This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Conviction Of Wrong Man Essay

553 words - 3 pages

Expert Witness Helped Convict Wrong Man

A panel of six independent forensic scientists stated, in a report filed in a Houston State court, that crime laboratory supervisor James Bolding helped convict an innocent man of rape in 1987. Because Bolding either lacked basic knowledge of blood typing or gave false testimony, George Rodriguez spent 17 years in prison for a rape that he did not commit. Bolding’s testimony in the case was challenged amid a scandal that led to retesting of evidence in 360 cases; And with the report filed, that number could increase by the thousands, involving 25 years of cases.

“The panel concluded that crime laboratory officials might have offered ''similarly false and scientifically unsound'' reports and testimony in other cases, and it called for a comprehensive audit spanning decades to re-examine the results of a broad array of ...view middle of the document...

In many cases, the HPD technicians used up all existing evidence, making it impossible for defense experts to disprove or verify their results.

Jim Fisher, a former FBI agent and retired criminalistics professor who has taught forensic science notes, in his book Forensics Under Fire: Are Bad Science and Dueling Experts Corrupting Criminal Justice?, that problems in forensics “have kept scientific crime detection from living up to its full potential” (Clarke, 2010). A concern that the judicial system has is properly differentiating between valid research and junk science. Some of the problems encountered by forensic expert witnesses include:
1) Unqualified or incompetent lab workers;
2) Personnel using false academic credentials;
3) Contamination in labs that cause false test results;
4) Employees falsifying test results to ‘help the prosecution’;
5) Lab examiners committing perjury; and
6) Lack of qualification standards and industry-wide training requirements for lab workers (Clarke, 2010).

Motivations for expert witness actions may include: 1) understaffing and excessive workloads; 2) an inability to perform the tests due to a lack of training, education and experience, or 3) the belief that the police have already arrested the right person, so evidence testing would be unnecessary.

Hiring qualified personnel, training them properly and providing adequate oversight, could deter the problem.

References

Clarke, M. (October, 2010). Crime Labs in Crisis: Shoddy Forensics Used to Secure Convictions. Retrieved from:
https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/news/2010/oct/15/crime-labs-in-crisis-shoddy-forensics-used-to-secure-convictions/

Liptak, A. and Blumenthal, R. (5 August, 2004). New Doubt Cast on Testing in Houston Police Crime Lab. The New York Times. Retrieved from: http://www.nytimes.com/2004/08/05/us/new-doubt-cast-on-testing-in-houston-police-crime-lab.html?src=pm&pagewanted=1

Other Essays Like Conviction of Wrong Man

Capital Punishment in the Us Essay

1344 words - 6 pages . Personally, I disagree with this opinion, for several reasons. I believe that it may be a cruel punishment, but a necessary one that fits some crimes. Also, even though it is true that the mistake of executing the wrong person can’t be corrected, this can be prevented by proper investigation before conviction. In this essay, I will be addressing the morality of this conviction, cost of death vs. life in prison, how effectively the death penalty

Cair and Radical Islam Essay

1216 words - 5 pages , since its founding in 1994, to gain sizeable donations from many spectrums, personal invites to the White House, respectful media coverage, and a serious hearing by corporations.  However, CAIR is something quite different than what it lets the general public allowable to see. For starters, it is on the wrong side in the war on terrorism continuously defending those involved with acts of terrorism around the world. Secondly, CAIR even includes at

Beliefs, Values, Morals Paper

1612 words - 7 pages Beliefs, Values, and Morals: Is man inherently good or inherently evil? Our Definitions of Beliefs, Values, and Morals Beliefs: Jennifer says that a belief is a conviction of her own, what she sees as truth, not judged to be good or bad. Joanne agrees that it is her unquestionable acknowledgment of something even though she may not be able to establish proof and also her faith or trust in God. Elisaba considers a belief either comes

The Multiple Conflicts on the Novel Lord of the Flies

1300 words - 6 pages physical appearance and the possession of the conch, is immature and lacks conviction. This leads to the destruction of the island and wrong decisions being made. Piggy, the most logical and rational boy out of everyone would make a greater leader because without his logical thinking, there would be no civility in the group of boys and without his rational ideas, all hope would be lost for extrication. Certainly, Piggy would make a better leader than Ralph if Piggy was given the chance.

