Death Penalty: An Exaggerated Punishment Essay

1524 words - 7 pages

Daniel Kontoh-Boateng
Dr. Susannah Chewning
ENG 101-301
13 December 2013

The Death Penalty: An Exaggerated Punishment
Furman v. Jackson, a case ruled in the State of Georgia in 1972 really aroused concerns regarding the death penalty. Technically, William Henry Furman was found guilty of murder which was supposed to attract a death sentence. However, his death sentence was said to be “arbitrarily and capriciously “applied and therefore regarded a contradiction to the eighth amendment that prohibits excessive bails and fines as well as cruel and unusual punishment. In effect, this argument hindered the death penalty law of forty states and the federal death penalty decrees and altered ...view middle of the document...

In a general perspective, the interpreters of the law and the supporting society of this form of capital punishment may see the death penalty as a mere way of eliminating some rogue who committed a disgusting murder. However, Radelet reinstates the question under the auspices of the sociological imagination that inquires the conscience of the nation as human beings? Again, he questions the integrity of the people involved in the whole death penalty execution process by asking who they really are as human beings. He goes on conclude that the view of the death penalty as a just way of punishment that is the good (lawful citizens) vs. bad (criminals) rather dehumanizes us all (“Humanizing the Death Penalty”). In a nutshell, the death penalty sentence elicits sadists (legislature and executioners) who in turn instill fear and emotional distress in the “innocent society” which does not put into effect the will of the Constitution of the United States.
Aside the fact that the death penalty contradicts the right of liberty, it ultimately infringes upon the right to life. The international global movement, Amnesty International states that “the death penalty violates the right to life as proclaimed in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights” (“Abolish the Death Penalty”). The Universal Declaration of Human rights was created subsequently after, the Second World War by the UN General Assembly and was endorsed by world leaders to protect the fundamental rights of individuals around the world(“The Universal Declaration of Human Rights). If life was not so precious, the United Nations would not have included the right to life in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in the first place. The Illinois Coalition to Abolish the Penalty States also states that “We don’t cut off the hands of thieves to protect property; we do not stone adulterers to stop adultery. We consider that barbaric. Yet we continue to take life as a means of protecting life.” Directly speaking, the Illinois movement implies that the government does not have the right to render human life worthy or not even though, the person committed wrong. A murderer must be punished in such a way that he will learn from his faults which will in turn teach the society that “to err is human and to forgive is divine”. The death penalty here does not serve as a good deterrent to serious crime but rather rubs off a sense of government hypocrisy which undermines the word “deterrent.”
Furthermore, Michael Ross, an inmate on death row from prison in Somers, Connecticut, wrote an article telling the story people who were found innocent after they had been sentenced to the death penalty. He declared the “beyond reasonable doubt” technique that the United States courts utilize to prove the innocence of accused persons is not reliable; to support, he quoted the statement of a late Supreme Court Justice Marshal “No matter how careful courts are, the possibility of perjured testimony, mistaken honest...

Other Essays Like Death Penalty: an Exaggerated Punishment

Death Penalty: the Most Extreme Punishment

762 words - 4 pages harm a person physically, mentally, or emotionally. For example, rape is something that may hurt one person mentally and/or emotionally. This way of punishment may sound very harsh and cruel but the only way to receive such punishment is to do the same to another human being. It is unfortunate to see that in some states the death penalty is no longer a used form of punishment. It has been an endless debate on whether or not the death penalty

Capital Punishment Essays - Benefits of the Death Penalty

634 words - 3 pages society. It asks our citizens to rely on legal procedures rather than to self-help their wrongs doings. It is morally right to sentence a person to the death penalty who has commited a serious crime as murder. If someone has murdered a person it is unethical to let the murderer live when you have an innocent person who is dead. Capital Punishment has to be based entirely on consideration of justice and morality.   Finally, the

The Death Penalty Is NOT An Effective Deterrent

2123 words - 9 pages (Texas, Florida, and Georgia), have the highest murder rates in the country (Iowans Against the Death Penalty, 1996). If the death penalty actually deterred murders, we would expect to see opposite results. If the death penalty was an effective deterrent, it would also be more cost efficient than any other forms of punishment. The fact is that a single execution costs more than two million dollars. This is $800,000 more than incarcerating a

Persusaive Communication

1051 words - 5 pages in a case gets handled by many people from the time of identification until the time of DNA testing. At any point errors are possible in the processing. Evidence planting occurs. Evidence sometimes gets destroyed. False testimony, fraud in the laboratory results, and exaggerated findings have led to wrongful convictions (2013). These are just a few of the examples that show that the death penalty is not an effective form of punishment

Death Penalty: Is It a Flawed System?

