This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Competing Theories Of Corrections Essay

2010 words - 9 pages

Competing Theories of Corrections

Eric Mack

American Intercontinental University

This paper will discuss the competing theories of corrections that are prevalent in today’s justice system. A series of suggestions on ways to implement some of the nontraditional theories of corrections will be reviewed. In recent years, parole and probation have been criticized for increasing the risk of community victimization by known offenders. A review of how the goals of punishment and rehabilitative strategies are different. It will show whether there is specific data to support one particular approach over another. Two nontraditional correctional approaches will be discussed ...view middle of the document...

Evidence shows that there are various successful programs that reduce future criminal activity not only from offenders but potential offenders as well. The Correctional Theory has caused justice scholars and policy makers to debate the effectiveness of correctional rehabilitation (, Intensive Supervision Probation).
Competing Theories of Corrections that are Prevalent
Shock Incarceration
The use of a military style boot camp consisting of a team orientated environment involving strict discipline, extensive physical training, and hard labor. The view is that a dose of military discipline would make a man out of a boy and set him on the path to be a respectable citizen (, Oct., 1989, Shock Incarceration).
Split Sentencing
The combination of a brief period of imprisonment followed by a period of probation where typically a defendant will spend mandatory time in jail but not for the entire sentence. The court suspends part of the sentence and places the defendant on probation for the remaining time. While on probation a defendant may be required to complete a number of tasks, like meeting with a probation officer, completing drug or alcohol treatment, or performing community service (Schmalleger, Ph.D., F. 2012, Chapter 10).
Shock Probation
Shock probation allows offenders to be released on probation after serving one to six months of their initial sentence. Offenders must apply for probation however it is not guaranteed depending on the judges resentencing decision (Schmalleger, Ph.D., F. 2012, Chapter 10).
Mixed Sentencing & Community Service
This theory requires offenders to serve weekends in jail and receive supervised probation during the week. Requirements may include treatment or community service programs while on probation (Schmalleger, Ph.D., F. 2012, Chapter 10).
Intensive Probation Supervision (IPS)
Offenders are closely monitored to ensure compliance with the Order of Probation/Parole Release Plan. Clients are required to meet with supervising officers on a regular basis (, Intensive Supervision Probation).
Home Confinement & Electronic Monitoring
Referred to as house arrest, provides a sentencing alternative that requires electronic monitoring of an offender serving a sentence of partial confinement at their own residence. Under certain conditions offenders may be able to leave such as medical emergencies, go to work, or buy household essentials (, n.d., Electronic Monitoring). Because of the severe limits enforced on offender whereabouts, house arrest has been quoted as presenting an alternative to prison (Schmalleger, Ph.D., F. 2012, Chapter 10).
How Goals of these Strategies are Different
Although the primary goals of these strategies are to make communities safer, they differ in their approach depending on the criminal act. The idea of incapacitation is to remove an offender from society, making it...

Other Essays Like Competing Theories of Corrections

Profiting from Punishment Essay

1293 words - 6 pages Profiting from punishment * As punishment is complex social, ideological and cultural terrain, it will never be an entirely rational execution of orders with clear objectives and controllable outcomes. It is has multiple and competing aims and innumerable intended and unintended consequences. In accordance with this Garland has argued “(t)he failure of modern punishment is in part the inevitable outcome of an over rationalized conception of

Work Place Violence Essay

2451 words - 10 pages Institutions, Private Security Companies, Political organizations, and advocates of workplace violence detection, intervention, prevention, and protection. Nevertheless, the most pervasive and recognizable entities are Law Enforcement, Corrections, and Private Security. These three different but related communities are frequently challenged by workplace violence. This paper shall discuss these three area that workplace violence has influenced, and

Identify and Briefly Describe

736 words - 3 pages CRJ O10 INTRODUCTION TO CRIMINAL JUSTICE STUDY GUIDE (CLASS NOTES) THIRD EXAM: PUNISHMENT AND CORRECTIONS 1. 2. Identify and briefly describe three types of sentences. 1. Fixed, Definite: 5 years, 10 years, 300 years 2. Indeterminate: 1-10, 5-10, 5-25 3. Indefinite: NO LIMIT 3. Identify and briefly describe seven sentencing options that are available to judges. Prison, Probation, Halfway House, Fine, Restitution, Community Service

