Do Americans Need Illegal Workers To Support Our Economy?

1697 words - 7 pages

English Comp II 201 06
21 January 2013
Do Americans really need illegal workers to support our economy?
It is a huge issue in America today, illegal immigration and what it means for our economy. The problem is divisive and a political hot potato. It has been discussed for the last thirty plus years and no solutions are in sight. We have some eleven million illegal, undocumented workers in America today and some argue we should round them up and send them home, regardless of the human suffering and others argue that our economy would collapse or at least be seriously harmed if we send them home.
According to Colin Powell, we need them because they are the lifeblood that is keeping this ...view middle of the document...

“(Matthews, 2013) This happens because these immigrants, both legal and illegal fill the jobs that we Americans don’t want. They take the jobs in the fields picking produce and in the slaughter houses processing animals. They take the menial positions in restraunts and make possible lower costs to the rest of us who either frequent these restraunts or buy the goods processed by these workers. These workers also demand labor as well, creating jobs for others.

Is immigration a drain on the welfare state?
According to George Mason University economist Bryan Caplan, contrary to popular stereotypes, welfare states focus on the old, not the poor. Social Security and Medicare dwarf means-tested programs. Since immigrants tend to be young, they often end up supporting elderly natives rather than ‘milking the system.’ Illegal immigrants who pay taxes on fake Social Security numbers are pure profit for the Treasury. In 2005, Social Security’s chief actuary estimated that without all the taxes paid on invalid Social Security numbers, ‘the system’s long-term funding hole over 75 years would be 10 percent deeper. (Caplan)

Does immigration help the economy grow?
According to University of California Economist, Gordon Hanson, low-skilled immigrant workers can make the American economy more efficient as well. First of all, low-skilled immigrant workers are more willing to move to find work than native-born American workers. Writes Hanson: “Low-skilled U.S.-born workers tend to be immobile across regions. When, say, the demand for low-skilled labor picks up in North Carolina, native-born workers in other regions are slow to move in . . . The consequence of the immobility of low skilled labor is to gum up the labor market, slowing the pace of growth in booming regions and the pace of recovery in slumping regions.”
There are two groups of immigrants, group one is highly skilled and arrive here on H1-B visas and group two are the illegals. We need both for this country to prosper. I would prefer that our politicians figure out a way to make sure that both groups would be legal. Group two fills the shortages at the bottom of the labor market. Those shortages are on the farms and other related agricultural markets.
I turned next in my search on this subject to the Center for Immigration Studies, an independent, non-partisan, nonprofit research organization. This organization has received praise from both Democrat and Republican lawmakers.
In a memo written this past December, the Director of research at the institute wrote that of the 11 or so million illegal immigrants in America perhaps seven or eight million of them are employed. Research indicates that most of these have no more than a high school education, if that. So if we allow these people to remain here, they will compete with the native born Americans who either hold only a high school education or less. This makes the already bleak employment prospects for these Americans even bleaker and...

Other Essays Like Do Americans Need Illegal Workers to Support Our Economy?

Do Parents Need to Take Control of Childhood Obesity?

2619 words - 11 pages Do parents need to take control of childhood obesity? Looking at Childhood Obesity Statistics and Various Causes RJ Mcckleene Western Governors University WGU Student ID# 109456 Do parents need to take control of childhood obesity? Childhood obesity has been increasing over the last 2-3 decades at an alarming rate. The U.S. Surgeon General says that in the last two decades the percentages of overweight children has

Do Police Need a Warrant to Search Property

1683 words - 7 pages Jennifer Springer BUSN201 Business Law - Final Paper Do Police Need a Warrant to Search Property On February 15, 2014 the Supreme Court ruled it would honor the Fourth Amendment’s warrant requirement when one cotenant refuses a warrantless search prior to being arrested, and then police receiving consent by the other cotenant to search the property. If a person’s health and safety are threatened by a domestic abuser, exigent

What Can We Do (to Help) in Our Environment

612 words - 3 pages from the sea. This can be attributed to illegal fishing practices such as cyanide and dynamite fishing, which turns out to destroy the coral reefs and seagrass beds where these fishes supposed to live. For the welfare of Philippine citizens, and as part of its mandate, the national government of the Philippines, particularly our current and his preceding president, President Noynoy Aquino and Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo launched different projects

Claim: Government Must Ensure That Their Major Cities Receive the Financial Support They Need in Order to Thrive

717 words - 3 pages 5. Claim: Government must ensure that their major cities receive the financial support they need in order to thrive. Reason: It is primarily in cities that a nation's cultural traditions are preserved and generated. As some people put forward, government must ensure that their major cities receive the financial support they need in order to thrive on the grounds that in these cities, a nation's cultural traditions are preserved and

Media and the Military "We Do Need to Control Media Access"

1477 words - 6 pages role in my duties to effectively lead and win the fight on the battle field over the next 10 years of my career. I will need to understand media management and how it impacts our troops and how it may impact our success on the battle field. There are varying opinions whether or not journalists should be present during combat operations. Regardless of the opinions on journalistic practices if these practices are not

Sleep Is Key To A Healthy Life Style: How Much Sleep Do We Really Need?

