Death Penalty Catholics And Capital Punishment

790 words - 4 pages

Catholics and Capital Punishment


Catholic opponents of the death penalty sometimes seem to lose sight of the primary purpose of punishment. The Catechism of the Catholic Church says, "Punishment has the primary aim of redressing the disorder introduced by the offense." If I commit a serious offense against society, I bring about a disorder, and the point of punishment is to reestablish the lost order. If I willingly accept my punishment, "it assumes the value of expiation." And it can protect you from future crimes I might commit. The Catechism thus gives three purposes of punishment: defending public order, protecting people, and moral change in the criminal.

...view middle of the document...

Unless, as suggested, "protecting society" be taken to comprehend "redressing the disorder." (Paragraph 2266 distinguishes "defending public order" from "protecting people's safety.") One sometimes hears in the clamor to end the death penalty that retribution is no longer the aim of punishment. But if there is no cause for retribution, punishment is unjust: All that would excuse it is the fear that someone might in the future harm us and that solitude might better his soul.


Enthusiasm sometimes obscures the fact that the Catechism "does not exclude recourse to the death penalty." However rare such recourse might be, even if it were only once in a millennium, it would have to be justified. The long and rich tradition of Catholic morality has made clear what that justification is. That doctrine is what would justify capital punishment, however rarely exacted. Which is why that doctrine must not be, however implicitly, trashed. We should not preen ourselves, as we join the somewhat motley parade of opponents of capital punishment, that we have advanced beyond our tradition to a higher plane of morality.


Actually, the Holy Father's campaign against having recourse to capital punishment is a corollary to his evaluation of dominant trends in modern culture. Ours, he has said, is a culture of death. We live in a country where, as Russ Hittinger puts it,...

Other Essays Like Death Penalty - Catholics and Capital Punishment

The Death Penalty Is an Acceptable Punishment

743 words - 3 pages The Death Penalty is An Acceptable Punishment Missing Works Cited When you think of an extreme crime you think of murder. When you think of an extreme punishment you think of the death penalty. Crimes of such severity sometimes deserve an equal punishment and we as a society accept this. However, Supreme Court Justice William Brennan argues that society seriously questions the appropriateness of the death penalty. It is true that over the

Death Penalty: the Most Extreme Punishment

762 words - 4 pages harm a person physically, mentally, or emotionally. For example, rape is something that may hurt one person mentally and/or emotionally. This way of punishment may sound very harsh and cruel but the only way to receive such punishment is to do the same to another human being. It is unfortunate to see that in some states the death penalty is no longer a used form of punishment. It has been an endless debate on whether or not the death penalty

Capital Punishment and Euthanasia

3227 words - 13 pages found their way into judicial rulings, but not always with the clarity one would wish (Brazier, 2003). The Case of Death Penalty Few areas of criminal justice have prompted as much controversy and debate as the death penalty (Branharn, 2003). Capital punishment itself is one topic on which many reasonable people disagree, and a “passionate and extensive debate” on the issue is ongoing in the legal and greater community in many countries

The Aclu and Capital Punishment

1143 words - 5 pages of Human Rights (UDHR) (ACLU Death Penalty par.1). While the right to life is more commonly referred to in the issue of abortion, it still applies in the issue of capital punishment. Article 3 of the UDHR does not specify that it is to only guard certain people and not others. The right to life protects all people, criminal or not, and we cannot take away their right to life just because they are brought into custody. What would make someone’s

Juveniles And The Death Penalty

2094 words - 9 pages criminal behavior including, in some jurisdictions, execution (Thomson vs. State, 1986:784) ? Should These juveniles who perform the same malicious acts as some adult capital offenders be subject to the harshness of the criminal courts and the finality of the death penalty ? This paper will discuss a history of capital punishment for juveniles in the United States, methods of transferring juvenile cases to criminal courts, and also my position on

Death Penalty and Lethal Injection

2726 words - 11 pages was abolished in the United States, but this did not last long at all. Some states were left to re-write their unconstitutional legislation of the death penalty. State legislatives reintroduced the death penalty in a form that broke away from the “arbitrary and capricious” invalidity of its predecessor (Adams, 2005). Gregg v Georgia (1976) ruled that the new death penalty statutes held that capital punishment was no longer unconstitutional. From

