Conversations Inside The Third Culture Essay

1582 words - 7 pages

Big Questions: Conversations inside the Third Culture

In 1961, C P Snow introduced the idea of the "two cultures", the scientists and the literati, divided by a lack of communication that had been crystallized through academic specialization (1). Thirty years later, John Brockman unveiled the Third Culture as the new face of intellectual life, consisting of scientific thinkers who had ousted the traditional literary scholars in "rendering visible the deeper meanings of our lives, redefining who and what we are" (2). He has been criticized for his fragmented vision of intellectual culture, which affords no place to non-scientists in spite of the apparent inability of science to ...view middle of the document...

In this respect, Brockman's scientifically imperialistic conception of intellectual culture lacks the "questions of subjective, of spiritual and of social values" (3) that must lie at its heart.

Furthermore, the criteria by which the sciences have established themselves and the standards to which they proudly hold have been responsible for the impressive advances, but as Taylor points out, "there are places where experiment and verification cannot go" (5). Given Brockman's emphasis on empirical facts, his understanding of "what it means to be human" (5) seems lacking. There is little room for the consideration of the moral dimension of the human experience. His words echo with what Leavis criticizes Snow for: an inadequate sense of human nature and human need (7). After all, according to Lanier, there are questions that must be addressed by any thinking person that lie outside of the established methods of science (5).

If so, is it reasonable to expect science to provide a full worldview that can provide answers on the moral and spiritual levels? Hut's answer is hesitant: "Science just isn't far enough along to address that quest" (5). Instead, the scientific method should be used to sort through our inherited wisdoms, to separate that which is still useful from the dogmatic trappings of the past. Taylor maintains, therefore, that the promise of science lies not in "sweeping away other aspects of existence ... (but) respectfully deepening understanding of what it is to live and die as a human being and observing the universe from that perspective" (5).

How is it, then, that Brockman can distinguish the achievements of the Third Culture, which he rightly predicts will affect everyone, from those of the humanities, described as the irrelevant and "marginal exploits of a quarrelsome mandarin class" (2)? Horgan reminds us that humanist scholars like Judith Butler, often derided for her work in deconstructing sexual identity, are "far more engaged with reality – our human reality – than are string theorists or inflationary cosmologists" (5). Ludwig Wittgenstein went so far as to argue that even when all the questions posed by science have been answered, the problems of human life will remain untouched (4). But is this true, or even a fair assessment of the purpose of science?

What Brockman failed to make clear was that the sciences and the humanities have different goals, that the "deeper meanings" that the humanists seek are not necessarily the same that the scientists seek. Comprehension may arise from explanation, as offered by Pinker in his biological account of human nature (5). But we learn too from empathy (some may say more powerfully), as from Shakespeare's portrayal of Lear as the figure of fallen pride, repentant too late. The different approaches of sciences and the humanities obscure the relationships that do exist between what are often seen as separate cultures. Levine maintains that a...

Other Essays Like Conversations inside the Third Culture

Electronic Surveillance in the Workplace Essay

885 words - 4 pages recently held that: “In an office or other workplace to which the general public does not have unfettered access employees may enjoy a limited, but legitimate, expectation that their conversations and other interactions not be secretly videotaped by undercover television reports, even though conversations may not have been completely private from the participants’ coworkers.” Sanders v. American Broadcasting Co., Inc., 978 P.2d 67, 69 (cal.1999

Ethnographic Observation Essay

2335 words - 10 pages Ethnographic Observation TSL 4520  Grading Rubric Background  (Milde, R., 2001) Common wisdom tells us that there are, in general, two kinds of writing: creative and expository. Creative writing tells about feelings, opinions, points of view, things that originate inside the writer. Expository essays tell about facts, things outside of the writer. Essays on literature examine a literary text, a thing outside the writer. Lab reports describe

Survellance

569 words - 3 pages typically two types of workspaces, on open area in which there are several desks and where conversations can be overhead, or a enclosed office in which when the door is locked conversations cannot be heard and where one would expect virtually total privacy. Explain whether if it makes a difference if an employee is in an open area or in an enclosed office. It defiantly makes a difference if employees are in an open area or in a close area

Popular Culture and Print Media Paper Ricky Harps Soc/105 Instructor: John Smith University of Phoenix Feburay 08, 2010 Popular Culture and

815 words - 4 pages capture audiences. Color technology has developed to the point where color is not as expensive to print and the bright colorful ads sell better. So far the newspapers make the front page of every section color to grab attention to inside articles and the back page has color advertisements. Computer generated pictures and art is the third trend in print media advertising. Computers have the ability to create all types of elaborate images

