Current Development In Accounting Thoughts Essay

2580 words - 11 pages

Question 1 (1000 words maximum)
Explain why theories need to be evaluated. Identify and justify the factors you would consider before deciding that a theory appears sound. Apply the factors you have identified to an accounting theory of your choice (e.g. Normative, Positive etc).

A theory could be defined as a consistent set of concepts that are aimed to explain and foresee a particular occurrence or “phenomena” (Kerlinger, cited in Mathews & Perera, 1996, p.51). Accounting theory could be described as a group of practical constructs that implementconjectures on accounting issues into accounting procedures (Sterling, cited in Mathews & Perera, 1996). This definition usefully relates ...view middle of the document...

Prior to accepting a theory to be sound the following factors should be considered:
1) Ensure that the theory is based on a reasonable central assumption(Tilley, 1977).For example, normative theories are based on propositions considered by researches developing these theories and appealing to find reasonable solutions to certain issues (Deegan, 2009).
2) Does the theory apply its proposition logically when deriving a conclusion (Deegan, 2009). To illustrate, positive theories asses their assumptions using inductive logic in order to make certain predictions of phenomena (Deegan, 2009).
3) Whether the theory uses an applicable evidence to support its’ argument (Deegan,2009).Again, as positive theories are inductive they use observations of specific events as their evidence for the general conclusion (Mathews & Perera, 1996).
4) Whether the theory is advanced to any other existing theory (Popper, cited in Mathews & Perera, 1996). Deegan suggests that preference of one theory over another is based on “particular value judgements” and satisfaction of certain information needs (2009, p.16).
5) Do the majority agree with the theory so that there is a prospect of its implication in the relevant area (Deegan, 2009).
6) Whether the theory can be seen to be working in practice (Deegan, 2009).
In order to exemplify the application of the above factors in practice more thoroughlya concept of Historical Cost Accounting (HCA) could be evaluated. Starting with the first criterion, the central assumption of HCA is that “money holds a constant purchasing power” (Deegan, 2009, p.165). However, according to Elliot in current economic conditions that proposition could not be of the same value as it used to be upon its development as the following circumstances apply: constant changes in price level due to rapid modifications in “consumer preferences”, inflation andalterations in exchange rates (Elliot cited in Deegan, 2009, p.165). Thus, the HCA inclines tooverestimate profits during the periods of high inflation (Deegan, 2009). That inconsistency of the central assumption of the concept might have an impact on financial management decisions (Deegan, 2009).
Equally, when applying the second criterion there is a concern whether the HCA concept enables users to perform logical calculations with financial parameters. For instance, the relevance of totalnon-current assets derived from assets revalued in different periods of time might be argued as during those periods money had different purchasing power (Deegan, 2009). Likewise, certain assets such as inventory, for example, that might be valued at net realisable value, could be added to assets that are valued at cost (Deegan, 2009). Thatcould question the relevance of the information performed in the financial statement.
Furthermore, in regrds to the third criterion the HCAas a theory derives its supportive evidence from the fact that it is currently applied in practice among the majority of business...

Other Essays Like Current Development in Accounting Thoughts

Reviewing Accounting Standards

987 words - 4 pages Statements. The Framework provides assistance with the promotion of harmonisation of regulations and accounting standards and procedures relating to the presentation of financial statements to the Australian Accounting Standards Board (AASB). It also assists with the review of existing Australian Accounting Standards and the development of future Accounting Standard. The Framework provides broad/general principles that provide guidance in

Intermediate Financial Accounting Essay

5060 words - 21 pages of "expectation gap". b 82. Reason accounting standards differ across countries. d 83. Advantage of countries adopting same accounting standards. a 84. Ethical concern of accountants. P Note: these questions also appear in the Problem-Solving Survival Guide. Exercises Item Description E1-85 Objectives of financial reporting. E1-86 Development of accounting principles. E1-87 Publications and organizations. E1-88 FASB

Different Accounting Software

3159 words - 13 pages (ASX) on 9 July 1999. In subsequent corporate development, MYOB Limited merged with Solution 6 Holdings in 2004, further expanding MYOB's footprint with accounting practices in Australia and New Zealand, and expanding its range of products and services for accounting practices. In May 2008 MYOB launched a new package of online services, including web hosting, email hosting and domain registration. In June 2008, founding CEO Craig Winkler

