This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Do Individuals Change The Course Of History, Or Is Change The Product Of Larger Historical Forces? Support Your Argument With Historical Examples

1365 words - 6 pages

Do individuals change the course of history, or is change the product of larger historical forces? Support your argument with historical examples.

Historical change is the outcome of a phase of change within a society. Individuals influence this phase through their actions; yet these actions are pre-determined by their experiences which they themselves had no control over. Historical change requires a permitting environment in which to influence; an environment where a majority must be knowingly affected by an individual, meaning individuals are under the constraints of historical forces. Power defines opportunities for change, a requirement where all aspects are founded on society. ...view middle of the document...

Hitler’s anti-Semitic biases emerged gradually through multiple observations with Jewish Zionists, conforming to evidence Hitler perceived (concerning propagated media within Vienna) that Jewish Zionism was morally unjustifiable towards personal beliefs (Mein Kampf 1942). Bias observations developed regarding Jewish culture, justifying his views of Judaism the race, not the religion:
“Was there any shady undertaking, any form of foulness, especially in cultural life, in which at least one Jew did not participate?” (Hitler, A 1925, Mein Kampf, p. 153).
Hitler’s situation was one he himself had no bearing on whatsoever; based on observations, Hitler’s flawed reasoning (flawed due to gradual bias) determined his comparably immoral beliefs, with similar cases such as his approval of eugenics (Richard Weikart, 2001), etc. Hitler’s story demonstrates the lack of control an individual possesses concerning the surrounding environment’s influence on themselves. Validation is given to the pre-determination assertion that experiences, through external factors, influence an individual’s actions within a phase of change. Experiences are gained within an environment or society, further proof denying the claim that individuals change the course of history, rather than larger historical forces.
Human nature possesses us to seek for personal benefit, attainable through the involvement of change. This applies nonetheless so on the scale of historical change, where an individual may influence change through their actions only if society permits; that is, if deviation from the norm knowingly affects a greater majority of that society. Einstein shares traits with the Spanish Inquisition in this manner: Einstein, through celebrated scientific success within the industrial era that would’ve been deemed blasphemous during the Spanish Inquisition; the latter’s executions of heretics and Einstein-like thinkers only possible with a supporting society (The Spanish Inquisition, 1996). Assuming a hypothetical situation of Einstein being executed by the Holy Tribunal, his theories would have followed his demise as blasphemous with no substantial impact on an un-permitting, unknowingly affected society. However, scientific ideologies deemed blasphemous by previous or existing societies may leave an extensive impression within an innovative secularised society, only if this approving society develops. This principle applies to other ideologies also (e.g. ethical, philosophical). Individuals are limited in their ability to influence change inside an un-permitting environment, and even if successful are ultimately tools of society themselves (see paragraph 2 for side proof). Societal constraints on individuals limit possible actions of historical change, meaning similar individuals’ ideological influences on change differ depending on society, which ultimately determines an individual’s actions’ success—bolstering the claim of change established by larger historical forces.

Other Essays Like Do Individuals Change the Course of History, or Is Change the Product of Larger Historical Forces? Support Your Argument with Historical Examples

The Aim of Marketing Is to Know and Understand the Customer so Well the Product or Service Fits Him and Sells Itself (Ducker). Though a Simple Statement, as the World Economy Grow and Consumers Change...

1990 words - 8 pages The aim of marketing is to know and understand the customer so well the product or service fits him and sells itself (Ducker). Though a simple statement, as the world economy grow and consumers change this gets increasingly difficult. Globalization has caused marketers to research different countries, creeds, and cultures to make unique marketing strategies. Globalization isn’t the future of our economy, it’s the now. Advances in technology

Hrm-587 Course Projectpart 3: Diagnosing the Change

3220 words - 13 pages their side it is unlikely they will ever gain much power in one of the largest internet markets in the world. Google has a long history of acquiring companies to help advance its innovation prospects, and it seems inevitable that sooner or later it would procure the most appropriate companies or individuals with the know-how required to resolve the sticky situation. High-priced products are a competitive disadvantage for Apple, and it has priced

Environmental Forces Promoting Social Change

1707 words - 7 pages levels, and gender would fall into this bizarre gap where tradition frequently fights with newer paradigms that come along to surpass it. Although such factors as the physical environment, population, technology, and social inequality serve as sources of change, it is the collective effort of individuals organized in social movements that ultimately leads to change (Schaefer, 2009, p. 401). Yuval-Davis (2009) explains it is gendered globalization

Reasons For A Change In An Organisations Product Or Service

1015 words - 5 pages produced at a higher rate, which in turn will mean the customer will receive an equally good product wit every purchase. Organizations will generally change any goods or services, to keep a high level of customer satisfaction, a high standard of reputation, but will also try to do this at a minimal cost. Research has shown me that kaizen is a very effective way of performing these things however there are a lot of other aspects in the business that

Do We Need Change

776 words - 4 pages evolved through time. So will it be wrong to say that all the different business evolved on the same principle? That is to make profit. But the businesses which stays for long as market leader are those who constantly innovating .Examples of those companies who once were major leaders are either have been shrunk ,or finished or have lost their identity or catching their tails since then due to not evolving or anticipating a change

To Conform or to Change: What Will Your Verse Be?

