Demise Of Management Essay

1229 words - 5 pages

Introduction

This essay will compare and contrast the arguments and themes of the following two articles – “Management: The Work that Dares not Speak its name” by Brocklehurst, Grey, & Sturdy (2010) and "We are all managers now’; ‘We always were’: On the development and Demise of Management” by Grey (1999). In each article the author’s provide a view that indicates significant research into the topic of managers and management. I intend to discuss two main points, the demise of management and the avoidance of being labelled a manager.

Discussion

Based on the evidence presented, each author has concluded the term manager and management has changed significantly over time and the ...view middle of the document...

However the demise of management or at least the perception that management may be on the decline could have many follow-on effects, one of which may be the impact on business and management training.

This may cause a shift in focus from the current ideals of management training to that of leadership training, this idea is supported by research by Brocklehurst, et al, 2010, p17 where they state ‘Is it possible to study a subject such as management when there is an overwhelming desire for executives to be known as anything but a manager?’

There is a view that ‘the term manager has been in decline for at least 30 years’ (Fletcher, 1973; Koch and Godden, 1996) however at ‘the same time the number of employees now designated as managers has increased’(Brocklehurst, et al, 2010). As society progressed through the 20th century everyday people continued their usual daily business and routines. However at some point there appears to have been a shift towards the changing status of management where there has been a level of embellishment in many position titles such that everyone became a pseudo manager.

The common theme in both articles is the changing perception of managers and the role that they now play in the private and public sectors. There is also some conjecture over what actually defines a manager, Is it what they do? Is it how they get people to do things for them? No matter how the information provided is interpreted there will always be a difference of opinion on whether there is demise or just a change in society’s acceptance of the title of the manager.

There was once a perception that ‘managers possess the technical knowledge’ however ‘such knowledge is increasingly being sub-contracted to suppliers or consultants’ (Brocklehurst, et al, p10). Additionally managers are increasingly becoming ‘coordinators rather than the owner of expertise’ (Brocklehurst, et al, 2010). These statements were once the opinion of many experts in the field of management but the continuing evolution of the manager has seen more support for the title of ‘coordinator’ than that of the possession of management skills.

Additionally there is a stigma attached to the idea of bureaucracy and the image of management that goes with it. There is perhaps no more stigmatic label than that of a ‘bureaucrat’. This may be one reason behind the gradual distancing from the term ‘Manager’ in the business titles held by many of today’s senior executives. The idea of being a leader and not a manager has far more appeal as it portrays someone who is centrally involved in promoting organisational change. ‘Leadership is both congruent with, and emblematic of, dominant contemporary understandings of what is valuable in organisations’...

Other Essays Like Demise of Management

Fall of Enron Essay

994 words - 4 pages The Fall of Enron is a perfect example of management failure. Enron started off as a merger between Houston Natural Gas and Inter-North. A few years after the merger, Enron started changing the strategy and structure of the organization. Enron went from a raw materials management company to a company selling energy commodities. Enron proceeded to change from an energy company to a risk management firm that traded everything from commodities to

Rdh Paper

1339 words - 6 pages culturally more aware which will lead to better management & higher productivity. References: Grainger (2008). The demise of International Management Contract. Retrieved from: http://mams.rmit.edu.au/3je3klf7vrprz.pdf Chen, M. (2002). Asian Management Systems: Chinese, Japanese and Korean Styles of Business. Learning, International Thomson Business Press, London. Yang, M.M., (2000). The Art of Social

History Of Management

980 words - 4 pages economic development through efficient and productive work was Taylor's own view of his work, the growing Labor Movement would see "Taylorism" as exploitive. Organized labor's antagonism to the American popularity of Taylor's work would eventually lead to Congressional hearings and, pretty much, the demise of "Scientific Management". Taylor developed his management theories in his book Shop Management published in 1903, making it arguably the first

Kramer Pharmaceuticals Case Study

641 words - 3 pages hospitals, he was anxious to excel, was appreciative and willing to follow suggested orders, and expressed great cooperation with fellow employees up and down the chain of command. Yet I personally believe that the slow demise of Marsh’s performance within Kramer lies on management. Over the course of Marsh’s service at Kramer there must have been at least a half dozen changes in management, more specifically, changes in the direct supervisor of

