This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

De Vaca And Smith Essay

551 words - 3 pages

Both Alvar Nunez Cabeza de Vaca and John Smith hold different attitudes regarding their accounts of Indian life. The difference in attitudes may have resulted from the difference in treatments that each man received while in captivity.

De Vaca’s experience is a humbling one. His account of Indian life is written in a thoughtful manner, and he describes the Indians kindly. While he describes his captivity as “melancholy and wretched” (De Vaca 34), it’s clear that he harbors no ill feelings towards the Indians. He states that he and his men were treated well, that they lived as “free agents” (De Vaca 32) and tried to accustom themselves to Indian life. He’s highly observant of the Indian life. He records the Indian lifestyles in detail; his account reads more like a cultural ...view middle of the document...

He continuously refers to the Indians as “savages” (Smith 46) or “barbarians” (Smith 48) throughout his account. He even describes them as “devils” (Smith 51). At one point, he thinks that the Indians are trying to “fat him to eat him” (Smith 50). Smith’s account is so incredibly dramatic that he expects “every hour to be put to one death or other” (Smith 52). Also, the incident with Pocahontas saving Smith appears to be highly romanticized. Smith’s manner of writing, in which he writes of himself in the third person, only adds to the boastful tone of this account. It makes the entire account seem impersonal. It also makes Smith appear self-important and frivolous.

One can only speculate on why there is such a huge difference in these two writers’ attitudes. Their backgrounds may be factors that have influenced their attitudes. For de Vaca, it may be his religious background that has influenced him and shaped his attitude. In his account, he acknowledges his religion several times. “My only solace in these labors was to think of the sufferings of our Redeemer, Jesus Christ, and the blood He shed for me,” de Vaca writes. Religion appears to be a great source of comfort to him, which may explain his peaceful attitude in his account. As for Smith, his personal background may play a role in his attitude and personality. It’s stated that “his early life was deceptively mundane” (Smith 43), and at the age of fifteen “tales of exploration, piracy, and military adventure had already stirred his imagination” (Smith 43). That along with his military background may explain his temperament and haughty attitude.

It’i s not surprising that de Vaca and Smith should have such different attitudes regarding their accounts with Indians. After all, both men did have drastically different experiences. It’s only expected that their attitudes should differ from one another.

Other Essays Like De Vaca And Smith

High school grammar book Essay

5987 words - 24 pages Present simple wordt gebruikt wanneer we het hebben over een vaststaand rooster in de toekomst. Vb. The bus leaves at 8.35 tomorrow morning. - We gebruiken de Present continuous om te spreken over acties/afspraken in de toekomst die zijn afgesproken vóór het moment van spreken. Meestal staat er bij ‘wanneer’. I’m seeing Mr. Smith next weekend. He is arriving on Tuesday. 2. Will and To be going to Will - We gebruiken

Jane Austen Essay

1761 words - 8 pages those who make mistakes. * Darcy and Elizabeth they lose their pride and prejudices along the story. * Lydia a “rational” woman who knows she is limited by society so she acts exactly as she is supposed to act. Jane Austen was very respected by the society. She was pretty well-known. A pesar de ello, Austen no podía vivir de su profesión como escritora porque en esa época no había copyright por lo que la editorial era la que se

How the Colonization Era Affected Authors

1161 words - 5 pages The atmosphere of which a writer adapts to affects his/her works. The writer's environment, and the churnings of history that feed the writer, gives him the material whereby he can construct, and create in. History, in this instance the colonization of the American continent, dictates what and how he is to write. Authors such as John Smith, William Bradford, and St. Jean de Crevecoeur are all examples of this. The

Company Expansion in South America

2441 words - 10 pages historic center of the Old Town . While at night when the city comes to live, tourist can enjoy out door authentic Colombian dinners with candle lights and lanterns, horse carriages, and most important Latin music (Smith, 2014). The following picture captures the night on a town in Cartagena: The following picture is of one of the beautiful beaches in Cartagena, called “Playa Blanca” or “White Beach”: Afar: The

The History of Hip Hop

644 words - 3 pages History of Hip Hop The first time I ever saw or heard of Rap was back in the day when MTV really played Music Videos. The Song was Walk this Way and Aero Smith Tune covered by Run DMC. The song resurrected the dying career of Aero Smith, and put rap out in front a large cross section of American Culture. From my perspective this is when Hip Hop and Rap entered the mainstream of American Culture. 1. The difference between Hip Hop and