1147 words - 5 pages 1 Hi 18.212002 B To Conform or To Change: What Will Your Verse Be? When it comes to the subject of death, one may realize that their life is temporary, hence, they try their best to live with the short period of time they have. Although the idea of “living life to the fullest” essentially means living an exceptional life and never wasting any opportunity given to you, many would take this in a different context and use it as

Which Characters Change Most Throughout 'an Inspector Calls' and Why Do the Change?

1147 words - 5 pages Which characters change the most through the course of the play and why do they change? This essay will be looking at which characters change and why throughout the play 'An Inspector Calls'. 'An Inspector Calls' was written in 1945 by J.B. Priestley and is set in the spring of 1912. The play is about the Birlings, an upper class family who are paid an unexpected visit from the mysterious Inspector Goole. They are thoroughly interrogated by

If You Could Change Places With Anyone In The World, Who Would It Be And What Would You Do?

486 words - 2 pages power of the world and the place of opportunities to flourish for every one, followed the instructions of Israel to have a war against Muslims and in the process earned disgrace from all over the world. It is a major loss done to America and Americans due to this heinous purposed war. After replacing myself with Mr. Bush, firstly I will order American armed forces to leave Afghanistan and Iraq and made the charge to UN peace keeping forces in these

A Smile Can Change Your Day

731 words - 3 pages A smile can change your day - "If you're not using your smile, you're like a man with a million dollars in the bank and no checkbook." Quote "A smile is a curve that sets everything straight." "A smile is the light in your window that tells others that there is a caring, sharing person inside." "Life is short but a smile takes barely a second." "What's the use of worrying? It never was worthwhile, so pack

Do Stereo Types Change over Time? Using the Gangster Genre as an Example

1050 words - 5 pages Whether it is possible to define a stereotype is one thing, but to define the change of a stereotype is something completely different. This is not because it is difficult to distinguish a change from the original, but because stereotypes are constantly changing, and differ from genre-to-genre, alongside the social, political, economic and cultural changes of the era. To pinpoint an exact change in a precise stereotype is not very easy to do

The Historical Roots of Logic

939 words - 4 pages , and they also may have discovered the first proof that the square root of two is irrational. The Pythagoreans were not the only Greeks who were passionately interested in arguments and proofs. The early Greek philosophers are generally distinguished from the sages, prophets, and oracles of other early Middle Eastern civilizations precisely in that they sought to support their opinions with reasons. An outstanding early example was Zeno of

Related Papers

Trend In Historical Causes Of Change In Societies

536 words - 3 pages occurred rather than outright adoption of a foreign cultural tradition was because when a reform was needed, the empire replaced the negative aspects and kept the positive to create a blend. Throughout history, after every empire began to decline or fall, constant chaos and disruption took place. Philosophers emerged and all of society would be lost without a leader or any sense of order. One great example would be the formation of the Three Schools of

"When People Succeed, It Is Because Of Hard Work, Luck Has Nothing To Do With Success”. Do You Agree Or Disagree With The Quotation Above? Use Specific And Examples To Explain Your Position

655 words - 3 pages "When people succeed, it is because of hard work, Luck has nothing to do with success" "When people succeed, it is because of hard work, Luck has nothing to do with success". Do you agree or disagree with the quotation above? Use specific and examples to explain your position. Everyone has strong desire for success in life. Some people believe that success is a result of hard work and luck has nothing to do

Look At The Way A Theme Or Character Is Presented In Your Chosen Text. Include In Your Response Any Social, Cultural And Historical Contexts That Are Important To Your Understanding Of The Theme Or...

887 words - 4 pages Look at the way a theme or character is presented in your chosen text. Include in your response any social, cultural and historical contexts that are important to your understanding of the theme or character. The character I have chosen to write about is Candy in the novel ‘Of Mice and Men’ by John Steinbeck. Candy is sort of like a narrator in the beginning of the story. He is the oldest ranch hand in the novel, who knows just about

The Change In The Power Of Kings Throughout The Course Of The Middle Ages

1220 words - 5 pages removed, meant death here and hereafter.”. This quote is from a text found online ( by Cox George W. (George William), called Epochs of History- The Crusades, showing that kings would be excommunicated very easily if they didn’t act the way the popes expected them to. The classic image of a medieval king that has such tremendous wealth and power comes from the period after the beginning of the Crusades