Crime And Punishment Style Essay

1446 words - 6 pages


Chose a character who might-- on the basis of the character’s actions alone-- be considered evil or immoral. Explain both how and why the presentation of the character makes us react more sympathetically than we otherwise might.

In Dostoyevsky’s Crime and Punishment, the character of Raskolnikov is one who may be considered evil or immoral for his actions, however his portrayal by the author is one that instills sympathy in the reader for the character due to his motives and personal, internal consequences he suffers for his crime of murder. There is considerable evidence supporting the view that Raskolnikov wants his theory surrounding the murder to be proven wrong, to get caught, and to ...view middle of the document...

Everything rests upon Natasya’s absence from the kitchen at the precise moment he needs it. Obviously, Raskolnikov is attempting to set himself for failure in this crime so that he may be caught and brought back down and in to society again. The reader may also feel sympathy because Raskolnikov is looking for a way out of his destitute condition. And while his methods are not those of a normal person, the intention prevails, making him seem as if he knows the right solution, just not the path to it. Furthermore, he tries to sabotage his plans and takes a nap, oversleeping the time at which he knows his victim (Alyona) will be alone. Then he forgets to get rid of his hat, which can be easily identified as it draws attention to him. When he remembers the mistake, he does nothing to remedy this, simply leaving the hat on. Immediately following the murder, Raskolnikov realizes "…how many obstacles there still remained for him to surmount.", and "…the horror of what he had done." (63) This shows the beginning of Raskolnikov’s mental weakness, and also reinforces his true intentions for the crime. The attempts time and again by Raskolnikov to sabotage his own plans display a side of him that is far from evil. He is calculating, but not in the sense that he is trying to get away with the perfect murder. He is instead trying to commit the perfect failure.

	Raskolnikov presents evidence of his true mental state, and that he wants to be exposed before his peers for the good of society, which allows the reader to see him not as evil, but terribly misguided as a tainted product of the world he has been forced in to. First, he forgets to lock the door and is forced to kill another woman who walks in unexpectedly during his crime. Next, with the door still open, he dallies several minutes washing his axe, taking even more time to scrutinize his clothing for traces of blood, all seemingly in the unconscious hope that someone will walk in on him. So Raskolnikov

seems to be leaning toward punishment rather than away from it. He returns to his room, pockets bulging with stolen articles, and falls asleep, forgetting to lock the door. From here on, he is continually leaving clues that encourage suspicion. The day after the murder he answers a summons to the police, which he expects deals with the murder. When he discovers that he is not suspected, he faints in order to arouse suspicion. This also displays Raskolnikov’s mental weakness, in that when placed in a compromising or surprising situation, he panics and does not know what to do. His fainting scene highlights his desperate cry for attention; in this case suspicion of murder. This is a trait evident in a detached man who needs to feel that his life is worth something again. He then nearly confesses to his friend Zametov in a tavern, and later, while visiting the scene of the crime, gives the men working there his name and address. The police investigator Porfiry...

Other Essays Like Crime And Punishment - Style

Crime and Punishment Essay

1544 words - 7 pages so silent and menial. However, they can have the same significance, if not more, as the main character. Take for example in the novel Crime and Punishment by Fyodor Dostoevsky. The role played by the daughter of a drunken father, Sonia. Her role is so significant to the main character and the end of the novel. The purpose of this paper is to demonstrate how a character that could be thought of as a minor character can sometimes be overlooked and

Crime And Punishment Essay

675 words - 3 pages Intellect and Emotion In Fyodor Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment, the main character is a man with two contradicting personalities a dark grim side and a warm loving side. The terms dark and grim used loosely to describe his intellectual side. It was this side of him that allowed him to commit a great sin, a murder of an old pawnbroker. Raskolnikov wants to use intellect to act and react with. With it he is able to demonstrate logic, reasoning

Crime And Punishment In The Seventeenth-Century

2857 words - 12 pages . The public attitudes towards the Conscientious Objectors remained constant over both the wars. They accused them of being cowards. They felt this because they did not see why their male relatives should go and fight and die in the war if the Conscientious Objectors did not. (d) (i) Source D is an extract from 'Crime and Punishment,' by Roger Whiting, written in 1986. The source explains how Sir George Paul, the

The Changes in Crime and Punishment in Schools

1556 words - 7 pages The Changes in Crime and Punishment in Schools Abstract I chose this hypothesis because crime and punishment has changed a lot and I want to see how much it has changed and the pupils’ attitudes towards it. The areas I hope to examine are the changes in crime and punishment in schools, how people get punished and what they did to receive that punishment and also the attitude the pupils have towards the