Langston Hughes: A Poet Supreme

2438 words - 10 pages affect a modern sensibility and at the same time maintain a grounding in the folk culture; (2) how to achieve the textual representation of the music, especially in terms of improvisation and variation of tone and timbre; and (3) how to use the vernacle without resorting to dialect. Hughes realized that is was impossible to do what he wanted to do in one piece, so he composed a series of short poems that play effect off eachother. Western

Communication Competence Analysis

548 words - 3 pages Communication Competence Analysis Strong I am sensitive to cultural variation and differences, and I see my own culture’s teachings and those of other cultures without undue bias. I have been a license practical nurse for 29+ years, and have worked with many ethnic groups. I am also a black American and have much compassion for people. It means a lot for my patients, my friends, and my relatives to understand me and my culture. I want to

Basic Principles to Aplly in Cross-Cultural Communication

2057 words - 9 pages €¢ • Third, incorporate some words and phrases from the foreigner's language into the conversation. An attempt to learn some phrases in the language of the host or visitor indicates that some good faith effort has been made to learn about their language, culture and background (Dulek et al., 1991). • • Americans, for the most part, do not speak or read foreign languages. English is the dominant language spoken

7 Reasons the Police Culture Is Broken

899 words - 4 pages that ignored behavior is condoned behavior. The next critical step to changing this culture and reducing line of duty injuries and deaths is to create a culture off courageous conversations. These courageous conversations need to be peer-to-peer and supervisor-to-subordinate. These conversations demonstrate that we care enough about each other to speak up and potentially save a life, a career, or a marriage.4. Officers are too quick to ‘eat our

PMAN 638 Quiz

1320 words - 6 pages decision making. Gender and diversity There always seem to be a battle of the sexes between men and women in the workplace where the communication style for men is to be aggressor and asserter, while the women are more caring, nurturing and comforting. According to Tannen (1995), women are more likely to be considered less confident, not heard in group conversations, and passed over for promotions than men because of a difference in

Electronic Surveilance of Employees

1698 words - 7 pages comes to innocent, unaware third-parties such as customers, it is important that they are informed that their conversations may be monitored. It is important that employers inform innocent third-parties as well as employees of the possibility that they may be electronically monitored. The easier way to go would be to just set up a visible surveillance system throughout the company and have employees sign an electronic surveillance policy when

Business Management

810 words - 4 pages Boys Will Be Boys Scenario Scenario/Summary This scenario takes place at a college campus among a group of student employees. We take a look at the interaction among a few employees and the proper approach to take when the behavior of some employees is deemed inappropriate by another employee. Your Assignment You are a student employee who overhears conversations among your coworkers. While on break, two of your male coworkers usually go

Related Papers

Understanding An Organization's Culture Essay

929 words - 4 pages together to foster connections and conversations both inside and outside their doors. They volunteer their time and talent, partner with like-minded organizations to build stronger, safer, healthier communities, and invest in the development and well-being of their team members. The fourth aspect I noticed was opportunities for growth. Target encourage endless opportunities for professional growth. They have watched their inventions lead to retail

Social Media Essay

655 words - 3 pages Social Media Social media has had a tremendous impact on our culture and on the world as a whole. Social media has forever changed the way people communicate and socialize on the Web, but also the way we interact with each other in daily life. This new phenomenon has had a negative impact on our society that far outweighs the positive aspects. First, it’s harmful to self-esteem. A UK study found that over 50% of social media users

Matthew, Mark, Luke, And John Essay

653 words - 3 pages humanity of Jesus. Representing Jesus as the Son of God. Luke features His kindness toward the weak, the suffering and the outcast (Luke 9:51-18:27). He seems to have had the Greeks, who represented culture, philosophy and wisdom, in mind. John places special emphasis on the Deity of Jesus. Consists mostly of Jesus' lectures and conversations. Discusses things Jesus said rather than things He did (John 1:1-18). By describing the eternal pre-existence

Juno: Female Memes Essay

1357 words - 6 pages scribe in the blogosphere, I think it's probably going to be the most used in our popular collective speech for a while. There are tons of more far-fetched expressions, but this one is noteworthy for being directly associated with the blogging/MySpace/Facebook generation. Our conversations are full of clichés, of comprised, referential expressions that we pull out time and again without realising we've borrowed them from the TV and other sources