The Pros And Cons Of Capital Punishment

1275 words - 6 pages to be innocent. How does one make up for such a great mistake. ("Capital Punishment: The Inevitability of Caprice and Mistake" 54-64) The death penalty can be as evil as the people it is attempting to punish. Those types of mistakes cannot be undone. The only blame has to fall on every one who is a part of society. It is the responsibility of society to work for a greater good, but the death penalty goes against that. By incapacitating a

The Death Penalty: Justice, Safety, and Deterrence

915 words - 4 pages The Death Penalty: Justice, Safety, and Deterrence Have you ever wondered why the United States has the death penalty? The United States uses the death penalty as capital punishment, so criminals can realize that doing such horrible crimes will lead to punishment, sooner or later. So therefore, the death penalty is a reasonable punishment system for those who committed a horrible crime because it provides justice, public safety, and

Death Penalty And The Eight Amendment

1230 words - 5 pages only be used as punishment for intentional killing. Still, the death penalty violates the Eighth Amendment and should be outlawed in the United States.Currently in the United States there are five methods used for executing criminals: the electric chair, gas chamber, lethal injection, hanging, and firing squad, each of them equally cruel and unusual in there own ways.When a person is sentenced to death by electrocution he strapped to a chair and

An Analysis Of The Article Billy Budd And Capital Punishment: A Tale Of Three Centuries

1645 words - 7 pages debates in New York, but the worldwide struggle to either justify or condemn the practice of capital punishment. Since the “Bloody Code”, a period of time when execution was common, was disliked in both England and America, participants in both opposing groups agreed that eliminating most of the codes capital offenses would be a notable achievement in society (3). Opponents of the death penalty referred of the “Georgian Code” as barbaric and

The Death Penalty: Is The Death Penalty Effective? Is It Necessary? Elaborate On How It Affects Society And The Fact That Innocent People Can Be Unfairly Executed

1679 words - 7 pages liberally, as did the Church of the Middle Ages. As history tells us, capital punishment, whose definition is "the use of death as a legally sanctioned punishment," is an acceptable and efficient means of deterring crime. Today, the death penalty remains an effective method of punishment for murder and other heinous crimes.There is debate over the morals and effectiveness of such a harsh sentence. Most commonly, the death penalty is challenged as a

Related Papers

Capital Punishment Death Penalty Essay

1410 words - 6 pages . “Dying is feared because death is expected; death is feared because it is confused with dying. Being death is no different from not being born, stage we all had before being born”. (P.338 Isenberg) In conclusion, I still agree that the death penalty is a great capital punishment. Murder is a crime that involves taking the life of another human, and that act needs to be punished justly not with a short sentence with free food, housing and free

Pro Capital Punishment; The Death Penalty

1600 words - 7 pages Pro Capital Punishment; The Death PenaltyAnyone you ask in today's society will tell you that we live in a crime stricken age. Crime rates continue to rise to more incredible numbers each year, with more and more victims suffering. Capital punishment should be utilized as much as possible. There are numerous reasons, and I plan to address a few of the more paramount issues.I believe that the death penalty serves as a deterrent and helps in

Capital Punishment Essays Benefits Of The Death Penalty

634 words - 3 pages Capital Punishment Essays - Benefits of the Death Penalty   In the eighteenth century,England would punish by death for pickpocketing and petty theft. Ever since the 1650's colonist could be put to death for denying the true god or cursing their parents advocates. Capital Punishment have clashed almost continuously in the forum of public opinion in state legislatures and most recently in courts. In 1972,the case of furman

Death Penalty: An Exaggerated Punishment Essay

1524 words - 7 pages people by act of fear and emotional distress. Michael Radelet, a sociologist, witnesses the ordeals of the family of an inmate who is scheduled to be executed in a few hours at a corrections prison. In a general perspective, the interpreters of the law and the supporting society of this form of capital punishment may see the death penalty as a mere way of eliminating some rogue who committed a disgusting murder. However, Radelet reinstates the