2429 words - 10 pages to... Amanda, this is an effective introduction and thesis. Good job! [Jayno Aki-Siler (TA)] Implementing the death penalty or capital punishment in a fair way is a problem that has stimulated disputes and anxiety in society for a long time. Capital punishment represents a sentence of death by execution for crimes that have been committed. To receive the death penalty, an individual needs to make certain types of violations known as capital

Should Death Penalty Be Abolished In America?

2342 words - 10 pages feelings. The risk to execute the innocent person is also a very important reason for people to object death penalty. Even those who support death penalty admit the existence of such risks. According to a new poll conducted by Pew Research Center, 70% of the subjects agree that the country’s capital punishment system carries with it an inherent risk of executing the innocent. (Berman, Mark). Just as Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr. pointed

The Death Penalty:Too Much Room For Error Includes Outline And Research

1505 words - 7 pages out, and they spend the rest of their lives livingwith what they have done and most likely suffering.The Death Penalty: Too much room for error!In the United States thirty-eight out of the fifty states have the death penalty as an option for punishment in criminal cases. If the death penalty was so effective in stopping crime, wouldn't all fifty states use it? Or is it that the twelve states that don't use the death penalty realize all the negative

Christian Worldview

1793 words - 8 pages group of ten inmates. What are the Christian thoughts about capital punishment in the United States? The Christian world do not support the death penalty of any Human being, it doesn't matter who you are. There have been many individuals who have been destroyed for an error made in a moment of anger, distress, and other things in their dysfunctional lives. It is reinforced in the Bible this statement " you shall love the Lord your God

Should the Abolishment of Capital Punishment in the United States Should Be Applied

1255 words - 6 pages clearly prefer it to execution. Otherwise, they would not try to be sentenced to life in prison instead of death”. Furthermore, the existence of the death penalty could make investigation process work effectively. Criminals commit all the crimes and homicides they have done to make an attempt to escape death punishment. Dieter (1993) believed that individuals are less likely to commit violent crimes, including murder, if they knew they could be

Death Penalty

1333 words - 6 pages dignity. Criminology & Criminal Justice: An International Journal, 11(2), 115-128. Wilkinson, D. J., & Douglas, T. (2008). Consequentialism and the Death Penalty. American Journal of Bioethics, 8(10), 56-58 Adkins, B. (2008). CONSTITUTIONAL LAW--THE DEATH PENALTY--DEATH PENALTY VIOLATES EIGHTH AMENDMENT WHEN USED AS PUNISHMENT FOR THE RAPE OF A CHILD WHEN DEATH DOES NOT RESULT. Cumberland Law Review, 39(3), 785-799.

The Pros And Cons Of Capital Punishment

1275 words - 6 pages used to condemn murder. Murder is still murder. Such an act by the government just displays the similarity of the criminal killing its victim. Punishment should not be on the same level as the action. An argument claims that certain people deserve to die. But what authority can exactly call for this. The government can make mistakes, or judge people wrongly. One action does not define the character of the person. The death penalty judges people

Related Papers

The Death Penalty Is An Acceptable Punishment

743 words - 3 pages The Death Penalty is An Acceptable Punishment Missing Works Cited When you think of an extreme crime you think of murder. When you think of an extreme punishment you think of the death penalty. Crimes of such severity sometimes deserve an equal punishment and we as a society accept this. However, Supreme Court Justice William Brennan argues that society seriously questions the appropriateness of the death penalty. It is true that over the

Capital Punishment Death Penalty Essay

1410 words - 6 pages banning the execution of the mentally retarded. Thirty eight states authorized the death penalty. Indiana and Missouri were among the 15 which now ban such executions. Also Georgia’s Supreme Court; was the first appellate court to rule that electrocution is unconstitutionally cruel and unusual punishment. So, with the ruling the state switches to the use of lethal injection under a law to provide an alternate method of execution. Alabama and

Pro Capital Punishment; The Death Penalty

1600 words - 7 pages reducing crime. What is deterrence? It is to punish somebody as an example and to create fear in other people for the punishment. The death penalty creates fear the minds of the sane people. Sane people know right from wrong. Violent crimes and murder are wrong, and the perpetrators should be punished accordingly and fittingly to their crimes. Capital punishment could work very effectively, if our legal system would enforce the punishment in a timely

Death Penalty Catholics And Capital Punishment

790 words - 4 pages bloody society that we might oppose having recourse to capital punishment.   Neither should we invoke human dignity as if our free actions do not specify us morally. A murderer and an innocent babe are poles apart morally. To talk about capital crimes as if they do not touch the moral essence of the agent is to trivialize human behavior and adopt the outlook of most others who oppose the death penalty. They are against punishment as