Case: 9 Enron

969 words - 4 pages focused on profits that nothing else mattered. In the beginnings of the company Ken and Jeff were very efficient in growing their company from a small oil and gas pipeline firm into one of the largest entities in its industry. As the company grew and so too did the demands of upper management. Ken Lay was never satisfied and always wanted more; in his efforts to achieve this he implemented coercive power to shape his corporate culture. This

Business Failure

1050 words - 5 pages demise. In addition, it will also be revealed how proper organizational behavior of management and leadership could have greatly impacted the structure of Enron positively. Enron’s executive team was trying to create and promote an enterprise which would increase vast wealth amongst their shareholders. However, when it was revealed that Enron’s stock prices were less than desirable, certain aggressive accounting methods and measures were

British Style of Management

803 words - 4 pages BRITISH STYLE OF MANAGEMENT Management and worker representatives in the United Kingdom are trained to negotiate, form agreements and stick to them. Bargaining may be hard and prolonged but in the end we can only work with people we can trust and that means with people whose word means something, moreover British are easygoing, humorous and risk-taking. , the British work more days and longer hours than most other European countries

Arthur Andersen & Co

1303 words - 6 pages business in the first place, or whether individual wrongdoers should have been charged instead," did not relive the firm of their social responsibility to their clients around the world and "the thousands of innocent employees who lost their jobs with its demise" (Waldmeir, 2005, ¶2).Management decision making, loss of ethical standards, and indictment of a crime are just three factors that influenced Arthur Andersen's strategic, tactical

Nick Lesson Case

1810 words - 8 pages arbitrage opportunities with derivatives contracts between SIMEX and Japan’s Osaka Exchange. Arbitrage involves going long in one market and short in the other one and thus making the differences as profits to Barings. In 1993, he singlehandedly contributed ~10% of the banks’ profits, which was worth about £10 million. This resulted with a £130,000 bonus on to top of his base salary of £50,000. Of course, with this success, his management team will

Mgt 521 Weekly Reflection Assignment Week 6

590 words - 3 pages ). This statement in their Code of Ethics was violated on many levels and ultimately led to their collapse. 3. What role did Lehman’s executives play in the company’s collapse? Were they being responsible and ethical? Discuss. The executives at Lehman Brothers were ultimately the cause of the company’s demise. Actions of managers are projected down through the management ranks all the way through to the lowest level employees. By

Enron Committed Suicide

995 words - 4 pages happen overnight. The failure was rooted in the company’s unethical leadership (Weidlich & Calkins, 2006). Enron’s fast rise to the largest energy management firm mirrored its demise because of unethical practices by Jeff Skilling the Chief Executive Officer (CEO), and Andy Fashow, the Chief Financial Officer (CFO) (Gutman, 2002). Enron’s leadership were accused of profiting from their activities, allowing the company to hide the massive debt

Related Papers

Demise Of Enron Corporation® And Worldcom®

654 words - 3 pages to the demise of Enron and WorldCom was employee’s unethical investment management. These organizations used employee’s investments to make a profit without the appropriate consent and authorization. When the profit came back empty, Enron and WorldCom were unable to pay its employees back leading to one of the biggest financial scandals in United States financial history. Another contributing factor to the demise of these two powerful companies

The Great Gatsby: The Demise Of Two Dreams

1278 words - 6 pages      While there are numerous themes throughout the text of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby, the most prominent is that of the American Dream. The American Dream is the idea that any person, no matter what he or she is, or from where he or she has come, can become successful in life by his or her hard work; it is the idea that a self-sufficient person, an entrepreneur, can be a success. In this novel, however

Will Changing The Australian Legal Drinking Age Be The Demise Of Youth Music Festivals?

1699 words - 7 pages ENG224 | Will changing the Australian legal drinking age be the demise of youth music festivals? | Stage Two Research Paper | | Maya Burvill 16568 | 4/twenty-one/2011 | Academic Research Paper – Stage Two | Will changing the Australian legal drinking age be the demise of youth music festivals? Abstract: Binge drinking and alcohol incurred road accidents by youth are a growing concern in Australia; issues which governments

Tennessee Williams' Play "A Street Car Named Desire" An Essay About How Blanches Society Is The Epitome Of Her Eventual Demise

1105 words - 5 pages to deceive the people around her, ironically it could be said that the secrets she keeps are a major factor in her decent into madness; which parallels the secret that Allen kept that was the determinate in his demise. These secrets are an attempt to shield the people around her from her history in hopes of creating a new life without the unfavorable reputation that she obtained in Laurel. In addition to this it could be said that lying was part