This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Drug Testing Welfare Recipients: Scandal Or Solution

1322 words - 6 pages

Drug Testing Welfare Recipients: Scandal or Solution
Welfare programs as we know today were created in the 1930’s during the great depression to aid unemployed and under employed people in supporting their families. (“The”) It was not intended to be a government funded crutch for substance abusers. Often tax payers complain about tax monies being spent to support the habits of drug users who receive welfare. The fix to this problem is simple, drug testing. Drug test everyone on welfare and when the welfare recipient tests positive, take away the benefit. Problem solved. But is it?
The consideration of testing welfare recipients for drug use has been debated since welfare reform in 1996. ...view middle of the document...

18). That is slightly more than 2.5%. But wait it gets better. Utah ran a drug testing program for about a year. In the data it collected, almost 4500 people were tested, 9 tested positive for drug use (McKitrick, par. 1, 2). In which case both Florida and Utah have proved there is not a catastrophic amount of drug fiends snorting government monies through a straw.
The general census around drug testing welfare recipients is to save money; Florida and Utah proved that drug testing wastes more money than it saves. Why? Both states used urine tests to test for drugs. A typical cost of a urine drug test is around $40 and that’s just the test (Poole, par. 12). That $40 does not include the nurse or medical assistant needed to administer the test or whatever else is needed to ensure the test is done properly and safely (Poole, par. 12). Most drugs will not be detected in urine after 4 days; whereas marijuana and PCP stays in urine up to 30 days (“Drug Use”). Anyone who is going to apply for assistance where there is a drug test involved plans accordingly.
Enough about drug tests, what about other costs. Kansas believes it will require the employment of at least four more people to handle drug testing with its newly past law not to mention the rehabilitation program is expected to cost one million dollars (Flatow, par. 5). Florida has already paid out over $45,000 more drug testing than it would have if it would have just paid out the welfare (Alvarez, par. 5). Governor Rick Scott of Florida has racked up a hefty $900,000 in lawyer fees in his quest to drug test the poor (Ossowski, par. 6). And let us not forget the American Civil Liberties Union of Florida’s request for a refund of their legal fees in defending the poor; $313,000 was asked for after the injunction in 2011 was ordered (Ossowski, par. 6).
Those who support the drug testing of welfare recipients would argue that it is the governments’ responsibility to ensure tax monies given to needy families as aid not a crutch for a drug user. As I absolutely agree with this argument but drug tests are not the answer. Oklahoma found that a simple questionnaire could detect drug abusers as well as alcoholics with an accuracy rate of 94% (“Drug”, par. 14). That’s better than most urine tests, as a urine test will not detect alcohol or drug abusers. Alabama found that concentrating on programs that taught employment skills was more effective in removing people from the welfare payroll than drug testing (“Drug”, par. 20). Helping families obtain knowledge for employment and saving money, sounds like a healthier alternative to drug testing.
Last but to least, drug testing violates personal rights. According to the Bill of Rights fourth amendment “The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and...

Other Essays Like Drug Testing Welfare Recipients: Scandal or Solution

Government Assistance Essay

898 words - 4 pages increasing needs of government assistance recipients, there are still some hard-nose conservative beliefs and attitudes around. For example, a recent amendment was introduced to the tax bill last month by Republican senator, Orrin Hatch, from Utah requiring those who apply for government assistance, including unemployment benefits, to pass drug testing in order to qualify. Generally, people with these kinds of attitudes believe the welfare system is

The Evaluation of Welfare Reform: Is It Actually Ending?

1440 words - 6 pages plan for action presented to the New York State legislation must be set forth. Welfare, and any form of stability aid should be given as a privilege to those who deserve it. Welfare fraud is costing Americans billions of their hard earned dollars (D’Souza, 2012). More factors must be involved, like drug testing and prior work experience. If the recipient chooses not to work after a year of receiving aid, the aid must be terminated. Each

The Argument Culture

948 words - 4 pages society portrays every issue to have a “right side” and a “wrong side.” Take the controversial subject of abortion for example. Some individuals believe that abortion is wrong no matter what the situation is, while others think it is a woman’s choice. Then there are the ones who are usually against it but think it is acceptable in certain situations. Or what about the up and coming topic of requiring drug testing for welfare recipients? Some

Employment Drug Testing

2531 words - 11 pages identification of illegal drug users through testing. On November 18, 1988 The Drug Free Workplace Act was enacted. This legislation applied to federal contractors with individual procurement contracts of $100,000, or more and to direct recipients of federal grants of any amount. The act requires that the employer certify that he or she will provide a drug free workplace in accordance with the directives of the act. However, it does not require

