Dead Poet's Society Analysis

977 words - 4 pages

Nick Savinar
October 13, 2010
Critical Leadership
Dead Poet’s Society Reflection

Dead Poet’s Society tells the story about a group of promising, young high school students and the top conservatory school in the country. The story is based around a new teacher, Mr. Keating, who uses poetry in order to inspire his students to pursue their own interests and desires. A group of his students learn about a secret club that he was involved in while he was in school called the Dead Poet’s Society, which inspires them to break away from the herd and begin to think for themselves. Later, when one student, Neil, commits suicide, the incident is blamed on Mr. Keating and he ...view middle of the document...

Today we live in a time when it is much easier to be an individual because our society has progressed towards a world with many more choices, and we are free to pursue them.
There is one aspect of this movie that I found to be particularly interesting, and at the same time slightly troubling. Clearly, one of the main teachings that Mr. Keating attempts to impose upon his students is that they should be individuals. He encourages, whether overtly or discreetly, to take lightly what the other authority figures at the school, as well as their parents, instruct them to do. He teaches his students to pursue their own passions and desires despite what they are told from all of these figures; however in the process of doing so, Mr. Keating elevates himself into a position of authority in the minds of the students. He tells them that he should be addressed as “oh captain, my captain” and clearly gains more influence over his students than any of the other teachers or parents are able to achieve. This situation that is created by Mr. Keating, whether it be subconscious or not, paradoxically creates the same exact situation that he spends so much time encouraging his students to avoid; following authority blindly. By establishing himself as the “captain” in the minds of the students, what Mr. Keating essentially does is to undermine the authority of his fellow faculty members while simultaneously elevating himself into a position of authority, whose instructions the students follow blindly. Sadly, when Mr. Keating ideas and teachings clash with the reality of his student’s lives, they play their part, however small, in the suicide of one of his students.
There is an undeniable difference between societal standard today and the time at which this film is depicted. In the film, those students wishing to express creativity and originality are...

Other Essays Like Dead Poet's Society Analysis

Traditional Conservatism and New Right Essay

1041 words - 5 pages ‘natural law’. A more widely held view portrays tradition as the accumulated wisdom of the past. The institutions and practices of the past have been ‘tested by time’, and should be preserved for the benefit of the living and for generations to come. In this view, society consists of a partnership between the living, those who are dead and those who are to be born. It has also been described as a ‘democracy of the dead’, reflecting the fact that the

This Essay Like The Summary Of My Last Duches

6551 words - 27 pages There is here a problem of framing, of bordering and delimitation, whose analysis must be very. finely detailed if it wishes to ascertain the effects of fiction.---Jacques Derrida, "Le facteur de la verite"If we are to approach a text, it must have an edge.---Jacques Derrida, "Living On: Border Lines"The interaction of creativity with interpretation concerned Robert Browning throughout a career in which he made the dramatic monologue converge

Walter Mitty

1000 words - 4 pages An Analysis of ‘Soldier’s Home’ by Ernest Hemingway Name Department Institution Date Abstract In times of war, soldiers may be exposed to highly different worlds. One involves a peaceful society where lies and complications proliferate. The other involves more direct confrontation and exposes the cruder aspects of the human psyche. Ernest Hemingway, through his short story, ‘Soldier’s Home,’ contrasts the

Havisham and the Laboratory

3127 words - 13 pages and mixes in the highest society. But she is very different from the Duke of Ferrara, who merely speaks a word, and silences his wife forever. This character is personally weak - unable to use her position or forceful speech to change her situation. She does not use open enmity - yet resorts to stealth. She cannot keep a man's love, but almost flirts with the old man who mixes the poison - she offers him a kiss, as if she were voluptuous and

Ballad of Birmingham by Randall

4886 words - 20 pages social outcasts — outlaws such as Robin Hood — or those alienated from the main centers of power in society — like the poor folk for whom Robin Hood stole. Ballads are always stories, often with tragic endings, and they frequently rely on dialogue to tell their tales. They were originally sung, so we can expect that the poem will be strong, musically. Finally, by noting that it is a ballad about Birmingham, Randall signals to his readers

