This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Do We Have Free Will Essay

1360 words - 6 pages

Student:
Instructor:
Class:
Date:
Do we have Free Will?
Yes. The issue of whether we have a free will or not is disputable. For the purpose of this study, I will look into what others have said about this topic. First, I will consider the opinions of three writers who have written contrary to my opinion supporting their argument with the reasons they have given. Secondly, I will analyze the opinions of those writers who believe that we have free will. This will of course be followed by supportive argument behind their opinions. On the last section of this study, I will rebut on the two different opinions.
It seems that we do not have free will. For as (Merrill 293), the idea of free ...view middle of the document...

Steve bases his argument on the elimination process. He argues that when theories and arguments of free will are eliminated, the conclusion we are left to make is that there is no free will. To support his argument the writer indicates that under favorable conditions, specific agents lead to free actions from a human being in a non-deterministic manner. He concludes that any agent does not cause free actions and that human beings have a basic mental action that is intrinsically free form any actions.
On the contrary, it seems that we do have free will. For as (Richard 457-470) says that their research support that college students believe in the existence of a free will that is not restrained by genetically or environmental factors. In their study, they argue that we act based on knowledge, habit, tradition, personal preferences and impulses. This study supports that our actions result from the responses we receive. Our ppredetermined causal knowledge or a rational thinking beyond causal knowledge guides what we choose.
On the contrary, it seems that we do have free will. For as (Nicholas 79-106) on his view of humanistic approach, not all our actions are determined. Personal agency determines the existence of a free will. Personal agency is the choices that we make in life and the effects the choices have on us. According to this writer, freedom is a necessity for any human being if we are to be fully functional. The arguments on whether we have free will are based on the argument that through human need of self-actualizations, we actually determine what to do and when to do a specific activity.
On the contrary, it seems that we do have free will. For as (Benjamin 833-852), cognitive psychologists, conscious reflection determines our behavior. Conscious reflection becomes the best way of achieving goals and learning from previous mistakes. According to this writer, if human beings actions are a product of unconscious processes, they remain our thoughts and actions. In other words, human beings are a sum of conscious and unconscious processes because although we can be influenced, we are unique. Two similar brains operating under the same instructions cannot necessarily come up with the same decisions.
Whereas Merrill suggests that the idea of free will does not exist, as same actions will result into different actions, I tend to differ. The ability of a human being to produce similar results is all a matter of providing favorable conditions. A certain activity can be done repeatedly provided the factors that produced the first result are maintained in the successive activities. On the contrary, if the repetitions of such actions are not supported by favorable factors, the expected results might fail to be achieved.
In his article Clement Dore, argues that before a human being carries a certain action, the brain will have already laid the foundation for the activity. This opinion is therefore supportive to the argument that we have free...

Other Essays Like Do We Have Free Will

Determinism And Free Will Essay

1026 words - 5 pages , is rooted behind the idea that we do have control over the choices we make, thus having free will, a requirement for being morally accountable for an action. But if determinism is true, and we have no control over the choices we make, then we do not have free-will; and therefore, nobody can ever legitimately be held morally accountable for anything. Our common practice of thinking of others and ourselves as accountable is simply not justified

Johnathan Edwards-Free Will Essay

1554 words - 7 pages power over the past or power of God’s beliefs? or to argue that we cant change God belief’s no matter what we do even though we are freely choosing our own actions. D God’s beliefs reside aside from our actions and our actions have no truth till they actuate? Or shall we change what we understand to be free will like Frankfurt and say that even though it is not in our power to other than God’s belief of those actions we are still free. Or

Free Will

986 words - 4 pages “Human actions are causally determined and therefore not free” Discuss. Determinism argues that all human actions are determined as they apply to natural laws. However, to say actions are determined means that human action isn’t free and we do not have free will. Free will is the term given to the idea of human ability to do what we like whenever we like without restraint. I disagree with the claim that human action is not free and I will put

Stock Market

586 words - 3 pages have an explanatory cause?” Maria: “Yes, I would like to believe that sometimes some choices or events are random leading to free will.” Socrates: “How do you define human choices, How do you define human event, are they different?’’ Maria: “Human choices are the options, power, right or liberty to choose, human events are occurrences or happenings at a determinable time and place with or without the participation of human agents, I would