1565 words - 7 pages , so that means that an adult could make do each day on only six hours of sleep while another person may need ten hours. Therefore, each person’s body and mind need a different amount of sleep each night in order to function each day. “Nevertheless, it’s important to pay attention to your own individual needs by assessing how you feel on different amounts of sleep”(“How Much Sleep Do We Really”). Sometimes, the body can function with a little

To What Extent Do You Agree That a Free Market Economy Is the Only Approach to Bringing About Economic Growth

2716 words - 11 pages To what extent do you agree with the view that only a free market approach to running the economy can bring about sustainable high levels of economic growth and development? The basic economic problem is that we, as consumers, have unlimited wants and scarce resources. (Anderton, 2008, p.1) Due to this, the questions of what shall be produced, how it will be produced, and who gets the product, arise. (Sandford, 1977, p.42) Therefore

BOREDOM - What Is Boredom? When Does It Occur? How Is It Related To Our "Actualizing Need"? And How Is It Related To Philosophy

441 words - 2 pages 3. Boredom occurs when there is little or no interest involved in the situation that is presented. You are bored because you are stuck in an instance that you don't want to belong in, but yet you cannot do anything about it or are not doing anything about it. Your mind is not completely focused and it is difficult to concentrate and feel interested. When one is bored, their boredom can be seen through their work. It is evident when somebody is

What Do You Feel Is an Appropriate Balance Between Being Successful Financially and the Need to Serve Others by Giving Back?

528 words - 3 pages What do you feel is an appropriate balance between being successful financially and the need to serve others by giving back? 1 My dream of becoming successful financially was something I thought I would never be able to accomplish. As a young single working mom it was hard raising my children on one income and no education. I was at a point in my life where it was just getting harder and harder to make ends meet and I didn’t see times

What Were The Crucial Differences In The Ideologies Of Du Bois And Washington And Which Of Them Do You Think Contributed Most To The Advancement Of African-Americans In The Early Twentieth Century?

2552 words - 11 pages focused on the actual people.In the course of his life he made efforts to raise the prestige of African Americans by initiating campaigns such as the one to spell Negro with Capital N and thereby expressing respect for this race.Furthermore, as "cleanliness" had always been an important part of Washington's philosophy, he launched projects such as the Negro Health Week to support increase awareness for health care among African-Americans at that

Immigration Reform

2530 words - 11 pages ," 2011). Illegal immigrants help the economy for the better. Industries like agriculture that requires a large workforce have been unable to plan their business strategies around an unstable workforce. These businesses have relied on immigrant workers to do those jobs. The hospitality, restaurant, business services, and manufacturing sections are facing similar problems. Americans workers are not willing to do those types of jobs. They

Related Papers

Do We Need Illegal Migrants? Essay

1140 words - 5 pages Mohamed Ali KCC Composition II 7 Dec, 2013 Do we need illegal migrants? There are many heard misconceptions about illegal immigration. Immigration levels have increased by a significant extent. People migrate for a variety of reasons and purposes, some are economic and others are non-economic. Any average people know the economic reasons, such as

We Do Need Pet In Our Life

518 words - 3 pages We do need pet in our life With the increase of life standard, an increasing of family choose to have a pet with them. However, the phenomenon also give rise to some controversy. The antagonistic opinion is hold by some people because they consider that pets must bring a big problem, such as additional expense, ailment and so forth. On the contrary, a large number of people agree that having a pet is such an

Are There Objective Values? Or Do We Need To Create Our Own Values?

933 words - 4 pages , but we have found nothing to replace God. Meaning people need to create their own life purpose by the values they choose, which is what Nietzsche worries about because without a purpose we would slide deeper and deeper into a dream world of mediocrity and comfort, which not an easy task to do because to do so one must first get rid/annihilate old values first to create space for new ones. Nietzsche doesn’t believe in being able to live a meaningful life with the values of society because we will never be happy with others values, not of our own individual values, only if we create our own.

Why Do We Need To Save The Environment

697 words - 3 pages WHY DO WE NEED TO SAVE THE ENVIRONMENT All of us should be very thankful because we are blessed with such a beautiful environment to live in. Even so, the environment we are granted with may not last for a long period if we do not take necessary actions to save it. We must realize that each one of us is responsible and plays a role in saving the environment. Many people tend to question the reasons for saving the environment. There are