This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Differing Definitions Of Critical Thought Essay

2208 words - 9 pages

Running head: Differing definitions of critical thought

Differing Definitions of Critical Thought
Victor M. Fraser
Capitol College

Abstract

This paper attempts to compare and contrast the differing definitions of critical thinking as defined by various writers on different publications. It appears that no matter how critical thinking is defined, the same components are standard, and the conclusions are somewhat similar and hold true. A true definition of critical thinking is by no feat an easy task. It is a complex and controversial notion difficult to define and also to study. Many definitions have been ...view middle of the document...

In some cultures, being critical may be interpreted as “argumentative” or ‘being critical of others” (J. Lau 2008). Some researchers see Critical Thinking as a form of philosophy; others see it as a set of skills. Tsui, on page 743 of “Fostering critical thinking through effective pedagogy” defines critical thinking from a pedagogic perspective and calls it an ability to “identify issues and assumptions, recognize important relationships, make correct inferences, evaluate evidence or authority and deduce conclusions”. The differing definitions appear to follow a trend in that the definitions are usually geared towards the attributes needed in the subject of research in which the research is being conducted. Staib from “Teaching and measuring critical thinking” on the other hand, refers to critical thinking as “the art of thinking about your thinking while you are thinking in order to make your thinking better” (p. 643). In addition to this, Torff sees critical thinking as comprising “cognitive skills and strategies that increase the likelihood of a desired outcome…” (Teacher Education Quarterly, 2006.).

To support a previous assumption that critical thinking definitions are biased towards the researcher’s field of study, take the example in the article, “Using Weblog to Promote Critical Thinking – An Exploratory Study”, it is cited that “For the context of this study, it is decided that critical thinking should be identifiable and quantifiable”. This makes it obvious that the notion of critical thinking does not have an exact definition, and that it can be tailored to encompass a particular field of study. Is critical thinking always measurable? How is it to be measured? That will depend on who is asked, there are standards available addressing it. Newman, Webb and Cochrane in 1996 created a model for analyzing online discussion. From this derived ten categories of Critical Thinking Characteristics. They are: Relevance, Importance, Novelty, Outside knowledge\experience, Ambiguities, Linking ideas, Justification, Critical assessment, Practical utility, and Width of understanding. We find that all definitions of critical thinking, no matter how defined contains most, in all cases all of the above characteristics.
Thinking is greatly affected by our surroundings, our culture and our values. One of the greatest barriers of thinking is our culture. The American culture is totally different in so many ways than the European culture. Granted there are similarities in many ways, the basis of the differences are found in the way our forefathers have passed on cultural teachings. It is customary for the British to have tea in the afternoon regardless of the season. This is not typical of Americans. Another example is the Spanish will take a siesta after lunch before returning to work. They believe that the refreshed mind is more productive. These differences can be taken one step further to include religion. What effects will these...

Other Essays Like Differing Definitions of Critical Thought

Me And My Self Essay

1358 words - 6 pages , married, divorced and many more, are the people that are found in organisations. These people have differing ways of living for example a single woman is independent and her needs greatly differ from those who are married. It is therefore of critical importance for employers to consider these status if they are to yield more in their organisations. Baytos and Cliff (1995) are of the view that there are three key drivers of diversity and these

What does Judaism mean to me and you?

371 words - 2 pages The word Judaism has two meanings. It can mean the civilization of the Jews, the culture of those who claim to be Jews or whom others call Jewish. And it can also mean the religion of the Jews.The two definitions are simple, but only on the surface. When we try to be precise, defining Judaism becomes a much more complex endeavor.How can we give a single definition of Jewish civilization? There are African Jews and Persian Jews, Jews in Israel

Critical Thinking Case Study

1234 words - 5 pages Critical Thinking Case Study:Let It Pour - My First Assignment as Executive AssistantThe mission of Faith Community Hospital is to maintain it's spiritual heritage and values, while providing health services to the community and retaining members that share the same vision and values. The Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of the hospital is facing many challenges in his present operating environment. Several of these challenges can be attributed to

Critical Path Method

817 words - 4 pages CRITICAL PATH METHOD (CEE 320 – VDC SEMINAR) 4 February 2009 Jesse Santiago & Desirae Magallon Overview Background & History CPM Defined The CPM approach Definitions Class Exercise Background & History Developed in the 1950s by the US Navy Originally, the critical path method considered only logical dependencies between terminal elements Since then, it has been expanded to allow for the inclusion of resources related to each

