in the Manx insurance industry • The current trends and drivers of the Isle

The Clothing Of Heaven Essay

2578 words - 11 pages THE CLOTHES OF HEAVEN based on Rev. 7:9-17 By Glenn Pease A taylor who used an apple as a trade mark was asked why he used that particular symbol. He replied, "If it hadn't been for the apple, where would the clothing business be?" He had a good point. The clothing business did start in the garden of Eden because of sin, and the need to cover the bodies of those who had started sin by eating of the forbidden fruit. Clothing is not

Once More To The Lake Essay

620 words - 3 pages The surprising conclusion to "Once More to the Lake” was an eye-opener for the readers. I believe the ending absolutely did not ruin the piece due to the simple fact that the ending was used to hit readers with a huge life lesson. Throughout the essay, White was preparing the readers for the conclusion, even in the title, but White made the readers so mesmerized by the amazing imagery he provides, it distracted them from the main point of the

In The Lake Of The Woods

882 words - 4 pages separate events that happened in real life, and those he dreamed of.John Wade loved magic. He had been practicing his tricks since he was a young boy, and magic had a major role in his development. Magic, as well as the mirror, allowed John to create an illusion, and hide himself from the reality of life. John continued on with his hobby, and when he served in Vietnam, he took on the pseudonym; the role of the Sorcerer. By creating a false sense