Blanc de Chine

2277 words - 10 pages Development Plan for Blanc de Chine To: Lisa Liu, Vice CEO, Blanc de Chine Prepared by: Xiaoxi Zeng Submitted: 9 December 2014 Subject: Recommended strategy to for Blanc de Chine to enhance competitiveness Executive Summary: Luxury brand is regarded as the highest level of prestigious brand. Researchers underscore its intangible value and psychological value, for example: conspicuous value

The Roles of Graduate Quantity Surveyors in the Malaysian Construction Industry

2378 words - 10 pages with the growth of comprehensive user-friendly estimating software for instance, the QS is dead, or “re-engineered” as a Construction Economist (Stacey and Wood, 1996). Smith (2004) pointed out the quantity surveying profession has experienced significant changes over the past decade in terms of scope and type of services provided within and outside the construction sector. As a result, quantity surveying firms expand and adapt their scope of

New Jersey

1059 words - 5 pages On July 12, 1967, a taxi driver named John Smith was beaten by police after allegedly violently resisting arrest. He had driven around a double-parked police car. A crowd gathered outside the police station where Smith was detained. Due to miscommunication, the crowd believed Smith had died in custody, although he had been transported to a hospital via a back entrance to the station. This sparked scuffles between African Americans and police in

Academic Performance

5957 words - 24 pages Quality & Quantity (2006) 40:661–674 DOI 10.1007/s11135-005-2072-7 © Springer 2006 Research Note Factors Related to the Academic Performance of Students in the Statistics Course in Psychology ` ´ JOAN GUARDIA∗ , MONTSERRAT FREIXA, MARIBEL PERO, JAUME TURBANY, ANTONIO COSCULLUELA, MAITE BARRIOS ` and XAVIER RIFA Dept. de Metodologia de les Ci` ncies del Comportament, Facultat de Psicologia, Divisi´ de e o Ci` ncies de la Salut (IV

Analysis of the Matrix

2630 words - 11 pages . Neo could have easily entered the portal and been transferred back to the Nebuchadnezzar and away from harm thereby preventing the potential loss of The One, but Neo is now the protector of the group and there was no way he was going to enter the portal without one of his own. This leads to an epic battle with Agent Smith which in turn leads us to our next stage of the monomyth. The Magic Flight: Throughout the battle, Agent Smith is

Implication of Human Dignity

1086 words - 5 pages Smith3 Shunell Smith Professor Butterly REL 401 – Module 3 Essay 13 November 2008 Relation of Christianity and World Religions Teilhard was committed to his work in science but he was also a religious man. Despite his speculations and optimism about evolution, Teilhard based his collective thoughts in the term of love, increasing in our global species. The basis of his research and method was the outcome of Godâ

Related Papers

Spanish Exploration And Colonization Of The New World

685 words - 3 pages SPANISH EXPLORATION AND* COLONIZATION* OF THE NEW WORLD Charles Walker History HIST 101 03 Jan 2010 Alvar Cabeza de Vaca thought he was going to settle near the coast when his party approached Florida in 1528. But after a series of tragedies, he and 300 other people were abandoned on shore.2 The men traveled west unaware of their location. They built rafts to cross the Gulf Coast, and by the end of their first year, only four

Estados Financieros De Guillermo Essay

3271 words - 14 pages cuatro años. [pic] Recurso: Annual Report Starbucks Corporation Fiscal Year 2009 Cálculo de la Proporción DuPont o DuPont Ratio Rentabilidad sobre el patrimonio, equidad multiplicadora o rendimiento de fondos propios son varios de los nombres con los que también se conoce la relación de DuPont. Según describen Morgan Stanley & Smith Barney, LLC. (2010) en su recurso electrónico, esta proporción significa la medida de ganancia en relación

The Father Of Economics Adam Smith

3176 words - 13 pages finally denied economist Pierr Samuel Dupont de Nemours’o considerations that the most important idea for The Wealth of Nations borrowed from Turgot (Haakonssen). Full lingering Smith’s oeuvre fits into six solid his scriptures volumes. In addition to the above works, the fourth Writings volume published student recorded Smith’s lectures on the wild rhetoric and literature, and the sixth volume - Smith letters (Ross). In The Wealth of Nations

Uitwerking Case 8 1 Allied Office Products

1306 words - 6 pages Uitwerking Case 8-1 Allied Office Products Door: Joey de Klerk (481002) en Roel van Berkel (468870) Introductie Allied Office Products is a large corporation that builds its reputation on its annual sales of $900 million in business forms and specialty in paper products. Its paper products vary from envelopes to greeting cards and writing papers. Allied has incorporated a new program called Total Forms Controls (TFC) for its clients