This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Corporate Governance David Jones Essay

2262 words - 10 pages

Corporate Governance and Regulation

Individual Assignment:
David Jones

Adam Golding

Words: 2156

Executive Summary

This essay examines the example of two former directors of retailer David Jones – Leigh Clapham and Steve Vamos. The two directors made the decision to purchase shares in the company during a delicate period for the company and while decisions were being made about it’s future. Discussion on the damage this decision caused to David Jones and the ensuing fallout, whereby the two directors and the chairman of the board were put in a position where they had no choice but to resign.

This essay will address the role of a board within a ...view middle of the document...

In the public domain, examples of governance failures are unfortunately argued over perception, rather than the evidence on hand. There is now, more than ever, a push to ensure companies formulate a robust corporate governance framework.

This essay will examine the issues surrounding two former directors of department store giant David Jones and their actions purchasing shares in the company around the time that decisions were being made regarding the future of the company.

This results of this case, like so many, was not decided but what really happened, but by what the public thought may have happened. In a competitive environment, like the one in which David Jones operates, public perception is everything.

2. Issues

The issue of governance was raised at David Jones following the actions of two former members of the board in late 2013. The facts around this case are as follows:

* On 28 October 2013, David Jones receives an offer from Myer – a “merger of equals offer”, meaning Myer will take over David Jones, but shareholders from both sides will receive an equal share of the combined group (Sydney Morning Herald).

* On 29 October 2013, two David Jones directors – Leigh Clapham and Steve Vamos purchased 20,000 and 12,500 shares, respectively. (ABC News)

* On or around 1 November 2013. David Jones released quarterly sales figures, prompting shares in David Jones to climb by 7%. (ABC News)

* ASIC investigated the two directors, but were forced to issue No further action letters to the directors – an acknowledgement in time that there is insufficient evidence to take the matter further. This is not an exoneration – the case can be re-opened at any time if further evidence is discovered.

As a result of these actions, there was significant backlash from David Jones shareholders. At the next AGM, shareholders voted down the remuneration report. This prompted a full apology from David Jones chairman Peter Mason. The two directors would later both leave the David Jones board in February 2014, four months after purchasing the shares.

3. Damage to David Jones

The fallout from these actions left a lasting impression on David Jones as a company. It served as an important lesson: image and public perception are far more important than whether or not these directors acted within the boundaries of the law.

Directors considering buying company shares in future need to consider whether the information they are in charge of could be or is considered market sensitive information – while also highlighting a key governance issues: obligations relating to disclosure, director responsibilities and rules surrounding directors engaging in trading shares of their companies. ( February 2014)

4. The role of a board

Under the Corporations Act 2001, companies in Australia are required to have at least one director (proprietary companies), while public companies are legally required to...

Other Essays Like Corporate Governance - David Jones

Financial Analysis

4501 words - 19 pages 1. Summary of activities and strategies of David Jones David Jones Limited trading as David Jones and listed on the Australian Stock Exchange is a high end department store chain. The principal activity for David Jones is retailing of different brands under various categories such as fashion, cosmetics, home wares and electronics. David Jones retails its products via departmental stores and have recently transformed itself as an Omni Channel

Business Failure at Worldcom Essay

1110 words - 5 pages the accounting, auditing and consultancy enterprise were involved in this big accounting fraud. The corporate scandal of WorldCom ultimately headed the company towards the disgrace that ensued in the biggest bankruptcy in American history. After this act company terminated the service of the top executive including Scott Sullivan (Sullivan), the Chief Financial Officer and David Myers, the Senior Vice President and Controller. The main entity

Evaluate the Practice of Earnings Management from the Prospective of Corporate Governance and Business Ethics

2383 words - 10 pages Evaluate the practice of Earnings Management from the prospective of Corporate Governance and Business Ethics Definitions of Earnings Management Traditionally earnings management is viewed as a distortion of economic events that is misleading to certain user of financial statements. Below are two widely quoted definition carrying this point of view: Schipper (1989, 92): “a purposeful intervention in the external financial reporting

Companies Use Corporate Advertising to Increase Awareness of Corporate Social Responsibility Therefore Increasing Profitability

4098 words - 17 pages can be traced back to the 1950’s and has many different names such as corporate social performance, corporate social integrity, business ethics, corporate philanthropy, corporate social policy, and sustainable development just to name a few. Consistently evolving, these concepts became known as to corporate social responsibility (Madrakhimova, 2013). CSR concentrates on nine areas: ethics, governance, transparency, business relationships

