This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Culture And Economic Development Essay

3220 words - 13 pages

Culture and Economic Development

by LAWRENCE E. HARRISON
LEAD ESSAY
December 4th, 2006

Since I was first involved in international development assistance, almost a half century ago, dominant development paradigms have come and gone, among them Rostow's stages of economic growth, national planning, focus on the poorest of the poor, appropriate technology, dependency, focus on the private sector, the Washington Consensus, and institutional development. During those fifty years we have witnessed a few success stories, largely in East and South Asia. But what most captures those years is a sense of disappointment, of frustration—of "development fatigue"—driven by the failure of the ...view middle of the document...

"[2] How then would Easterly explain why, in multicultural countries where the economic opportunities and incentives are available to all, some ethnic or religious minorities do much better than majority populations, as in the case of the Chinese minorities in Indonesia, the Philippines, and Thailand—and any other place to which the Chinese have migrated, including the United States? Why has the Washington Consensus worked well in India and poorly in Latin America (with the exception of Chile), where socialism, and even authoritarian socialism in the cases of Cuba and Venezuela, appear to be alive and well? Cultural factors may not supply the whole explanation, but surely they are relevant.
Alan Greenspan got it right when he said, in the wake of the collapse of the Russian economy in the late 1990s. “I used to think that capitalism was human nature. But it isn’t at all. It’s culture.”
Some Culture-Sensitive Economists
Some economists have confronted culture and found it helpful in understanding economic development. Perhaps the broadest statement comes from the pen of David Landes: "Max Weber was right. If we learn anything from the history of economic development, it is that culture makes almost all the difference."[3] Elaborating on Landes's theme, Japanese economist Yoshihara Kunio writes, "One reason Japan developed is that it had a culture suitable for it. The Japanese attached importance to (1) material pursuits; (2) hard work; (3) saving for the future; (4) investment in education; and (5) community values."[4]
Even the culture-skeptic Jeffrey Sachs recognizes the influence of culture. His chapter in Culture Matters says, in essence, that culture doesn't matter. And while that theme echoes in his recent book The End of Poverty, at one point he also has this to say: "Even when governments are trying to advance their countries, the cultural environment may be an obstacle to development. Cultural or religious norms may block the role of women, for example, leaving half the population without economic or political rights…"[5]
Italian economist Guido Tabellini recently undertook a study of comparative economic performance in European regions employing data from the World Values Survey concerning trust, control of one's destiny, and respect for others (all three of which turn out to be positively correlated with economic development), and obedience, which correlates negatively. His conclusions:
These cultural traits are strongly correlated not only with the economic development of European regions, but also with the economic development and institutional outcomes in a broad sample of countries…An implication of this analysis, therefore, is that there is no primacy of formal institutions over culture. On the contrary, both are likely to interact and to shape the actual functioning of real world institutions, and to influence the incentives and the behavior of economic and political agents. [6]
Moynihan and the Culture Matters Research...

Other Essays Like Culture and Economic Development

Review: Strategies and Lessons of China’s Post-Mao Economic Development

587 words - 3 pages , the author dug in-depth and discussed about the four major strategies implemented that readers should focus on. The four major strategies are: the contract responsibility system, the dual price system, special economic zones, and administrative reform. These changes all represent different reform periods. Next then, the author summed up little bit, he used one section to talk about the lessons we should learn from economic development. In this

Organization Can Be Successful Whrn There Is Match Between Organizational Culture, Economic Sector and Leadership Style

3267 words - 14 pages account for differences within countries; ethnical and religious groups often transcend political country borders” (Hofstede, G., Hofstede, G.I. & Minkov, M., 2010). The outcomes from economic development on a national level could be influenced by the different cultural settings of the society. To flourish some economic sectors prerequisite more authoritarian culture opposite to others that usually depend on widespread of liberalism

Is Technological Innovation the Main Source of All Economic Development and Change? How Might Differing Research and Development Systems Influence the Performance of Major Nations

2638 words - 11 pages performing well in terms of productivity in the 1960s and 1970s (Walker in Nelson, 1993). In recent years, the British innovation system has become relatively low priority. Walker (1993) sees this as a “consequence of the prevailing economic culture, even ideology, which has come to place quick gains before the patient, long-term development of industrial capabilities” (Walker in Nelson, 1993: 176). In the second half of the twentieth century

Is Globalization Welcome?

