Dr. John Watson: A Complement Who Compliments

1891 words - 8 pages

Karilyn Johnson
MC #1174
Professor Aling
LIT1107
October 17, 2012
Word Count: 1,829
Dr. John Watson: A Complement Who Compliments
Is it possible for a person to be so clearly superior to others in intellect, observation, and reason, and yet be so utterly dependent on another in matters of routine life? It is. Such a condition exists in the brilliant personage of Sherlock Holmes, a man of renowned detective skills, who relies heavily on his ever-present assistant Dr. John Watson. To quote Dr. Watson as relating to Holmes, “I shall ever regard [him] as the best and wisest man whom I have ever known” (291). Such a compliment comes even from the man whom Holmes cannot function without, ...view middle of the document...

In cases Watson is involved in, when all seems lost to him, Holmes solves the crime. Watson finds himself incredulous as to how Holmes solved it. Holmes’ “brilliant reasoning power” (56), as Watson says, is his key to solving the toughest cases. A phrase commonly stated to Watson by Holmes is that Watson “[sees] but [does] not observe” (21). Unlike Holmes, Watson sees things the way an average person sees them, but Holmes is different. He observes. Observing is the secret to his success. Watson compliments Holmes by simply narrating about his greatness and ability to solve crimes through his genius as an investigator.
Sherlock Holmes’ second area of genius, as a master of disguise, is also revealed through Watson’s complimentary narration. Watson describes the complexity and sensationalism of Holmes’ disguises and relates how he is “accustomed to his friend’s amazing powers in his use of disguises” (28). Frequently, when Holmes is in disguise, Watson is utterly unaware that he is looking at his friend Sherlock Holmes. Watson is clearly in awe of the cleverness of Holmes, and how he is able to transform himself from looking like Sherlock Holmes into a “drunken-looking groom, [who is] ill-kempt and side-whiskered, with an inflamed face and disreputable clothes” (28) in A Scandal in Bohemia. Few people have the ability to accomplish such a task. Watson cannot imagine changing his own appearance so completely, and looks up to Holmes for his ingenuity at impersonation.
Finally, through Watson’s complimentary narration, he reveals Holmes’ genius in discernment. Watson looks up to Holmes for his ability to detect motive behind every crime or mystery that he is summoned to solve. Holmes rarely fails to crack the case and get to the bottom of it. One reason is that Holmes does not get emotionally involved in his cases. He is more worried about the case than the victims or others involved in the case. Therefore, Holmes’ judgment and discernment are not clouded due to an emotional connection. For example, Holmes figured out in “The Adventure of the Dancing Men” that the notes of the dancing men were from Abe Slaney to Elsie Cubitt because “[he] loved her. [He] had a right to her. She was pledged to [him] years ago” (359). However, Elsie did not feel the same. “She fled from America to avoid [him], and she married an honourable gentleman in England” (360). Holmes’ ability to distinguish motive here was commendable, and Watson clearly reveals his appreciation in his narrative.
Not only does Watson compliment Sherlock Holmes through his narration and biography, but Watson also complements Holmes in the roles of personal aide, counselor, friend, and protector. As Holmes’s personal aide, Watson is Holmes’ foil through a servant/master relationship. As such, Watson complements him by following his every order and living at his disposal. Whatever Holmes requires of Watson, Watson fulfills immediately and without complaint. Holmes’ having Watson’s assistance...

Other Essays Like Dr. John Watson: a Complement Who Compliments

Sherlockholmes Essay

1687 words - 7 pages   was  a  brief introduction  to  the  great  sherlock  holmes  who  is  methodical,  intelligent,  analytical  and  observant.  He  is also  shown  to  have  an  healthy  relationship  with  Dr.  Watson.  Then  arrives  Dr.  James Mortimer and the sherlock  realizes some of their deductions were a little wrong which was essential for the author to show to  the  audience  that  he  is  indeed  human.  Dr  mortimer  then  told  that  he  considered

Little Albert and Classical Conditioning Essay

1176 words - 5 pages Little Albert and Classical Conditioning John B Watson was one of the most notable psychologist scientists of the 20th century. He wrote about applied psychology for academic journals, popular magazines and business publications. He is considered to be the founder of behaviorism. Watson's work was based on the experiments of Ivan Pavlov, who had studied the responses of animals to conditioning. Pavlov sustained the theory that the humans

The Sign Of Four And Cawelti: Social Prominence And The Classical Detective Story

890 words - 4 pages him. She has one lead, and that is a contact, who every year send her a pearl. She is for the most part a middle class citizen except for the fact that unknown to her she is the heir to a treasure that could make her one of the richest ladies in the country. Not only is she the heir to a treasure, but she is a beautiful lady that catches the eye of Dr. Watson.Dr. Watson is himself a middle class citizen. He lives with Holmes as friend and

Health Comparison Post Civil War and 1950-2000

618 words - 3 pages ideas to create theories, machines, algorithms, and even diets. Two extremely influential men came about during two different time periods, one in the late 1800’s and the other in the latter half of the 1900’s. Both of these men harbored extraordinary ideas in their heads about nutrition and diet, which eventually shaped the pop cultures of the day. Dr John Harvey Kellogg and Dr Robert C. Atkins were two extremely significant nutritionists in the