Where the Mind Is Without Fear

1218 words - 5 pages Where the Mind is Without Fear ~Rabindranath Tagore CRITICAL ANALYSIS: Where the Mind is Without Fear was included in the volume called ‘Naibedya’, the original poem bears the title ‘Prarthana’ meaning prayer. The poem is a prayer to God. The poem was written by Rabindranath Tagore during the time when India was under the British Rule and

The Failure of Culture

1130 words - 5 pages interpolated into a prepatriarchialist paradigm of reality that includes narrativity as a totality. 2. Joyce and textual narrative “Society is intrinsically unattainable,” says Bataille. McElwaine[2] states that we have to choose between the prepatriarchialist paradigm of reality and posttextual capitalism. It could be said that several discourses concerning cultural theory may be found. The main theme of Buxton’s[3] analysis of textual narrative is

Lord of the Flies Chapter 6 Summary

836 words - 4 pages the island, dead. His chute becomes tangled in some rocks and flaps in the wind, while his shape casts fearful shadows on the ground. His head seems to rise and fall as the wind blows. When Sam and Eric wake up, they tend to the fire to make the flames brighter. In the flickering firelight, they see the twisted form of the dead parachutist and mistake the shadowy image for the figure of the dreaded beast. They rush back to the camp, wake Ralph

The Outsider

942 words - 4 pages The Outsider Analytical essay Question: Mersault is as much a victim of his own attitude to life and society as he is of the judicial system. Discuss ‘The Outsider’ by Albert Camus is based on the first person narrative of the protagonist Mersault. Throughout the novel, it is comprehensible that Mersault is different and indifferent towards the society he lives in. It is also understandable that Mersault lives life according to

The Rise and Fall of Equality

1038 words - 5 pages was doomed for an insidious but inevitable death, and it is not historical observation and political analysis which doomed it, but an intrinsic and fundamental flaw in the idea of a stateless society. The flaw is that man will always be a man. They tried so hard to create a society that was equal, where there'd be nothing to envy your neighbour. But the truth is, that there's always something to envy. A smile, a friendship, something you don't have and want to appropriate. Even in a Communist world, there will always be rich and poor. Rich in gifts, poor in gifts. Rich in love, poor in love.

Recognition eng

841 words - 4 pages husband and Kobus were not rivals. 6. The President wishes to make peace with the past , this is his way of showing that reconciliation can take place. 7. Not to forget the past, or change it but make peace with it and the other former wifes. 8. The black woman has ben married to a man who has ben Kobus rival. 9. They have ben rivals, they haven't fought for the same. 10. They can change the past by talking to each other. Make peace. Analysis 1

Related Papers

Fathers And Sons In Dead Poet's Society

2607 words - 11 pages Fathers and Sons in Dead Poet's Society A father is perhaps the most important role model to his son. The dominant culture states that when a boy is young, he looks to his father for help in identifying his role in society as a man. As the boy grows older, he looks to his father for guidance as to what course he should take in life. The boy becomes a man, and takes care of his father when he grows old and decrepit. This ideology

Dead Poets Society Essay

469 words - 2 pages Emerson once said, "For nonconformity the world whips you with its displeasure." When one doesn't follow the rules, they will always end up with discomfort. They will feel the crack of the whip against they bare skin. By not following the rules one will suffer the brutal consequences. In the movie "The Dead Poet's Society" many characters disobey the rules and they get into trouble. The movie "The Dead Poet's Society" shows that the conformance

Travelling Through The Dark Essay

1191 words - 5 pages Robert Hodge Professor Kathryn Hinds English 1102 13 April 2015 Traveling through the Dark By William E. Stafford Traveling through the dark I found a deer dead on the edge of the Wilson River road. It is usually best to roll them into the canyon: that road is narrow; to swerve might make more dead. By glow of the tail-light I stumbled back of the car and stood by the

Anyone Lived In A Pretty How Town

2127 words - 9 pages deceptively simple-complex language of childhood. The poem is a criticism of blindly following social conventions, as well as society's intolerance of nonconformists. Cummings shows us how society is not willing to acknowledge differences. He asks us to question traditions, and to understand them for their true intent. He is challenging anyone, meaning any one of us, to push the boundaries of our known space so that we may achieve our dreams