Strategic Management

565 words - 3 pages * (2) are an overseas student doing a course that takes more than six months to complete * (3) have been in Australia continuously for six months or more and for most of that time you worked in the one job and lived in * the same place * (4) will be or have been in Australia for more than half of the financial year (unless your usual home is overseas and you do not

Socratic Conversation

999 words - 4 pages one not free. Explanatory cause is just reason for our actions and behaviors; it does not strip us of the freedom to make those choices. Socrates: Oh, then will you tell me how you define free? Beth: Yes I would be glad to tell you my thoughts. To me, free is to not be under anyone's control but my own. Whether right or wrong we have the ability to do what we choose. Socrates: You have brought to my attention some powerful insight, but let me

Free Will Defense

1117 words - 5 pages happening? Wouldn’t he only want good things to arise? The only problem with this is that we were all given a free will to either choose to do a right thing, or something wrong. And since these are choices that we must make subconsciously, there is no way of escaping the consequences that will come our way due to our actions. With this being said, we cannot have free will and yet be able to enjoy a life absent of evil at the same. The evil

What the Black Man Wants: a Modernization of Frederic Douglass's Speech

851 words - 4 pages someone else choose who leads a free man’s country? The answer may be obvious, but to us, the line is blurred. The black man may be “free”, but he certainly isn’t free to do what he wants. We are true Americans. As true as any other person of any other color. Yet we do not have the same rights as others. It may seem surprising that we now demand the right to vote, so soon after we have abolished slavery, and been given the right to work

Freedom and Determinism

1768 words - 8 pages said it all in his assertion, “man is condemned to be free” because freedom cannot be separated from the nature of man. Moreover, despite the fact that man is free, he is not absolutely free. I know that this statement will raise a tingling ear and seem as if am supporting the fact that freedom and determinism are compatible? Hold your breath and do not jump to conclusions yet. Going back to the analysis of the philosophers that we have

Examine the Concept of Time Value of Money in Relation to Corporate Managers. Propose Two (2) Methods in Which Time Value of Money Can Help Corporate Managers in General

546 words - 3 pages 1.From the research I have done the question that comes to mind dose freewill exist. Science has contributed to the free will problem in at least three ways. First, physics has addressed the question whether nature is deterministic, which is viewed as crucial by incompatibilists (compatibilists, however, view it as irrelevant). Second, although free will can be defined in various ways, all of them involve aspects of the way people make decisions

Free Will vs Determinism

638 words - 3 pages Ted Honderich Determinism Vs Free Will Psychology 101-1322 Professor: James Pattison By: Belinda Bielicki July 2, 2011 Determinism versus Free Will: The most important and the oldest philosophical question is perhaps that of free will and determinism. Do people have free will, or are our actions pre-determined? Ted Honderich defined determinism as the philosophical idea that every event or state of affairs, including every human

Related Papers

Do We Have Free Will Essay

3213 words - 13 pages Do We Have Free Will? Thomas Ash In some sense, you have just chosen to read this essay... or at least to start it. But was this a free choice and if so, in what sense? If you're surreptitiously reading a philosophy essay when you should be working, can you be blamed for this? These are the sorts of questions that intrigue people in the age-old philosophical debate about "Free Will", which tends to get muddied by its archaic name and the

Free Will; Do We Have It Or Not

1218 words - 5 pages Free Will; Do We Have it or Not The question of free will is one which has been hotly debated for millennia. Some people believe that humans have the capacity for free will - the ability to choose their actions without being forced to follow a certain course by either by the influence of others or by natural laws. For many theists, free will is regarded as a special gift from God. The notion of human free will is also an important premise

Pollution: This Essay Answers To Questions Like "What Is Pollution?", "Why Do We Have Pollution?" And Etc

346 words - 2 pages PollutionAs the twentieth century is at its final curtain, our country has marked a new era in Science and Technology, which has also created pollution as the adverse effect.The definition of pollution is the contamination of the air, water, and land. We have to recognise that pollution is inevitable in any developing country, and its increasing quantum threatening the population's health, must be reduced by identifying its sources. Even though

Free Will 3 Essay

546 words - 3 pages Free will implies that we have the ability to choose something or to not choose something regardless of the circumstances. Determinism is the idea that something causes every event, and therefore what we do is decided by prior events and not what we freely choose. Therefore this paper will argue that one theory cannot exist where the other does and they are therefore incompatible. If free will does exist then determinism does not. As I will