1749 words - 7 pages include economics, culture and environment generally, each section also contains two opposite sides, which are advantages and disadvantages of globalization brought to the developing nations economically, comparing with the advantages and disadvantages, globalization takes more economic advantages to developing countries than disadvantages. Namely, globalisation brings healthy economic development to developing countries. According to positive

How Has Confucianism Influenced Modern Economic Development in East Asia

1843 words - 8 pages comparison to the rest of the world highlights a necessity to identify how Confucianism has influenced the economic models within the region. (Goldin, 2010) Argues that Confucianism has influenced East Asia’s economic development because of its strong ties to hierarchical structures and the belief that loyalty and effort will be rewarded from the top-down. Japanese workplace culture in particular adheres to these doctrines, as prominent feature

Alibaba's Taobao (a)

862 words - 4 pages , language, economic and geographic; this is another significant of development studies where it enables man to understand the diversity of culture of different countries, also enables to understand different political system in different countries can be developed or developing countries, also understanding the geographic location of a country. However development studies guides people to know the economy structure if is high or low compare with

Cultural Effects of Business

1657 words - 7 pages emergence of consumer power in China, explains that a DRI/McGraw Hill report forecasts an average annual growth of 7.5 percent for the Chinese consumer market over the decade. Now Chinese give up the long-term closed culture and become more open and inclusive. The China's economic development makes an excellent platform to put more attention into the service marketing. The service marketing of China is just in its infancy. Enormous things need

The Social And Pragmatic Aspects Of Culture

1826 words - 8 pages multiple practical functions within society including guiding and bringing people together. This sense of community can work to physically manifest in the social world, such as in the form of cohesion and the development of social institutions, or as a kind of upheaval that can bring about social change. Therefore, culture is both influenced by and consistently informs and affects the social world, which makes it a necessary component of study

Type of Ministries

551 words - 3 pages Type of Ministry | Agencies | 1. Prime Minister’s Department | a. Economic Planning Unit (EPU) b. Permodalan Nasional Berhad (PNB) c. Multimedia Super Corridor (MSC) | 2. Ministry of International Trade and Industry | a. Small and Medium Industries Development Corporation (SMIDC) b. Malaysian Industrial Development Authority (MIDA) c. National Productivity Centre (NPC) d. Technology Centre, Kuala Lumpur e. Malaysian

Critical Issues Concerning Management Method Through Corporate Culture

2542 words - 11 pages and positive corporate culture is a true asset under the perspective of economic and accounting. Although its advantages have been identified for decades, difficulties in how to utilize, develop and manage corporate culture remain to be uncertain. In this essay, the argument will be illustrated in three sections. The definition and significance of corporate culture will be introduced in the first section in detail. After that, deficiency of

The Remarkable Phenomena

583 words - 3 pages . Globalization of economy With the concept of globalization, which is including “international economy” and “domestic economy” and the “multi-national or transnational markets” This definition is only emphasized the economic aspect of globalization; Economic globalization is the world’s product of the development of economic and technological. From some point of view, that means it can adapt to the requirements of the further development of the productive

Related Papers

Financial Development And Economic Growth Essay

2819 words - 12 pages Executive summery This literature review discusses objectives of financial development and economic growth as well as existing relationship of this concept. Financial development is strongly connected with economic situation, but we do not know for sure if this always implies economic growth. There are many factors which influence relationship between financial development and economic growth and its effects such as financial

Socio Economic Development And Health Essay

1963 words - 8 pages Question One There are a number of ways in which the increasing socio-economic development of a nation can help improve the health of the population. 1.     There is a correlation between mortality rates in the developing countries, especially amongst children, and the level of education of the parents of the children. For example, in Morocco, a mother who has completed 4-6 years of schooling, their child is 45

Education Of Women And Socio Economic Development

3546 words - 15 pages Education of women and socio-economic development ABSTRACT In the political and economic spheres, for example, this is conspicuous presently in the enthusiasm for global governance among thinkers, academics, and international institutions.It can also be seen in the acceptance, among many influential opinion-makers, of the need for a world currency and for international economic policy coordination.Many other ideas and institutions prescribed

Economic And Human Development In Global North And Global South

2972 words - 12 pages The disparities between the Global North and Global South is accounted by the low level of Economic and Human development in the Global South compared to the Global North. The four underlying factors that contribute to this lack of development in the Global South are Institutions, Culture, Geography, and Imperialism/Colonialism. The Global North refers to “industrialized nations, including West Europe, North America, Japan, Australia, and New