Evaluate the Strengths and Weaknesses of Reason as a Way of Knowing

1486 words - 6 pages the unreasonable man.” And if man loses his reason, the world comes to a standstill, a doomsday, an apocalypse. The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere      The ceremony of innocence is drowned;      The best lack all conviction, while the worst      Are full of passionate intensity. W.B.Yeats in his famous poem “The Second Coming” said that the world was coming to an end as man lost his reason. The falcon cannot

A Theme in the Story “the Death of Ivan Ilych” by Leo Tolstoy

1011 words - 5 pages fighting another man, a dark, unknowable wrestler who had him pinned and was bearing down on him for the final blow. “In the depth of his heart he knew he was dying, but not only was he not accustomed to the thought, he simply did not and could not grasp it.” (p 302, paragraph 174) It was hard work to die, particularly when one had not accepted death nor come to any mental, emotional, and spiritual conclusions. “He was hindered from getting into it by his conviction that his life had been a good one. That very justification of his life held him fast and prevented his moving forward, and it caused him the most torment of all.” (p 315, paragraph 346)

Police Politics

1366 words - 6 pages punishment. Even with the officer’s assault while on duty conviction the panel set aside his discharge and suspended the officer for just two years. There was a public back lash to this and many wanted to know why two years of suspension was given the board would not say why and by law did not have to. The cop’s record acquired another blemish when the Feds charged him with civil rights violations for beating up the handcuffed man

Aslooking at the Present State of Affairs in India, the Birthplace of Gandhi, One Would Probably Surmise That Gandhism, Whatever the Term May Mean, Cannot Have Any Relevance in This Twenty-First...

2176 words - 9 pages snail’s pace.” “Non-violence” Gandhi said “is a tree of slow growth. It grows imperceptibly but surely.” And then “Mere goodness is not of much use.” Gandhi stated. “Goodness must be joined with knowledge, courage and conviction. One must cultivate the fine discriminating quality which goes with spiritual courage and character.” The modern man can also take great wisdom from what Gandhi said the seven social sins: Politics without principles; Wealth

Wrongfully Convictions

2736 words - 11 pages , research has estimated about 5% of the cases that are tried annual result in a false conviction. Since 1989, 1,241 people have been wrongfully convicted and later cleared of all charges based on evidence that they were innocent, according to the National Registry of Exonerations, a project of the law schools at the University of Michigan and Northwestern University (Clark 2013). The Michigan Innocence Clinic was the first clinic of its kind to

What Is Islam

1220 words - 5 pages The word “Muslim” means one who submits to the will of God, regardless of their race, nationality or ethnic background. Becoming a Muslim is a simple and easy process that requires no pre-requisites. One may convert alone in privacy, or he/she may do so in the presence of others. If anyone has a real desire to be a Muslim and has full conviction and strong belief that Islam is the true religion of God, then, all one needs to do is pronounce

Capital Punishment Is Wrong

2804 words - 12 pages imprisonment. Timothy McVeigh is a man who committed a mass murder to get back at the U.S. government for a previous mass murder and with the execution the U.S. government will be getting back at Timothy McVeigh, in other words revenge. (Don't kill McVeigh, 2001). The issue is not McVeigh, but whether our State and government should at ant time take the life of anyone convicted of murder. If capital Punishment is wrong, it's wrong in all

Related Papers

Abc Accounting Essay

639 words - 3 pages ye. Mrs suffering sportsmen earnestly any. In am do giving to afford parish settle easily garret. Possession her thoroughly remarkably terminated man continuing. Removed greater to do ability. You shy shall while but wrote marry. Call why sake has sing pure. Gay six set polite nature worthy. So matter be me we wisdom should basket moment merely. Me burst ample wrong which would mr he could. Visit arise my point timed drawn no. Can friendly

This Website Forces You To Submit A Paper

622 words - 3 pages feet each so went no from. Truth began maids linen an mr to after. By so delight of showing neither believe he present. Deal sigh up in shew away when. Pursuit express no or prepare replied. Wholly formed old latter future but way she. Day her likewise smallest expenses judgment building man carriage gay. Considered introduced themselves mr to discretion at. Means among saw hopes for. Death mirth in oh learn he equal on. Forfeited you

Major Flaws In The Criminal Justice Of Several Nations

1108 words - 5 pages Major Flaws In The Criminal Justice Of Several Nations These days there multiple changes taking place in this world we live in,many of which are good but some maybe for the worst.The criminal justice system is a system that is meant to convict someone of their wrong doing and only that , but in each and every country there are number of flaws in their Justice System.Some forms of the major flaws in the criminal justice system of several

Killing Is Never Justifies Essay

1612 words - 7 pages committed society's most heinous crimes, including rape and murder. Ultimately, Capital punishment is wrong due to the likelihood of error, the unjust racial allocation, and the violation of constitutional rights. However, many people believe that capital punishment is morally correct and preserves human dignity. Primarily, until human judgment is proved to be infallible, capital punishment will always carry a likelihood of error along with it. As