Christopher Marlow's Life And Work

1136 words - 5 pages the rest of his life. Evidently, in his brief, tragic, and passionate life, Marlowe was the kind of man who could not help making enemies. He seems to have lived, as he thought, dangerously. The history of Marlowe's remaining six years of his life traces a series of violent clashes with the law. By 1589 he was living in Norton Folgate, near the theaters, close to Thomas Watson, the poet. In September, Marlowe and William Bradley fell to fighting

An Analysis of Sherlock Holmes' Character

4549 words - 19 pages observing him carefully – a skill inherited by Sherlock Holmes. Holmes also seems to take over Bell’s angular nose and chin and a great energy flowing from his twinkling eyes and from the way he walked. Sherlock Holmes appeared for the first time in A Study in Scarlet published in Beeton’s Christmas Annual for 1887. The whole story is narrated by Dr. John H. Watson who is to become famous as Holmes’s one and only friend and biographer. Watson

Sexual Harassment essay

1284 words - 6 pages most credence and value. One has to be quite practical about the First Amendment’s meaning today in everyday life. So, of course, a threat to somebody’s personal safety should not be legally tolerated whatsoever. However, for example, saying ‘hey babe’ is not a threat, is it? That is a rhetorical question. Obviously, it is not a threat. Therefore, there is no solid ground to stand on in attacking someone who compliments a co-worker or any other

Sherlock Holmes Evaluations

2133 words - 9 pages from the opium pipes. In general, the setting of ‘The Man with the Twisted Lip’ is urban, miserable and hidden away. ‘The Speckled Band’ has a very different setting to ‘The Man with the Twisted Lip’. It is set mostly in the country village of Stoke-Moran in Surrey. Holmes and Watson stay the night in the wealthy Dr Grimesby Roylott’s mansion. The house seems to be falling to pieces and has not been well looked after: ‘The windows were broken

Book Report on Double Helix

656 words - 3 pages follow Pauling’s way of model building instead of experimentation to figure out the structure. Another way of experimentation could be the x-ray pictures given crystallization which gave the scientists a background to start of with and compare findings to what was shown in the pictures. The scientists included in the novel are James Watson, co- founder of the structure of DNA in 1953 along with Francis Crick, Maurice Wilkins, the crystallographer who

4a06 Dangthithaonguyen a Contrastive Analysis of Compliments in American English and Vietnamese

1664 words - 7 pages compliments, American has a tendency to accept the compliment more than Vietnamese who prefer rejecting the compliment as a sign of politeness and modesty. Pedagogical implication Having examined three elements of compliments in American English and Vietnamese under the contrastive view, I would like to discuss some implications for English language teaching at high school in our country. Firstly, notoriously known as a compliment

Jean Watson

2163 words - 9 pages . Transdisciplinary defined as involving two or more academic, scientific, or artistic disciplines. "Transpersonal caring relationships are foundation of work," (College of Nursing University of Colorado Denver, 2008). "Transpersonal conveys a concern for inner life world and subjective meaning of another who is fully embodied," (Watson Caring Science Institute, 2011 ). One goes beyond the ego self and moves toward a spiritual concern. These

Related Papers

Dr. Watson–– The Time Epitome Essay

1937 words - 8 pages alterations of Dr. Watson within current Holmesian adaptations provide an insight into how modern-texts continue to use Watson to represent and cater to its twenty-one-century audiences. In BBC’s TV series Sherlock, directed by Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss, John Watson is portrayed as a former military doctor back from Afghanistan. Throughout Sherlock, John Watson is still characterized as a loyal, professional, moral and ordinary partner of

The Life Of John B Watson

1371 words - 6 pages stated by none other than a determined man who is best known for behaviorism and the Little Albert experiment, John B. Watson. Mr. Watson’s life story intrigued me greatly to study his theory and also to write about it for my research paper. Mr. Watson didn’t have a “Brady Bunch family” where there was positivity and smiles all around in contrast; he had a hard life in his early stage but, managed to still excel in life. His work was based on

The Greek Interpreter Essay

884 words - 4 pages skillset is compared to Dr. Watson. The author uses Dr. Watson’s observation to show what someone who works with, but does not share the same ancestry as Sherlock sees. Doyle is proving that the hereditary trait is the difference between Mycroft and Dr. Watson. In Conclusion author Arthur Conan Doyle use of Mycroft Holmes was intended to be used as proof that Sherlock Holmes’ gifts of deduction and observation due to his ancestry. Doyle’s belief that a person’s gifts are attributed to his heredity is prevalent in many scenes in The Greek Interpreter and is proven to be true in the behavior and abilities of Sherlock and Mycroft Holmes.

Sherlock Holmes Essay

1328 words - 6 pages Coursework Question: Why is Sherlock Holmes stories still popular today? In 1891, Sherlock Holmes was a character very much of his time and place, who appealed to British readers directly by confronting the messy, changeable world they lived in. It was the time in which science challenged long-held beliefs and the status quo was threatened by social and economic changes. Holmes was grounded squarely in Victorian London. The Victorian city of