Welfare in the Us

2600 words - 11 pages eligibility for welfare may also be constrained by means testing or other conditions. In more general sense, welfare also means the well-being of individuals or a group, in other words their health, happiness, safety, prosperity and fortunes. Welfare may be provided directly by governments or their agencies, by private organizations, or by a combination of both in a mixed economy model. The term welfare state is used to describe a state in which the

Legal and Ethical Issues Concerning Welfare Reform

2128 words - 9 pages recipients to find employment within a certain time limit. Recipients are required to be employed within the two years of receiving aid. After five years of being on welfare with or without a job recipients benefits cease completely. There is an article on USA Today of a single mother with three kids who was forced to find work. She struggled, and was even forced to mow lawns to try and make ends meet. After struggling from job to job she final found

Public Assistance

4682 words - 19 pages paycheck weekly, without any effort in looking or applying for a job, it becomes almost repetitive and dependent. Politicians, Interests Groups & Social Policy Experts According to Newt Gingrich’s (1995) essay called "Renewing America,” the welfare system has sapped the spirit of the poor and made it harder to climb up the economic ladder. A system like this not only leads welfare recipients to become satisfied with lives of ‘subsidized

Welfare and Graduation Rates

2201 words - 9 pages graduate from college while still receiving aid or in the two months following exit. 20% graduate during a period when they are not receiving Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC). Of those who graduate, welfare recipients are far more likely to obtain an Associate’s Degree (as compared to Bachelor’s or higher degrees) than those who do not receive welfare. 59% of college/welfare students who graduate complete an Associate’s Degree

Classic Arugment Welfare

747 words - 3 pages . Another things goverment need to fix is that we have a big portion of welfare recipient that suffers from substance abuse and mental health. According to the Michigan “A bill reintroduced this year and set for a hearing today in a House committee calls for the state to start a suspicion-based substance abuse screening and testing program for cash assistance welfare recipients in the state’s Family Independence Program.”(Par. # 2). That means that

Ruling Ideologies

542 words - 3 pages Core Studies 3 Casilda Adames Take-Home Exam November 16, 1999 The ruling ideology dealing with welfare is a negative view among the majority of Americans. It states that welfare recipients are lazy people who have lots of children and collect checks for a long period of time. This statement is believed mostly among higher-class people because they feel that if they can work hard for their money, welfare recipients can do the same, and not

Cjs 220 Law

1028 words - 5 pages -existing customs, codified law derived from written statutes or codes maintained by the government. Today in America, legislatures gather together in an effort to create and enact new codes or statutes; the judiciary reviews and decides the soundness of these laws, and executives enforce these laws. One law to have in the United States that will decrease the numbers of state assistance recipients would to require recipients to be drug-free

Related Papers

Drug Testing Welfare Recipients Essay

1077 words - 5 pages Drug testing for welfare recipients: Con By Austin Keller / In Blogs, Politics / January 17, 2014 See the opposing argument here. When one first hears about the idea of testing welfare recipients to make sure that they are not using drugs, the idea seems to be sound. Of course we do not want welfare money going toward the purchase of drugs when it should be going only to necessary and useful things. As with almost any political idea, however

Drug Testing Welfare Recipients Essay

1821 words - 8 pages . There are many people who are against drug testing welfare recipients and it is mainly because of cost and who has already failed. The state of Florida drug tested 4,086 Temporary Assistance for Needy Families applicants and only 108 of those applicants tested positive for illegal drugs, or 2.8%. Many say that is not enough positive test results to even come close to breaking even in costs. It cost the state 178 million dollars to drug test all

Drugs And Welfare Essay

1467 words - 6 pages , there are flaw. Many feel that people on food stamps or welfare assistance should be required to submit a drug test. Do people think mandatory drug testing is fair? Many think it is because welfare recipients accept millions of American aid every year. It is fair for them to be tested so the aid is given to those in need of help. Some say this is not right because of their civil rights. Most employeers require drug testing pior to hire date and

Welfare Fraud Essay

1882 words - 8 pages fraud where the money one has received goes to drug or criminal related matters. Mandatory drug testing could in turn reduce the number of welfare fraud being committed. It is the researchers intent to prove why drug testing should be made mandatory. Welfare Fraud Drug testing for welfare should be made mandatory. There are the exceptions to rule however, such as someone on welfare recovering from a drug addiction. There is a severe problem