Information Management Case Study

5846 words - 24 pages explain the concept of `intellectual capital’ and how it is managed and exploited in organisations. The course will demonstrate a critical understanding of knowledge management policies and strategies in organisations that enhance effectiveness. You will be able to apply a range of transferable skills including literature search, analytical skills, application of theory to real-life situations, teamwork, motivation and interpersonal skills. Module

Team Science A Concept analysis

1538 words - 7 pages together a diverse group of individuals who fully integrate theories, methodologies, and frameworks from their respective fields to work as a cohesive unit on complex issues (Rosenfield, 1992). Consequently, a problem exists in the definitions of interdisciplinary research, a precursor to transdisciplinary team science. The NIH Roadmap initiative defines interdisciplinary research slightly different than Rosenfield. The NIH takes the interdisciplinary

The Providence of God

881 words - 4 pages understanding. The question of the providence of God is one topic that takes this time, energy and patience. The time spent exploring this topic is well worth it. Wright states, “But the question (of providence) is finally unavoidable, and the answer one attempts to give to it will necessarily affect all the rest of one’s theological outlook.”[1] My purpose for this paper is the analyze Wright’s article with a critical lens. Brief Summary Wright

Talent Management

935 words - 4 pages exist in how the term ‘talent’ is defined across differing sectors, and organisations may prefer to adopt their own interpretations rather than accepting universal or prescribed definitions. That said, it is helpful to start with a broad definition and, from our research, we have developed a working definition for both ‘talent’ and ‘talent management’: * Talent consists of those individuals who can make a difference to organisational

Critical Thinking

1055 words - 5 pages Community states; “Critical thinking of any kind is never universal in any individual; everyone is subject to episodes of undisciplined or irrational thought. Its quality is therefore typically a matter of degree and dependent on, among other things, the quality and depth of experience in a given domain of thinking or with respect to a particular class of questions. No one is a critical thinker through-and-through, but only to such-and-such a degree

Hrm - Case Study Chap 7

5155 words - 21 pages compensate employees according to objective measures of performance, even though performance is at least partially determined by factors beyond their control? Should a salesperson, for instance, be paid completely on commission even in the midst of a recession that makes it practically impossible to sell enough to make a decent living? Students should have some differing opinions on this, especially with the example of economic factors

Creative Thinking

736 words - 3 pages Critical Thinking Critical thinking can be defined in a numerous ways, but all the definitions agree that critical thinking is definitely thinking about thinking. Webster’s dictionary defines it as the mental process of actively and skillfully conceptualizing, applying, analyzing, synthesizing, and

Related Papers

Critical Thinking Essay

1232 words - 5 pages mistakes in reasoning Solve problems systematically Identify the relevance and importance of ideas Reflect on the justification of one's own beliefs and values Other definitions of critical thinking have been proposed. See bottom of this page for explanations of critical thinking from other sources. It can be seen that clarity and rationality constitute the common core across the different conceptions on critical thinking. Critical thinking is

Piaget Essay

352 words - 2 pages intellectually, children develop increasingly more complex schemes, i.e. organized patterns of thought used to cope with or explain an experience (Shaffer, 2005).According to Piaget, children are born without any knowledge. Children are constructivists, meaning that their cognitive development occurs because of curiosity and active interactions with the environment. Piaget found that children naturally and continuously organize schemes into specific

Ducks In Malibu Playin Cart Essay

554 words - 3 pages whose sub-components needed to be distinguished in relationship to other sociological variables. Contents [hide] 1 Overview 2 History 3 Definitions and concepts 4 Origins and development 5 Critical Implications 6 See also 7 References 8 Further reading [edit]Overview The notion of social structure as relationships between different entities or groups or as enduring and relatively stable patterns of relationship'[2] ' emphasises the

Critical Thinking And Ethics Essay

798 words - 4 pages thinking can seem like a very complicated process but with practice it can be applied to everything in life. So what exactly is critical thinking? “Critical thinking is the objective analysis of an issue in order to form judgment” (Ridel, 2015, pg. 7). Although there are many different definitions for it the one above explains more clearly what it consist of. What it doesn’t include is the six steps in the critical thinking process. Step one is