Death Of A Salesman And All My Sons As Optimistic Tragedies

4243 words - 17 pages

Death of a Salesman and All My Sons as Optimistic Tragedies

    This essay deals with Arthur Miller, and his uniqueness as a tragic playwright. The research question that this paper attempted to answer was, why were Miller's plays different from many other tragedies. Two of Arthur Miller's tragedies were used in this essay, Death of a Salesman and All My Sons. The thesis of this essay is, Arthur Miller deviates from the standard perception of tragedy in his plays, Death of a Salesman and All My Sons because unlike other tragedies, they are optimistic in that the main character causes the tragedy for what they perceive to be the greater good.

The body of this essay starts out with ...view middle of the document...

He is known throughout America and in many parts of the world for his tragedies. Miller has worked in other forms of literature, including his own autobiography, but he is most famous for his plays that he has been writing for more than sixty years, and continues to write. He has received many prestigious awards, including the Avery Hopwood Award, and his greatest honor, the Pulitzer Prize for his play, Death of a Salesman. Besides writing plays, Miller has also written books and essays. One of his more interesting essays was on the definition of a tragic play. He is one of the many literary scholars who have created their own definition of a tragedy. Arthur Miller deviates from the standard perception of tragedy in his plays, Death of a Salesman, All My Sons, and A View from the Bridge because unlike other tragedies, they are optimistic in that the main character causes the tragedy for what they perceive to be the greater good.

What Defines a Tragedy

The definition of tragedy has been argued for thousands of years. Literary scholars have different ideas, none of them wrong, but distinct in their own ways. Some have loose definitions, with very flexible standards. There are others that believe quite the opposite, having very strict definitions with no room for variations. Aristotle was one of these latter scholars. His definition was very exact, with no room for flexibility. He believed that, "A tragedy is the imitation of an action that is serious and also, as having magnitude, complete in itself; in language with pleasurable accessories, in a dramatic, not in narrative form; with incidents arousing pity and fear, where with to accomplish its catharsis."1 This definition is very binding, giving the impression that if one doesn't fit all of these requirements then it's not a tragedy. There needs to be more variation, room for playwrights to make their tragedy different from others, not all plays should have the same components. The definition of a tragedy needs to be broader than that, but not without any rules.

Arthur Miller also defined tragedy. There are several different things that Miller believes make a tragedy. One is that the main character does whatever he has to do to secure his personal sense of dignity. Miller says, "tragedy, then, is the consequence of a man's total compulsion to evaluate himself justly."2 Pride goes along with this, which is also a major part of many of Miller's tragedies. The character's "personal sense of dignity" can also be seen as his pride. This isn't true in all cases, but in many. Another key part of a tragedy, according to Arthur Miller, is the "tragic flaw" that the main character has. The tragic flaw is the characteristic that the character has that makes him fail, whatever it may be. The character fails because he tries to overcome this flaw, but does not succeed. Miller explains, "nor is it necessarily a weakness. The flaw, or crack in the character, is really nothing--and need be...

Other Essays Like Death Of A Salesman And All My Sons As Optimistic Tragedies

All My Sons Essay

855 words - 4 pages ‘All my Sons’ By Arthur Miller ‘All my sons’ by Arthur Miller is a play that is about an average American family who has made a lot of money from a business that made parts for plane engines during the war. The play is set in the back garden of the family home, the father Joe Keller has a guilty secret which only his wife Kate knows. Joe has 2 sons, Chris has fought in the war and his personality has changed from a greedy and self-centred

Streetcar and Death of a Salesman

1005 words - 5 pages Question: “ Modern Literature asks questions instead of providing answers” Tennessee Williams along with Arthur Miller are considered two of the greatest American playwrights since World War II, their tragedies A Streetcar Named Desire and Death of a Salesman are assed as Modern American Literature. Both authors provide messages in order to help the reader understand the plays thoroughly but they do not offer answers to the questions asked

Death of a Salesman

1067 words - 5 pages Death of a Salesman As Aristotle proposes in Poetics, Sophocles' Oedipus the King is “ example of the highest achievement in tragedy.” Similarly, Death of a Salesman shares characteristics of classical tragedy in a contemporary setting. Just as hamartia and hubris bring devastation and ruin upon King Oedipus and his family, Death of a Salesman has a hero whose life, through a series of flawed decisions, spirals out of control and ends in

Death of a Salesman

1237 words - 5 pages Death of a Salesman There are some who would argue that it is precisely the ultra-capitalist mentality of individuals like Willy Loman that has propelled the American Economy to global dominance, but Arthur Miller’s classic work “Death of a Salesman” begs the question: at what cost? What does it do to a person, this desperate need to “be number one man?” Each of Willy’s sons draw a different lesson from his life and their assertions about