Criminal Justice

1067 words - 5 pages Shelby County Correction Center (now known as the Shelby County Division of Correction) in Memphis. Both began their corrections careers in 1975 and Moral Reconation Therapy™ (MRT) was developed in 1985. In 1987, Robinson founded Correctional Counseling and began offering workshop trainings and consulting services to correctional agencies to implement the cognitive-behavioral treatment programs he developed during his time at the Shelby County

Criminal Justice Trends Paper

1642 words - 7 pages enforcement, (police, detectives, or any other), courts (judges or lawyers), or even corrections, they are all important. They all have a big impact on the criminal justice system and how it is ran. There are different types or jobs of law enforcement. Some of these jobs are: * Uniformed police officers * Sheriffs and deputy sheriffs * State police, also known as state troopers or highway patrol officers. * Detectives Just to name

Contemporary Issues on Social Work

2316 words - 10 pages wellbeing and this will straight the available scarce resources. While competing for these resources with the residents of the host country, the asylum seekers are likely to face discrimination and isolation by the community. Also, the way of life of the asylum seekers is likely to vary with that of the host society, and this will cause more antagonism between the two groups. The presence of health care and social work professionals to help the

Case Study Pizza Palace

1029 words - 5 pages ge > risk Miller’s theory-corporate taxes and personal taxes: the presence of personal taxes reduces but does not completely eliminate th e advantage of debt financing VL=VU+ [1- Tc : corporate tax rate , Td: personal tax rate on debt income, Ts:personal tax rate on stock income * MM theories favor operating at 100% debt but it ignore the risk associated with it Trade off theory

Origins Of Modern Criminology: Classical Versus Positive Theory

2366 words - 10 pages they based their critiques on their personal speculations as well as the work of other leading figures at the time. Ultimately, classical and positive theories of criminology can be compared and contrasted through their philosophical foundations, assumptions and policy implications. When comparing Beccaria and Lombroso’s theories, their ideas are similar because they reject the demonic perspective and stress alternative explanations. However

Cja 324 Syllabus

3886 words - 16 pages : Ethical Behavior of Probation, Parole, and Correctional Officers | |The Ethics of Corrections | | |Details |Due |Points

Rehabilitation of Criminals in America

1622 words - 7 pages one individuals problem might have already been solved by another group member and can be suggested. Often if a peer proposes a solution it carries more weight than if the counselor were to suggest it (Bennett 20-24). Further, in sociology, one of the major theories of delinquency is differential association (Cressey 1955). This means some people learned their ways from ³undesirable² people who they were forced to be in association


1144 words - 5 pages conflict model argues that in diverse society, the dominant groups exercise power by codifying their value systems into criminal laws. Choice theories are perspectives on crime causation that states that criminality is the aftermath of conscious choices. Offenders desire to defy the laws when they believe that the cost of doing so does not outweigh the benefits. Choice theories state that the decision to commit (or refrain from) crime is

Related Papers

Competing Theories Of Corrections Essay

1249 words - 5 pages The Steps to a Search Warrant Landry Nesmith AIU Online 08/05/12 The way that I look at the way that the government issue and exercise a search warrant it relatively fair and the reason why I say that because for the most part the police have numerous of searching for evidence and that is done to protect the rights of the suspect and the officers. The fourth amendment played a major role in the many laws set up to issue and executes

Prison Downsizing Essay

1185 words - 5 pages spotlighted in this campaign as a state that identified with the ‘tough on crime’ theories and changed to community corrections approach. Community corrections, and treatment for drug or mental issues. Texas, Florida and our own state have seen such success, that not only has there been reduction in crime rates, but reduction in prison population as well. (Gingrich) Policy is usually led by public demand. When the public felt that crime was out of

Criminal Justice System Essay

816 words - 4 pages power. Sociological and psychological theories are based around norms set up by society and an individual’s ability to follow those norms. Now that crime is defined, the components and structure of the criminal justice system and its goals can be discussed. The criminal justice system is made up of three major components: the police, the courts, and corrections. Simply put, the police enforce the law, the courts adjudicate the law, and corrections

Future Of The Juvenile Justice System

1296 words - 6 pages Future of the Juvenile Justice System The future of the juvenile justice system is uncertain. There is a struggle to try a find a way to serve the needs of the juvenile delinquents and issue them a punishment for violating the law. In order to improve the direction of the juvenile justice system, recommendations are needed regarding community involvement, law enforcement, courts, corrections, and the private sector. These recommendations