Hope As A Means Of Discovering Personal Meaning In Crime And Punishment

1346 words - 6 pages Punishment, Fyodor Dostoevsky places a form of collective hope in Raskolnikov that revolves around searching for his meaning in life. In the novel it is inevitable to associate the actions of the characters to their differing hopes, therefore coming to the compromise that hope explains the process of a character's journey. As a consequence, many readers mistaken hope as a source of aggression, or murder in the case of Crime and Punishment, or even

Personal Motive Vs. Societal Influences: The Powerful Role Played By Society In "Crime And Punishment" And "The Stranger"

1550 words - 7 pages PERSONAL MOTIVE vs. SOCIETAL INFLUENCESBourgeois society enslaves one such that any attempt to transcend the induced limitations results in self-destruction. In The Stranger by Albert Camus, Meursault's lack of a local cause, motivation, and personal means of justification for his crime offers the possibility of such an outside force pulling him towards the direction of wrongdoing. Raskolnikov of Fyodor Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment

The Rime of the Ancient Mariner Is Simply a Tale of Crime and Punishment. How Do You Respond to This View?

919 words - 4 pages Although Coleridge’s protagonist in ‘The Rime of the Ancient Mariner’ commits a ‘crime’ of sorts and faces a series of ‘punishments,’ it is debateable whether it can simply be considered a ‘tale of crime and punishment’. As a phrase, ‘crime and punishment’ refers to a specific crime fitting a specific punishment, usually adjudicated by a governing body but could extend to the judgement of God if the historical context of the text is to be

Capital Punishment Essays - Benefits of the Death Penalty

634 words - 3 pages controversial issue over many decades. The problem lies between, is the death penalty being accepted in murder cases or ruled out completely. While some people feel that Capital Punishment will not discourage crime, Capital punishment should be legalized in all states, because it is morally just and it will deter crime.   The many opponents of capital punishment who are against it feel that the death penalty is not a deterrent and that

General Deterrence

1772 words - 8 pages belief that people, in general, can be prevented from engaging in crime by punishing specific individuals and make examples of them” (Keel, 2005). General deterrence was first introduced in the 1970’s by a criminologist named Cesare Beccaria (Deuschmann 2007). Beccaria thought that the legal system should focus more on preventing crime from occurring rather than punishment. Many societies continue to use general deterrence when trying to prevent

What Causes Juvenile Crime And Who Is To Blame?

2564 words - 11 pages of all of these should take on the responsibility of his or her own actions regardless of age. After determining the life style of the child in question, their mental state, and the crime committed an examination of the laws that are currently in place to protect the rights of the child and their parents is in order. The first factor in the placement of blame and punishment is negligence, which is one of the biggest arguments when trying to

Capital Punishment

1586 words - 7 pages VICTIM IMPACT STATEMENT, AND CAPITAL PUNISHMENT ALTERNATIVE TO SEMINAR SESSION By GINGER SMITH KEN METCLIFF INTRODUCTION TO CRIMINAL JUSTICE 09/14/2014 The victim impact statement can be a written or oral statement to the courts at pretrial, sentencing or parole board a statement of the crime committed on or towards the victim or the family left behind. The victim impact statement is allowed in the fifty states the attorney or victim

Related Papers

Crime And Punishment Essay

842 words - 4 pages Society’s response to crime has impacted public policy differently over the years. The way crime and punishment has evolved over the years has been tremendous, but still has the same goal, punishment for a crime committed. The need for crime and punishment has and probably always will be a debate, but in the end what matters most is rehabilitating the criminal to reduce recidivism rates. Society’s views on crime and punishment have always

Crime And Punishment 5 Essay

1201 words - 5 pages Crime for what, and punishment for whom? May happens in a park and maybe in a room! Maybe at night or afternoon, here or there or close to the moon. A man who makes a crime may be a tycoon or maybe just a vagrant without a small home. Now the problem is for what, for whom do a little vagrant or a tycoon want to be a prisoner or a dark moon? Making crimes comes as a result of many various things in life. The first and the greatest

Crime And Punishment Abstract Essay

797 words - 4 pages Crime and Punishment Abstract Rodion Romanovich Raskolnikov is a former student who lived in a tiny garret on the top floor of a run-down apartment building in St. Petersburg, Russia. He is not doing as great as he thought he would be doing. He is very sick, dressed in rags, short on money, and talks to himself, but he is also handsome, proud, and intelligent. He is contemplating committing murder and he thinks it is a good start to his nee

Metamorphosis & Crime And Punishment Essay

1175 words - 5 pages Guilt is when someone is blamed for something he did. Guilt is not always controlled by us, one can create guilt. Guilt is also when someone innocent is blamed for something he has not done. Guilt can also be a feeling. Some people feel guilty for something they have done. Both Crime and Punishment by Dostoyevsky deals and Metamorphosis by Kafka deal with guilt we can see how guilt and its causes affected the protagonists Raskolnikov, and Gregor