Death of a Salesman

1657 words - 7 pages Death of a Salesman The play Death of a Salesman (DOAS) by Arthur Miller, written in 1949, focuses on the life and actions of the Loman family in the heart of Brooklyn. The man of the house Willy and his two sons Biff and Happy are the most interesting of the bunch, since they are very much alike on the surface, but oh-so different on the inside. Willy Loman, the main protagonist (and antagonist) of DOAS, is your usual patriotic father

Death of a Salesman - 961 words

961 words - 4 pages The madness of Willy Loman the Salesman As the story of “Death of a Salesman” by Authur Miller unfolded it became clear that that the main charter Willy Loman is losing his mind. It all seems to begin when Willy starts having flashbacks of an earlier life. The flashbacks quickly turn into a nightmare, and just the sound of the woman’s laughter can set Willy off. Eventually, Willy’s madness destroys his life and everyone around him. He sits

Death Of A Salesman

889 words - 4 pages The Dysfunctional Family      In Arthur Miller’s drama, “Death of a Salesman” the protagonist is a sixty-year-old salesperson by the name of Willy Loman. Willy suffers from self-delusion and is obsessed with the desire to succeed. Willy’s actions strongly influence his family, which contributes to their self-delusions. Willy’s wife Linda is an enabler and is codependent upon him. Linda encourages and participates in

Death Of A Salesman

948 words - 4 pages Critical Essay – Drama      The idea that any person can rise from humble beginnings to greatness is the basis of the American Dream. Arthur Miller paints a harsh picture of this ideal in the drama Death of a Salesman. The main character, Willy Loman, is a complex and tragic figure. He is a man striving to hold onto what dignity he has left in a world that no longer values the beliefs he grew up with. While

Death Of A Salesman

328 words - 2 pages "Death of a Salesman" One of the main conflicts in "Death of a Salesman" is, father versus son. This conflict is one of the main points in the play that we see Biff separate from his father Willy. There are two times in the entire play when you see both Biff and Willy actually acting like father and son. One is when Willy talks about Biff playing football in the city championship game. The other is when Biff decides to stay in the city and go

All My Sons - Essay 3

1151 words - 5 pages Courtney Krus 4th hour AP Lit Throughout the play All My Sons by Arthur Miller, Kate Keller hopes that time will stand still for everyone so that her family’s past won’t become publicized, and realizes that while she may be stuck in time everyone else is moving on. She also denies the fact that her son, Larry, has died and that her husband is responsible for the death of 21 solders so that her family will survive. Kate does those

Death of a Salesman Analysis

637 words - 3 pages the protagonist, Willy Loman’s lack of fairness or justice to his family via complex words, emotional appeal, imagery, flashbacks, and different points of views. Willy feels physically and mentally drained, he is not successful in his job as a salesman and as a result he is transferring all his dilemmas and negativity to his wife Linda, and his two sons Happy and Biff. Linda attempts to act jovial suggesting excuses and trying to give him hope

Related Papers

View Of War In All My Sons

833 words - 4 pages All My Sons, a play by Arthur Miller, tells predominantly the story of the Kellers. This play takes place after World War II, in the year 1947. It is a criticism of the “American Dream,” which can be defined as a life of personal happiness and material comfort as traditionally sought by those in the U.S. The pursuit of the American Dream consisted of anything tangible, such as things, numbers and people. There is no mention of anything

All My Sons Essay

1701 words - 7 pages All My Sons In the play All My Sons, as in Death of a Salesman, love is the basis of all the evil and tragic events that happen in the play. The play involves the Keller family, of which the two boys are grown men. One of the sons, Larry, went to war and was reported missing. The family never knew what happened to him. While the father, Joe, and other son, Chris, have come to realize that after three years he must be dead, the mother, Kate

Death Of A Salesman Essay 1168 Words

1168 words - 5 pages uses the plot of the play to portray a modern day tragedy that mirrors the traditional misfortune of one character. In Death of a Salesman, the lead character, Willy Loman, is a traveling salesman that believes in the true American Dream and striving for success ("Death of a Salesman."). However, as the play unravels, it reveals Willy’s tragic flaw and emotional instability. Willy’s two sons, Biff and Happy, have not fulfilled their father’s

All My Sons Essay

581 words - 3 pages Chris in the play All My Sons. After George’s visit, Chris begins to distrust his father after finding out that he was the person to be blamed for the death of those 21 pilots. Chris is amazed that his father was able to kill those 21 pilots for the good of the business. Chris thinks that what his father did was wrong and he should pay for what he did. Chris is right and Keller is completely wrong. Chris stated that he looked up to Keller as his