Ethics & Governance

2070 words - 9 pages maximization, corporations will not even have the necessary funding to begin with fulfilling its social responsibilities. Corporate governance and ethics in management As agency problems may arise due to the principal-agent relation, corporate governance should be applied to improve the conduct of corporations. Effective corporate governance can be achieved using a set of best practices and principles, in reference to means that are used to “govern

Strategic Management

3275 words - 14 pages Semester III UNIT – I STRATEGY AND PROCESS |Conceptual Framework for Strategic Management – Concept of Strategy and Strategy Formation Process – Stakeholders in Business – Vision, | |Mission and Purpose – Business Definition – Objectives and Goals – Corporate Governance – Social Responsibility | CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK FOR STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT Strategic management deals with decision making and actions which


3034 words - 13 pages DaimlerChrysler: “A New Kind of Car Company” Table of Contents Introduction 2 Corporate Governance: Co-determination 2 Multinational DaimlerChrysler 5 Globalization Glitches 6 Consumerism 9 Reference List 13 Daimler-Benz AG and Chrysler Corporation shocked the world they announced a merger of both companies in what would be considered one of the most significant industrial

The Financial Statement Auditing Environment

4827 words - 20 pages rather that there is reasonable assurance that they do not exist in material amounts. 2-6 The essential components of the high-level model of business offered in the chapter are: corporate governance, objectives, strategies, processes, controls, transactions, and financial statements. Corporate governance is carried out by management and the board of directors in order to ensure that business objectives are carried out and

Boards of Directors’ Composition and Financial Performance: the Columbia Sportswear Case

4807 words - 20 pages Corporate Governance Aikaterini Dimitriou 1030771 Boards of Directors’ Composition and Financial Performance: The Columbia Sportswear Case Aikaterini Dimitriou 1030771 Contents I. Introduction ...................................................................................................................................... 2 II. Theoretical Background

Should Government Be Responsible for Csr?

2339 words - 10 pages private corporation has responsibilities to society that extend beyond making the profit. (Thomas L. Wheelem, J David Hunger. (2012). pp. 72). A business firm has some responsibilities and they should be fulfilled. This chapter will describe the relationship between corporation governance and social responsibility. In Friedman’s traditional view, he thought to maximum the profit is the primary obligation of business. To take actions

Strategic Management Process. Sunway group

688 words - 3 pages people and enhance your skills in an environment that promotes innovation and empowerment. The corporate governance that Sunway Group use are the executive chairman Tan Sri Dato’ Seri Dr Jeffrey Cheah Fook Ling, he maintains high standards of accountability and corporate governance. While we work to deliver value to shareholders, the Group is continuously enhancing accountability, transparency, and integrity by strengthening internal controls

Related Papers

Observance Of Good Corporate Gorvance And Avoidance Of Corruption On An Enterprise Effectiveness

2324 words - 10 pages ., 1999. Corporate ownership around 25 the world. Journal of Finance 54, 471-517 La Porta, R., Lopez-de-Silanes, F., Shleifer, A., Vishny, R., 2000 ―Investor protection and corporate governance,‖ Journal of Financial Economics 58, 141–186 Lee, Charles, and David Ng. 2002. Corruption and International Valuation: Does Virtue Pay? Unpublished working paper, Cornell University. Available online at

Two Tier Model Essay

2202 words - 9 pages London, Department of Management Research Papers, 40 Kotler, D. A. and Swedloff, R. (2003) ‘Sarbanes-Oxley’s Impact Onstate Corporate Governance’ Legal Opinion Letter, 13(16) Hall, P. A. and David, S. (2001) ‘An Introduction to Varieties of Capitalism’ in P. A. Hall and D. Soskice (Eds). Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage, Oxford: Oxford University Press Hollingsworth, J. R. and Boyer, R

A Csr Do Collection Essay

1259 words - 6 pages and environmental benefits for all stakeholders. CSR is a concept with many definitions and practices. The way it is understood and implemented differs greatly for each company and country. Moreover, CSR is a very broad concept that addresses many and various topics such as human rights, corporate governance, health and safety, environmental effects, working conditions and contribution to economic development. Whatever the definition is, the

Mba560 Week 6 Corporate Compliance Report Citigroup

2176 words - 9 pages billion in 2005 to $234 billion in 2006, as well as an 85% increase in the number of subprime mortgages originated. Citi’s 2008 losses “are a clear indication that the committee failed to properly assess and control risks,” Egan-Jones said. Directors at other companies should take heed of this action and ensure their corporate governance and enterprise risk management are solid. Remember that ERM is an ongoing process; it is not a project with