Case Summaries Accy 401, Emba; Fall 2000

5169 words - 21 pages item, a firm lowers its net income in the current period. By capitalizing the item, a firm would show higher net income in the current period, but lower income in each of the future periods when the capitalized expense is depreciated (fixed assets), amortized (intangible assets), or depleted (mineral assets such as oil or gold). When considering whether to capitalize or expense an item, we considered two accounting concepts: the concept

Ifrs and Fasb Comparison on Accounting Errors

1207 words - 5 pages and Carcello, FASB Statement No. 154, Accounting Changes and Error Correction. 2005). It showed the cumulative effect of the difference between the two accounting principles in the current income statement (Bloom and Fuglister 2006). Now, companies no longer report a cumulative effect on the current year's income statement, instead, they report any necessary adjustment as an adjustment to the opening balance of retained earnings for the

Management and Cost Accounting Theory

1026 words - 5 pages MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING What is Accounting? • Need for Accounting – o Increased global trade, o Rise in the complexities of business, o Large scale, due to Industrial Revolution • Father of double entry system of accounting – Luca di Bargo Pacioli (Italy, 1494) • Accounting can be defined as recording, classifying, summarizing, analyzing and interpreting the business transactions. • The


566 words - 3 pages , classification, and recording of financial transactions and the ascertainment of how such information will be reported to the various users. It involves the development of general-purpose financial statements largely for external reporting. These statements are developed in accordance with standards imposed by the public (through the professional accounting bodies such as the Institute of Certified Public Accountants of Kenya – ICPAK and the International


1305 words - 6 pages statement credits and charges among different time periods. The prime objective is to moderate income variability over the years by shifting income from good years to bad years. An example is reducing Discretionary Cost (e.g., advertising expense, research and development expense) in the current year to improve current period earnings. In the next year, the discretionary cost will be increased. Ambiguity in Capitalizing and Revenue expenditure


722 words - 3 pages purposes. Eg - land was purchased at a value of $140000 2 years ago. Its current value is considered to be $350000. For accounting purposes the land will be recorded at the original purchase price of $140000. Going concern assumption - refers to the fact that accounting reports are prepared under the premise that the entity will continue to operate in the foreseeable future. Accounting period assumption - the accounting period

Computer Information System Paper

1056 words - 5 pages current system. By purchasing the more sophisticated software such as Tivoli, which is excellent security, network intrusion prevention software is a must to ensure security of the computer network. Opportunities in Accounting Technology Technology has grown at an accelerated pace with numerous accounting software in the market that does a variety of different things. The Tivoli Security

Fair Value Accounting Under Financial Crisis

2476 words - 10 pages mechanisms in place that should alleviate potential contagion effects. 5. Conclusion The preceding sections illustrate that the debate about FVA is full of arguments that do not hold up to further scrutiny and need more economic analysis. In the paper, we review the shortcomings of the HCA and survey the development of the paradigm of fair value. To determine whether Fair Value Accounting contributed to the current crisis in financial markets

Related Papers

Current Topics In Accounting: Relevant Issues

1772 words - 8 pages Current Topics in Accounting: Relevant Issues Current Topics in Accounting: Relevant Issues1a. Describe the impact that implementing FAS 157 had on EMC's financial statements, based on the footnote information provided. Can you tell if the current economic conditions influenced the valuation of their financial assets and liabilities from this disclosure? If yes, what information told you this, if not, what information do you feel is missing? As

Development Of Accounting Practices In Austrailia

1896 words - 8 pages The history and Accounting practices in Australia Development of accounting practices in Australia: The Accounting Practices were firstly recommended and issued by the Institute of Chartered Accountants in Australia (ICAA) in 1946 and these accounting practices were called as “Recommendations of Accounting Principles”. These accounting principles were just barely “copied” from those issued earlier by the Institute of Chartered Accountants

Accounting Research Essay

934 words - 4 pages Evidence from Vietnam of Public Sector in Current Conditions In recent years, Vietnam has made a significant progress in completing the legal system in general and the regulations on accounting and auditing in particular, including the regulations to ensure the efficient management of public expenditure and to create a more favorable environment for the operations of the public sectors (Kara, 2012). The actual implementation of current legal

Accounting Standards Boards Paper

1367 words - 6 pages Financial accounting is influenced by the environment in which it operates. Nations have different histories, values, cultures, political and economic systems and they are also in various stages of economic development. These national influences interact with each other and, in turn, influence the development and application of financial accounting practices and reporting procedures (Schroeder, Clark, & Cathey, 2005). Financial statements are